« BACK  |  PRINT

RS

EDITOR OF REDSTATE

Mitt Romney’s Remarks are Another Chick-Fil-A Moment

Just a few months ago, Dan Cathy of Chick-Fil-A, gave an interview to a Christian publication that asked him about the Chick-Fil-A Foundation’s support of marriage. Cathy defending his position and spoke about his family’s faith. CNN.com picked it up and ran a story that Cathy had come out against gay marriage.

In fact, Cathy hadn’t been asked directly about gay marriage, but it was implicit in what he said. The CNN.com story swirled around the internet. Leftwingers and media mouthpieces across the country condemned Chick-Fil-A for serving bigotry on a bun. Suddenly the most controversial thing in America was two buttered buns and a pickle. Mayors were demanding Chick-Fil-A not come to their cities. Liberals were screaming about intolerance and bigotry.

Then Mike Huckabee and others declared a Chick-Fil-A Day. On the appointed day, lines of cars stretched around city blocks. Lines of people stretched across parking lots. Turns out a lot of people agreed with Dan Cathy. But it also turned out a lot of people who did not agree, but were not offended and showed up to support Chick-Fil-A.

A counter protest was held — a so called “kiss in.” Few people showed up.

The Chick-Fil-A controversy animated a whole lot of people. It just turned out that the people it most animated were the people who agreed with Dan Cathy.

So it is, I think, with Mitt Romney’s comments. I think the media and the left have badly misread the American mood on this. On CNN yesterday, I spent a fair amount of time with Kate Bolduan and Joe Johns, two of my favorite people. They kept focusing on Mitt Romney’s characterization of the word “victims.”

What I explained to them and what I think the media misses is that many of the people the media would claim Mitt Romney described as “victims’ weren’t who Mitt Romney was speaking about. And those people intrinsically know it. They may technically fall into the category Mitt Romney described as government dependent victims, but they know he’s not talking about them. He’s talking about the people they also are talking about.

But more than that, and this is really what the left and media miss, a fair number of those people in the 47% are not there by choice. They are there by Barack Obama’s economic policies. And they absolutely understand that Barack Obama’s policies got them there. All they need to hear from Mitt Romney is that he really does get it and really will fix the problem, not just manage the decline of the nation as his primary opponents claimed he would.

That off the cuff, off the record talk was what they needed to hear. Mitt Romney recognizes we have a problem with government dependency, as do a majority of Americans. But more importantly, Mitt Romney will improve the lives of that 47% by growing the private sector, not redistributing pieces of the economic pie.

Remember folks, if you listen to the media and watch the public opinion polls, gay marriage wins everywhere. But if you actually pay attention to the voters at the polls, it has lost in every state in which it’s been put to a public vote. That issue doesn’t actually animate and motivate enough gay marriage supporters to offset how it motivates actual marriage supporters. Mitt Romney’s comments may rile up the left, but I think it’ll rile up a whole lot of people who agree with him.

As a bonus, it puts the left and the media in the very awkward position of telling key segments of the population that they’re the victims Romney was talking about when those people don’t view themselves as victims and think a whole lot of people are actually living off the system. You ever try telling someone they aren’t doing as well as they think they are? Good luck with that. It didn’t work convincing people they were better off than they knew, might as well try it! Oh, and in the process, you might as well accuse them of bitterly clinging to their guns and religion.

One caveat here — Mitt Romney must be prepared to fight on this ground now. He should let Paul Ryan do a lot of the talking. This is Paul Ryan’s turf and there are few, if any, more articulate people on the issue of government dependency.

One final point as well — this episode epitomizes how the media is an enemy collaborator with Barack Obama’s campaign. When conservatives accurately quoted Barack Obama’s “you didn’t build that” line including the context in which he meant it, the press immediately folded when Obama claimed conservatives were taking him out of context. In Romney’s press conference after the revelation of the tape he said he was speaking off the cuff and maybe was not as articulate as he could have been without a prepared text. Nonetheless, unlike Obama’s “you didn’t build that” remark, the press demands that we all take Mitt Romney literally in his remarks.

COMMENTS

  • http://edgeinducedcohesion.wordpress.com nathanalbright

    This is the sort of quote that infuriates leftists and also motivates conservatives (including independent conservatives that think of themselves as responsible, no matter how straightened their economic position). But I don’t think it’s really all that bad for Romney.

  • greyeagle

    Romney and Ryan will get this country back to work. Obama will ensure more people are on government dole because of his policies. We want a President that will work to fix this country, not a dictator.

  • swi2522

    this is an arguement worth having. mitt also showed me he is conservative
    about time we started talking real issues like government entitlemente
    lets talk about the dems socialist policies

  • PowerToThePeople

    Do not be an idiot bub. Across the country, the vast amount of polls show a clear and defined support for traditional marriage. California has voted against gay marriage each and every time, 2011 through today is no different.

    As to your constitutional claim, please show me where in the constitution it states a person has a right to marry. A quote from Earl Warren that you are wrongly applying to gay marriage does not count since nothing he says becomes a constitutional right.

  • lineholder

    Aye, it is very much so a battle worth fighting. I hope the choice is made to chunk the left’s narrative of “makers and takers” in doing it, because it allows the foundation of their social argument protecting and preserving an ever-growing welfare state to stand if we don’t.

    This battle should be fought, especially for the sake of younger generations. I spent some time talking a young friend of mine last night. She’s a single mother, late 20s now, partially dependent on welfare, and poor. Growing up in the public school system, what she had reiterated to her time and time again was that “government is always good”. Dangerous mindset, that is. Doesn’t allow for much truth on the fact that what goes on politically can be more about establishing power in a society than anything else. Also doesn’t allow for the fact that government is compromised of fallible human beings, and human beings can corrupted either.

    Odd thing is that she actually believes in free-market principles. Goes against everything she was taught, told, and led to believe by our modern-day public school curriculum, but she believes it all the same.

    Ryan may be more articulate on such things, but Romney is the one with practical experience in this regards. He could bust the false narratives that the left has used to try to set portions of our society against free-market capitalism wide open, if he chooses to pursue it.

    We’ll have to see what he makes of this, but it is an opportunity for Romney/Ryan. No doubt about that.

  • PowerToThePeople

    Ummm, no it did not. But keep showing us you are full of bovine excrement and that you are a liar willing to twist facts when it suits your interest.

  • ultimaistanza

    Marriage IS a civil right. Take a look at the 14th amendment “All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the
    jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the
    state wherein they reside. No state shall make or enforce any law which
    shall abridge the privileges or immunities of citizens of the United
    States; nor shall any state deprive any person of life, LIBERTY, or
    property, without due process of law; nor deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws.” Also, who is forcing people to marry a person of the same sex?

  • celador2

    Smallb, good point, Romney spoke of campaign process not policy, he said in his efforts to clarify his comments.

  • tnfriendofcoal101368

    There is infighting on every campaign (and really there should be strong voices with different ideas) – heck it’s pretty well known Stephanie Cutter and David Axelrod barely speak to each other. The next kind word Robert Gibbs finds for Valerie Jarrett will probably be the first. The one difference is that Cutter, Axelrod, Gibbs, and Jarrett are all dedicated to getting Obama elected…sometimes (and only sometimes) – you get the impression that Stevens is not all about Romney. I don’t know if that is spin by people who are well known Stevens haters (Mike Murphy and Alex Castellanos – I am looking at you) that the media is more than willing to go along with or actual truth.

  • sayoung80913

    I have two children a son who is nineteen and a daughter who is twenty-both are in the army. My son saw something about this on facebook and texted me” 47% of the country pays NO taxes?” he pulled up his LES and saw that he-at nineteen- pays a good chunk. He was pretty surprised at that number. My daughter too, was quiet when she heard that. They are both PFCs and thought for sure all adults paid in because that would be fair-surprise- then anger -was their response. Both barely make ends meet, but at least they contribute to society. I wonder how many other people-younger or otherwise-are just now learning this sad truth via CNN,etc? CNN may accidentally expose a carefully hidden secret and have the exact opposite reaction then the one they were intending with their wall to wall coverage of this supposed “gaffe.”

  • shakazulu2012

    Romney HAS to use this. It’s the perfect personal ridicule that will resonate with voters. In Obama’s economy, not even the grandson of a president can find a job and is reduced to making secret tapes to get by.

  • http://hehasfailed.wordpress.com/ HopeHeFails

    You keep Peggy Downer… I’ll take Romney any day.

    By the way, Romney is up in New Hampshire by 3. The ‘turnaround’ needs to come from Obama.

  • bassethound

    Sadly enough, I’ve read on a couple of other web sites that Chick-Fil-A has caved to the deviant bullies and is no longer donating to Focus on the Family or Exodus. HuffPO and Daily Kos are crowing.

  • armedpatriot

    lol, I stay up late to watch Pawn Stars and Chopped.