« BACK  |  PRINT

RS

EDITOR OF REDSTATE

My iPhone 5 Review

Between bourbons and technology, I should put more of these up. On Friday morning, I decided to jump ship to Verizon from AT&T, where I have been forever. Put it to you this way, I was a Powertel user in college. They got bought by T-Mobile. Sometime around 1997, due to coverage issues, I switched to Cingular. You know the rest.

Many of you know Clayton, without whom this site would not exist. He and I were in line for the original iPhone together. I’ve had each new model since. This is the first time I’ve gotten the new iPhone and been kind of “meh.” That’s not to say it isn’t a great phone, it is. I just don’t have the giddy excitement I did of the original or of the 4S because, at the end of the day, the first major impression is that it only one more row of icons and is lighter.

Here’s the thing though — spending now several days with it, it may be an incremental upgrade from the 4S, but it is a huge step up from just the 4. And after several days, the phone, plus the new operating system, really are powerful and impressive.

It is the lightest iPhone ever. It disappears, though not in the Joe Biden “literally” sense, in my pocket. Yesterday, in church, a friend wanted to see it and I couldn’t remember which pocket I’d left it in. I just simply could not feel the weight of it in my suit. Once using it, the speed difference between it and the 4S is apparent.

While it may have initially been “meh” for me, my wife got one too. She spent no time with it for several days. She hates technology and really despises phones. Last night she sat down with it and her first reaction was, “This screen is incredible.” The Samsung she switched to because she hated the iPhone 3GS really had a cheap feel and low resolution screen. This blew her away. Then the speed impressed her. We both then really were struck by the absolute refinement of iOS 6. In particular, it has the only feature I’ve long requested and the one about which I once I got a reply from Steve Jobs.

After the iPhone 3GS came out, I emailed him and said I really wished they could add a feature that turns off the ringer and email overnight. My wife was making me turn my phone off at night and I kept forgetting to turn it back on the next day. My old Blackberry had that feature. I’d love it if the iPhone would get it. I think he only replied “We’ll see” or something like that. It was awesome in and of itself to get an email from him. Finally, with the iPhone 5, I’ve got what I wanted. The “Do Not Disturb” feature is perfect.

Siri is a bit more flexible. Yes, I did make reservations at a restaurant for the sole purpose of telling Siri to “make me a reservation for 2 at Bones at 8pm tonight.” Flawless. The program still gets hung up, though, often having to repeat the request or just do it myself.

Maps sucks. I get why they did it, but I think they probably should have invested more time in it before releasing it to the public. That’s not a phone issue, but an iOS issue. On my 4S, I was running iOS 6 since the GM build was released. I tested the navigation feature to go to a spa in my wife’s hometown. I needed a gift certificate for my mother-in-law. It got me there okay. It’s just that it took me a mile out of the way.

Again though, that’s not an iPhone 5 issue. The phone itself is stellar in weight, thickness, design, build quality, speed, and screen resolution. I don’t think I needed to upgrade. I don’t think I need the extra half-inch. But I’ll take it. There probably is no need to upgrade from an iPhone 4S to the 5. But it really is a major upgrade from the 4 to the 5. If you have the 4, you will have no “meh” reaction to the 5.

Now, one last thing — the carriers.

I switched from AT&T to Verizon. I broke my contract. My contract was up at the end of next year. My wife’s contract is up at the same time. We broke them both.

I wanted a 64GB iPhone 5 and my wife wanted the 32. AT&T was going to charge us the full price for each, which would amount to about $1500. It only cost $650 to break our contracts with AT&T. Verizon gave me $300 for my iPhone 4S and $70 for my wife’s phone. Our total bill at the Verizon Store, which also gave me a 20% discount via my employer, was $325.00. I’m also saving $100.00 a month on my wireless plan now with twice as much data. I saved big by jumping to Verizon. Verizon also has LTE in my neighborhood and AT&T won’t bring it here until at least 2014.

I stood in line Friday morning, but had to leave the line to go fill in for Neal Boortz. The line wasn’t moving fast enough though I was near the front. While I was on the show for Boortz, the Verizon sales rep texted me and said to come by when I got off at 1pm. One of the other stores hadn’t sold their whole stock and they’d go get me a 64GB one. I was in and out of the store in under and hour with the new phones. The customer service was excellent. LTE is really, really awesome. That, by the way, is an iPhone 5 thing. That’s something to consider when thinking of the new phone. The battery life remains impressive, if not better than the 4S. And I’m optimistic about Verizon.

Tags:

COMMENTS

  • proudmarinemom

    Not sure why this is on the front page at Red State. $325 is a lot of money for a toy to some people, by the way.

  • scott8251

    We’re not iPhone fans, but the Mrs. & I have been with Verizon since we moved to Maryland from Hawaii in 2004. We liked Sprint, but had to switch due to their poor coverage in our new home area. We have had no complaints with Verizon.

  • http://deadite.wordpress.com deadite

    I was on the fence about waiting to see the DROID RAZR Max or just going ahead and getting this in two weeks when my contract allows it. Frankly, and I hate to say it (not to be insulting) but this is one of the better reviews I have read on the iPhone. The rest talk about the specs, they blabber on about what its not. You did a great job of answering questions that a typical user would want answered. Thank you…

    They need you over at the PC and phone mags.

    A final question, and anyone can answer… How is the voice reception – hearing the other party, how does the other party hear you? My first use for a cell is and will be – a phone… How does it work vs the other types? Samsung, Droid (I hear Nokia has excellent sound, but its going to have to prove itself before I consider it next time… If it survives…)

  • WA_Cowboy

    Thanks for the review Erick. As a total newbie to smartphones, I’m always eager to know what the non-tech guys say about how it works. Now the question for any others who are smart-phone literate: which is better, the Galaxy III or the iphone 5?

  • proudmarinemom

    Not expecting Red State to embrace the manual typewriter or plain gray “day-vare / evening- vare” attire (remember that ad? the only difference in Olga’s outfit was she was carrying a flashlight with her “evening vare”).

    Just wondering what’s up with the obsession with gadgets and the free plug for Verizon and Apple.

  • tnfriendofcoal101368

    “Verizon also has LTE in my neighborhood and AT&T won’t bring it here until at least 2014″ – Neil may disagree but this is going to be one of the big stories in tech – how Verizon moved on 4G LTE much quicker than it’s competitors. I fully expect to see some full on lobbying by Verizon’s competitors to try and stem the advantages Verizon has gotten by being smarter than their competitors.

  • tnfriendofcoal101368

    Did they do something besides block the T-Mobile acquisition (ok, that was wrong and anti-competitive)? I actually like having AT&T as someone Verizon might consider to be a threat. Isn’t a lot of Verizon’s advantage in that they fitted their towers with LTE while AT&T was busy fitting theirs with HSPA+ (short term gain/long term pain typical of AT&T)? Didn’t the DOJ or FCC actually block Verizon’s acquisition of more spectrum from cable companies?

  • izoneguy

    $325 is not a lot of money if you live on your phone. The iPhone replaced my laptop computer when I travel now. I just wish we had this technology 20 years ago!!!

  • M_Becker

    Ouch.

  • tnfriendofcoal101368

    My wife too…she is a photographer and I take crowd shots with the I phone 4S for her while she uses the Canon DLR- it’s a better camera than most of the point and shoots on the market.

  • tnfriendofcoal101368

    To be fair, Disqus works lots better than Apple Maps…

  • Bill S

    You missed the point. HSPA+ is fast enough that the advantage that VZW has on LTE borders on irrelevant. I’ve used both. I’m well familiar with the coverage of both. Depending on where you live, it really doesn’t matter one way or the other. In Erick’s case, he has a big advantage from VZW. There are other places where Verizon coverage is poor and AT&T isn’t (I happen to live in one of those).

  • http://libertynews.com/ mbecker908

    Yes, I do. I simply have a completely irrational dislike of all things “AT&T” or “Bell”.

  • tnfriendofcoal101368

    I think your wrong, people aren’t going to go for “fast enough” over “fastest” and Verizon will make their 400 market target by Christmas. Verizon is going to keep pressing that advantage – I’ll bet you a dollar in 6 months, Verizon is covering your area with LTE while AT&T is still trying to get up in Atlanta. AT&T is going to spend the next year to two years bleeding customers.

  • tnfriendofcoal101368

    I could add it’s a pretty solid business decision to drive traffic to the site because the iphone 5 is a pretty hot topic; people are googling a lot at the moment. A person looking for an iPhone review might see some of the political stuff on RedState and decide their is an alternative to politico’s lie of the day….well, it could happen.

  • Thomas Crown

    When I first started to read this, my body became enveloped in a cold sweat. Could Erick seriously be about to suggest that the latest iteration of the Jesus Phone is less than amazing? That he was only slightly overwhelmed? THAT IT WASN’T WORTH UPGRADING YET?!

    But then I read, and lo, all was well. The iPhone now has functionality Blackberries(!) had in 2006. The screen is pretty. All of Erick’s Cupertino-approved life enablers can speak together with one, perfect voice.

    And dude, Bones?

  • tnfriendofcoal101368

    Blackberries – are they still making those? Though for the love of mankind, could Apple and Google call a 10 minute truce and get the same version of google maps into the App Store that is in Google play even if you have to pay for it. Then at least when you are going down some 1 lane, gravel road – you end up at the right address not “close”. Close being defined as in the same country.

  • aeaeren

    So my first impression is the phone looks nice and feels nice. I didn’t think that extra 1/2″ was going to make a difference but then when I started using it for twitter and stuff like that is makes it much easier to read. It is faster then the 4S but the one thing I like the most was the new headphones. I have always had issues with old round ear buds, he rubber would eventually give out and the sharp edges would start to cut. AT&T doesn’t have LTE where I live but do where I work. I will find out about that tomorrow when I drive into the office, otherwise I just use the Wifi at home.
    Overall it is a subtle but very nice upgrade. You get the ‘meh’ view but it’s the little things you start noticing when you are using it that makes it a much better phone then the 4S.

  • aeaeren

    Now if only the ios App works with the website we would be golden :)

  • http://www.hakubi.us/ Neil Stevens

    Well, let’s elect Republicans, apply pressure to Romney to appoint strong, reformist regulators, and fix the whole spectrum situation.

  • http://www.hakubi.us/ Neil Stevens

    That’s always an interesting statement. To say that X now has what Y had in year Z may be true on its face, but it’s often used to imply that Y is ahead of X, which is terribly false in the case of Blackberry vs iPhone.

    RIM declaring the iPhone’s feature set flatly impossible is one of the great failures of vision in the history of computing. RIM’s collapse due to the inability to compete with the myriad features iPhone does better, or does that Blackberry couldn’t do at all, is surely on par with the collapse of IBM’s PC division in terms of units sold and market dominance.

    But sure Thomas. You stick with your failing, uninnovative Canadian phone, and I’ll use my iPhone 5. :)

  • http://www.hakubi.us/ Neil Stevens

    If you can’t argue the facts, downrate.

  • Thomas Crown

    As you well know, I don’t use a Blackberry, hence the “(!).”

    And no implication was intended other than that the super-gee-whiz Jesus Phone was more a toy than a phone for much of its lifespan.

    This is 1985 all over again. Y’all just keep paying for the new Macintoshes as they roll out. I use the PC. Guess who wins.

  • http://www.facebook.com/richswarnick Rich Warnick

    The limitations Verizon has on there data I.E. talking while using GPS/checking email/Internet etc, Ill stay with AT&T. I multi task way to much to give it up.