« BACK  |  PRINT

RS

FRONT PAGE CONTRIBUTOR

Detroit, Michigan – America’s Ghost of Christmas Future

Proof That Government-Claus Doesn’t Exist.

Detroit, Michigan shows us the ruins of a once-great civilization. It does us an even better favor than that. It shows us these ruins as a precautionary warning – while our civilization actually embarks upon collapse. You can view the very artistic now vs. then photos of Cass Technical High School, and see the crash that awaits the rest of America if we continue to believe in impossible things.

This crash will certainly take place, and Detroit’s future will certainly become yours if you remain foolish enough to believe in Government Claus. Libertarian Author James Payne explains the foolish fallacy of Government Claus below.

(HT:Reason.com)

Essentially, people have come to believe that Government is a magical entity that can create value out of nothing. They can create money out of nothing. Most of America’s money supply exists only in the digital Astral Plane. They cannot force the average American producer or consumer to believe that the money has any realistic value. This can be seen in the prices of commodity goods such as Winter Wheat (104.81% increase since Nov 2002), West Texas Intermediate Grade Crude Oil (226.39% increase since Nov 2002), Mild Arabica Coffee (128.90% Increase since Nov 2002), and Rebar Steel (204.76% increase since Nov 2002).

These increases in commodity prices are indicative of the gradual and long-term destruction of the value of individual wealth and savings. This destruction of value makes the prolonged maintenance of capital assets such Cass Technical High School beyond the means of the tax base that uses them.

Once this problem takes hold, we get lots of theories from people close to the situation as to why this happening. Councilwoman JoAnn Watson believes that President Obama hasn’t shown Detroit proper gratitude for supporting him politically. Once the President pays his Detroit Vignette, all will be well as she explains below.

“Our people in an overwhelming way supported the re-election of this president and there ought to be a quid pro quo and you ought to exercise leadership on that,” said Watson, according to FOX 2 Detroit. “Of course, not just that, but why not? After the election of Jimmy Carter, the honorable Coleman Alexander Young [Detroit’s former mayor of 20 years and former vice chairman of the Democratic National Committee], he went to Washington, D.C. and came home with some bacon,” she added. “That’s what you do.”

(HT: The Blaze)

Detroit Mayor, David Bing blames a culture of victimization and entitlement. This better explains the impending death of Detroit and the long-term threat to America better than anything else you will read on Detroit. He has a point which former City Council Member, Shiela Cockrel amplifies below.

“This city has a lot of issues with entitlement, there are people who believe because I’m a business and I stayed in Detroit I’m entitled to this consideration, there are people who bring their businesses in and say ‘I came to Detroit so I’m entitled to this’ — special timing, special attention. “There are residents who say we’ve lived with this for so long that we’re entitled. We have politicians who foster this culture of victimization and entitlement, which is one of the political issues that really hurts this city.”

(HT: CBS – Channel 62)

Detroit is a harbinger of what could be America’s eternal damnation. But, as was shown in Charles Dickens’ A Christmas Carol, this doesn’t have to be. As we look at the ruins of Cass Technical High School we Americans should perhaps keep the following passage from Dickens’ literary masterpiece in mind.

“Before I draw nearer to that stone to which you point,” said Scrooge, “answer me one question. Are these the shadows of the things that will be, or are they shadows of things that may be, only?” Still the Ghost pointed downward to the grave by which it stood. “Men’s courses will foreshadow certain ends, to which, if persevered in, they must lead,” said Scrooge. “But if the courses be departed from, the ends will change. Say it is thus with what you show me!”

The point here is that the tragedy that has befallen Detroit can also serve as an admonishment. We can’t continue our false belief in Government Claus. If we lose that argument, we lose the wealth and power of our country. Nothing about America is exceptional unless our conduct as a nation and a people makes us exceptional. Detroit should stand as a stark reminder that the government cannot just magically create value anytime it is needed. American Exceptionalism is not a “Get Out of Stupid Free Card.” We must emulate Ebenezer Scrooge and heed the warning of Detroit, MI. Not everybody on the wrong path is blessed enough to receive a visit from The Ghost of Christmas Future.

COMMENTS

  • reddog53

    Terrific essay and spot on. We cannot continue on this course and expect a different result from Detroit. We must hold what line we can in Washington, even if it means accepting yet another stop gap 3 month effort in order for the next Congress to actually deal with the issue.

  • fredflintlock

    So you’re urging politicians and citizens alike to put down the crack pipe.
    I’ll ponder that during my trip to The Prepper Depot this afternoon.

  • Repair_Man_Jack

    I didn’t have the space to include Office Linebacker saying “You payin, Baby! You Payin!” Maybe another post on another day…

  • Repair_Man_Jack

    OK, you’d like a few more.
    http://blogs.denverpost.com/captured/2011/02/07/captured-the-ruins-of-detroit/2672/
    Have a wonderful day!

  • Repair_Man_Jack

    I don’t *just* blame the government policies. It’s the deluded belief that they could work in the 1st place that is truly the problem.

  • timmcg

    Come on. It’s just government policy? Really

    Pitts has one of the top engineering schools in the world and a terrific public university.

    Don’t you the the brilliance of the engineers trained there had anything to do with it?

    Or do all things good come from the government?

  • Repair_Man_Jack

    Yeah, I guess no U Mich. alums *ever* get engineering jobs in Wayne County or Detroit. Wolverines! Thanks. For. Playing.

  • http://www4.webng.com/rickbull/lostlucky/ rickbull

    ” We must emulate Ebenezer Scrooge and heed the warning of Detroit, MI.
    Not everybody on the wrong path is blessed enough to receive a visit
    from The Ghost of Christmas Future.” A very Dickensian way of saying, “Learn from the mistakes of others: you don’t have time to make them all yourself.”

  • checkmate2012

    I always wanted one of the presidential candidates to use this as an example of what we’ll get with more O and Democratic policies.

    This is your country; this is your country with O and the Dems running it (hope the vid works):

    http://youtu.be/ub_a2t0ZfTs

  • LibertyWins

    This is what happens when a political structure combines the worst of a host of liberal policies with ethnic cronyism. If it were liberalism alone, Detroit would look like Portland, Oregon , Seoul, or Zurich.

  • LibertyWins

    Another problem is that we have no conservative urban philosophy. Why are urban areas so expensive to live? Too much regulation! Imagine what housing costs would be in New York if the market was allowed to meet demand. Hong Kong demonstrates what could be in a conservative city.

  • commonsenseobserver

    I think Enterprise and Empowerment Zones are a good idea, though we must be careful about creating shelters and loopholes.

  • checkmate2012

    They are very telling pics and many have pointed out the flaws of Detroit, CA, IL, etc. That’s why I wanted our candidate to point out, this is our country on drugs, I mean Dem rule of freebies for all. The freebies don’t last and Greece is our future. Shocking pics for sure and Romney did talk about free enterprise but not enough with clear examples. I wanted him to do an ad infront of the Detroit decay. C’est la vie!

  • LibertyWins

    I agree but, why not just free up the whole market within a city? That way we get the best results city-wide. Far too often, empowerment/enterprise zones just gentrify the area. The result is that the poor and their problems just move elsewhere.

  • LibertyWins

    What did you expect in a city known for ethnic cronyism? Pittsburgh was too diverse to become dominated by one ethnic group. That’s what prevented New York, Philly, and Boston from becoming like Detroit, Baltimore, or New Orleans.

  • timmcg

    Clinging to the idea that the government is the one who creates the atmosphere that allows success?

    I’m sure Penn St grads live in Pittsburg.

    But here is the difference. Pittsburgh attracts some of the worlds greatest math, science and engineering minds to do research inside the city limits. Those minds attract some of the world’s best students to study and participate in that research within the city limits.

    From your article, “the region now supports 1,600 technology and research companies, ranging from major campuses for Google, Intel, RAND, Apple[17] and Disney Research to small startups.”

    I don’t read in there that the re-birth of Pittsburgh is from getting non-union manufacturing jobs from the rust belt.

    This is another example of Cargo Cult Economics.

    If you have the Government policies of a successful area, you will get that success elsewhere. Except, success doesn’t come from government policies. It comes from people.

    Detroit was built on good paying jobs for people who weren’t well educated and added their unique value by living near the factories. When the factories moved, living near empty factories wasn’t a benefit.

    Look at the Bay area. Google, Apple. Facebook. Twitter. Intel. the list is endless but is not because the secret sauce for start ups is insanely high property taxes, insanely high sales tax & insanely high state income tax.

    No, it’s because there is a start-up culture going on for decades. Employees who spend their career in serial startups. It attracts some of the worlds most creative minds and the venture capitalists who can back them.

    Not government policies. Not the permission of the of the government.