« BACK  |  PRINT

RS

MEMBER DIARY

Immigration as a Public Charge

Our immigration system is broken, but not in the way that those who utter such declarations believe it to be.  Immigration can be an integral part of a pro-growth economic agenda.  It can also become a public charge.  When liberals lament our broken immigration system, they are suggesting that we don’t admit enough low-skilled immigrants who will become a public charge and vote Democrat.  The reality is just the opposite.

According to Senator Jeff Sessions, only .0084 percent of applicants from 2005-2012 were denied visas under the assumption that they would constitute a public charge.  During the turn of the 20th century, this wouldn’t have been such a concern because we did not have a vast welfare state – one that markets taxpayer-funded services to foreign countries.  Now we do.  Read this Daily Caller exposé and weep:

The United States Department of Agriculture has been working to dispel immigrants’ concerns that getting on Food Stamps will harm their chances of becoming U.S. citizens.

The USDA addresses those fears in Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program, or food stamp, brochures it distributes to Mexican consulates as part of its “partnership” with the Mexican government “to help educate eligible Mexican nationals living in the United States about available nutrition assistance.”

In one portion of the brochure, USDA’s text asks, “If I get on SNAP benefits, will I be a ‘public charge?’” The brochure then answers: “No. You and your family can apply for and receive SNAP benefits without hurting your chance of becoming U.S. citizens.”

So at a time when food stamp usage has surged to astronomical heights, costing over $80 billion per year, we are insisting that food stamp usage does not constitute a public charge.

In addition, the USDA assures illegal immigrants that they can still secure benefits on behalf of their children:

The brochure further advises immigrants that members of their family could qualify for food stamps, even if they don’t.

“If you are not eligible due to your immigration status, your legal immigrant or citizen children may still qualify,” the brochure reads. ”You do not have to provide immigration information about yourself  when you apply for your legal immigrant or citizen children.”

 

This is one thing that is lost on all those Republicans pushing the Dream Act.  Once the children of illegals are granted legal status (and a fast-track to citizenship), they will be able to secure benefits on behalf of their families.  The idea that we can grant citizenship to illegals or children of illegals without ending future anchor babies is absurd.  The idea that we will not balloon the welfare budget is preposterous.  It would take an awful lot of “Dreamers” ‘scoring 4.0 averages at Ivy League schools’ to outweigh this public charge.

Our current immigration system is completely inimical to the financial security of the country.  As the DC notes, 45.3 percent of households headed by a Mexican immigrant reported using food stamps, compared to 4.1 percent of all immigrant household heads and 13.9 percent for the native-born population.  It would be nice if we could feed all 7 billion people in the world, but both liberals and conservatives must admit that we need to prioritize the programs for those who are already here.  Any immigration reform must be built on a merit-based system that is pro-growth, not tendentious to any one region of the world, and won’t add to the budget.

Meanwhile, nobody is taking a leadership role on these much-needed reforms, due to the inane consensus that we must deal with the illegal immigration problem before reforming our legal immigration system.  Only in Washington can they demand we grant citizenship to 12 million illegals before fixing our legal immigration system and before we ensure that there is no future flow of illegal migration.

The lack of leadership on this issue is utterly astounding.  Speaking with a number of conservative offices, it appears that many of them are undereducated on this issue or indifferent to it altogether.  Folks, this is not just some periphery cultural issue.  It is a fiscal issue as well.  In what way is it fiscally conservative to adopt a blueprint that will add millions to the rolls of means-tested programs?  That is the trillion dollar question which remains unanswered by conservatives who support the Obama/Schumer proposals.

COMMENTS

  • mkeprof

    Just a data point in how broken the legal immigration system is – I am a recent immigrant from India (>10 years, <20 years). Folks from India who are graduating from graduate programs from top universities are looking at a 10+ year wait to get a green card. So many of them are unwilling to spend a decade in the uncertainty of whether they will get to live in the country that they are returning back with their excellent educations – only to be our competitors.

    We could have helped the situation tremendously by removing country quotas from the employment based green card process. HR-3012, that tried to do that passed the house with more than 90% votes. It died in Senate because of Senator Grassley's hold on it. A lot of Asian Americans are pretty angry with republicans because of this issue.

  • norris

    Only a few years back if a worker wanted to come to the states he would need an employer to agree to give him work and find a place for him to live. The employer would see that he returned to his native country when the job was finished.

  • adumas

    Might I ask why everyone feels it is somehow their right to immigrate to America? Our country, as prosperous as it may be, cannot support the population of the entire planet.

    Contrary to what those with progressive agendas may claim, our immigration system is not “broken”; one million people are allowed to enter this country each year. The number is limited for a reason, which is to facilitate assimilation into OUR society and culture.

    It is a privilege to be allowed to immigrate to America – not a right. If the wait is too long, there are hundreds of other countries to immigrate to. I wonder if applying their education towards the improvement of their “country of origin” every crossed their minds?

  • mkeprof

    Adumas – Thanks for your response. I will only respond to the content of your response and not the tone.

    Of course immigrating to this country is a tremendous privilege. Most of the reader of this site are here because either they or their ancestors were given the privilege to immigrate here and contribute to the greatest country on earth. I believe it continues to be in the country’s best interest to attract the best and the brightest from around the world that would contribute to future growth of the country.

    The one million figure you mention is misleading – 140K every year receive their Green Card through employment – of those more than half go to dependents of workers – so in effect we give green cards to 70K working professionals each year. You can argue whether that is too much/less – but the 1 million number is not relevant to my comment regarding employment based green card process.

    About other countries to immigrate to – that is already happening. US has about 13% of its population as foreign born. The same number for other immigrant attracting countries: Australia: 20%, Switzerland: 23%, Canada: 19%, New Zealand: 15.5%, Germany: 12% etc. Bangalore is littered with folks with Silicon Valley experience.

  • WmCraig

    Lets separate guest worker from immigration. Lots of people come to this country to make money, take advantage of opportunities so they can go home and live a good life, far better and far younger then if they stayed at home. Not everyone, and perhaps from some countries most are interested in never returning home. I have a niece who married one of Reagans creations. They own a great business and spend the winters when his construction business is idle at home in Mexico. In a nice warm region in a large estate enjoying the benefits of the income he derives in the USA. Oh, and recruiting next years staff. Most of whom never stay in our country,. They come, they work, the enjoy the great fourth of July picnic, then go home. When things work out, they stop coming which is why he has to recruit.

    Eliminate the guest worker, make everyone here a guest worker, with a requirement to prove their identity, residence, fitness and gainful employment, Make them pay taxes as a fee for the right, but not grant them any benefits. Think of it as renting the right to be here, rather than owning it. We are entitled to compensation.

    Then you can deal with the immigrants who want to make this their home. Those that have to get a plane ticket to reach our shores.

  • richardsaunders1

    What makes you Indians think you are entitled to emigrate to the United States?

    When it comes to foreigners, India is one of the most racist countries on the planet.

    Americans don’t have reciprocal rights in India.

    Americans can’t get jobs in India nor can they own property in India.

    Americans can’t own their own businesses outright in India.

    Americans aren’t treated by the Indian bureaucracy equally with Indians.

    How is that anybody who practices racism and discrimination against immigrants in their own countries thinks they have any right to demand anything in the United States?

    Asians don’t have a right be angry with anybody in the US when you Asians are hypocrites and racists when it comes to foreigners in your own home countries.

  • mkeprof

    I respond to only content and not tone. So I refuse to dignify your rant with a rebuttal.

  • westcoastpatriette

    “The lack of leadership on this issue is utterly astounding.” You can say that again. And that is exactly why there is so much pushback from informed citizens every time Congress decides to do something about illegal immigration.

    Those of us who are informed know the true costs of allowing too many poor, illiterate people into the country. FAIR estimates the total costs California incurred from illegal immigration in 2010 at $22 billion. That includes the law enforcement and incarceration aspects as well as the education of the children of illegals whether they were born here or not. And don’t forget how they are “entitled” to Emergency Room care by virtue of the fact that they are on our soil. Yup. Those putting together the comprehensive reform bill never discuss the costs and, indeed, expect Americans to pay for the welfare of illegal immigrants out of what? A duty to feel compassion? Give me a break.

  • richardsaunders1

    Of course you won’t respond to the facts of my post, because the facts might interfere with your hypocrisy.

  • richardsaunders1

    You are not dignified enough to refute any of the facts