« BACK  |  PRINT

RS

MEMBER DIARY

Why Is No One Talking About The War in Afghanistan War and Our Mounting Casualties?

war-casualties.jpg       (If you can not see the image)

There is no topic that raises my blood pressure more than the one pictured above.

It is the War in Afghanistan and the question is: “Why in this election year is no one talking about the war and our mounting casualties?” Nothing, I repeat, nothing makes me angrier.  So if this piece suddenly stops in mid-sentence kindly call 911 because it means I finally blew a gasket and here is why.

On Sunday morning we recorded ABC This Week with George Stephanopoulos. Near the end of the show, George typically posts on screen a list of our best and bravest military service members who have given their all during the past week in Afghanistan.

Yesterday’s segment included about 12 names of the deceased. Now predictably, every week it is at that point in the show when I spring off the couch, flee the room and yell: “I can not watch this, I can not look at their ages. Why are they dying? What are they dying for? Why are we still there? Why is no one talking about this?” 

Will someone in Washington PLEASE try to answer these questions?

How about you folks in the mainstream media taking a short break from asking Mitt Romney to release this old tax returns and focus instead on asking our leaders about this drip drip drip of needless deaths? (For example, there were 36 in May, 42 in June, 29 in July and so far in August there have been at least 6.)

Now, as predicted, I am about to blow a gasket and must stop writing, but quickly before I do, here is a link to the official list of casualties.

Look at their names, look at their ages.  Why is no one talking about trying to end this endless, useless war where these brave, young volunteer patriots are dying in vain?

No one seems to know why we are still there. Perhaps that is why Obama and Romney, as well as officials in both parties running for reelection, are neglecting to mention the war in their campaign ads and speeches.

But every month it is drip drip drip, with more deaths and countless broken bodies and even more with Post-traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) which is a ticking time bomb from within.

Truthfully, if our nation had a draft, there would be protest marches in the streets (instead of Occupy Wall Street) and our elected leaders would be held more accountable for the monthly casualties.

Furthermore, with a draft in place, Americans would force their leaders to take action by either offering up realistic explanations as to why our mission in Afghanistan is vital to our national security interests or voters would demand their leaders take the necessary steps to end this war now.

Could it be the war drags on because these brave solders are volunteers and generally tend to be from the nation’s lower socio-economic strata? It is my bet that if the monthly casualties were more representative of the sons and daughters of the upper classes who rule this nation, then the War in Afghanistan would be more of a hot button issue this election cycle.

Instead, the war is ignored by our leaders, the media — and especially by our Commander in Chief — who is too busy commanding his reelection campaign and his Organizing for America troops to answer the questions I ask every Sunday when I flee the room in anger.

Now more than ever, since Afghanistan is being completely ignored this election cycle, my heart goes out to the families of the fallen who are left asking those questions for the rest of their lives.

This piece is dedicated to them.

Re-posted from PJMedia

 

 

 

COMMENTS

  • Cornholio

    If the mission was to eliminate OBL, and topple the regime that harbored OBL, than the mission has been accomplished and we should bring our young men and women home.

    Trying to extirpate the Taliban’s supporters from Afghanistan is like trying to get the liberals out of San Francisco – short of vaporizing the whole place, it will never happen.

    • audax

      ditto, Cornholio! Not one more drop of American blood in the Middle East. In future, if we feel the need to go into the Muslims areas, couldn’t think of a better place to test our nukes.

  • streiff

    and is pretty shameful. In fact, I think I read this a dKos in 2004.

    1. The draft is a bad idea. It is un-American in the first place and inefficient in the second.

    2. Troops, since 2005, have come from middle income families. But thanks for denigrating them as poor dupes who have no other choices.

    How many young men died in auto accidents last month?

    Go the hell away.

    • Frederick

      It is tragic that our brave soldiers die. It’s equally tragic that this Administration has no real plan for victory in Afghanistan.

      But enacting a draft is the absolute wrong answer. Our soldiers are the best in the world because they volunteer: The want to be there. The right answer is to deal with the idiots in charge and hold them accountable for their failure to lead. That means vote against Obama, Democrats and RINOs in the primaries and in the General election this fall.

    • Cornholio

      I agree completely that the draft is a terrible idea, and that the idea that our military is full of poor, destitute American is insulting.

      But I disagree that it is “leftist” to ask what the hell Obama is still trying to accomplish in Afghanistan, and whether that objective (whatever it is now) is worth the cost in both dollars and American lives.

      • audax

        I agree again Cornolio. The Draft is a bad idea in today’s world. Before I resigned (left the States) they were thinking about implementing planning for a special draft just for medical personal. Don’t know what happened with this.

      • streiff

        she wants to use the war in Afghanistan against Obama the way the left used it against Bush and she wants dead soldiers to be political props.

        • Cornholio

          But I’m not sure the poster was using our deceased soldiers in that manner.

          My read on it was that she was asking why the media no longer seems to care about war casualties now that a liberal is in the White House.

          As noted above, I disagree with the idea of a draft. Moreover, the notion that American soldiers are economically coerced into joining the military because they were raised in poverty is simply offensive and ignores reality.

          But I don’t think there is anything improper in considering the loss of American lives in the cost/benefit analysis of military operations. Any normal person who sees a young child growing up without his father, a mother losing her son, a young man returning from war without his limbs or even a soldier tormented by PTSD, recognizes these as the most substantial and tragic costs of war. Every American should rationally be expected to demand from our government a strong countervailing benefit that outweighs, and ultimately justifies, the costs borne by our troops (as well as the monetary costs borne by the taxpayers).

          Under Bush, our operations in Afghanistan began with a justifiable mission objective – get OBL and topple the Taliban. No one doubts that these objectives outweighed the anticipated costs of the campaign. Whatever criticisms people had about the way the war was managed under Bush and Obama, both of these objectives have now been accomplished, yet we are still paying enormous monetary and human costs as we continue fighting with no clear objective.

          I don’t think our troops would say they are being minimized as political props by Americans who ask why they should still bear the cost of what now seems (at least from my perspective) like an aimless and senseless miliary operation. In fact, I believe our troops would be honored to know that America does not decide to wage war without considering the human costs borne by these brave men and woment.

  • wintermute

    I agree the draft is a terrible idea but your analogy is horrid. Nobody is driving to the 7-11 on their way home from work on my behalf. These men and women are dying on my behalf as a US citizen whether I agree with their orders or not.

    Myra- nobody is talking about Afghanistan b/c 1. the media isnt doing anything that would harm the current commander in chief and 2. its hard to focus on a place on the other side of the planet when you aren’t sure if you’re going to make your next mortgage payment. Id imagine that if we fixed the economy Afghanistan would be up their on our list of things to light our hair on fire about.

    • wintermute

      .

    • streiff

      1. No one is fighting on your behalf. Or my my behalf. Wars are conducted, as Clausewitz said, as an extension of politics. Our military fights to achieve military objectives which in turn further the policies of the United States.

      2. No one has enlisted in the US military since March 2003 and not known they were going to combat. No one has reenlisted since March 2003 without knowing they were going back to combat. These men are naifs who were just plunked down in the middle of Afghanistan. They are professionals. The deserve honor and respect for their sacrifice, not pity and sniveling.

      • wintermute

        Who makes up the body politic of the United States? If you don’t think its the citizens of the United States I am not sure why you are here? If you DO think that, then I am not sure how you justify the belief that we as citizens aren’t responsible for the wars the nation fights. The men and women in the military are fighting wars as a direct result of my political activity. I am partly responsible for sending them there.

        I think you are contradicting yourself. I don’t think I was pitying them or sniveling at them, quite the opposite. And I feel like treating war deaths like car crashes is very flippant and dismissive of their sacrifice. If holding a soldier’s sacrifice for his country above an auto fatality is pitying them I am not sure how exactly I am supposed to respect them.

        I agree that we have a volunteer military so our men and women know what they’re signing up for and should not be treated like little children. But these men and women are going to carry out their orders no matter what. If its a terrible move, its my fault for either supporting policies that started it or not working hard enough to prevent it from happening. You might disagree but I just don’t see how you can not acknowledge responsibility for our military endeavors.

        Please dont ban me.

  • checkmate2012

    I disagree with your points on the draft and echo Streiffs on that matter.

    However, I too am upset with a lack of focus on our mission from this admin. The prez only talks about when asked rather than setting out his goals as if the war doesn’t exist. Sure he gave an end date for political expediency as ususal but that made matters worse.

    And by cutting troop levels to less than the generals wanted and with rapid withdrawl, he has made them easy targets. Last week we found out that the Pentagon won’t approve superior IED tools for no apparent reason except they picked another vendor. Simplifying I know.

    Lastly, I am outraged that the Left isn’t outraged. The constant Sheehan types against Bush are now silent for their chosen one. They are disgusting, obviously, but mostly on this issue when it was soooo important to them before a Leftie got in office.

    I don’t know where you live but suggest writing your senators and representative to get them to push for answers from the admin.

  • emptybucket

    casualty brought G.W. Bush up. For me the big difference is G.W. agonized over each death. He cared, he felt for the families that lost their love one, yet the media bashed and bashed away.

    Now for the last 3-1/2 years the savior of the left has been in office there has hardly been a whisper.

    That Myra is why no one is talking about the casualties of war. The media
    is so busy trying to protect Obama that to mention casualties would, well, they just can’t bear to do it. Don’t watch George S at all, tried once and made me feel ill. Have to wonder why he is naming the dead on a regular basis. What is his point. Obama’s fault, or still blaming G.W.?

    Don’t want the draft activated. Would like to get just a smidgen of compassion out of mr cold fish Obama….but he is too busy thinking about if he had a son, it could have been him gunned down by Zimmerman. AND what if his daughters had been sitting in that theater in Aurora.

    Mr cold fish BTW is Obama, not Romney. I look at Obama and almost feel compelled to spit at the picture. He is an pretentious, arrogant, sniveling brat that McCain and his RINO minions allowed to take the presidency.

    Myra, I read you all the time, know your heart aches for these dying soldiers. The Wounded Warrios Project is a most worthy cause if you’ve got a few extra bucks. The way some of our soldiers come back home so maimed is such a heartache.

  • emptybucket

    also sorry for the spit comment. Got to learn to control myself.

    • checkmate2012

      It’s hardly offensive IMO. I just mute or turn the channel and save the screen!

      BTW, you can call me check as the regulars do now. I’m just hesitant to call you empty! It just doesn’t seem right. How about e’bucket or empty’b (don’t like that one either for obvious reasons).

      Some names are just too long, like mine, so please advise if I should stick with the full name as I don’t want to insult anyone :) I kind of like e’bucket or the longname. Your call.

      • emptybucket

        n/t

        • checkmate2012

          e’bucket was way better that the other way around. But I can still write the full name if you prefer.

      • PowerToThePeople

        At least I know where I stand with you as I have never been asked what I want to be called in future responses. :)

        Just in case anyone wants to know, I prefer being called………..

        grandPoohBahofjackassconservatismwithaspeckleofsnidelacedwithmomentsofgeniusbutusuallyjustenoughIQtogetby

        Hope you can remember my preferred name.

        • checkmate2012

          else. How insensitive of me! Can I PLEASE still use PttP instead of your preference:

          grandPoohBahofjackassconservatismwithaspeckleofsnidelacedwithmomentsofgeniusbutusuallyjustenoug

          I know you’re about to check me on the tentacles comment I just wrote but I can’t promise to remember the whole preferred name. GrandPoohBah is easy tho’!

          • PowerToThePeople

            but since I view myself with such grandeur, everyone else must use my full self made name.

          • checkmate2012

            Good luck on getting the rest of this crew to use your new name. Although it is shorter than supercalidocious!

            BTW, I’ve been trying tinypics and so far, no luck. I haven’t registered for an acct and perhaps that’s the problem. Still trying :)

          • PowerToThePeople

            It is so hard to work through these types of things by typing. Too bad we live so far apart, I would just drop by and show you in person.

            Oh well, we can only work with what we have.

            Let me know what you have tried and what issues you are having. I will look back in the morning and if we can not get this worked out, I will film me doing it, post it to youtube, and then post it here.

            I will look back at this post by 10est and will leave a response or let you know I am going to record the process. We will get you going one way or the other.

          • PowerToThePeople

            works without one.

          • checkmate2012

            tomorrow (don’t want to threadjack) so don’t go to the taping trouble yet. Thank you!

  • Pingback: Information

  • Pingback: Salvatore Capek

  • Pingback: Paul Cozzy