« BACK  |  PRINT

RS

MEMBER DIARY

Successful Small Business Owner on the Public-Sector Union Kerfuffle

My dad began working for himself as a carpenter and cabinet maker the year I was born, when he was 25 years old. Thirty-two years and four kids later, Crowe’s Cabinets, Inc., is a successful, small, *non-union* cabinet shop just outside of Youngstown, Ohio. I don’t believe he has ever employed more than 10 people at a time. Through the recession of late they haven’t grown at the clip that they had grown for the four years prior, but they didn’t shrink, either.

And did I mention it’s in Youngstown? As in, the city Bob Hagan represents in the Ohio General Assembly?

You remember Bob, right? He was the one who used “Macaca” “Buckwheat” as a pejorative on his Facebook page, but insisted it wasn’t racist. In making his defense he said “They are so full of s—” and dropped “teabagger.” More recently he was one of the speakers who ranted like an angry, well, union thug at a rally held at Youngstown State University in opposition to Senate Bill 5, which would significantly curtail collective bargaining for public unions in Ohio. At one point during his rant Hagan instructed all those who support SB5 to “kiss my union ass.”

Charming fellow, as you can see.

On the other side of the ledger, Governor John Kasich, who would lose an election in Youngstown to Stalin, has been to Youngstown three times in the past month, and took a great interest in a recent shooting near Youngstown State University. Note the comments in that video from Youngstown’s Democrat mayor, who ran as an independent D against the Democrat-nominee, one Bob Hagan.

The other day, Kasich was in the Youngstown area where he gave a speech about his efforts to bring the state’s budget under control. He talked specifically about things that were being done at the state level to assist the local economy, and cited the GM plant north of town, where union concessions helped the plant win the Chevy Cruze, as an example of how unions and management can work together to help the company flourish, to everyone’s benefit.

In response to Kasich’s speech and everything going on my dad sent an email to our family list which I have edited and have encouraged him to submit to the Youngstown Vindicator. I present it here (in part because I doubt the Vindicator will print it). I think he crystalizes well the dynamic that we are seeing in the battles in Wisconsin, Indiana, Ohio, and in Washington.

Governor Kasich spoke well. I’m thankful he didn’t use language like what Bob Hagan has been using lately. Hagan should realize he lowers himself, and our area, when he rants like that.

I may not agree with Hagan much, but I need him to be the best representative he can be for me and you and ALL people in this valley.

He might come across better if he cleans up his choice of expressions (“teabaggers” was uncalled for).

He might even consider a leadership role in admitting that maybe the government employees could possibly, just maybe, reconsider the fact that they have not been subjected to the budget axe quite like their private sector counterparts. Things like accumulated sick pay, personal days, etc. need to be eliminated (can you say Wendy Webb?). I have many friends, union and non-union, who work for all manner of contractors. We all see this issue from the same side–not union vs nonunion, but public vs. private.

Maybe Hagan would gain a lot of insight by opening a business of his own, hiring some employees, and try to make a profit with absolutely no government help. If he is as passionate about helping the working man as he says, he could join the ranks of the private sector employers and deal with EPA; Workers’ Comp; new and exotic taxes and fees; sending in required reports on time or facing penalties; dealing with government employees who never give a straight answer, but know how to levy fines; lazy employees who, when they must be laid off, still get money from the employer through unemployment benefits (NOTE: I believe MOST employees are hard-working and honest); making payroll even though you are waiting to get paid; health insurance; etc,etc. For how many people would he “create” a job?

I’m not attacking anyone. I know there are honest, sincere people—and unscrupulous people—on both sides of the issue. This economy is hurting all of us. But I believe that government should spend less, and regulate less. Those are two of the major reasons businesses are hurting.

After all, last time I looked, small business is where most people work. Small business IS the engine that makes this country run. Everything else, especially government, is the lead weight that slows us down.

Bring jobs to America by reducing government interference, which will reduce the cost of doing business.

Paul Crowe
President
Crowe’s Cabinets, Inc.

COMMENTS

  • Mike Ferguson
  • kowalski

    We need more people like your Dad in the world to write things like this. For more than 30 years my father has been self employed and I’m part of a 2 person business with him doing printing and direct mail in Massachusetts. It’s a profitable business because we do our own maintenance and we know what the real costs are. We work hard to make money – for our CLIENTS.

    We don’t need to government to get on our backs more, we’ve already gotten on our own backs: we use green printing wherever possible, we use energy-efficient printing all the time. No high volatiles, and intelligent machines that shut themselves down when they’re not being used. We’re extremely frugal with resources. We waste virtually nothing, including the cardboard boxes our paper is shipped in, which we donate to a local charity.

    We work weekends and we work holidays. My father hasn’t taken a vacation in more than 25 years, and I haven’t taken one since 1994. The small businesses in America like your father’s and mine are the backbone of this country and it’s time the government got the boot off the backbone.

  • kowalski

    The people of America are here with the expertise and the willingness and the ability and the self-reliance. We need government to be on our side, on the side of people who do everything they can think of to keep things moving when other people wouldn’t.

    We’ve largely survived this recession and we’ve done it while making a profit for our clients at every step of the process. That’s required sacrifice on our part, but we’ve done a lot of great work for a lot of good causes, and we don’t intend to quit.

    It sounds to me like you and your father are cut from the same cloth, and that’s the real fabric of America.

  • kowalski

    For a lot of small business owners in the past three years, I consider “success” equivalent to “survival.”

    Because that has been the reality. If you’re surviving in your small business right now in America and have been for the past three years, eating home made spaghetti and not driving your car, you’re a success. That’s how bad it’s been.

    It’s really time we had a change in thinking at the Federal level about how in the world we’re going to honestly change the business climate in this country so that America can once again become an economic powerhouse without resorting to idiotic tactics like protectionism.

    There are things that can and should be done. I’ve referenced them before. The last thing we should be doing is making America look More Like Michigan. I intend to keep quoting this article until something really happens in America:

    http://philip.greenspun.com/politics/economic-recovery

  • kowalski

    The most important thing for America is to capture investment and keep it and use it to build wealth, not just wealth that’s here already but also foreign wealth.

    We do not provide a climate right now in this country in which any investor, foreign or dometic, feels comfortable or even reasonably sure about their ROI without a government bailout in the background.

    If we want to reduce unemployment by several million people in the next few years and really put America back to work, this country absolutely must reduce the uncertainty of investment here.

    Barack Obama gives that lip service to the Chamber of Commerce; he talks to them about going around the world and saying: “Invest in America” but those people are not stupid: they see that his actions so far are doing nothing but discouraging them from doing so.

    The people of America will continue to suffer until our President changes from lip service to real action, and it’s going to be at the expense of his base, which is why he will not do it. Instead his strategy is to blame Republicans for doing the heavy lifting and then take the credit.

    Watch.