« BACK  |  PRINT

RS

MEMBER DIARY

Small Victory, Card Check Slashed from Bill

We can at last mark one small victory against the Orwellian named Employee Free Choice Act (EFCA). The card check feature of the bill has been successfully cut out of the bill in the Senate.

The card check feature would have allowed unions to eliminate the ages old democratic practice of allowing prospective union employees the benefit of a secret ballot to vote “yes” or “no” for organizing their work place.

Removal of this feature of the EFCA proves that our Senators can be moved by pressure from constituents. But, let’s not imagine that the war is now won. This one small victory still leaves a bill jammed full of anti-business, economy killing aspects and we need to keep the pressure on to kill this mess.

The card check feature is nothing compared to the forced arbitration aspect of the bill, so we still have work to do.

But even this victory is not a sure thing. As Service Employees International Union President Andy Stern says, it could go right back in later.

As we have said from day one, majority sign-up is the best way for workers to have the right to choose a voice at their workplace. The Employee Free Choice Act is going through the usual legislative process, and we expect a vote on a majority sign-up provision in the final bill or by amendment in both houses of Congress.

In other words, Stern thinks that once the bill gets to the reconciliation phase where the Senate version and the version from the House of Representatives come together, they will slip that card check feature right back in when they think no one is looking.

That’s the underhandedness of Congress, folks. Nothing is ever a victory won. The forces of good must fight those Democratic Party forces of darkness every day.

So, let’s keep the pressure on those Congressmen. This bill is bad for workers, bad for business, and bad for government. Let’s keep working to kill it.

COMMENTS

  • bk

    Things can always appear magically in conference reports.

    • http://www.examiner.com/x-1597-Charlotte-Law--Politics-Examiner Mike gamecock DeVine

      just as Health Care Reform and the Budget and Cap and Trade. Any of these, by themselves has such potential.

      • bk

        until you see what comes out of conference. If it gets slipped back in and the Dems love to do, it could rear its ugly head again. And correct me if I’m wrong, but conference reports can’t be filibustered, can they? I believe at that point you get a simple majority vote on the compromise bill.

        • IJB

          …And that’s my recollection too.

          It’s only conference reports on budget reconciliations that can’t be filibustered.

          • bk

              

  • Richard Mullins

    In this this I mean the house and senate calender. They have a targeted adjournment of October 30th. We really need to stall legislation.

  • http://andrightlyso.com/ civil_truth

    This is a point that Art has made for months.

    The point being that expanding interest arbitration to the private sector expands into a new direction the heavy hand of government on how people operate a private business. At its best, it will cripple business operations by putting it into a straitjacket fo the next two years (at least). At worse, behind-the-scene government manipulation of the process can drive an unfavored business (or business owner) right out of business – opening up the doors to another avenue for government thuggery and intimadation of political opponents.

    Not to mention, once the precedent of interest arbitration is set, it will much easier to expand this in future legislation at a calculated pace – the enpoint being government setting wages and conditions of employment for all workers.

    • http://www.examiner.com/x-1597-Charlotte-Law--Politics-Examiner Mike gamecock DeVine

      and in secret ballots, the 40+ year trend of less unions in the private sector continues.

      • Swamp_Yankee

        You need collective bargaining power first.

        Keep card check away and do what Colorado is doing, which is to bolster its right to work status and in some weird way a bill without card check could bolster Red States in that it will be even harder to conduct business in Blue states, while Red States attract even more business.

        That’s my kind of wealth redistribution.

      • http://andrightlyso.com/ civil_truth

        The “compromises” in the bill tilt the playing field quite sharply, and will escalate the battle. While card check is the front door, the bills opens up the back door much wider.

        Again, as Art points out, right now, a new union can be subject to decertification at one year (I think) – which means that if the union isn’t able to negotiate a favorable contract by collective bargaining, the workers will become quickly disenchanted by the results of their union choice and be ready to vote out the union at the earliest opportunity.

        Under interest arbitration, the arbitrator will almost always impose a contract that is far more generous to workers than they could have achieved by collective bargaining. Plus the argreements are two-years, which means that the workers should be pleased by the results and become comfortable with the union, which will make them so much harder to dislodge.

    • http://andrightlyso.com/ civil_truth

      …is sort of comparable to deciding whether hanging, cyanide, or beheading is the worst method of execution. All are very fatal to the victim.