This Must Be What It Felt Like


Some other changes of power.

This is a risky diary. Any of our Lefty friends who read it will catastrophize it and misrepresent it. I’m really not talking about issues, but rather about interests and worldviews. If all you know about 1860 came from a government school textbook, you believe that the American Civil War was about the abolition or preservation of slavery. It wasn’t. Without the slavery question there would not have been secession and a war, but the causes were much more than slavery.

Admiral Raphael Semmes, Commander of the CSS Alabama, once said, probably not originally, but he’s the one who’s quoted, that the Yankees believe that they must toil to make the World turn. Mid-19th Century America was religious but not so much “churched,” especially in The South and West, West being the lands along the Mississippi in those days. The Northeast was churched and they mostly believed that Americans were all sinners who should be writhing in the hands of an angry God. Almost since the founding, they had fomented ism after ism in their attempt to prove the notion of the perfectability of man and of salvation by works. Nothing has changed. They have replaced the Christian God with a witches’ brew of post-modernism, atheisim, and communism, but they’re still the same narrow, rigid, and xenophobic people they were when they were burning witches.

The South was a wild land. Even where Tara existed, the family had probably only held the land for fifty years or so. Inside or close to those white-columned mansions, what few there actually were, was the rough-hewn log cabin that daddy or grand-daddy built when he first got the place for his service in the Revolution or simply because he was lucky in one of the land lotteries. I share both of those heritages.

The South and Southerners had been under attack from the Northeastern elites almost since the Founding. They said the same things about Southerners then that they say about Sarah Palin today; read Olmstead. The Southerners over time developed a seething hatred for all things Yankee. 85% of Southerners didn’t own slaves, but 85% is a good approximation of the number of them who hated Yankees. They didn’t hate them over slavery, they hated them over arrogance.

In the Fall of 1860 Southerners faced the possibility, even probability, that a President and a party would take power in this Country that in the main hated them and did not have to take their interests into consideration. Were Abraham Lincoln and the Republicans to win, they would do it without a single Southern state. If they had a majority in the Congress, they would have it without a single true Southerner. When Northern Republican hegemony was established in the election of 1860, The South said, “you will run roughshod only over our dead bodies.”

Nothing much changes. Look at the electoral map. America today is divided into the lands below the Mason-Dixon Line, Texas, and The Territories in Red and New England, the Middle Atlantics, the Old Northwest, and the Pacific Coast in Blue. That’s about where it was in 1860 except the Middle Atlantic states were a little more in play; they didn’t have ACORN and the mob in those days.

So, it is entirely possible that on November 5th we in the Red States will find ourselves governed by people who hate and despise us, people who consider us a bitter, ignorant, and rebellious rabble who must be “perfected,” whose consciousness must be raised. If Barack Obame is President and we do not on 5 November have enough votes in the Senate to filibuster the wild fantasies of the unions, the community activists, and the trial lawyers, we face subjugation. They will NOT adopt a “New Tone.”

I know the thoughts of that period pretty well. My gg/grandfather was an educated and politically active man and I have many of his letters and other writings. He was a friend and adherent of former Georgia Governor Herschel Johnson and shared Johnson’s belief in Union and opposition to secession. Once secession came, he tried everything that a well-connected man could try to avoid The War, but ultimately he died in Mahone’s counterattack at The Crater.

There are two groups of people in this Country who see America in irreconcilably different ways. I would NOT live in a Blue State, maybe I could not. If the Blue States establish a political and legal hegemony over my Country, it isn’t my Country any more. That must be what it felt like in the Fall of 1860.


Category:

RSS feed

63 Comments Leave a comment

Relax

LAWizard (Diary) Tuesday, October 14th at 2:41AM EDT (link)

I think you’re getting a little too obsessed with colors and lines on a map. Even in most red states the democrat receives ~45% of the vote. The reverse is true for blue states. I imagine those sizable minorities don’t feel it is no longer their country.

There’s two candidates: one winner and one loser. Obviously it sucks to be on the losing side, but (and here’s the brilliant part) in just a few years we’re going to do it all over again.

In the meantime take pride in the fact you live in the greatest democracy in the world.

 

Leftie characterization of your comment

bk (Diary) Tuesday, October 14th at 2:58AM EDT (link)

“Achance equates today’s southern conservatives with slave owners.”

Seriously though, it’s all part of the vibes given off by the O-bots….
- We don’t need to “agree to disagree” when we can force our views on you.
- Disagree by putting up a sign or putting on a bumper sticker? Expect signs to get stolen or vandalized and cars with such blasphemy to get keyed or worse.
- Disagree via talk radio? Not for long, once we get the “fairness” doctrine in place along with the muscle to enforce it.
- Dare to speak against us? Prepare to be labelled a racist hate-monger and have your life trashed by our army of O-bots and, in the most severe cases, our battalion (or is it a brigade?) of lawyers.

Obama and his crew give me the creeps.

 

Amen, Achance.

stang (Diary) Tuesday, October 14th at 4:57AM EDT (link)

Dennis Prager has this up this morning at WND.com.

2 irreconcilable Americas

For most of my life I have believed, in what I now regard as wishful thinking, that the right and left wings have essentially the same vision for America, that it’s only about ways to get there in which the two sides differ. Right and left share the same ends, I thought.

That is not the case. For the most part, right and left differ in their visions of America, and that is why they differ on policies.

Right and the left do not want the same America.

snip

For these and other reasons, calls for a unity among Americans that transcends left and right are either naive or disingenuous. America will be united only when one of them prevails over the other. The left knows this. Most on the right do not. (emphasis mine)

Prager has consistently been one of the most thoughtful voices around and makes a compelling argument that buttresses the points you have made here.

“When men yield up the privilege of thinking, the last shadow of liberty quits the horizon.”

Thomas Paine

“Whenever the legislators endeavor to take away and destroy the property of the people, or to reduce them to slavery under arbitrary power, they put themselves into a state of war with the people, who are thereupon absolved from any farther obedience, and are left to the common refuge which God hath provided for all men against force and violence.”

John Locke

Any other time I'd agree with you.

Achance (Diary) Tuesday, October 14th at 7:55AM EDT (link)

The lines have increasingly hardened, especially in the House. The “safe districts” of the last couple of reapportionments have made “moderate Democrat” almost a thing of the past. I say almost only because in ’06 they went after “safe” Republican seats with faux Republicans who though they ran like Republicans, often even to the right of them, they vote with the Pelosi-led caucus. Those members have to moderate themselves somewhat or face the wrath of their district.

I’ve seen what it is like when Lefties get back in power after a time in the wilderness. They were out of executive power for three gubernatorial terms here: Sheffield through Hickel (both Sheffield and Cowper were Democrats but decidely of the moderate sort, certainly more conservative than “Republican” Jay Hammond who preceded them and who let the Lefties in the Legislature run riot). The first couple of years of Knowles were simply a feeding frenzy even though the Rs controlled the Legislature. Democrats are far more willing and able to use executive power than are Republicans. If the Ds get BHO and a Senate that cannot be reliably filibustered, they WILL remake this Country with an avalanche of legislation and executive actions not seen since the early days of the New Deal.

In Vino Veritas

 
 

Very well said

johnCV (Diary) Tuesday, October 14th at 8:43AM EDT (link)

You have put many of my thoughts on our current national situation into an apt historical context.

The Left/progressives are at war with the Right/traditional and they are in the process of excalating from a ‘cold war’ to a hot war. Unfortunately, most on the Right do not even realize that we are at war at all. It’s ironic in that the Right has the same blinders on that the Left wears when viewing our external conflicts with radical islam or other despots around the globe (the ‘surely we can talk through this’ mentality). The Right believe that we are all Americans first and we can work for our common good. This has become impossible as the current crop of Leftists view America as inherantly evil and must be torn down and reformed to thier image. How do you negotiate with some one who wishes to destroy you (or everthing you belive in)?

Achance, your use of the word subjugation is a perfect descritpion of what we can expect. Just looking at how pelosi and reid have run the congress over the last 2 years provides ample evidence of the kind of open and accessible government those who don’t share thier utopian worldview can expect.

My mother and grandmother were in nazi Germany in the 1930′s. My grandmother ofter said that the people of the US had no idea how easy it would be for a dictator to come to power here. I never really appreciated that view until recent events.

I have never before felt so without any represention and I share your concerns. Gramsci provided a brilliant master plan.

 

I have one thing to say to you

shooflyguy68 Tuesday, October 14th at 9:16AM EDT (link)

This could have been written by any random Leftie from 2001-2006. All you have to do is reverse the Left and Right fears/talking points/paranoia. We’ll be fine.

 

Dude, just start calling for impeachment.

birdmojo (Diary) Tuesday, October 14th at 9:37AM EDT (link)

Once you see what a unitary executive looks like when he’s a Democrat, you won’t be able to scream “Checks and Balances” loudly enough.

Man is free at the moment he wishes to be. –Voltaire

No, shooflyguy68, we won't be fine.

Achance (Diary) Tuesday, October 14th at 10:14AM EDT (link)

You’ll think you’re fine for a little while as you giddily celebrate The Coming. Then you’ll find that this wasn’t your Salvation after all, you were merely a useful idiot, no longer special, just another faceless, nameless member of the mass.

These are not Democrats in the sense of old trade unionists and mushy white liberals. The old trade unionists were drummed out of Party leadership in the wake of McGovern: too conservative and too anti-communist. The old-fashioned white liberals who haven’t recoiled from the coercive utopianism and become Republicans are merely tolerated in the Party and form the bulk of the white useful idiots. The interest groups form and organize the mass but even the leadership of the interest groups are in the main expendable; to be given positions but not power.

BHO is merely an attractive relatively blank slate who can act as a mouthpiece and focal point for hard leftists who’ve been planning this for decades. They’ve followed Gramsci’s precription and taken over the schools, the bureaucracies, the non-profits, and, especially, the unions. If you would find Bill Ayer’s less agressive comrades from the old SDS, look to the “community organizers” and the staffs of the public employee unions.

I was pretty comfortable as an old-fashioned Democrat even into the Seventies. Likewise, I was pretty comfortable as an old-fashioned trade unionist – still am. By the early eighties, the Party made it clear that it had no place for either and if you were one of those, you could join the mass of useful idiots or leave. Likewise, the trade unions were supplanted in the AFL-CIO by the ever more leftist public employee unions. I left, and you’ll find several others on this board who share a similar experience.

If on 5 November the people really running the Democrat Party look around and find that the dreams they had smoking dope in college dorms in the Sixties have come true, they will do what they have always planned. There WILL be a revolution. The takeover of the US that forty years ago most thought would require an armed struggle will have been accomplished by the peaceful means advocated by Gramsci with occasional assistance with less peaceful means by various activist groups of useful idiots. Unlike “compassionate conservatives,” they will make good use of their power and take as many steps as possible as quickly as possible to make sure that they hold on to that power. America in 2013 will be as different from America in 2008 as was the America of 1866 from that of 1860.

In Vino Veritas

Actually, based on what we've made him retract so far...

Moe Lane (Diary) Tuesday, October 14th at 10:25AM EDT (link)

…a hypothetical President Obama divorced from a Hard Left Congress would be very useful for us. He’s very amenable to being bullied, it seems.

And who, birdmojo, would pay attention to those calls?

janis (Diary) Tuesday, October 14th at 10:30AM EDT (link)

If the lefties control all three branches, I guarantee that impeachment would never be a possibility.

These people will have our obedience one way or another. Look at how they deal with “dissent” now. Threats, violence, and profanity directed at anyone who dares to question Obama and his minions.

Achance is right–if they win, we’re screwed. They MUST not win, not if we are to remain a free people.

From where I sit...

birdmojo (Diary) Tuesday, October 14th at 10:33AM EDT (link)

Clinton was the best Republican President since Reagan and Bush was the best Democratic President since FDR.

I don’t know that Obama will be quite so easily bullied when Hillary is just another senator.

I certainly don’t know that Obama will be quite so easily bullied if he has any coattails at all.

I worry that he voted for FISA not because he was bullied into it… but because he can’t wait to get his hands on it.

I suspect, in a year or so, we’ll know for sure.

Unless, of course, McCain wins. I’ll write an essay explaining how silly it was to think that Republicans might need Fiscal Conservative support (let alone the Libertarians!) to win an election.

That’s not the essay I’ve been working on in notepad at home, however.

Man is free at the moment he wishes to be. –Voltaire

The tools he'll have in his hands...

birdmojo (Diary) Tuesday, October 14th at 10:34AM EDT (link)

Will have been forged by Republicans.

Man is free at the moment he wishes to be. –Voltaire

Right now he's very amenable

Achance (Diary) Tuesday, October 14th at 10:34AM EDT (link)

to anything that he calculates to be helpful to his becoming President. If he’s President, he doesn’t have to be amenable to anything and if he falters, his masters will set him straight.

In Vino Veritas

I'd agree, birdmojo, with your assessment

Achance (Diary) Tuesday, October 14th at 11:16AM EDT (link)

of Clinton at the policy level. Of course, he was helped in his “republicanism” by a Republican Congress for much of his tenure. That said, he did incalculable damage to the Republic and to Republicans at the administrative level, unfortunately assisted by the Republican proclivity for porking.

First, he fired everyone in the federal government even suspected of having had a Republican thought. In the guise of Algore’s streamlining iniatives, he removed most of the controls over money, people, and stuff in the government – an initiative replicated in many states as well. Then he set up all sorts of grants and contract schemes to devolve federal functions to the states or to the “private sector.” Republicans couldn’t resist that one either. So, all the left wing non-profits have nice federal contracts to keep them going and form a nice place for out of power Democrats to hang out, organize, and draw a nice salary. He was able to creat all sorts of grant funded sinecures in state and local governments, which also give a nice place to park Democrats who need a job and who can organize sleeper cells inside Republican governments. DHSS, HUD, DOL, and DOEd have become an ATM for leftwing advocacy groups, e.g., ACORN. Of course, the Republican Congress couldn’t see past the money coming to their states, so they helped him do it.

Unfortunately, in his two terms, GWB was content to place a thin veneer of his appointees over the federal government and has done almost nothing to interrupt the federal money pipeline to his enemies. Give me a good fifty person audit team and some GTR books and I’ll put half the non-profit and union leaders in the Country in jail!

In Vino Veritas

Oh Come On

LAWizard (Diary) Tuesday, October 14th at 12:48PM EDT (link)

You sound like the liberals in ’04 who vowed to go to Canada. Sure there may be various policy decisions and laws passed we disagree with; elections have consequences. But it’s not the end of the world or the end of the country. I promise you.

In the meantime you might as well work double time for McCain.

We have underestimated the left since the 30's...

stang (Diary) Tuesday, October 14th at 1:21PM EDT (link)

and continue to do so at our own peril.

The left does not play by our rulebook, they play by theirs. Their overarching purpose is the acquisition of and exercise of power. They know they must destroy capitalism and Judeo-Christian ethics and morality to make the imposition of their utopian world view even remotely possible.

See here,

http://www.americanthinker.com/2007/02/cultural_marxism.html

and here.

http://www.academia.org/lectures/lind1.html

Your promise does not reassure me.

“Whenever the legislators endeavor to take away and destroy the property of the people, or to reduce them to slavery under arbitrary power, they put themselves into a state of war with the people, who are thereupon absolved from any farther obedience, and are left to the common refuge which God hath provided for all men against force and violence.”

John Locke

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

GC HIGHLY RECOS - and Martin Knight, this column will explain why I am wrong if we lose

Mike gamecock DeVine (Diary) Tuesday, October 14th at 2:15PM EDT (link)

A loss would be a combination of

manifestation of white guilt that is larger because McCain doesn’t present a clear enough distinction on economics

Achance’s theme which is also much of the theme of Prager today and his two Americas column – see link below – which I agree with both, but would also add that

a loss would mean that the babyboom left did not yet reach its population peak despite all the abortions

and then finally

voter fraud

prager column

more later

Mike DeVine’s Examiner.com and Charlotte Observer columns
“One man with courage makes a majority.” – Andrew Jackson

 

The only thing that can heal the divide in our nation is a return to true federalism!

Vaughn Harold (Diary) Tuesday, October 14th at 2:47PM EDT (link)

Otherwise I would imagine things will turn volitale when free men once again decide that they will not be lorded over by that distant corrupt institution that we currently call the Federal government.

 

60% of Americans Say They Are Conservative or Somewhat Conservative: Rush Limbaugh

Strelnikov (Diary) Tuesday, October 14th at 2:51PM EDT (link)

Rush Limbaugh quoted a poll today – and he said the results have been constant for many years – that 60 % of Americans describe themselves as conservative or at least somewhat so.

Describing yourself as liberal was in the 30% range.

If the respondents know what “conservative: is supposed to mean, how does Big Brobama have any chance?

Especially after his Robin-Hood economics answer to the plumber in Toledo yesterday?

As of November 4, 2008, the Code Words will be: “Klaatu – Borada – Nikto!”

 

Fundemental Change

Michael DeWeese (Diary) Tuesday, October 14th at 3:09PM EDT (link)

New Deal II

kllyhlls (Diary) Tuesday, October 14th at 3:20PM EDT (link)

I heard some guy yesterday talking about how we need Obama (paraphrasing)”to create ‘The New Deal II’ to bring us out of the new depression like the first New Deal did”.

I can’t blame the guy too much for thinking that; I was taught that in College too.

Still.. scary.

Clinton benefited the Republicans for reasons that will not exist for Obama in 2009.

nogyro35 (Diary) Tuesday, October 14th at 3:25PM EDT (link)

I voted for Clinton in 92, while I was attending college. I watched what he did because as a Democrat I was excited to see what a Democrat President would do.

His policies in 93-94 were a taste of what I expect from Obama.

Just 2 examples of many.

  1. His housing policies eventually led to our current problems with Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac.

  2. His dismantling of our intelligence agencies tied our hands pre-911.

All this was done with a Democratic Congress. He was only benefitial to us after the Republicans took Congress.

Looking back at what horribly destructive actions Clinton took in his first two years should make all of America fear what Obama would do if given the power.

That and I believe Obama thinks of himself as some sort of Messiah. Clinton thought of himself as a movie star.

If the nominee were HRC, I'd agree with you.

Achance (Diary) Tuesday, October 14th at 3:51PM EDT (link)

We wouldn’t like her even as much as we liked her husband, but both he and she are pretty traditional Democrats and very self-interested. Life would go on, we’d carp from the minority and put our plans in place to become the majority. Not much would really change on Main Street. One thing is real about The One; he is a different kind of political animal and is as close to a Manchurian Candidate as you get in the real world. They WILL seize power and run with it if they have a filibuster-proof Senate.

In Vino Veritas

As much as I rail against the bankruptcy of the dem party, moral and

Mike gamecock DeVine (Diary) Tuesday, October 14th at 6:31PM EDT (link)

intellectual, esp the leadership, and despite Hillary’s Alinsky past, her exp with Bill and his DLCism and her exp in the campaign, does present I whole OTHER

Obama is like electing a mobster

Mike DeVine’s Examiner.com and Charlotte Observer columns
“One man with courage makes a majority.” – Andrew Jackson

agreed, he seems to be timid due to ignorance and teachable

Mike gamecock DeVine (Diary) Tuesday, October 14th at 6:33PM EDT (link)

a t some level

I suspect his arrogance will take over and he will over=-reach to the left

esp, if he is elected, the press will one day turn on him and use all this stuff we have dug up

Mike DeVine’s Examiner.com and Charlotte Observer columns
“One man with courage makes a majority.” – Andrew Jackson

I do see an outside chance he would turn

Mike gamecock DeVine (Diary) Tuesday, October 14th at 6:34PM EDT (link)

pragmatic so as to get re-elected

Mike DeVine’s Examiner.com and Charlotte Observer columns
“One man with courage makes a majority.” – Andrew Jackson

yes, I had even seen a chance that liberals would see the utility of federalism

Mike gamecock DeVine (Diary) Tuesday, October 14th at 6:36PM EDT (link)

as it would empower them to control things in their big blue cities, but if Obama is elected, that chance is probably over given the sup ct appts

Mike DeVine’s Examiner.com and Charlotte Observer columns
“One man with courage makes a majority.” – Andrew Jackson

he may not have a chance - we will not know

Mike gamecock DeVine (Diary) Tuesday, October 14th at 6:37PM EDT (link)

until election day and if he does win, I would not rule out mass fraud

Mike DeVine’s Examiner.com and Charlotte Observer columns
“One man with courage makes a majority.” – Andrew Jackson

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

an interesting and risky diary Achance

pilgrim (Diary) Tuesday, October 14th at 7:36PM EDT (link)

You bring up an interesting comparison between the southern man in 1860 being no less demoralized than a conservative man in 2008.

Here’s the rub IMO, this being demoralized has been an ongoing project of enemies to the US for decades. Everybody who has received a public school education or reads the NYT, WaPo, and LAT, or watches news anchors on NBC, ABC, and CBS has been indoctrinated to believe the US is most responsible for all that is wrong in the world. And what really makes me nervous is what phase comes next after the demoraliztion phase.


Activists Taking Action: Unified Patriots

I am afraid I have to agree with you...

Aaron Weatherford (Diary) Tuesday, October 14th at 7:57PM EDT (link)

I am sitting in my econ class right now listening to my liberal professor talk about how labor is the key to our economy and we must create more government programs making sure our workers are healthy, educated, and motivated. I asked him what government programs he would recomend and he said this is a econ class and not a political policy class.

“My friends, it is coming to my attention that a great number of you are fearful of an Obama win. I must stress that you have nothing to fear from Obama winning the election as I have the greatest confidence he would be a most benevolent dictator.” – Hopefully John McCain

Like the leftists' 2004 secession fantasies

gensec (Diary) Tuesday, October 14th at 11:14PM EDT (link)

You sound like the liberals in ’04 who vowed to go to Canada

No, it’s even crazier than that, more like the leftist kooks in 2004 talking of partitioning America (kinda’ like Biden wanted to partition Iraq). The explicit comparison here is with the sore losers after Lincoln’s election to the Presidency, who subsequently tried to violently secede from the United States. This is as silly as the partition maps some leftists were circulating after Kerry’s 2004 defeat. Maybe even sillier, because for most of those leftists it was stated as a joke, however bitter that humor was.

Yes it will truly suck if Obama is elected, enough to make us nostalgic for Bill Clinton, but not having a better way to say it than a comparison to the start of the Civil War is just nuts.

Amen

Finrod (Diary) Tuesday, October 14th at 11:27PM EDT (link)

Give me a good fifty person audit team and some GTR books and I’ll put half the non-profit and union leaders in the Country in jail!

This is exactly why I want you as President McCain’s Chief of Staff.

PETA and the ASPCA are pure evil. See here and here.

Thinking by analogy is a valuable skill, gensec.

Achance (Diary) Wednesday, October 15th at 1:50PM EDT (link)

You should try thinking at all. It is clear that you have at most a government school understanding of the period in question. The point was, as it was in 1860, that if successful, the Ds can govern without the slightest consideration of the states that they don’t control.

There will be absolutely nothing we in the Red States can do to stop them, at least in the first two years. In point of fact, Lincoln was a minority President, one of the slightest “mandates” of any President. BHO will have a much greater “mandate” and a governing Party that seems likely to have a filibuster proof Senate.

For those of us with different interests and a different view, that is as close to subjugation as I care to get.

In Vino Veritas

Well OK, at least navel gazing self pity isn't as bad as treason

gensec (Diary) Thursday, October 16th at 2:43AM EDT (link)

You should try thinking at all. It is clear that you have at most a government school understanding of the [Civil War] period in question.

It’s utterly irrelevant to this discussion what the relative importance, as motives for treason in the 1860′s, was of slavery, tariffs, southerners’ fragile emotions about northerners looking down their noses, whatever. I was pointing out how ridiculous was your hysterical self-pity over the prospect of a major election loss to Obama and party.

Try rereading the close of your diary and ask yourself how many people (in either red states or blue) could take you seriously if you really believe it:

I would NOT live in a Blue State, maybe I could not. If the Blue States establish a political and legal hegemony over my Country, it isn’t my Country any more.

My response to that sewage is the same as to the Hollywood kooks talking about emigrating if Bush won: If that’s all it takes for you to feel like America isn’t your country, then please take full advantage of our freedom of emigration. Good riddance, and don’t let the door hit you on the way out.

Regardless of the sincerity vs. PR motivations for his words, even a fool like John Kerry after his 2004 defeat knew what’s obvious to most of us, but apparently is beyond your grasp:

whether or not our candidates are successful, the next morning we all wake up as Americans. That is the greatest privilege and the most remarkable good fortune that can come to us on earth.

Your government school induced

Achance (Diary) Thursday, October 16th at 3:07AM EDT (link)

obsession with slavery and treason blinds you to the fundamental point.

As I said at the outset, I was not writing about issues, yet, like Pavlov’s dog, you salivate over issues. Learn to think instead of hurl out your programmed response. For these purposes, I’ll just assume that you can’t overcome your government school programming rather than simply assuming that you’re stupid.

This is not just another election. We on the right may not have liked the fact that we woke up and found Algore or John Kerry to be President, but the World would have been fundamentally unchanged. Giving Presidential power to The One’s friends is a fundamental change.

In Vino Veritas

So do you still say America is "not your country" if Obama wins?

gensec (Diary) Thursday, October 16th at 3:25AM EDT (link)

I have enough trouble with the Lower 48

Achance (Diary) Thursday, October 16th at 4:00AM EDT (link)

under the best of circumstances. These aren’t the best of circumstances. Lots of days I’d cheerfully give the US its $7.2 million back just so I could refuse entry to anyone from NY, CA, or DC.

In Vino Veritas

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

I must take issue

jeffreywturner (Diary) Friday, October 17th at 9:12AM EDT (link)

In one sense, I agree with you that the Civil War was about something other than slavery. In much the same way, I would say that Roe v. Wade is about something other than abortion, that something being the unelected judges saying that things are in the Constitution when they clearly are not.

That said, the South was not justified in succession. The southern states agreed to play by the rules just as everyone else. There was no stipulation in the Consitution that said you don’t have to abide by the results of an election if your side loses. That is the very essence of a republic. Sometimes you lose. Majority rules. End of discussion. Ironically, if the South had not succeeded, and had snet all of their representatives to DC, they would have had enough votes (more than 1/3) to block the amendment ending slavery.

Finally, I just have to say; Abraham Lincoln was the greatest President, and one of the great leaders the world has ever known. He is the reason I am a Republican, and whenever I hear a revisionist historian downing him, I always defend Lincoln. If a few of our politicians today had even half the testicular fortitude of Lincon, we would not have half of the problems in government we have. To me, Honest Abe is as American as apple pie or baseball.

“Life is too short, can’t we all just eat pork and kill some terrorists?”

"Demoralized" isn't the characterization

Achance (Diary) Friday, October 17th at 9:22AM EDT (link)

I would choose for either the Fall of 1860 or 2008. I beleive that for common people in The South there was the sort of resignation that comes with a conclusion that differences are irreconcilable and nothing will bring the sides together. Only the secessionist firebrands welcomed that situation.

I think the only thing that is holding up the R vote is a firm resolution on the part of R voters that they do not want to be governed by BHO and the people who support him. I think there is some bitterness in that resolution, but not demoralization.

I know that the ticket is not the one I would choose. I know that I am thoroughly disgusted by what passes for Republican leadership at both the national level and in my state. Even with that, I wrote my check, put up my signs, put a bumper sticker on my truck, and try to talk it up and help the Campaign where I can.

I also know that I can hardly stand to be in the same room with activist BHO supporters even when they’re not in power. Given power, they’ll be insufferable and some will be outright dangerous.

In Vino Veritas

 
 

Superbly written in the achance style, but I don't agree.

streetwise (Diary) Friday, October 17th at 10:37AM EDT (link)

For many reasons.

Probably the most important -my view of Obama is different. I see him as a schmoozing machine politician who used leftist connections to get his start. If he had started someplace else, he would have started spouting DLC centrism. I don’t believe he believes in the leftist BS of his associates. Truthfully, I don’t think he believes in anything other than his own persona, which seems to have a new release every couple of weeks. We’re on Obama 10.3 right now, where he is playing victim in the third week of October.

Where did I defend secession?

Achance (Diary) Friday, October 17th at 10:59AM EDT (link)

I never even discussed it in a legal sense. I was simply talking about the psychology of finding yourself to be an “other” who does not have to be considered.

Now, I can have that discussion about the legalities of secession, but it bores me and probably will irritate you, so I’ll pass.

In Vino Veritas

Hope you're right, streetwise.

Achance (Diary) Friday, October 17th at 11:04AM EDT (link)

Nothing would make me happier than for him to turn out to be just a hack politicians who took in first the Democrats then the useful idiots around the Country.

I just think he, or at least the people behind him, is much, much more than that.

In Vino Veritas

 
 
 

Economic civil war...

izoneguy (Diary) Friday, October 17th at 11:13AM EDT (link)

… is more like it. Those strong red states (Texas) have economies the size of most countries. When push comes to shove we will resist every attempt from Washington to come looking for a hand out. As the squeeze goes in California, Florida, Ohio, Michigan, New York – business’s will and already are flocking to Texas. Cities and towns in Texas are gearing up for an all out blitz to caprture business and employees from battered leftist states. We won’t have to talk about secession,
after 4 years of Obama, Washington will have done it for us.
Does Texas have the resources to be in independent nation? Texas has 23,507,783 people; 11% larger than Australia. 79% of the nations have populations smaller than Texas. Texas GDP is $1,065,891,000,000; 32% larger than Australia. 93% of the nations have a GDP smaller than Texas.

Those who had once simpered: “I don’t want to destroy the rich, I only want to seize a little of their surplus to help the poor, just a little, they’ll never miss it!” – then, later, had snapped: “The tycoons can stand being squeezed; they’ve amassed enough to last them for three generations” – then, later, had yelled: “Why should the people suffer while businessmen have reserves to last a year?” – now were screaming: “Why should we starve while some people have reserves to last a week?” – Atlas Shrugged

I wasn't using demoralized to describe political parties

pilgrim (Diary) Friday, October 17th at 1:11PM EDT (link)

I was using it to describe the way that some people believe about the nation and not a party. People who believe that the USA is arrogant and evil and responsible for everything that is wrong on planet earth are demoralized. There are no arguments or facts that can cure these sickos.

In 1860 the abolitionists’ followers of John Brown were completely demoralized because of the large southern plantation system of slavery. There also may have been people in other countries like England who wanted to sow the seeds of discontent between the Americans for their own reasons.

I did not mean that the South was demoralized in 1860 or that the Rs are demoralized in 2008.


Activists Taking Action: Unified Patriots

 
 

A more hopeful comparison could be 1800.

streetwise (Diary) Friday, October 17th at 5:21PM EDT (link)

Jefferson was castigated as anti-business, anti-finance, a devotee of the French Revolution ideologically (a fashion with the Virginia planter class of the time), a pacifist on foreign policy, pro-French culturally and hostile to American military power.

With reason.

Still, in office, he used the Navy to suppress the Barbary pirates. was reasonably conciliatory to his Federalist political opponents, was willing to ally with the British against Napoleon, finagled the Lousiana purchase with Napoleon, and governed with moderation.

His first term was quite successful. His second was stormy, especially the fiasco of the Embargo Act. But most second terms go awry.

you mean he said one thing and did another?

kyle8 (Diary) Friday, October 17th at 5:30PM EDT (link)

In other words, he was a politician.

“Nothing works like freedom, Nothing succeeds like liberty”
Kyle

 
 

you echo

Charles Lee (Diary) Friday, October 17th at 5:49PM EDT (link)

The words of my Great,Great,grandmother,she died in 1960 at 104 as she said it is not what they say but what they do one needs to understand.

joe6pack

...And you have Ted Nugent

FreeCapitalistPig Saturday, October 18th at 1:35AM EDT (link)

A great American. Ted fled the Socialist Republic of Michigan which he once loved. He did a lot for Michigan, for him to leave, you know it was worse than Cat Sratch Fever ! He also stood by the NRA whom we owe a lot to for their fight against the Rosie O’donell crew. I really want to hang out with Bush and Nugent, that would be fun. O.K., if NObama wins, I’m headed down.

 
 

I'm a conservative getting a PHD in history

cp4three2 Saturday, October 18th at 2:19PM EDT (link)

I’m writing a dissertation on the causes of the secession crisis. You couldn’t be more wrong.

This notion that “northeastern elites continually attacked the South” is ridiculous. Northern doughfaces (google it) continually compromised with the South. Almost every president before Lincoln was Southern and those who were Northern did everything they could to satiate the South and the interests of slavery. There were no two term Northern presidents before Lincoln.

In the 19th century the North was just as religious, if not more religious, as the South. The movement to abolish slavery was an evangelical movement. The political division of 1860 was purely sectional between slave and free. Lincoln was chosen because of his moderation. Lincoln offered plenty of compromise with the South, he even got rid of his VP and replaced him with a Southerner, Andrew Johnson.

Today’s division is not sectional. New Hampshire and PA are still swing states. Washington just nearly elected a Republican governor. California’s governor is Republican. If it weren’t such a bad year for the GOP because of W. NJ would be up in the air.

Iowa and New Mexico are looking to go to the Dems. They are hardly Northern elites.

Alot of this angst that you’re seeing has been caused by George Bush. Those in blue states view him the way that those in red states view Obama. I’ve been saying for a while that Obama is just the liberal’s version of Bush.

Conservatives lost their way and ran out of ideas under George Bush. We’re now reaping what we sowed.

Is this election over? No. But regardless of who wins on the 4th, conservatives need to find new ideas that fit their conservative principles instead of running on emotion.

Agreed. Republicans stopped explaining market-based mechanisms to improve health care, education, social security, and the economy generally

JSobieski (Diary) Saturday, October 18th at 2:48PM EDT (link)

nr

Did you know that China has been losing manufacturing jobs since 1995? For the specific data, see Table 1 in the following link: http://www.bls.gov/opub/mlr/2005/07/art2full.pdf

The country has almost never been united. The Jefferson vs. Adams/Hamilton rivalry has always been with us

JSobieski (Diary) Saturday, October 18th at 2:53PM EDT (link)

We have also always had kooks, appeasers, etc. There were more people running on an avowdly socialist ticket 100 years ago than are running today (Obama is a stealth socialist preaching middle class tax cuts).

We have had would be appeasers in all of our wars. WWII had its protestors and kooks.

The difference now is merely that the nut factor has grown from about 10% to around 30-35% (the percentage of people of believe Bush knew about 9/11 in advance).

Did you know that China has been losing manufacturing jobs since 1995? For the specific data, see Table 1 in the following link: http://www.bls.gov/opub/mlr/2005/07/art2full.pdf

card check

Michael DeWeese (Diary) Saturday, October 18th at 3:03PM EDT (link)

You are assuming that he won’t have the Democratic Triumvirate enact a law similar to the Union “card check” law. He has promised this to be the first law he passes when elected. A similar law based on party affiliation for local, state, and national elections could be in the future for America.

there is a reason for that Jsob

kyle8 (Diary) Saturday, October 18th at 3:22PM EDT (link)

A whole lot of elected Republicans never believed in those things in the first place.

Either they did not really believe them, or didn’t understand them. And you can put John McCain in that category.

I am hoping that we can farm a new batch of younger people to run for office who actually believe in freedom, free enterprise, and markets.

“Nothing works like freedom, Nothing succeeds like liberty”
Kyle

Agreed. But our time will come . .

JSobieski (Diary) Saturday, October 18th at 3:44PM EDT (link)

nt

Did you know that China has been losing manufacturing jobs since 1995? For the specific data, see Table 1 in the following link: http://www.bls.gov/opub/mlr/2005/07/art2full.pdf

Seccession?

alicelouise58 Saturday, October 18th at 6:38PM EDT (link)

I told a Lib/Dem in 2004, “Ya promise honest and for true? Don’t let the door hit you on the backside on the way out!”

That option may not be preferred in the event of this UnVelvet Divorce. For instance: Who would get the nukes? How much of the foreign debt would be appropriated on both sides? How would Alaska and Hawaii be held(Alaska esp w/the resources). What if the Peoples Republic of California wanted Chinese military advisors? Could us Red Staters accept that? Heck, what if Uncle Joe in Florida wanted to visit Aunt Ruth in New York? Would it require a visa? This would be worse than the Civil War in the 1860s because there are so many entanglements.

America not your country?

alicelouise58 Saturday, October 18th at 6:52PM EDT (link)

Many people in November 1992 thought that the US had voted in a new Soviet Union with the election of Bill Clinton. I even thought that. Universal Health Care was supposed to be enacted in the first 100 days and other Liberal fantasies. It didn’t happen…

It won’t happen with Barack Hussein Obama. I don’t think he’ll even win this.

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

Somthing to cheer you up

QueenOfCups (Diary) Saturday, October 18th at 10:28PM EDT (link)

http://news.aol.com/political-machine/straw-poll

He believes it Street, but is so ignorant

Mike gamecock DeVine (Diary) Saturday, October 18th at 11:51PM EDT (link)

that he gets startled by truth and so is teachable, but when trapped without a script all he knows is to resort to his leftism that he was nursed on my a marxist mom; dreamt of from his marxist father and was educated in his whole life in university and in Chicago activist work.

He is one of those guilt ridden liberals and also one that sought to be authentically black.

And when you look at what he did with Ayers in terms of the Afrocentric radical education indoctrination agenda that he wasted 120 million on and then his statements about babies as punishment and that we should teach sex ed to grammar school kids (remember the nervous laughter of his own crowd when he they assumed his critics were crazy for “accusing him” of being for it and then he said, “its the right thing to do”).

I fear you are guilty of what Krauthammer and others are guilty of when they conclude that he is not a leftist that agrees with his alliances even though they chose each other precisely because of what they believed, and that is, you all are gulity of

HOPE that he isn;t what he obviously is because you fear it so much. You simply can’t imagine that such a freak could be close to being elected President.

But its true.

Mike DeVine’s Examiner.com and Charlotte Observer columns
“One man with courage makes a majority.” – Andrew Jackson

Agree in part, and disagree in part

JSobieski (Diary) Sunday, October 19th at 12:07AM EDT (link)

I don’t see how anyone can say that Obama isn’t a leftie. That is where is heart is. And like any smart leftie, he knows he has to say things like “tax cuts” to get elected.

I don’t think Obama has any sense of guilt at all. I think the guy has a sense of entitlement that is so oversized, it is why he is dangerous.

In many ways, it is Obama’s sense of himself that scares me even more than his rehashed marxism

Did you know that China has been losing manufacturing jobs since 1995? For the specific data, see Table 1 in the following link: http://www.bls.gov/opub/mlr/2005/07/art2full.pdf

 
 
 

I'm late to the party Achance

itrytobenice (Diary) Tuesday, October 21st at 11:27AM EDT (link)

but if it was then like it is now, it’s no wonder it came to war.

My sister lives in Boston and we’ve been there several times. Not only do they think we are the Beverly Hillbillies, they think they are God’s gift to America.

Their arrogance is only matched by their condescension.

I’d like to snatch off their heads and spit in their necks.

Proper grammar saves lives.

Let’s eat Grandma.
Let’s eat, Grandma.


Activists Taking Action: Unified Patriots

 

I don't know how I missed this diary for so long

1SGinTN (Diary) Tuesday, October 21st at 11:49AM EDT (link)

Great piece. As time permits I want to read all your replies as well. I have spent a lot of time looking at the similarities between what Obama threatens to bring us and the Woodrow Wilson / FDR brand of American Fascism. I haven’t spent a whole lot of time looking at our situation today in the context 1850-60′s America. You just changed that. Thanks. I also regret showing up late to this ‘party’ you posted.

Tu Ne Cede Malis
-Virgil

Don't tell us to relax

E Pluribus Unum (Diary) Tuesday, October 21st at 12:14PM EDT (link)

If you don’t see the hard lines, and if you do not have a sense of the tyranny that the left is fairly chomping at the bit to exercise (to do legislatively what the lefty courts have been doing by fiat for decades), then shame on you.

This is a crossroads for this nation. This greatest nation the world has ever seen is in danger of becoming Europe.

Kill the Terrorists
Protect the Borders
Punch the Hippies h/t IMAO

A co-worker and I were in a bar near Hahvud

Achance (Diary) Tuesday, October 21st at 12:18PM EDT (link)

back in ’05. We were in Boston to attend some expensive but thoroughly worthless training put on by Hahvud/MIT. Anyway, the bar had a collection of cops’ shoulder patches from around the Country and my associate and I were looking at them and talking about them. I have a bit of a Southern accent and my associate is from Wyoming originally and has a bit of a rural Western accent.

Out of nowhere, this woman sitting nearby turns to us and says, “You two are from one of those Red States, what the @#$% were you people thinking?” I then proceeded to tell her and the conversation as it always does with lefties degenerated into a a discussion of ancestries and sexual proclivities.

I’m no stranger to spirited political discussions in various watering holes, I live in a capital city after all, but I’ve never been attacked out of nowhere like that. It only ended when the local don, or whatever you call the Irish version of a mafia don, walked up to her, big guy with lumpy fitting suit in tow, and told her to be nice to his guests. She slunk off and he apologised and bought us a beer.

Truly strange experience and a truly strange place. Boston is the only place I’ve ever seen slovenly looking cops. As we were taking the subway back to the hotel one night, the “engineer” was slumped in his chair before God and everybody sound asleep! ‘Course, it didn’t matter, the train was totally automatic and the “engineer” was just there for featherbedding purposes.

In Vino Veritas