In one of the most conservative districts in the country, one that has been held by Republicans since 1977, Democrat Jim Harlan seemingly thought he had a shot and went overboard in November’s election.
Before getting to what actually happened, let’s look at this district’s most recent (30 years) history. In the past 30 years, the district seat has been held by 4 of the most conservative Republicans in the state and according to various conservative ranking organizations, the country:
-
Bob Livingston served from 1977-1999. Some of you may remember him as the man who was selected to succeed Newt Gingrich as Speaker of the House before he suddenly decided to retire.
-
David Vitter took his spot, and despite the recent discovery that he cheated on his wife with one of the “DC Madam’s” girls, had an astoundingly conservative voting record in the House, which he has now transferred to the Senate.
-
Bobby Jindal. Enough said (I think everyone is familiar enough with him by now).
-
Steve Scalise was elected in a special election this past May after Jindal left his seat in January to become Governor of Louisiana and has a perfect rating from the American Conservative Union.
In light of this, with Scalise winning a dominating majority in the election in May and in one of the most conservative districts in the country, we see this from Jim Harlan in the November general election:
Wealthy Democrat Jim Harlan was convinced he could beat Republican Rep. Steve Scalise in Louisiana’s 1st district, even though the district is the state’s most educated, most affluent and most Republican. George W. Bush drew a stunning 71 percent in the district in 2004, an even stronger showing than he had in Wyoming. Harlan put more than $1.2 million from his own pocket into the race, and his campaign directed some of the most ridiculous attacks of the cycle against his opponent. For example, the Harlan campaign criticized Scalise for misleading voters by claiming he had a 100 percent voting record, even though he did have a perfect attendance record. “Scalise actually missed 1,453 votes in the 110th Congress before taking the seat in May,” charged a bizarre Harlan press release.
In the end, while Harlan’s campaign bragged about being added to the Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee’s “Red to Blue” program and touted a late September Kitchens Group poll showing Scalise with an 11-point lead, the Democratic challenger drew an embarrassing 34 percent of the vote, losing by 32 points. He never had a chance, but his campaign acted as if a win was likely.
Ridiculous is the right word for it. Harlan claimed that Scalise missed votes that occurred *before *Scalise was even elected. Yet another reminder of the lengths Democrats will go even in a seat that is completely out of reach. And, I think a lesson to act realistically in how to appropriate resources in a campaign.