« BACK  |  PRINT

RS

MEMBER DIARY

Mitt’s Polish Connection

As the political discussion shifts for a moment to the international stage the Romney camp’s hope is to capitalize on Mitt’s role in saving the 2002 Salt Lake Olympics and stress his two foreign policy themes: he will be a stronger military and diplomatic leader of the Free World; and he will be a more reliable partner for our long term allies. Beyond the Olympics, most attention will go Romney’s fourth visit to Israel where he will meet with former Boston Consulting Group colleague Benjamin Netanyahu. The Polish visit is being shrugged off by much of the media, but it may be more important.

On the substance:

-  The Poles, caught between Germany and Russia, have embraced the West and the United States since Reagan backed down the Soviet Union.  They joined NATO in 1999, the European Union in 2004 (but not the common currency), and have provided units of 2500 troops in Iraq and 2600 in Afghanistan.

-  After six years of missile defense negotiation and agreement between the Bush Administration and the governments of Poland and the Czech Republic, Obama abandoned the plan in 2009 without consulting with the Poles and Czechs, and getting nothing in return from the Russians. He chose the 70th anniversary of Russia’s invasion of Poland to make the announcement.

-  Beyond the substance, relations with the Obama administration have been prickly. In May Obama offended many Poles by refusing Lech Walesa’s request to represent a WW II Polish hero at a Medal of Freedom ceremony – probably due to Walesa’s caution about our “slipping into socialism”. Obama’s inadvertent reference to “Polish (not Nazi) death camps” at the ceremony, brought the current Polish president’s response that “we always react in the same way when ignorance, lack of knowledge, bad  intentions lead to such a distortion of history, so painful for us here in  Poland, in a country which suffered like no other in Europe during World War  II.” Reagan and the Bush’s were friend of Poland; Obama not so much.

-  Romney’s characterization of Russia as “our number one geopolitical foe” plays well in Poland, following Obama’s accidental on-mike assurance to Russian leaders that he would have “more flexibility” to deal with central European issues after the election.

And on the politics:

-  Narrowly, there are about 10 million people of Polish ancestry in the United States.  In a time of ethnic politics – African-Americans for Obama; Hispanics for Obama – they are an identifiable subset of “Reagan Democrats”, making up 9.3% of voters in Wisconsin, 8.6 % in Michigan, and 6.7% in Pennsylvania where the election promises to be very close.

-  Few seem to be watching the large geopolitical trends, but as we have been focused on the Muslim world since 9/11 (Iraq; Afghanistan; the Arab Spring), Putin’s Russia has gone about consolidating the Kremlin’s power internally, and reestablishing it’s hegemony over much of the former Soviet Union with the Georgia War in 2008, and the establishment of the Belarus/Kazakhstan/Russia Customs Union in 2010.

There are lots of options for Romney to make symbolic visits to allies who have been shorted by the Obama Administration – Canada; Mexico; the United Kingdom; Germany; Japan – but his choice of Poland shows both a bit of “out of the box” thinking, and a broad geopolitical grasp. Not that the media will give him credit for a very real foreign policy difference with the Obama administration.

—–

Senator Scott Brown’s “Let America Be America Again” is the best political ad in a long time – bipartisan references, patriotic, pro-jobs, and even pro Red Sox.

www.RightinSanFrancisco.com

Get Alerts

COMMENTS

  • Ausonius

    Let me dispute very gently your following statement:

    “Obama

    • http://www.hakubi.us/ Neil Stevens

      I think he’s just too ignorant about things and misspeaks because he’s spent his life studying radicalism, which precludes honest accounts of things like World War II.

      • Ausonius

        I am not sure if it is not an act: I have seen too many smart kids play dumb to be accepted as “cool” by their inferiors. We know he wants it both ways: smartest kid in the class AND local cool dude slacker down at the basketball court sneering at The Man and racist capitalist American life.

        In the Polish insult case, I believe it was premeditated.

        Let’s face it: he might not be the stoopnagle intellectually that we could consider him to be. And his ruthlessness about his ideology trumps any lack of knowledge about who might have been at war in World War II.

  • elizaliza

    We’re also not going around saying that Dutch-Americans are right or leftwing because their native countries are right or leftwing.

    Most Dutch-Americans are very conservative, like Pete Hoekstra.

    Any Democrat is polling 90 percent in the Netherlands.

    London for the money, Israel for the politics, but Poland? It’s all so hush hush.

  • Pingback: Resource

  • Pingback: Paul Cozzy

  • acat

    .. used to be, anyway. Many are now 2nd and 3rd generation, and moved to suburbia.

    The majority still love their homeland, and this may present some interesting challenges to Team Obama .. if Team Romney can play it right.

    Mew

    p.s. also a large eastern European population in Wisconsin ..

  • greyeagle

    is not a stupid man by any means. He certainly can out think Obama. His campaign needs to think down and dirty like Obama. We need to make Obama a one term President or there will not be any country left. Poland might make that happen.

  • JSobieski

    In terms of population behind Warsaw. More Poles in Chicago than Krakow or any other Polish city.

  • JSobieski

    A large chunk of those people live in the Warsaw area.

    A small nit…

  • acat

    Casimir Pulaski Day is still celebrated in Chicago, first Monday in March.

    Mew

  • zachv

    Having a ‘Polish’ ancestry is very different than identifying yourself as a Pole. OK, maybe Romney gets Babcia Beata’s vote, but I don’t think there’s that many Polish grannies dawdling around the US.

  • elizaliza

    I for one do not buy into this folly that Polish-Americans will all of a sudden ALL vote against Obama because “Obama abandoned the plan in 2009 without consulting with the Poles and Czechs”

    This means that Polish-Americans put the interest of Poland (mucho American Defense dollars) before the interest of the US, which is cutting spending.

    Have Polish-Americans ever voted as one block?

  • acat

    We’ll fix you right up with some pierogi.

    Mew

  • zachv

    But I have been to Polish Fest (and German Fest, Festa Italia) numerous times having grew up near Milwaukee. I still don’t see it.

  • zachv

    d’oh

  • acat

    Romney isn’t going to win Illinois, but he’s going to push Obama onto the defensive…. and this is certainly more sand in the Obama machine’s gears in Wisconsin.

    Yes, the average 3rd gen Pole in Milwaukee isn’t going to vote Romney purely because of this, but .. his parents might be more open to the idea.

    Mew

  • tnfriendofcoal101368

    It would be like someone insulting George Washington….to his face. You might not vote based on it but you’d not forget it either.

  • GregInFla

    Obama does not understand the significance of Lech Walesa and Solidarity in Poland’s history, and that of the free world as well. I say this as a Chicago-born Pole now living in Florida, and heading up the Illinois next week (missing redstate in JAX).

  • aesthete

    while discontent with and hatred of the USSR was widespread in all Warsaw Pact nations (including Poland), Hungary and Czechoslovakia both engaged in armed resistance against the USSR much earlier than Solidarity’s efforts, and in the pre-WWII era Ukraine and Finland resisted Soviet attempts to reclaim the demesnes of the former Russian Empire.

  • GregInFla

    The Poles were the first to successfully stand up to USSR, and did it using economic means and public opinion. Plus, I’m biased.

  • JSobieski

    Not to mention post WWII activities that predated Solidarity.

    Solidarity was not the birth of resistance…it was the grandchild.

  • aesthete

    but I do think that Ukraine or maybe Finland was the first of the Russian Empire constituent countries to break off and wage protracted war against the newly-christened USSR. (I might be wrong about that, but I’m probably not :) ) You are right that Solidarity was the last in a long line of resistance post-WWII, but I think it would be difficult to decide which country or region in the USSR was the first to see any form of resistance; more fair to compare national confrontations, IMO.

    None of that historical minutia diminishes the tremendous respect I have for Poland’s Solidarity movement in general and Lech Walesa in particular, an amazing man who IMO did at least as much for liberty and equality around the world as MLK or Gandhi. The Polish might have had their autonomy returned to them far too late, but they have made up for lost time by living up to the ideals of the Constitution that their forebears signed on May 3, 1791 and the Golden Liberty that they were known for in years prior.

  • JSobieski

    There is no Lech Walesa without Pope John Paul II, and there is no Pope John Paul II without Cardinal Stefan Wysznski.

    Wyszynski was in many ways the father of how to resist Soviet communism without triggering military reprisals. The man was a political genius in addition to being a true man of God. He was in a very real sense leading an opposition force to the USSR beginning in January 1953.

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stefan_Wyszy%C5%84ski

    His “deal” with Communist authorities in 1950 was probably the most successful tactical decision in the resistance movements under the USSR’s yoke.

    Unlike some of the other Soviet block countries, resistance groups in Poland were really a continuous phenomenon going back the government-in-exile located in London during WWII, through a Catholic Church that maintained its independence from the government via the Cardinal’s 1950 “deal”, through the Solidarity movement in the 1980s.

  • JSobieski

    http://books.google.com/books?id=QAG3_nDrWPwC&pg=PA396&lpg=PA396&dq=Stefan+Cardinal+Wyszynski+1950+deal&source=bl&ots=OvYubresKb&sig=5wGNAlQKoduCRTIzVlZbgkivnSU&hl=en&sa=X&ei=fb4UUJrRLsbf0QH92YG4CQ&ved=0CFAQ6AEwAg#v=onepage&q=Stefan%20Cardinal%20Wyszynski%201950%20deal&f=false

    The guy was a saintly man, and remarkably successful at dealing with a communist government that had at various times placed him under house arrest.

    If Republican’s in 2012 had as much tactical political skills in the aggregate as Wyszynski had in his pinky, Obamacare would be repealed by now.

  • aesthete

    but I just don’t know that I would pin them as the first of the Soviet bloc countries to embark on mass resistance. Remember, the Polish resistance was exhausted and in many parts of Poland wiped out after resistance to the Nazis; it took a very long time for there to be organizational resistance to the Soviets as a result of diminished capacity to engage in resistance which was worn down by fighting against the Nazis. Totally agree that the Catholic Church in Poland and the Polish resistance in general made some very savvy choices in the wake of a difficult occupation. I think it’s a toss-up between them and the Finns for who fought the hardest and the smartest for their liberties and autonomy from the Soviets, though the Polish position was undoubtedly the harder of the two.

    As an aside, there’s a pretty decent TV ministries based on Pope John Paul II’s life that has Christopher Lee playing Cardinal Wyszynski; you would probably enjoy it.

  • JSobieski

    I am not necessarily arguing the point about which country was first or not. My point is really that Polish resistance went from resisting the Nazi’s to resisting the Soviets in a very continuous and organic fashion. The same people were involved in both. Cardinal Wyszynksi is an excellent example of that, but there were many many others. Poland’s modern existence before WWII was short—being a reformed nation after WWI. Poland was basically in resistance mode since the third partition in 1795.

    It makes the question of who was first both hard to answer and kind of irrelevant. For example, Josef Pilsudski was born in 1867, bean a resistance movement in the late 1880s, was captured by Russia and sent to Siberia. He escaped, started a paramilitary force in Austria prior to WWI, and became the leader of Poland after WWI.

    None of the other countries you are talking about has such a long and continuous history of resistance. Trying to identify a starting point when you had a line of people going back to Pilsudski is an arbitrary exercise.

    I have seen the Christophe Lee movie–it is for the most part excellent. I was grateful that such a great actor took on the role.

  • elizaliza

    Why would you feel the need to stress this? Besides, his gaffes in London were kind of mildly stupid. “don’t insult your host” is a rule that even goes before “politics end at the water’s edge”.

    I mean, provoking a Conservative Mayor into dissing you before a crowd of 100,000 ….
    Not that it would influence the election either way.

  • aesthete

    Poland has a very interesting history when it comes to resistance; lots of continuity stretching back to at least the 19th century — though if you really wanted to play Six Degrees of Polish Nationalists, there would be a good deal of continuity stretching back to even the Third Partition.

    I have always wondered why they have such terrible gun laws, given that context.

  • commonsenseobserver

    There’s really no need to insinuate that Gov. Romney’s stupid.

    I like Boris, of course (compared to Ken!!!), but he went a bit too far, even if Romney’s comments were careless.

  • commonsenseobserver

    Or cede Europe to Russia. We must find a balance, which I’m sure Polish Americans understand.

  • aesthete

    with selling our allies down the river to their revanchist, illiberal neighbor down the road, without so much as a courtesy call.

  • GregInFla

    I agree about John Paul II. He is a true hero for freedom as well.

  • JSobieski

    Polish resistance was continuous going back to before Chopin