« BACK  |  PRINT

RS

MEMBER DIARY

Barack Obama vs. Sarah Palin

Superman comes to the Acropolis, and Smalltown Sarah comes to the Heartland

Palin Speech

“My understanding is that Gov. Palin’s town, Wassilla, has I think 50 employees. We’ve got 2500 in this campaign. I think their budget is maybe 12 million dollars a year – [my campaign has] a budget of about three times that just for the month.”

“This is a man who can give an entire speech about the wars America is fighting, and never use the word “victory” except when he’s talking about his own campaign. But when the cloud of rhetoric has passed … when the roar of the crowd fades away … when the stadium lights go out, and those Styrofoam Greek columns are hauled back to some studio lot – what exactly is our opponent’s plan? What does he actually seek to accomplish, after he’s done turning back the waters and healing the planet? The answer is to make government bigger … take more of your money … give you more orders from Washington … and to reduce the strength of America in a dangerous world. America needs more energy … our opponent is against producing it.”

A week ago, from far and wide, the followers came to the mountaintop to glimpse Barack Obama in his moment of glory. And the New Adonis did not disappoint.

The event was an act of soaring political grandeur, inspiring the devoted flock to call out in hallelujahs. Yet in the speech itself, try and find it you may, but there was no phrase particularly memorable, no quotable line.

Do not hold that against his speech. It is not what Obama said that mattered.

The lasting image of Obama’s speech will be the spectacle itself: a Super Bowl halftime show without a game score to go with it (unless it is New Democrats 0, Neo-Old Democrats 1). No one is prompted to such an equivalent force of emotion, the tears of joy, at the idea of President McCain. At least, no sane person. But sanity itself is an act of rebellion in a civic universe where the political pageantry surrounding a man who has accomplished such meager political crumbs and done so little in life is enough – more than enough – to carry a candidacy based on the unassailable purity and goodness and untapped power of that one man all the way to 1600 Pennsylvania.

What Sarah Palin came the Twin Cities to say tonight mattered. It mattered because it proved she was not merely chosen for her gender, for her looks, for her style, or for the historic mark she represents for the Republican Party. She was chosen because of her beliefs – because she’s taken on the hordes of corrupt bureaucrats and pork swilling politicians, even those in her own party, to achieve what she believes is right. It’s because on the most crucial test for any politician – will you stand up, despite all the forces arrayed against you, for what you believe to be right? – Sarah Palin passed, and Barack Obama has that nagging Incomplete.

Palin Speech

When has Barack Obama taken an arrow from his own party for anything he believed in? When has he decided that he would act, with bravery and courage, staking out a tough decision that he believed to be right, against the wishes of the old political masters of his party? When has he broken with the leftist base, who today screams with all their might that this woman is not fit to lead even as she governs a state budget and an employee base that dwarfs anything Obama has run, that her family is fair game because she is vile, that her place is the home and not the campaign trail, and cannot possibly be a mother and a political leader?

Obama has no lack of a certain kind of courage – give him that. It takes bravado of a sort to declare that you deserve the credit for so many things in the state senate, in a biopic video so short that it cannot find space to mention Columbia or Harvard Law, where you had no hand in the legislation, and most often voted “present.” It is courage of a sort to take a file photo of yourself standing alongside Dick Lugar as an indication that you, through sheer force of will and over the objections of the warmongering right, ended the expansion of nuclear weapons. It is a form of boldness, yes, to declare in one instant that John McCain is a man to be respected and honored, and in the next contend that this man – who defended the Democratic nominee in 2004 against all attacks, even accurate ones – has committed a grave insult against all in the arena by declaring, old war hero that he is, that he will put his country first.

That man in the arena presented himself the kind of savior America needs, after all of his promises, declaring his ascendant “humility.” He read the word off the teleprompter carefully, as if using his mouth in a way it was not used to. Humility. Yes, the humility that promises on the one hand to create massive corporate loopholes to encourage artificially-created jobs, then on the other to pay for them by closing massive corporate loopholes. The humility that swears in the one instant to lessen costs, and in the next to require vast sums of money from corporations to a degree that would drive any sane organization from our shores. The humility that promises to cut taxes, even for people who do not pay taxes, and pay for them by going line by line through the federal budget and cutting out the treasured programs managed and cared for by Democrats in the bureaucracy since the days of Franklin Delano Roosevelt, and defended by their allies in the Congress, with but the stroke of a pen.

And this is the man – humble, humble Barack, who has never cut one program, who has never shrunk one agency, who has never fired one bureaucrat – who says that Sarah Palin is too raw and naive.

One wonders which reporter will be brave enough to ask which major program he will cut first. He had, before people started paying attention to his campaign, mentioned NASA as a possible plum target – creating a sucking sound of irony, considering the prominent placement of the returning astronauts in his campaign video…but such needling questions are for after an election, not before.

Barack Obama came to Denver to give a Democrat speech. It may eventually be remembered as the apotheosis of a conventional Democrat speech: the images taken from places he did not live, jobs he did not work, wars he did not fight in, to connect with the broadest possible audience of people. It could have been given, nearly all of it, by John Edwards, man of the milltown – before he ceased to exist – or by Hillary Clinton, the original blue collar warrior from Chicago. It was a speech for Democrats, and delivered to Democrats – and hence the lack of the true outline that makes for powerful remarks. Like the State of the Union speeches given by the eloquent yet fickle President Clinton, it is assumed that this laundry list, a litany of campaign promises that merge together into a mushy feeling of warmth and contentment, would be met with glorious clamor, as if proceeding from the mouth of a god. And they were.

Sarah Palin did not come to speak as a god. Her words proceed not from the bowels of Olympus, but the heart of the enduring American spirit – the driving force that calls out from the rough frontier for young men and women to go West, and ever West. It asserts the worth of the seekers, the pioneers, and all those who are ever unsatisfied with the limits of the status quo – that things are as they ever will be, and you should accept it, and move on. She speaks to those who heed the call to carve out a spot of land and make it your own, to build a good home, to raise a good family, and to be ready, should they ever call for you, to defend the freedoms that made all this possible – to defend them with your all. This is an ordinary action – but in the course of doing it, it can become extraordinary.

What Sarah Palin said tonight matters. She asks you not to vote for her because of what she claims to be, but because of what she is – because of the principles that undergird her, that motivate her, that made her challenge the old guard in her own party and the bureaucrats in others – and now, to take on the self-proclaimed Arbiter of Change. What she said tonight shows that underneath her pleasant exterior and her mother’s smile is a sharp, talented executive – one who knows how to throw a punch, and how to make change a reality, not a promise. She is tough – she is a fighter – and she is not about to blink.

“Yes, I am a woman,” she says. “And I am ready.”

It was not what Obama said that mattered. Those were words – just words. He shined in his moment of beauty, his message delivered with the Chestertonian clarity of the absurd.

“No, I am not a man,” his speech declared, “I am a cause.”

And so, as the man has declared it, he is.

Get Alerts

COMMENTS

  • Steven_Willis

    I’ve heard and seen a lot of political speeches. That was one of the best.

    In terms of speakers, she is a female Reagan. Better than Huckabee, better than Obama.

    Palin/Jindal 2012.

  • Old_Crow

    except you have actual responsibilities… Home run.

  • justinx0r

    Wow. I thought Rudy’s speech was great and would be hard to top. But Sarah really hit a home run tonight.

    They tore Obama to shreds.

    • billevans

      Right on! She did a wonderful job tonight.

  • jelswor

    Great speech! She proved herself as a worthy opponent tonight. I can’t wait to watch the fireworks. I’m sure the libs are steaming mad. From my quick glance at the CNN blogs (they shut it down by the way) I would say they are very afraid of little Sarah.

  • Pezman

    I thought Rudy’s speech was amazing, but then Palin came on and holy crap did she deliver! She not only hit a homrun she hit it out of the park, down the street, over the bridge and into the next town…. amazing speech done by an amazing person and I can not wait for her to run for president.

  • twelvepackabs

    If she had stumbled tonight, the response would have been muted, but she didn’t, and you just know that the knives are being sharpened as we sit here.

    I would point out that her comments on energy were really quite revealing, and should remind us that she was the governor of THE energy state….she knew her stuff, and it was obvious. Experience comes in many forms…how about the Energy VP.

    Finally, I think that it is revealing that she outspoke all three of the major opponents of John McCain who took the podium tonight (and she was right there with Fred Thompson’s speech last night).

    • billevans

      Sorry I made a typo in his name.

  • Rod_Patrick

    The Best Ever!

    The Best Argument!

    The Greatest Woman on the Planet!

    JOHN MCCAIN, YOU’RE SUCH A LUCKY MAN!!!!!

    REPUBLICAN PARTY, YOUR COLOR REMAINS BLUEST!

    AMERICA, YOU STAND VICTORIOUS IN THE EYES OF THE WHOLE WORLD!!!!!!

    THIS WOMAN CAN REALLY ROCK!!!!!

  • tankertodd

    Holy cow. This person is for real. I expect more great things.

    • speciallist

      n/p

  • Wintergreen

    about what Obama is really planning to do was right on.

    Underneath all his glitzy bullsh*t, is an extremely liberal engine determined to repeat the disaster that was Jimmy Carter all over again.

    Nothing he is offering is new. It is the same big-wasteful-government garbage the dems have always peddled.

    The only difference is that they now found an empty suit who reads the teleprompter really well (but sounds like an idiot without it) to deliver their crap.

    Medicare and Social security are set to wipe out our entire budget in the next 20 years, and the messiah wants to increase entitlements???

    • blooch

      nt

      • blooch

        I just flipped over to MSNBC and saw Olbermann stuttering and sharting himself. LOLOLOLOL Go back on The Soup, Olby…It’s more your speed.

  • jarrod21

    “they slaughtered a small cow out there on stage”

    • gamecock

      to be qualified to be CINC is to have been CINC. Palin should declare war on Manitoba and send in the AK militia.

      • kyle8

        It was shots of the Republican convention mixed with shots of the flaming retard moonbat protesters.

        It was a hilarious juxtaposition.

  • Kansas

    A candidate who can read a teleprompter well. She can add that to her resume now (I guess in fairness that was probably the part of the resume that really sold her to McCain in the first place, filling in where he is lacking).

    • itrytobenice

      That’s what’s great about her. She can read a teleprompter.

      Idiot.

      • Nick_Haynes

        She can read a teleprompter well? Well, she didn’t have one in Dayton last week and did very well.

        She had malfunctions tonight and did extraordinary.

        If you listen to her on the stump, you don’t have to cut out 1/5 of the talking because of the “uh’s” like some candidates who happen to be named Barry Obama.

        And she also not only talks the talk but walks the walk. Barry talks about corruption in government but never mentions that his wife got a $200K raise at her job right around the time that Barry was elected to the U.S. Senate. Sarah Palin resigned her job when she got tired of dealing with the corruption and the blockage, and instead ran to change the system. Barry considers future unplanned pregnancies for his daughters a punishment. The Palin family is welcoming the new addition that will be coming to their family soon.

        She has more leadership experience than Barry could even conceive of. And she has more courage in the smallest bone of her little pinky than Barry does in his entire body. She showed her fortitude tonight, delivering one of the greatest speeches of our new century amidst attacks from every side. You can say all you want that Barry is ready. Answer me this, then: from flag pins to preachers to domestic terrorists, Barry always runs. How can we expect him to show backbone against the Ahmadinejad’s and Chavez’s of the world when he can’t even stand up for a male jewelry decision?

        Be gone, troll.

        • Raven

          And at the very end of his show, as they were pulling away from him on the way to credits, the corners of his mouth quivered and his eyes filled with tears.

          It was kind of cute, actually. Like a little boy whose dog just died…

          • blooch

            nt

  • mikewas

    Don’t forget that she gave a pretty good speech last Friday, without a teleprompter, much of which she ad-libbed.

    Not only will she hold her own against Joe Biden, the clown prince of the Senate, but I imagine she’s do pretty well against the Harvard Law grad who is Biden’s running mate.

    • rickf

      McCain just a few days ago wanted Lieberman. As a conservative, I’m very disturbed by this. Does McCain really give a darn about the social issues we so care about. I think not.

  • GMURedStater

    with a bunch of other women. We are all younger, and we all know we watched history. And we were all sold (well, I already had been) by the end of the night and had tears in her eyes. What a great speech. What a fantastic woman. I am in complete awe, and I know many, many others are in agreement, judging by the text messages I was getting.

  • carolinacal

    • Raven

      And I’m sure she’s a better shot than he is. Politically as well as with firearms.

      • BillM

        lol