
Yesterday Moe and I with his colleagues in respected corners of the news media who had disparaged Sarah Palin, relying on the rantings from the foulest corners of the blogosphere as the basis for their articles. Douthat’s disappointment – along with that of his colleagues McArdle and Goldberg – turned slowly into outrage over the course of the day, as it became clear that much of his frustration was directed at the worst offender of them all: Andrew Sullivan.
Sullivan is on the extreme edge of the assault on Palin – even as Campbell Brown and others have drastically scaled back their attacks on Palin as they realized their allegations were either unfounded, irrelevant, or significant stretches of fact, Sullivan continues to beat the drum. He repeats rumor and innuendo as established truth, but even worse, insists that every tabloidesque rumor be met with immediacy by Palin herself. It’s more than a little pathetic: Andrew Sullivan, once one of the most brilliant wits of the neocon blogosphere, now occupies that darkened zone of the tabloid preacher – the streetcorner pamphleteer who cries to all who will hear, “The Government will not respond to my writings the existence of extraterrestrials among us, and THIS LACK OF DENIAL PROVES DEFINITIVELY THAT THEY ARE HERE!”
As Jonathan Last blogs at the fantastic Galley Slaves: Sullivan demanded that he be able to inspect Palin’s amniotic fluid or Trig Palin’s placenta in order to determine the “hidden truth” about Palin’s pregnancy. Sullivan posted repeatedly, writing over and over again – with no basis other than his own expertise in photo analysis and the rantings of bloggers and commenters with no reputation for accuracy – that Palin’s pregnancy was a suspect issue that demanded clarification. Was the baby hers? Who was the father? Was it a faked pregnancy? All were questions that Sullivan insisted needed answering.
In the wake of revelations about Bristol Palin, rendering much of what he argued moot, Sullivan now insists that his continued writings and tabloidesque musings about Trig Palin’s conception and birth aren’t out of bounds at all, merely because the baby exists.
Presumably, they should put it wherever people put babies to keep them out of the public eye.
Sullivan’s public descent into rampaging dementia is frightening, and one wonders what it could possibly signify about his relationship with The Atlantic. I have been public for years in my belief that The Atlantic is the best magazine in America, and it has, as others have noted, a brand built on a century of brilliant writers and the best minds of the literati. Today, Sullivan represents a complete downfall of that brand name – embracing fully the worst kind of speculatory writing, based on nothing more than what he sees on television and receives from adoring fans in his inbox.
Sullivan has had a bizarre series of public loop-de-loops in recent months, primarily motivated by his devout affection for Barack Obama. His insistence on ignoring his own past political views led to a strong back and forth earlier this year, when Pete Wehner – who I know to be a former fan of Sullivan’s writings before the man went nuts – showed how Sullivan’s current claims completely conflicted with everything he’d once written about the war on terror. To which Sullivan, after much ridiculousness in response, could only respond: “I was deceived and feel terrible responsibility for my naivete.”
Perhaps someday Andrew Sullivan will say he feels deceived by the Andrew Sullivan he is today, and feel terrible responsibility for believing the rantings of the nuttiest members of the online left. But until that day, if it ever comes, he will keep up his courageous quest, insisting that he is just “posing questions,” that he has no bias on this point but a search for hidden, dirty, scandalous truth. He will ask the tough questions, the hard questions, the questions he can ask about medical practice and birth because of his long history as an OB-GYN, an educated nurse, and the handsomest midwife in the tristate area.
Jeff Emanuel
Neil Stevens
Caleb Howe
Daniel Horowitz
I'm Embarrassed
jimmuy8 (Diary) Thursday, September 4th at 4:19PM EDT (link)I ever read him. But I spotted his shrill, self-serving, phony conservative act clear back when he hoisted a pitchfork and torch, demanding the resignation of Trent Lott, “for the good of the party.” Oh, yeah, forcing Lott to step down sure insulated the Republican party from racism charges, didn’t it?
(Yes, I know, Lott needed to go–but, not because of what he said at Strom’s birthday.)
Then, his “pledge drives” that raked in multiples of ten times more than needed to cover “rising bandwidth costs.” Followed by another drive for the same reasons months later. Followed by a month-long vacation.
Crook.
It's All They Have
SlowpoketheCruiser Thursday, September 4th at 4:25PM EDT (link)We should not be kind in the condemnation of the DNC running-dog lackeys’ attacks on Sarah’s credibility: after all, It’s All They Have. It just sux to be a Democrat right now: no real ideas, no fathomable spirituality, and no safety nets under the platform. Surviving the media warthogs is the least of Mrs. Palins’ worries, I think, because the cattiness of the femi-nazi is just getting warmed up. Next, from the worst of them in The View, we’ll hear that her shoes don’t match her skirt (by the way, did you notice that at the GOP acceptance speech last night that a pantsuit was not present?) or, perhaps the media darlings will endlessly discuss the temerity her second youngest daughter displayed to kiss and play with her baby brother when she should have been listening to the speeches: but then, after all, It’s All They Have.
McCain/Palin ‘08
See You at the Polls!
I disagree.
JustinArmstrong Thursday, September 4th at 4:28PM EDT (link)I disagree 100%. Palin is a new figure on the national stage. The public deserves to know as much about her as possible, including her medical records. You have to admit, it was very odd of her to fly all the way back to Alaska from texas, considering the baby’s condition and her age. THere’s no harm in asking questions.
Sarah Palin must be read to be president on day 1. It’s legitimate to ask some questions about her background.
The Atlantic used to be a pretty good...
furious (Diary) Thursday, September 4th at 4:31PM EDT (link)…read, pre-Michael Kelly, even. I hung on to my subscription after Michael Kelly died in Iraq, as there was always a great Rob’t Kaplan essay to make one by James Fallows go down a little easier.
Unfortunately the drift Fallows-ward continued, and I regretfully let the subsription lapse after almost 15 years. Now that Hysterical Andy has sublet the attic apartment, so to speak, no regrets.
–furious
“I find your lack of faith disturbing.” — Darth Vader
I expect to see Sullivan faint from euphoria soon.
phxg (Diary) Thursday, September 4th at 4:34PM EDT (link)nt
It is the mark of an educated mind to be able to entertain a thought without accepting it. –Aristotle
Andrew Who Writing in The What?
streetwise (Diary) Thursday, September 4th at 4:38PM EDT (link)I subsribed briefly to The Atlantic, before Sully came on the scene. I gladly let it lapse, despite a couple of good articles now and then.
I'm sure there are plenty of questions that seem legitimate
Leon H. Wolf (Diary) Thursday, September 4th at 4:38PM EDT (link)to absolute freaking idiots, conspiracy theory nuts, and raving leftists (but I repeat myself), but that’s no reason for an allegedly respectable publication to air them.
————
We can’t stop here. This is bat country.
I Like Reading Sullivan
Swamp_Yankee (Diary) Thursday, September 4th at 4:40PM EDT (link)in that car wreck sort of way. He really is unhinged. It’s bizarre. He’s a one man Palin smear machine, all the while lamenting the “Rove” Republicans. He’s gonzo.
29 min concern troll...this ain't your type of site...n/t
Attack Mode (Diary) Thursday, September 4th at 4:45PM EDT (link)n/t
“Land of the Free and Home of da Whopper” Peter Griffin…Family Guy
conform and celebrate diversity….or else!!!
Steel-Belted Radial Right Winger

“I’ll create 5 million jobs from out of unicorn farts and pixie dust” Justatron paraphrasing Obamessiah…yes I love it that much.
Very odd, considering her OB/GYN...
furious (Diary) Thursday, September 4th at 4:51PM EDT (link)…was back in Alaska, Mrs. Palin had her doctor’s clearance to board the flight back, and she’d had four other deliveries without incident.
What is even odder is Andrew Sullivan’s new, sudden obsession with gynecology.
–furious
“I find your lack of faith disturbing.” — Darth Vader
I may have been insufficiently clear in my last reply.
Leon H. Wolf (Diary) Thursday, September 4th at 5:00PM EDT (link)To further clarify, this blog does not peddle in that particular variety of smut, nor allow commenters who do. Nor does it permit “questions” to be “raised” about something which was stupid to begin with, and conclusively debunked with the announcement of Bristol Palin’s actual pregnancy. If this cramps your style, feel free to get lost.
-Mgmt.
————
We can’t stop here. This is bat country.
Where's the placenta?
ojintoad Thursday, September 4th at 5:07PM EDT (link)I’m sorry, I feel like there is some sort of mistake with one part of your article. You state:
I don’t see in either of the linked articles the work “placenta” or “amniotic” in either of the linked articles in that sentence. How can they have reported that if they don’t use those words?
The links in the quote, in order:
http://galleyslaves.blogspot.com/2008/08/andrew-sullivan.html
http://www.weeklystandard.com/weblogs/TWSFP/2008/08/vileandvilercolmesand_sull.asp
I could give a rats ass about Sullivan, he obviously seems really obsessed about a witch hunt based on his blog and all the links you have. But I’d like to see the backup for your claim of his demanding to see physical parts of Palin. As far as I can tell the most he demanded was a doctor/medical document.
If you were being over the top I totally missed it. But the point of links are to back up your argument and I don’t see the backup at the link.
excuse typos/grammar, hit submit instead of preview.
ojintoad Thursday, September 4th at 5:09PM EDT (link)n/t
LANGUAGE (nt)
Neil Stevens (Diary) Thursday, September 4th at 5:10PM EDT (link)RS contributing editor and “a hardy variety of crabgrass.”
Read the RedState Posting Rules
Unlikely Voter: Poll Analysis, Election Projection.
“I rejoice that America has resisted.” – William Pitt, the Elder
appologies.
ojintoad Thursday, September 4th at 5:16PM EDT (link)n/t
Sen Obama's medical records?
Brock Thursday, September 4th at 5:36PM EDT (link)I fully expect you to be as outraged that Sen Obama has not released his medical records. This is particularly troubling since he is a smoker.
Medical reality
Ralph4159 Thursday, September 4th at 5:41PM EDT (link)If there was ever a medical reality that Andrew Sullivan is probably intimately familiar with it is this: over 73% of male homosexuals who are carriers of the AIDS virus for over a decade will develop dementia. This is the brutal truth everyone is afraid to mention. It’s obvious the guy has lost his mind.
And who can forget this sickening escapade: Sullivan’s HIV ads
In Sully's defense (not really)
RJD (Diary) Thursday, September 4th at 6:27PM EDT (link)Obama responds to every slight, wayward glance and thought that may or may not besmirch him. Sometimes, it takes him more than one response.
It should be expected, then, that all politicians are just as thin-skinned and lily-livered. Of course, that is not true, and quite the opposite.
Most folks that decide on a life of politics, learn along the way that it’s a full-contact sport. But, not Obama, he isn’t one for sports (ok, maybe a little basketball, for the camera’s).
In Andy’s small Obama-world, Obama can do no wrong, thus what he does must be right and everyone else should follow. Thus his outrage at Sarah Palinm, a woman who would dare to be strong, confident and who wears her nickname “Barracuda” as a badge of honor.
Andrew Sullivan is Gay
PHenryandWEarp (Diary) Thursday, September 4th at 8:36PM EDT (link)That explains his hatred for the GOP. Like Jann the evil man who controls Rolling Stone and US Weekly, he is part of the “vast conspiracy” that unlike Hillarys figment is real. He is part of an organized group of homosexuals who have decided to do anything in their power to fight the war they see before them as they seek to silence anyone who gives them less than everything they ask for, marriage, benefits etc. They seek not negative tolerance that says you do what you want and leave me alone, but positive tolerance that says it is okay for them to be gay. They will never get it.
Dementia sounds plausible
AnnaD Thursday, September 4th at 8:59PM EDT (link)I used to enjoy reading Andrew Sullivan, but I’m beginning to think there is some HIV-related dementia going on here. I’m sorry for him as he loses his mind.
Hyperbole, but
Ben Domenech (Diary) Thursday, September 4th at 9:49PM EDT (link)Sullivan demands to see DNA evidence from medical records. He’s done it repeatedly, most recently here: http://andrewsullivan.theatlantic.com/thedailydish/2008/08/a-smear.html
Such DNA evidence would’ve been obtained at the time of Trig’s birth from placenta or amniotic fluid. Hence: hyperbole based on what he asked for.
Follow me on Twitter.
Hitchens
jcallis Thursday, September 4th at 10:16PM EDT (link)There are two writers I respect the read weekly and that is Christopher Hitchens and Victor Davis Hanson. I was first introduced to Sullivan when I heard him debate Hitchens on Charlie Rose and later on Tim Russert’s show. Hithens positions were clear. Sullivan seemed at odds with the facts on many fronts about the Iraq war so as a reasoned writer I discarded him. Perhaps I was biased to Hitchens whom I consider to be one of our best American (he recently became a citizen) writers and debaters.
Hitchens was right about Reverend Wright and Iraq. Hitchens was right about Iraq even before McCain.
Here he support Reverend Wright basically saying that Wright was given a bad wrap:
Hitchens and Sullivan
Basically, Sullivan is passing a journalistic fart in a crowded room by writing this article. We should leave the room and let him sit in it for a while.
I suspect the article is crap as well as his positions on other issues he writes about.
Judge Sullivan two years after a position or article he write…and you will find him lacking.
John
Typos...
jcallis Thursday, September 4th at 10:27PM EDT (link)Sorry for the typos and grammar. I have night duty with a 3 week old and I’m limited to one hand.
I'm concerned about you're ability to take care of that baby and post on Redstate..
speciallist (Diary) Thursday, September 4th at 10:42PM EDT (link)if you made this many errors posting…how many errors are you making with that precious baby?
Here we go again.
PSDA (Diary) Thursday, September 4th at 10:53PM EDT (link)Sullivan’s shtick is EXTREMELY obvious. He’s the prototypical “Moby troll” writ large. He was doing it before that term was even invented, and all for self-promotion and personal moral vanity. Also, it needs to be pointed out, to turn an easy buck.
He pretends to BE a part of some group that he actually hates in order to conjure up the credibility to attack it and to be listened to when he’d otherwise be ignored.
Come on. Look at his “Catholicism.” He agitates for gay marriage, exaggerates every failing of the church and rejects any authority whatsoever of the pope.
He claims to be “conservative” but rejects ALL conservative values and cheerleads for the biggest socialist, left-wing politician to ever hit the stage.
May I make a suggestion?
It seems that about every five minutes, some conservative commentator puts up a post about how off-the-rails Andrew Sullivan is, how he’s no longer worth reading, how he’s gone off the deep end. Can’t he just be ignored?
reply to jcallis
speciallist (Diary) Thursday, September 4th at 11:05PM EDT (link)opps
well...
jcallis Thursday, September 4th at 11:07PM EDT (link)I admit, my focus was on said baby but I’m getting better typing with my left middle finger.
Careful ...you'll be using that finger alot
speciallist (Diary) Thursday, September 4th at 11:11PM EDT (link)Agreed
Brock Friday, September 5th at 8:08AM EDT (link)Right of center sites should make it policy not to link to anything Sullivan writes.
Descent? This lying fraud has been in total free fall for years.
spainishirish (Diary) Friday, September 5th at 12:17PM EDT (link)I’m not going to tapdance around it, either, although it puts me near the same level as he (but in my case, there is a factual basis for the assertion). Sullivan has a disease that leads to dementia. Why the editors at The Atlantic let him continue to spew obviously psychotic and increasingly incoherent rants is beyond belief. He is a very sick man and his on-line display is a throwback to the most exploitative freak shows that once made the carnival circuit.
Sullivan always was a fraud and a two-bit street hustler. What has changed is the obvious madness you pointed out. It is unlike anything I have ever witnessed in a relatively sane publication.
Absolutely.
spainishirish (Diary) Friday, September 5th at 12:21PM EDT (link)Sullivan links should be banned.