Turmoil on Wall Street: A News Roundup


Lehman Brothers Will Go Down

Ladies and Gentlemen, I’ve been faithfully chronicling the global credit and financial crises for you since the first cracks started appearing in early summer of last year.

Tonight, with the almost-certain collapse of the investment bank Lehman Brothers, the crisis moves into a new and possibly very dangerous phase.

I’m going to keep you up-to-date on the key developments over the next few days, or longer if necessary, and give you as much analysis as there is time for.

The extraordinary events of this weekend will go down in history. To me, at this early point, I think there are instructive parallels to the financial crises of 1907 and 1987. Read on for a roundup of the events of the last two days.

UPDATE: Bank of America is expected to acquire Merrill Lynch, the third-largest Wall Street investment bank, for about $29/share, which is a large premium over MER’s Friday close just above $17, and far below its 52-week high above $78.

On Friday evening, Tim Geithner of the New York Fed called an extraordinary meeting of the CEOs of several Wall St. firms and large banks. Secretary Paulson attended some of the sessions.

The goal was to find a buyer for some or all of Lehman Brothers, a very well-respected firm that has been around for 158 years.

Lehman’s CEO Richard Fuld has been trying to sell off assets to raise capital for months now, for example the Neuberger-Berman investment-management business. But Fuld has been faulted for trying too hard to keep Lehman’s ownership structure intact and not working hard enough to raise new capital.

That’s the essence of Lehman’s problem. This is different from Bear Stearns, which was killed by liquidity problems as people suddenly started refusing to trade with them and clients started pulling their money out.

Lehman has large holdings (numbers like $50 billion are floating around) of debt securities that are backed by mortgages, including mortgages on commercial real-estate. (This is something of a twist, because residential mortgages have caused most of the problems to date.)

And Lehman’s mortgage paper is suffering the same reductions in valuation that everyone else is facing. If there is an expectation that mortgages may default or that cash flows may become less reliable, the value of the assets decline precipitously.

But it’s simply not an option for Lehman or anyone else to simply keep the paper in the bank and hold it to maturity, cashing the monthly payments. They’re required to mark the value of their portfolio to market on a regular basis (for some asset classes, several times a day, in fact). And when their marks reflect lower values, the difference comes out of the equity capital of the bank as a whole.

In short, Lehman ran out of capital. Their stock price has fallen nearly 90% over the past year. Obviously, this makes it hard for them to make money because they can’t take new positions. But when it gets really bad, they start looking too risky to the people they trade with and who invest with them.

That’s where Lehman is now. They need capital, or else they will be forced to liquidate their positions. And a liquidation, if done in a rapid and disorderly fashion, has the ability to depress the prices of similar securities all over the world, and possibly topple other institutions the same way.

Keep this point about destruction of capital in mind over the next few days. I’ll come back to it whenever I can. It’s really become the story in the ongoing financial crisis, which started as widespread liquidity impairment and has moved into a new phase.

The Treasury Steps In

The Treasury, Congress and the Fed have been criticized sharply for committing large amounts of public money in their attempts to quell various emergencies over the last year. Paulson and Geithner were absolutely determined to draw the line here.

After all, capitalism is supposed to punish risks taken imprudently, and to do so swiftly and severely. That’s what we free-market conservatives are all about, after all. If market participants form the impression that banks or Wall Street firms are “too big to fail,” meaning their mistakes will be made whole from taxpayer funds, then they have no incentive to avoid making mistakes.

So Paulson insisted throughout the weekend that no taxpayer or Federal Reserve funds would be committed to acquiring the “bad” (distressed) assets of Lehman Brothers.

One of the structures that was discussed throughout Saturday was the creation of a “bad bank,” which would acquire Lehman’s distressed assets, leaving behind a relatively healthy business consisting of investment-management, commercial-paper underwriting, and some proprietary trading.

The idea was that either Bank of America or Barclay’s would acquire the “good bank,” and a consortium of perhaps 10 other firms would pony up to buy the “bad bank.”

Long-Term

Do you remember the Long-Term Crisis of September 1998? Bill McDonough, then President of the New York Fed (the job Geithner has now), essentially ordered a group of Wall Street CEOs to sit in a room until they had a deal to acquire the assets of the Long-Term Capital Management hedge fund, and end the crisis. About 10 firms put in enough to buy Long Term’s assets for about 10 cents on the dollar. (Three months later, the assets were right back up to almost par, just as John Meriwether had long insisted would happen.)

This weekend, they didn’t make a deal.

With the moral-hazard precedents of Bear Stearns and Fannie Mae/Freddie Mac in the rear-view mirror, none of the firms in the conference were willing to undertake any acquisition of Lehman assets without government participation, or a taxpayer guarantee of some kind.

In essence, they called Paulson’s bluff. And first Bank of America, and then Barclay’s walked away from the table and there was no deal.

Paulson didn’t blink. If he had, then moral hazard would have become permanently embedded in Wall Street’s DNA, and Treasury would have lost most of its credibility. But by showing Paulson down, the CEOs of Wall Street put their self-interest (and possibly their desire to see the death of a capable rival) ahead of systemic stability.

An extraordinary thing happened then. This afternoon was hot, muggy, and brilliantly sunny in New York, but armies of traders were suddenly called off the beach and out of the Hamptons, and into work. On a Sunday. The International Swaps and Derivatives Association called a special trading session from 2pm to 4pm this afternoon, with a very unusual twist.

Traders were allowed to assume that Lehman Brothers would declare bankruptcy, and to make trades that would limit or offset their exposure to Lehman. These trades were permitted under the stipulation that they would be automatically “broken” (cancelled) in the event that Lehman did not execute a bankruptcy filing before midnight on Sunday.

As I write, that bankruptcy filing is reported to be imminent. Indications are for a very sharp drop in the stock market tomorrow (at least 300 points off the Dow, maybe more), and there has already been a large trade into short-dated US Treasury securities.

This is the nature of the risk that the financial world faces tomorrow morning when trading resumes in New York: a large amount of mortgage-backed securities may suddenly hit the market in a disorderly fashion. And if trading is messy and prices gyrate wildly, there is a strong possibility that other assets, like stocks, bonds, credit-default and interest-rate swaps, commodities, etc., may also be drawn into the maelstrom.

What would I be doing if I were in charge of the situation now?

Well, Secretary Paulson is a large, powerful and intimidating man, and he has a good handful of equally large, intimidating men working for him and in the Federal Reserve. These are the kind of guys that can make your ears bleed right through the telephone.

If I were them, I’d be burning up the phone lines all night tonight, and making the ears of CEOs bleed like never before. Their job is to persuade key people all over Wall St. not to panic in the morning. By brute force if necessary.

The fact that the stability of the system will once again depend on forceful personalities, rather than regulations or systems, is what makes me mindful of the crises of 1987 and 1907.

Stay tuned. I’ll be reporting here as necessary.

-Francis Cianfrocca


RSS feed

39 Comments Leave a comment

I'm long SKF, EEV, TWM.

MrSandman (Diary) Sunday, September 14th at 8:19PM EDT (link)

I’ve been long for a month or so waiting for the reality to set in.

I’ll sleep okay tonight.

Next one going down is WaMu….followed by many many more over the next months.

Hey!! At least the Fed won’t be tightening.
LOL

“Americans can no longer trust the economic information they are getting from this Administration.”

— Republican Senator Jim DeMint

 

How quiet do you think it's going to be....

MrSandman (Diary) Sunday, September 14th at 8:21PM EDT (link)

around the executive offices up in Detroit tomorrow morning??

Got layoffs??

“Americans can no longer trust the economic information they are getting from this Administration.”

— Republican Senator Jim DeMint

 

This has the chance to get really ugly very quickly.

Kenny Solomon (Diary) Sunday, September 14th at 8:35PM EDT (link)

I absolutely despise the ‘what if’ kind of thing, but . . . .

What if . . . . . A foreign bank – read that as China, Dubai, or The Saudis – buys Lehman Brothers and then turns around and says to all debtors, “Margin Called”.

What then Kemosabe, eh ?

They had their chance this weekend

Francis Cianfrocca (Diary) Sunday, September 14th at 8:39PM EDT (link)

Nomura, Deutsche, and several others had a chance to bid and didn’t. Don’t forget, all the sovereigns have been putting equity into Wall Street firms for nearly a year, and every one of them has been badly burned. The Chinese nearly put $1 billion into Bear Stearns, but lucky for them the deal didn’t close before Bear bit the dust. And you know how the Chinese hate to look stupid. That window is closed and painted over.

 
 

Merrill Lynch for $29

mcg Sunday, September 14th at 8:40PM EDT (link)

Well, looks like I’m going to be a client of BofA soon. Merrill bought for $29.

 

CNBC says Lehman is toast

mcg Sunday, September 14th at 8:43PM EDT (link)

They will be filing shortly. Here is the story.

I hear ya, Blackhedd

Kenny Solomon (Diary) Sunday, September 14th at 8:51PM EDT (link)

I thank you sincerely for reminding me of those equity investments which I honestly forgot about and I deep-down believe that ‘our own house’ will stay that way.

But the scenario is still “out there” and that’s pretty scary to a boatload of people.

But as usual, the media will end up blaming GWB and all Republicans for this mess. Dumb-as-boxes-of-rocks people will believe it too.

Cheers !

 
 

What is the likelihood...

chrome_plated Sunday, September 14th at 8:59PM EDT (link)

…of a “circuit breaker” being tripped tomorrow on the NYSE, shutting down trading for a time? Is this severe enough that we could see panic on this order?

You know what's funny

Jack_Savage (Diary) Sunday, September 14th at 9:05PM EDT (link)

This is like when an NFL owner goes before the press and says,”The coach has my full support.” When this happens, you know the coach is on his way out the door.

Likewise, the next time people from Wall Street make comments supporting a company in trouble, like they did with Lehman this week, I am shorting the stock to zero.

Dow Futures - 14 September 10:15 pm Eastern

Kenny Solomon (Diary) Sunday, September 14th at 9:13PM EDT (link)

Per CNBC — 10:15 pm Eastern.

Dow Futures are down 273.

 
 
 

Which way will the S&P 500 go?

SteveLA (Diary) Sunday, September 14th at 9:15PM EDT (link)

Blackhead

Nothing I can do about it now, but which way do you think the S&P 500 will go tomorrow? I tend to not mess around much with individual stocks or funds and just stick with vanilla.

______________________________________

Competency over ideological purity and litmus tests

 

Mr. Sandman re SKF

txchick57 (Diary) Sunday, September 14th at 9:17PM EDT (link)

is diverging in a very large way from the blow off top in July. If you get a big gap up on that in the a.m., I’d take it. I’m looking to short that pretty soon. FWIW

(former bankruptcy professional, now stock/derivatives trader)

 

This is a pretty good analysis

txchick57 (Diary) Sunday, September 14th at 9:20PM EDT (link)

http://blogs.wsj.com/deals/2008/09/14/mean-street-if-lehman-liquidates-wall-street-gets-set-to-make-a-killing/

 

This is a pretty good analysis

txchick57 (Diary) Sunday, September 14th at 9:21PM EDT (link)

http://blogs.wsj.com/deals/2008/09/14/mean-street-if-lehman-liquidates-wall-street-gets-set-to-make-a-killing/

10:30 #

Kenny Solomon (Diary) Sunday, September 14th at 9:29PM EDT (link)

Dow Futures – Down 305

S&P Futures – Down 101.64

Oil Futures – 99.62 – Down 1.65

There are several circuit breakers

Francis Cianfrocca (Diary) Sunday, September 14th at 9:30PM EDT (link)

There’s one at 250 Dow points, and another one at 500 Dow points. The latter one actually freezes trading for a short time. We’ll hit at least a few circuit breakers tomorrow, almost for sure.

This will be a big system test. The S&P Index is not known to be particularly correct from moment to moment when markets are extremely active.

Do yourself a favor

Francis Cianfrocca (Diary) Sunday, September 14th at 9:33PM EDT (link)

Unless you’re a professional, don’t even think about trading tomorrow. It’ll be hurricane weather.

now I'm sorry I paid off my credit card

David Hinz (Diary) Sunday, September 14th at 9:36PM EDT (link)

I'm not and thanks...

SteveLA (Diary) Sunday, September 14th at 9:37PM EDT (link)

Good advice and that’s what I think most folks will do…BTW CNN saying S&P futures down 3 percent.

This election is sure turning into one about finances.

______________________________________

Competency over ideological purity and litmus tests

WAMU...

mbecker908 (Diary) Sunday, September 14th at 9:42PM EDT (link)

eh.

Actually, it’ll be a race between WAMU, Wachoiva and Downey Savings.

My bet is on Downey.

Change

My Bad - S&P number

Kenny Solomon (Diary) Sunday, September 14th at 9:45PM EDT (link)

The proper S&P Futures number is Down 40.5.

I had incorrectly posted the S&P/ASX number earlier.

Sorry ’bout that.

I agree with his basic point

Francis Cianfrocca (Diary) Sunday, September 14th at 9:48PM EDT (link)

Wall Street has too much capacity and won’t miss Lehman Brothers.

His analysis of the bid/ask spread on distressed mortgage paper is interesting but a bit more tenuous. We’ll get a much better idea when we see where that paper ends up over the next few weeks. It’s not a good sign that so many people wanted to see the government end up with it.

But I agree that there is a lot of real money out there, that after months and months of distress, is finally starting to react to all the blood in the water. Even though the next few days will be wild and crazy, I happen to believe that the major risks in the system are on the upside.

Thx for the link.

HA!

MrSandman (Diary) Sunday, September 14th at 9:55PM EDT (link)

Didn’t even think of that! That wouldn’t change the terms on a WAMU cc account would it?? Whomever buys that paper would have full legal recourse of the credit agreement right??

“Americans can no longer trust the economic information they are getting from this Administration.”

— Republican Senator Jim DeMint

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

Structures built on bad foundations must come down

Neil Stevens (Diary) Sunday, September 14th at 10:04PM EDT (link)

I don’t like the idea that our economy will be impaired because of things like this, but I think it’s probably necessary for this to happen. If a number of major firms have built up large structures of investments on a foundation of risk management that appears to have been wrong, then those structures must come down, and the people who invested in those structures must lose out.

I think we’ll come out of this healthier than we went in. Our economy will be rooted in more sustainable investment, instead of all this hocus-pocus where you think you can make risky investments for high growth of your money, but then mix a few differential equations in and make it turn into free money.

If every single one of the important firms of this era has to go down, in the event that this culture was everywhere, so be it. Big firms with a century of history are romantic things to keep around, but if we all are to maintain our freedom to make money for ourselves and our families, then we must also maintain the freedom to lose money.

So I’m glad the Treasury didn’t blink today, even if that gladness is tempered by the continuing rough times facing our economy.

RS contributing editor and “a hardy variety of crabgrass.”
Read the RedState Posting Rules

Unlikely Voter: Poll Analysis, Election Projection.

“I rejoice that America has resisted.” – William Pitt, the Elder

 

If You Have Any Money...

Strelnikov (Diary) Sunday, September 14th at 10:06PM EDT (link)

tomorrow around 11:00 A.M. buy buy buy!

General Mills, Campbell’s, Proctor and Gamble, discount stores, all the basics!

Oh yes! A few oil/energy stocks would be a good buy!

As of November 4, 2008, the Code Words will be: “Klaatu – Borada – Nikto!”

yes, the Treasury didn't blink, that was the key

Mike gamecock DeVine (Diary) Sunday, September 14th at 10:07PM EDT (link)

we are lucky to have paulson now

Mike DeVine’s Examiner.com and Charlotte Observer columns
“One man with courage makes a majority.” – Andrew Jackson

Glad we agree on something :-)

Neil Stevens (Diary) Sunday, September 14th at 10:11PM EDT (link)

RS contributing editor and “a hardy variety of crabgrass.”
Read the RedState Posting Rules

Unlikely Voter: Poll Analysis, Election Projection.

“I rejoice that America has resisted.” – William Pitt, the Elder

If the market were that simple... :-) (nt)

Neil Stevens (Diary) Sunday, September 14th at 10:16PM EDT (link)

RS contributing editor and “a hardy variety of crabgrass.”
Read the RedState Posting Rules

Unlikely Voter: Poll Analysis, Election Projection.

“I rejoice that America has resisted.” – William Pitt, the Elder

 
 
 
 

Be Careful..

MSU_Charles Sunday, September 14th at 10:33PM EDT (link)

over the next few days trying to earn a quick return. I agree with blackhead, if you are not a savvy investor you better proceed with extreme caution.

I personally believe that we might see 500 point circuit breaker tomorrow.

I agree with the lack of intervention on this one. The Fed and Treasury must allow the market to rid itself of some of these weaker firms.

Remember that down cycles (and maybe an actual recession) are necessary in to enable efficiency in capital markets.

I learned a lesson in 2001

mcg Sunday, September 14th at 10:38PM EDT (link)

I don’t trade my own money. Too stressful. In fact, I was the most stressed the day I made the most.

Since then, I’ve also learned not to sweat days like tomorrow either.

Long-Term Thinking in Stocks!

Strelnikov (Diary) Sunday, September 14th at 10:40PM EDT (link)

Buy low, sell high, and think long-term: if you want to treat the market like Las Vegas, then be careful!

And beware of free advice about stock tips! :}

As of November 4, 2008, the Code Words will be: “Klaatu – Borada – Nikto!”

 
 
 

This one has been developing for awhile, unlike Bear, so the psychological shock

streetwise (Diary) Sunday, September 14th at 10:42PM EDT (link)

won’t be as bad. Probably!

Hopefully, the powers-that-be are prepared to act responsibly, with a little pressure from the government if need be.

We CAN all get along :>) nt

streetwise (Diary) Sunday, September 14th at 10:55PM EDT (link)
 

Bad timing for Don Luskin

JohnKaspok Sunday, September 14th at 10:55PM EDT (link)

One of McCain’s advisors penned a piece in the Sunday WaPo titled “A NATION OF EXAGGERATORS Quit Doling Out That Bad-Economy Line”

Not exactly the best time for financial feel-good articles.

We agree on most things bro, and also heard

Mike gamecock DeVine (Diary) Monday, September 15th at 7:39AM EDT (link)

on John Batchelor’s NY radio show last night that Pres Bush has had problems with Fannie Freddie from the git go.

Mike DeVine’s Examiner.com and Charlotte Observer columns
“One man with courage makes a majority.” – Andrew Jackson

Oh I know we do, heh

Neil Stevens (Diary) Monday, September 15th at 9:41AM EDT (link)

It’s just that there are some people I seem to tangle with on here more than others. You and Adam C mostly.

RS contributing editor and “a hardy variety of crabgrass.”
Read the RedState Posting Rules

Unlikely Voter: Poll Analysis, Election Projection.

“I rejoice that America has resisted.” – William Pitt, the Elder

Want to mug AdamC?

Mike gamecock DeVine (Diary) Monday, September 15th at 9:56AM EDT (link)

LOL

Mike DeVine’s Examiner.com and Charlotte Observer columns
“One man with courage makes a majority.” – Andrew Jackson

Heh, I like and respect you and Adam

Neil Stevens (Diary) Monday, September 15th at 10:05AM EDT (link)

I just seem to argue with you guys more than I do most people is all!

I don’t know why that is, but it is, so I like it when we agree.

RS contributing editor and “a hardy variety of crabgrass.”
Read the RedState Posting Rules

Unlikely Voter: Poll Analysis, Election Projection.

“I rejoice that America has resisted.” – William Pitt, the Elder

Free Advice and Philosophy on Stocks

Strelnikov (Diary) Tuesday, September 16th at 6:27AM EDT (link)

A small item in this morning’s (Tuesday, Sept. 16th) Wall Street Journal on page C1 mentions General Mills as the “comfort” stock these days, since it is expected to show a 10% increase on share earnings tomorrow.

I recommended this on Sunday, along with “basic stocks” e.g. Kroger’s, the grocery store chain.

McCain is correct: in general, take a deep breath and let the bubblers burst and learn a lesson about Las-Vegas style thinking in investing in business.

Investing should be about patient, long-term thinking and logical risk, i.e. the willingness to spend money for the creation of a product or service of some kind, thereby increasing employment and long-term wealth for society in general. Investing should NOT be about e.g. trading paper back and forth by computer in the hopes of making a profit after holding it for 5 minutes.

As of November 4, 2008, the Code Words will be: “Klaatu – Borada – Nikto!”