THE 4TH OF JULY IN SAMARRA, IRAQ


Just a Company of American paratroopers, a guitar plugged
into the outpost's PA system, and a whole lot of demolitions.

McCain echos Gamecock in attack on Obama as "insensitive" to the poor

By gamecock Posted in Comments (31) / Email this page » / Leave a comment »

Since I have been at Redstate, I have been begging Republicans to follow David Horowitz's advice, in his Left Illusions, on how to beat Democrats, to frame issues in explicitly moral terms.

Finally, a Republican has done it in the blunt terms needed.

HOW TO HELP LOW-INCOME AMERICANS
McCain: Obama's insensitive to the poor
GOP candidate cites rival's opposition to suspension of fuel tax
RASHA MADKOUR
Associated Press

CORAL GABLES, Fla. --Republican presidential candidate John McCain on Sunday called Democratic rival Barack Obama insensitive to poor people and out of touch on economic issues.

The presumed GOP nominee rapped his Democratic rival for opposing his idea to suspend the tax on fuel during the summer, a proposal that McCain believes will particularly help low-income people who usually have older cars that guzzle more gas.

"I noticed again today that Sen. Obama repeated his opposition to giving low-income Americans a tax break, a little bit of relief so they can travel a little further and a little longer, and maybe have a little bit of money left over to enjoy some other things in their lives," McCain said. "Obviously Sen. Obama does not understand that this would be a nice thing for Americans, and the special interests should not be dictating this policy."

My conservative and Republican friends, this could be a seminal moment. As Horowitz points out, Americans love the underdog, and the main reason for democrats' success over the years, given the failures of their policies, is best explained by how they control the narrative.

Republicans too often come across as policy wonks and too nice. The Bush "new tone" as well as the McCain "honorable friend" old tones come to mind.

The fact is that liberal democrat policies of the past 40 years are immoral in their results, yet, they continue to push the policies to create more victim dependents that will vote for them.

For McCain to call Obama insensitive to the poor is akin to Washington's crossing of the Delaware in rhetorical terms.

It is no sin to advance policies that help lower income families. Conservative policies actually do that. Liberal policies don't. Their policies substitute class warfare anger as a substitute for actual financial help.

Our policies are moral. Theirs are not

Thank you John McCain for being willing to say it out loud. For too long Republicans have endured being called devils with a smile.

I see a trend. John McCain's temper is being re-focused on those that deserve it.

Mike DeVine’s Charlotte Observer columns
The HinzSight Report
The Minority Report
Race 4 2008
"One man with courage makes a majority." - Andrew Jackson

Great post. There are five key arguments that McCain can make in framing Obama as insensitive to poor people (and furthering the divided between Obama and working class voters) and the middle class as a whole.

1. Gas Tax - Obama is more concerned about his environmentalist cronies than about lowering your gas prices.
2. Biofuels - Obama supports ethanol subsidies which is raising food prices and further squeezing lower income Americans
3. School choice - Obama reserves the right to send his daughters to private schools but does not believe that those who cannot afford to should be able to choose their children's educational destiny.
4. Retirement - Obama supports raising the capital gains tax which hurt 100 million Americans and will reduce the nest egg of 401k investments for retirement.
5. Culture - Obama is insensitive to your needs because he doesn't remember where he came from. He's become the offspring of Harvard, Hyde Park, and San Francisco instead of Kansas and Hawaii. He now spends more time worrying about arrugula prices and looking down on your values which courting left-wing elites than he does on actually addressing the issues that matter most to lower-income and middle-income Americans.

There is nothing lonelier than being a black Republican in Boston, Massachusetts

your point five: by kyle8

that is exactly who he is and where he comes from. His mother was a well off, academic radical and he was the black liberal savior from almost the beginning of his life.

"Nothing works like freedom, Nothing succeeds like liberty"
Kyle

One of the most regressive and hurtful taxes there is the gas tax. Everybody pays the same amount. In fact the poor pay more because they can not afford the expensive hybrid like the rich guys. I love seeing a Republican step up and frame the narrative instead of always having to play defense.


The purpose of communist propaganda was not to persuade or convince, nor to inform, but to humiliate; and therefore, the less it corresponded to reality the better.
Dr. Theodore Dalrymple

555-nt by gamecock

Mike DeVine’s Charlotte Observer columns
http://thehinzsightreport.com
www.theminorityreportblog.com
www.race42008.com
"One man with courage makes a majority." - Andrew Jackson

thanks br-nt by gamecock

Mike DeVine’s Charlotte Observer columns
http://thehinzsightreport.com
www.theminorityreportblog.com
www.race42008.com
"One man with courage makes a majority." - Andrew Jackson

toward voting for him. A vicious blow to the Dems following the (successful) push for more Nuclear power in the US...

"Always be honest with yourself. Even if you are honest with no one else."
--me

Will wonders never cease ...?

Romney/Pace 2008

Input?

USC 4 section 8 (a) distress signal: Is It Possible To Do a Convetion at Red State on This?


Help!!/
Spending, Corruption, Earmarks
”Your Silence Is Your Consent!”

We the People remain in charge but McCain responded to the outrage and appears to have gotten the message that expressing faux public outrage against fellow republicans due to fear of the msm pc police is wrong and also counter productive. I think he sees that he need not fear them maybe bfor the first time. Moreover, he is directing real and deserved such outrage at liberals.

I would also say this. I think it would be counter productive for us conservatives, on balance, to put upside down stickers on cars and yard signs, due to its effect on non-political voters.

more later

Mike DeVine’s Charlotte Observer columns
http://thehinzsightreport.com
www.theminorityreportblog.com
www.race42008.com
"One man with courage makes a majority." - Andrew Jackson

I would also say this. I think it would be counter productive for us conservatives, on balance, to put upside down stickers on cars and yard signs, due to its effect on non-political voters.

Good to see others recognize the problem with this campaign. Hope the sense spreads.

______________________________________
Donate to the Rs in Close Senate Races through Slatecard

I'd be interested in Dave's input on it but haven't heard from him yet.


Help!!/
Spending, Corruption, Earmarks
”Your Silence Is Your Consent!”


Help!!/
Spending, Corruption, Earmarks
”Your Silence Is Your Consent!”

Have patience with him. He had been unemployed for quite some time.



Now also found at The Minority Report

Steve is now employed, I'm really not sure what Dave's situation is.

That's what I get for going to the Cardinals game last night. [Did anyone else see that wicked semi-in the park home run! Go Cards!]



Now also found at The Minority Report

Wish I could have seen the game. Sigh.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Just a typical, small town, white girl...

Finally, finally, finally we're addressing this massive hypocrisy of the Democratic Party. We need to push this and develop policies that help the poor help themselves, or at least develop aid programs that actually aid the poor. Turning food into fuel is the height of insanity. You can't eat a barrel of oil. Supporting bio-subsidies is about as abjectly anti-poor as any policy can possibly get. Who gives a crap about CO2 levels when you are starving? Perhaps by not feeding these people we'll at least control another greenhouse gas: methane.

Barack Obama is living a life that is charmed and privileged. 95% of whites will never enjoy such a quality of life. The silver spoon isn't in his mouth, but rather somewhere else. Most white people could only be as lucky.

I hope to heck if he gets elected he tries to zero out this abusive scam.

"Nothing works like freedom, Nothing succeeds like liberty"
Kyle

He can afford a bit of socialism, the poor can't

Great post gc by simpson316

Let's take the fight to the Ds and show the American public that Democrat policies on taxes and the economy affect the poor in great(negative) ways.



Now also found at The Minority Report

This is exactly by rstreu

the sort of leadership I expect from our nominee. The Dems have been claiming to corner the market on social justice for too long -- and it's about time we actually see a politician (as opposed to just Conservative bloggers) calling them out on this BS.

Dare I say it? Way to go, Sen. McCain.

btw, Gamecock by rstreu

I'll be making mention of this post today, as my own official departure (for now) from the Hinz campaign at Independent Thinking.

Mike DeVine’s Charlotte Observer columns
http://thehinzsightreport.com
www.theminorityreportblog.com
www.race42008.com
"One man with courage makes a majority." - Andrew Jackson

"Democrats define compassion by how many people receive welfare, Republicans define compassion by how few need welfare"

I hope Barack continues to attack the gas tax break, his socialist pals at Daily Kook seem to want to make this a real issue.

___________________________________________________________

Molon Labe!

http://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2008/04/29/gas-tax-follies/
"Why doesn’t cutting the gas tax this summer make sense? It’s Econ 101 tax incidence theory: if the supply of a good is more or less unresponsive to the price, the price to consumers will always rise until the quantity demanded falls to match the quantity supplied. Cut taxes, and all that happens is that the pretax price rises by the same amount."

And Heritage has pretty good article on Tax Incidence
http://www.heritage.org/Research/Taxes/cda04-12.cfm
"Taxes affect tax­payers’ behavior, triggering economic changes that regularly shift some or even the entire economic burden of a tax to other parties, and alter total out­put and incomes. Taxes reduce and distort the mix of what people are willing to produce in their roles as workers, savers, and investors. Taxes increase what these producers seek to charge for their ser­vices or products. Changes in the prices and quan­tities of output in turn affect people in their roles as consumers when they try to spend their incomes. The lost output and other consequences of taxation impose additional costs on the taxpay­ers that are not reflected in the mere dollar amounts of the tax collections."

There are various eyes. Even the Sphinx has eyes: and as a result there are various truths, and as a result there is no truth.
~Friedrich Nietzsche

Thanks for the "econ 101" shot.

I will respond with a "Conservative 101". Any time the government reduces taxes, it is a good thing. Where did I say I wanted the price of gas to fall? I said I wanted the tax on gas reduced. Also, I think your theory is bogus. We have seen the demand for gas to this point to be about as inelastic (econ 102 term) as supply. So it stands to reason that many people that MUST pay for x amount of gas a week, will have more money for other things.

I am well aware that cutting taxes will at some point need to go hand in hand with a reduction in government spending. I don't mind cutting taxes first, think of it as tough love for the feds.

___________________________________________________________

Molon Labe!

On your point about reducing taxes, who cares if taxes are reduced if prices are the same. I believe that to be "insensitive" to the poor.
Furthermore, this is not my theory. I cited heritage.org which provided sufficient amount of info on the "tax incidence" and heritage.org isn't a very liberal website.
As long as the demand exists, the tax cut will do nothing. If people continue to consume gas ravenously, the prices will shoot up.
and even if it does something, then right after the tax holiday we'll be back where we were a couple months ago. High gas prices and an insatiable demand, ultimately, solving nothing.

There are various eyes. Even the Sphinx has eyes: and as a result there are various truths, and as a result there is no truth.
~Friedrich Nietzsche

What about my money by speciallist

It takes alot of fuel to fill up my pickup...why wouldn't I want to save a little doe...I can't eat at Long Jon Silvers every night..can I? Your just Anti-taxcut.

"40 million American households with guns are generally happier
than those people in households that don't have guns."

across the border from nc to sc
18 cents is the difference in state gas tax
the same amount of the fed gas tax

it is not bogus

Mike DeVine’s Charlotte Observer columns
http://thehinzsightreport.com
www.theminorityreportblog.com
www.race42008.com
"One man with courage makes a majority." - Andrew Jackson

Really? by PressureP

18 cents less, if I'm doing the math correctly, would save less than 3 dollars per fill-up. If you think that's going to make a difference in driving habits, then we'll just have to disagree. Driving 5 miles probably saved you less than 2 dollars. You probably have a Prius though, so maybe more?

Groups of people gossip about gas prices all the time. I've known people to do exactly what gamecock has said. They will drive to where prices are lower. If you really think that $3 buck is nothing, multiply that $3 bucks by the number of fill ups per week. Then multiply it by the number of cars on the road. That's millions of dollars that consumers can use on other goods and services.



Now also found at The Minority Report


blog advertising is good for you



blog advertising is good for you


 
Redstate Network Login:
(lost password? new user?)


Image

image

Get RedState by E-mail



Delivered by FeedBurner

©2008 Eagle Publishing, Inc. All rights reserved. Legal, Copyright, and Terms of Service