Dede Scozzafava is every bit the Liberal Republican the Grassroots has been warning about for weeks. Bowing to the political reality, reported in the Watertown Daily Times, “that Siena Research Institute poll numbers show her too far behind to catch up - and she lacks enough money to spend on advertising in the last three days to make a difference”, Scozzafava announced this morning she was suspending her campaign. However, claiming that, “Today, I again seek to act for the good of our community,” and, “I am and have always been a proud Republican,” her actions reveal that nothing could be further from the truth. She did not withdraw from the race, she suspended her campaign. While the practical result is the same, the difference is telling.
She continues her explanation with, “It is increasingly clear that pressure is mounting on many of my supporters to shift their support.” Nowhere does she address the reasons for her lack of money or the pressure on her supporters. All of this is understandable. In the pressure of the moment, it’s hard to be either precise or circumspect enough to satisfy everyone. There is, however, one specific thing it is incumbent upon a candidate to do in such a situation. They must tell their supporters what to do next.
At the end of a primary, losing candidates all pledge to rally behind the person who won their Party’s nomination. Hillary Clinton sounded positively Republican in telling the nation how bad a President Barack Obama would be. But when he was the Democrat’s nominee, she supported him and encouraged her followers to do so as well. OK, maybe the PUMA people are evidence she didn’t really do that but you get the idea. The Hoffman challenge of Scozzafava in NY-23 was a primary of sorts. It was a fight to see what values and principles the Right of Center voters in NY-23 would rally behind. The voters chose Hoffman’s and that didn’t sit well with Dede.
What Scozzafava did next was unconscionable. She “[released] those individuals who have endorsed and supported my campaign to transfer their support as they see fit to do so.”
This is key because in her official statement, her very next words were, “I am and have always been a proud Republican.” What a slap in the face to the NRCC and RNC which spent $900,000 in support of her campaign. When the NRCC recently withdrew from the NY-23 race, it made overtures to Hoffman. Scozzafava knows Hoffman is the obvious candidate to support if she gets out. But she couldn’t make herself do it. It is a slap in the face to all the GOP supporters across the country who supported her because they understand the importance of keeping the seat in the GOP. It is a slap in the face to all the people in NY-23 who want Republican representation in DC. With proud Republicans like Scozzafava, the GOP doesn’t need Democrats to worry about. And that’s been the point of Hoffman’s candidacy all along.
Some will rightly argue Hoffman isn’t running as a Republican, he’s the Conservative Party candidate, and so there will be no GOP representation even if Hoffman wins. But Scozzafava herself was running as both the GOP candidate AND the Independence Party candidate. Hoffman would have run on the GOP ticket had he been allowed to. Since there was no primary he had no choice except to run as another Party’s representative. Scozzafava’s refusal to specifically tell her supporters she was supporting Doug Hoffman; that they should support Doug Hoffman, too; and that even though her name was on the ballot, she was requesting her supporters NOT to vote for her but to vote for Hoffman instead can be spun as defending the Republican brand. More likely it will be seen for what it is - what happens when RINOs go on a murderous rampage.
Of course, all this is what you’d expect if Scozzafava’s opponents were correct and folks like Newt Gingrich and the NRCC were wrong. If Scozzafava were the Conservative Republican they said she was, she would have fought hard, been gracious in defeat and supported the candidate with the most Conservative principles moving ahead to Tuesday’s election. Instead she proved herself to be the Liberal RINO she was charged with being and has outed herself as the petty, vindictive and mean-spirited Republican that your Democratic friends are always telling you about. You know the ones. The Democrats in Republican clothing.
Now that this is done, it’s time to focus on Tuesday. We have an election to win!
Cross posted from Blue Collar Muse
Jim Kelly
Caleb Howe
Dan Spencer
James Richardson
Thank you, Ken, for putting this into the correct perspective.
janis Saturday, October 31st at 2:42PM EDT (link)Because I have some Dem friends who are always telling me what big meanies the R’s are, how they are all about just themselves and don’t want to play nice with anyone else.
So now I have face to go with the characterization. How lovely it is that the face belongs to someone that radical lefties like Kos supported!
It gives me no pleasure to do so.
Blue_Collar_Muse Saturday, October 31st at 3:56PM EDT (link)But you’re welcome, nonetheless.
Every time I hear mean spirited Republicans I always think of things like:
Al Gore recanting his concession;
Ashcroft not contesting losing to a dead guy in Missouri;
Thune waving off a constitutionally mandated recount in SD;
The whole Toricelli debacle where the NJ constitution was simply ignored;
the list goes on. For the life of me I can’t figure out why it is that the GOP, with all its problems, still far outperforms the Left when it comes to civility and continues to suffer from being tagged with the label “mean spirited”.
Blue Collar Muse
Smaller Government! Lower Taxes! Stronger Defense! More Liberty! Complete Transparency!
Because we don't have the MSM trumpeting our virtues?
janis Saturday, October 31st at 4:23PM EDT (link)They trumpet the non-existent virtues of the Left continuously, but nothing that our side does is given any credit at all. That’s if it’s even recognized as something to deserve positive credit for. I think that our habit of not shouting about our good deeds or adult behavior is just part of being good citizens and good people.
Take heart, BCM, because they don’t give Christians any credit either. But God does.
My thanks to Penguin for saving me ...
Blue_Collar_Muse Saturday, October 31st at 4:00PM EDT (link)from the embarrassment of having to explain why I said Doug Hoffman was the Constitution Party candidate when in fact he’s the Conservative Party candidate.
I changed the diary above and elsewhere around the interwebz to correct my error.
I especially regret that it might have caused any of you out there to think less of me …
Blue Collar Muse
Smaller Government! Lower Taxes! Stronger Defense! More Liberty! Complete Transparency!
Good pickup, penguin2! And, Ken, we couldn't
janis Saturday, October 31st at 4:19PM EDT (link)possibly think less of you than we already do.
(I’m sorry, that’s not true at all, but it was just sitting there waiting for a comeback…..)
That's what happens when you serve up ...
Blue_Collar_Muse Saturday, October 31st at 5:14PM EDT (link)a hanging curve ball in this crowd. Your mental picture of me should be that of Charlie “Chuck” Brown, the pitcher. Line drive right back across the mound. No deflection or even dodging. Just getting my world rocked …
On a more positive note, I haven’t laughed that hard in at least a week. I think I pulled a hammy or something but it was worth it!
Blue Collar Muse
Smaller Government! Lower Taxes! Stronger Defense! More Liberty! Complete Transparency!
My pleasure, BCM, anytime!
janis Saturday, October 31st at 5:23PM EDT (link)B_C_M, didn't you know that Janis is incorrigible?
penguin2 Saturday, October 31st at 5:45PM EDT (link)Besides being such a great influence…Stick with us here and you will find yourself thinking these RS folks are something else!
Your take on Scozzafava is correct. She was never one of us and her graceless exit adds to the perception. Would have thought more of her if she had run as a Democrat.
Not only do we have to strip the sheep’s clothing from the Democrats, we have to strip the disguise from our own candidates. Well, it is Halloween….
Resistance to tyrants is obedience to God. - Benjamin Franklin
When Good stands up to Evil, Evil blinks. - Vassar Bushmills
Constitutional Knowledge found at: RedState University
Conservative Education: Suggested Reading List
Excellent breakdown BCM, reco'd. nt
Aaron Gardner Saturday, October 31st at 9:56PM EDT (link)Aaron’s Archive I
Aaron’s Archive II
conform and celebrate diversity….or else!!!