« BACK  |  PRINT

RS

MEMBER DIARY

Time to Bail Out the UAW?

Regardless of who wins Tuesday’s election, the next great argument in Washington is whether there will be a second ‘stimulus bill’ (ie, bailout). Constituencies are already lining up. House leaders have heard from mayors, governors and state transportation officials, looking to Washington to save them from the balanced budget requirements imposed on them. Environmentalists are hoping to add billions to fight global warming, and other interest groups are expected to jump into the fray after election day. Where will the money come from? Charlie Rangel is clear: it will be tacked on to the federal deficit.

There will also be tremendous political pressure applied to bail out the U.S. automakers. It will come from Michigan’s Senators and Congressmen, as well as Governor Stabenow. But the most powerful constituency for a bail our of the automakers will be the unions. That’s because — as Steven Pearlstein points out — they would be the prime beneficiary:

The real flaw in the government-financed merger proposal is that it spares the companies from bankruptcy reorganization, the very process they need to get their costs and structure in line with market realities.

Only a bankruptcy court can reduce the burden of pension and health benefits to 600,000 retirees that are slated to cost the companies $90 billion over the next decade…

And only a bankruptcy court can impose on members of the United Auto Workers pay and benefit packages comparable to those paid at the nonunionized plants of foreign manufacturers that have been stealing market share from the Big Three for decades.

If the Treasury were to commit government funds without getting this kind of long-overdue restructuring, it would simply be throwing good money after bad.

Do the American taxpayers want to see billions more of their hard-earned tax dollars spent propping up companies and unions that have spent years using Washington to protect themselves from the realities of the market?

COMMENTS

  • pa_scientist

    I wish to bail out neither the UAW nor the white-collar workers at the big three. The execs at those companies should share the blame for the demise of the US auto industry. Have any of these guys taken courses in strategy or marketing? If you can’t win on cost, differentiate your product! They need the auto industry equivalent of Steve Jobs. For years there has really been nothing exciting about US cars. People by them because with the admirable goal of buying American, but truth be-told the their cars are uninspiring and poorly engineered.

    Rant aside, the pressure to prop up the big three is going to be enormous. We’ll hear statistics about how one out of every 10 US jobs is tied to the auto industry, etc. Also, people will no doubt cry afoul about how government was willing to rescue wall street jobs but not main street jobs.

    If the Democrats sweep I expect we’ll see fiscal conservatives use this as a starting point for trying to re-build the Republican brand.

  • briefsynopsis

    And this may be the only opening that we get.
    Once the masks come off the White “Props” that have been staged behind “The One” and are replaced by the likes of Ayers, Wright, Farrakhan, Jackson, Sharpton, et al., It will than be our job to implement the dem strategy of driving a wedge using the same grass roots model employed against us. The “Blue Dog’s” will be shocked by what their party before the people mentality has wrought. Our mission is very clear, –to smash to bits the MS(L)M generated vilification of conservatism.* We must also look within our own house and cast off the Country Club elites and their intellectually superior attitudes. From my low altitude, 3.5 to 8.0 on a scale of 1 to 10 fit perfectly the conservative fold. We have seen, with this election cycle, that those in the very upper and very lower ends are PURPLE, we have been sold a linear scale, when in fact the scale is circular with over lap occurring primarily in the parasitical elites from 8.5 – 10 and from 1 – 2.5.
    Lets stop Obama and his hell bent destruction of America on Tuesday, but should that fail, lets first define what we will not accept and attack it by opening eyes, not self flagellation.

  • izoneguy

    neither Chrysler or people that are behind in their mortgage.
    it would never end. Soon, no one would have an incentive to pay their mortgage or run a company in an efficient manner.
    I do work for small business up to Fortune 100 companies.
    The waste in large corporations is awful. The biggest problem is government regulation and government human resource issues.
    If a company could fire unproductive people without fear of lawsuits that alone would correct some of our economic problems. Socialism is alive and well in most large corporations.

  • drawlings

    When these naive voters realize that Obama can not give them free food, housing, a college education, and pay off their credit cards, they will go from euphoria to disillusionment very quickly.

  • briefsynopsis

    As interesting…, Obama’s apparent lead with Jews, Muslims, and Christians!? Alot of somebody’s are going to get really upset! I personally think this will mark the end of Israel. Christianity will be under siege from Black Liberation Theology, And the Muslims are going to feel betrayed if “The One” does not emerge as one of them! I have no doubt that this chatter about a homeland civil defense corp is a sharp understanding on the Dems part that once the “Fool-aid” wears off all hell is going to break loose! As a security consultant that means I will do just fine!

  • Raven

    And I doubt it’ll be the last time.

    We’ve been bailing out at least 1 US automaker every 5 to 10 years for the last 30 or 40 years as it is thanks to the UAW and the Execs’ repeated bending over and grabbing their ankles every time the UAW wants to renegotiate.

  • summernite

    Granholm is the Governor. Stabenow is the Jr. Senator of Michigan

  • MuskegonCritic

    From the Democrats. I think Michigan should drop its Right To Work laws, kiss the UAW goodbye, and encourage Hyundai, Toyota, and Honda to set up shop. Bailout GM and Ford? Eh…if they haven’t learned their lesson by now, screw ‘em.

  • Rural_Michigan

    Michigan gets what it deserves. Until people wise up around here, they better get comfy with liberal policies – and yes that means more job loss and pain for the Big Three. It’s time Michigan gets past automotive – invest in something else. Michigan just isn’t a great place to do business right now. Two more years until the witch in Lansing is gone! It’s about time, with approval ratings as low as Congress.

  • ricbach229

    I was a member for 7 years and they were a pretty good union, I have a lot of family that work at the Ford plants in Kentucky and Michigan, so I’ve always been sympathetic towards them. What’s killing me is that the company doesn’t seem to be very motivated to get new products out or retool their plants. After a decade they seem to have found a comfortable operating system around economic collapse. The old guys who remember the good days are retiring and the young guys with less than 10-12 years experience only know the current slow death method of operation. They just don’t have enough guys with 10-20 years experience left that know that they need to light a fire under some asses and get things done, rather than just doing things by the book.

    Between the lack of outward motivation by the companies, and the Employee Free Choice Act, I’m really feeling that they should be actively opposed rather than ignored in the market place.

  • briefsynopsis

    as were most of my family here in Northern Lower Michigan. My grandfather (fiercely loyal Democrat) had a bumper sticker on his Dodge Pickup that read, “If you don’t like the police, Next time your in trouble, call a hippie”. When did I become counter culture?*
    I have witnessed firsthand the demise of a once great state, look no further than Michigan (New York, California) to see what is in store for the rest of the nation!

    Warning* **A child will not value, that which a parent affix’s no worth