Will NY GOP Nominate Liberal in House Special?


As Congress has been debating Obamacare, cap-and-trade, and the Sotomayor nomination, the cracks in the Democrat foundation are starting to become clear. Americans recognize the failure of Obama’s approach to the economy. They worry that massive government intervention in health care will lead to rationing. And they fear the colossal drag on the economy that Obama and the Democrats seek to impose through new and higher taxes.

In short, Americans are becoming more conservative.

With that in mind, the upcoming special Congressional election in New York’s 23rd district is well worth watching. Republicans are considering 9 different candidates for the nomination, but the focus is on New York State Assemblywoman Dede Scozzafava. Scozzafava is a union supporter who has voted for gay marriage, and has pledged to support abortion rights in the state. Her views are liberal enough that there has been a strong push on the Left to recruit her for the Democratic nomination for the seat. Her views cost her the endorsement of New York’s politically-important Conservative party last year, and earned her the backing of the leftist ‘Working Families’ party.

In a special election that will depend on the ability to rally the base in a traditionally Republican district, why would New York Republicans nominate a candidate who splits the party badly? Furthermore, New York Republicans have traditionally attached a high value to the endorsement of the Conservative party. Having ‘the conservative line’ on the ballot is often the margin of victory for winning Republican candidates. Why throw that asset away by nominating a liberal Republican who seems out of step with the district, out of step with the Republican party nationwide, and out of step with the national mood?

Republicans and conservatives around the country are watching. They stand ready to provide support in what will be seen as a bellwether race. Republicans in New York’s 23rd district shouldn’t ignore that as they choose their standard-bearer.

Category: ,

RSS feed | Trackback URI

8 Comments Leave a comment

Are you really asking this

johnCV Thursday, July 16th at 1:52PM EDT (link)

In a special election that will depend on the ability to rally the base in a traditionally Republican district, why would New York Republicans nominate a candidate who splits the party badly?

Or is it just a rhetorcial question? Nobody snatches defeat from the jaws of victory like the GOP.

 

Rudy Guilliani

mbauer Thursday, July 16th at 2:10PM EDT (link)

If I recall correctly, he had the working families endorsement and his opponent had the conservative party’s endorsement.

So, maybe this isn’t that simple?

Rudy Giuliani?

Brian Faughnan Thursday, July 16th at 3:30PM EDT (link)

If you’re arguing that a Republican can win in New York with the Working Families endorsement, I agree. But New York city has little in common with the 23rd district.

New York city has 4 or 5-1 Democratic enrollment, and it elects Democrats to almost all offices, by overwhelming margins. The 23rd district elects boatloads of Republicans, as well as moderate Democrats.

There’s not much reason to think that what works in Manhattan will work in Plattsburgh. The outgoing Congressman had a lifetime rating of more than 70 percent from the ACU. A winning Republican probably ought to look something like that.

 
 

Not only the backing of the Working Families Party...

randy streu Thursday, July 16th at 2:50PM EDT (link)

She’s part of it. I have a huge problem with Scozzafava. Especially with some better Conservatives on the horizon.

 

Is the concern vote-splitting among the conservatives allowing Scozzafava to sneak in?

civil_truth Thursday, July 16th at 3:36PM EDT (link)

Will there be a run-off if no one wins an outright majority, or does a plurality win. If it comes down to a run-off, then surely a conservative should win that one

Hoewver, if a plurality decides, the conservative candidates need to put aside petty ambition and decide among themselves who is the strongest candidate so as to prevent such a scenario.

Otherwise, conservatives have no one to blame but themselves.

I'm still learning how NY politics work, but I don't think we GET a primary, per se.

randy streu Thursday, July 16th at 3:51PM EDT (link)

I think the Party makes the decision, and then they’re on the ballot. The problem is, from what little I’ve seen of St. Lawrence County (the bulk of the district) GOP, it’s not all that Conservative, though SLC itself tends to be VERY, and pretty much based on the “you scratch my back” method of politics. The big problem is, the best and brightest just don’t have time to become Party insiders. I’m working on it, though. ;)

So its the party insiders who get to make the pick, not the voters?

civil_truth Thursday, July 16th at 3:54PM EDT (link)

That’s a horse of a different color - pointing out again the importance of getting into the party structure, as many have advised here at RedSTate.

Based on how it's been going down, I believe that to be the case, yeah. nt.

randy streu Thursday, July 16th at 3:59PM EDT (link)
 
 
 

Leave a Comment

 

Be respectful, or be banned. No Profanity.