« BACK  |  PRINT

RS

MEMBER DIARY

America Does Not Need a Government Run Health Care System

Two days and two health care town halls. At least, that was what I had planned for. Instead, as nearly three thousand of my constituents turned out to express their concerns about Obamacare, we held a second town hall each night for the folks who couldn’t get into the first ones. All in all, everyone was passionate but very civil with their questions and comments.

What folks said in my four town halls was akin to what others have been repeating at gatherings all across America. In Clarkesville, I was asked why so many expensive bills – like Obamacare – are being rapidly pushed through Congress. They have concerns that big mistakes will be made if health care reform is rushed through so quickly. I could not agree more.

We have seen hurried mistakes with the recent bank bailouts, the so-called “stimulus,” and cash for clunkers, because they were rammed through Congress with little or no debate. Health care reform impacts a very large part of our economy and our daily lives. Doesn’t Congress owe it to Americans to have an open and meaningful debate that produces a plan supported by a large bipartisan majority? I think it does. But that’s not what the President and Democrat leaders in Congress are doing.

America’s health care system needs reform. But it does not need to be transformed into a government-run program. Bureaucracies simply do not cut costs, and they have never increased efficiency. I don’t know about you, but I don’t want to turn my family’s health care over to the same system running the Post Office. With a $7 billion operating loss this year alone, even the President admits that, “If you think about it, UPS and FedEx are doing just fine. It’s the Post Office that’s always having problems.” Unfortunately, Obamacare would hand over control of the health care system to likely the same system failing at the USPS.

Other constituents, in Augusta, asked about health care costs and portability. As a medical doctor, I have seen these problems first hand, and I believe that we must work to lower health care costs, allow folks the opportunity to shop for health care plans across state lines, and the ability to take their health insurance with them when they switch jobs. But instead of reinventing the wheel and placing bureaucrats in direct control of a huge part of our lives, we should institute meaningful market-based reforms that will lower costs across the board and allow doctors to provide care to the neediest patients.

In the United Kingdom, their health care bureaucracy (NHS) has become the 3rd largest employer in the world – just behind China’s Red Army. But a big bureaucracy certainly hasn’t helped. Aside from its unbearable budget, earlier this year, an investigation of an NHS hospital in Staffordshire found dehydrated patients forced to drink water from flower vases, accident victims left untended for hours, clinical judgments being made by receptionists and the unnecessary deaths of between 400 and 1,200 patients. When questioned, both Prime Minister Gordon Brown and Health Secretary Alan Johnson issued an apology on behalf of the government bureaucracy.

We must lower health care costs and make coverage available to more people, but we must not sacrifice our freedom, our principles, or our children’s future for a new government bureaucracy. Please join me and millions of other Americans in stopping Obamacare in its tracks, and instead working together to make health care more affordable and accessible for all Americans.

COMMENTS

  • Sharp_Right_Turn

    We want AFFORDABLE health care. Not a socialized, government-sanctioned health care system. As the saying goes, “If you think health care is expensive now, wait and see what happens when it becomes free.”

    • http://www.marklaiminger.org Lammo

      who don’t cover all of our citizens so we must adopt a British/Canadian style plan. As the elected prosecutor who hired me always used to say: Maybe we are the only ones doing it the right way.

      Stop this monstrosity by all means necessary. Absolutely do not pass a bill just to pass one and do not “governmentize” our heatlh care just because everyone else has.

  • mallcopsaysno

    Given the current state of affairs, Obama’s plan flailing, it’s time I believe to start putting forth a serious alternative. It’s time to propose legislation. It’s time to start referencing bills in committee that will improve the health care situation in this country without putting it all under government control. It’s time for more doctors to speak up about what happens when health care becomes a “right.”

    It isn’t enough to say no. There is a real crisis of health care costs in this country. Conveniently for us, and unlike a goverment-run plan, the solutions we propose don’t necessarily have to wait for a healthy economy. Americans need to hear what those solutions are and how they would work.

  • sickofitall

    For the comments and insight. I for one am not surprised at the close standing of Britain’s healthcare system and the Red Army. As a tangent, I hope that this discussion paves the way for a discussion on turning the USPS over to the private sector, as well as numerous other govt. programs (Social Security, SEC, EPA, etc). Also, I’d personally like to thank you for my sig file- I feel like you were the first of many to make this startling and all-too true comparison.

  • http://www.ssce.net/Web-Articles/Web-articles-indexed-authors.html#authors-l JLenardDetroit

    and you need to make sure all your fellow Party members look at: Republicans must be the Party of NO [to Bigger Govt.] not the Party of SLOW[er Liberal Incremental-ism] (especially Senate Republicans and even more especially John McLame as we disussed his lack of understanding as demonstrated by him at his Townhall [McCain is appropriately BOO'ed at his Townhall]) and ensure they do NOT act like Democrats holding Townhall Dog and Pony shows (Dingell Townhall – Democrat Health Care Townhall propaganda – a place to report the Dem’s Talking Points (read: Lies) and refute them with specifics More Townhall Hi-jinks – More HC Townhall Hi-jinks) and don’t help us when (Dealing with our Frustration with the Politically Brain-dead) because you undermine our efforts to educate others why the Bills must be completely killed and started over from scratch when folks try to still compromise (Gang of Sicks (er… Six) – The Senate HC “Gang Of Sicks” (formerly 7, but Hatch left and that didn’t have the fun play on words ;-) lol)) even after every Republican Amendment gets defeated by Party line votes!!!!

    • http://www.ssce.net/Web-Articles/Web-articles-indexed-authors.html#authors-l JLenardDetroit

      The Car Dealerships have been spending way more time and effort dealing with the Govt. Paperwork over the CARS program than selling Vehicles (and, an aside, created another artificial BUBBLE ala CRA/Mortgage-meltdown)….

      There will be less and less Doctors but higher and higher COSTS as Hospitals, Doctors’ Offices, etc, have to hire in more and more Lawyers and Office Administrators to deal with the BILLING PAPERWORK to beg the Federal Govt. SINGLE PAYER PLAN to actually pay the bills they promised would be covered DRIVING COSTS UP NOT DOWN!!!!! Further, as the Govt. CAPS more coverage levels at 80% payments HYPER-INFLATION OF FEES will ensue in order to adjust up the amount received at the 80% cut rates!

      This math is simple and we’ve seen how Govt. monies have driven up costs (flooding Education with money, Medicare, etc) NOT reduced them … EVER!!!!