In his editorial in the Wall Street Journal today, Karl Rove points out a few facts that should be obvious. Unfortunately, the liberal spin machine that is the MSM has largely refused to acknowledge them.
Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac were under-regulated, and that did contribute to their recent problems. But the lack of proper oversight was not the fault of the Bush Administration or John McCain, regardless of how many times you have been told that it was.
No, the responsibility lies in large part at the feet of Chris Dodd, Barney Frank and their friends in the Democratic caucus. Because they were blinded by their desire, rooted in good intentions, no doubt, but pursued at any cost, to get minorities and poor people into homes regardless of whether or not they could afford them, Democrats cried racism and charged Republicans as being elitist. They refused to allow anything that might slow the flood of unqualified new homeowners.
When Republican Richard Shelby of Alabama, then chairman of the Senate Banking Committee, pushed for comprehensive GSE reform in 2005, Democrat Sen. Chris Dodd of Connecticut successfully threatened a filibuster. Later, after Fannie and Freddie collapsed, Mr. Dodd asked, “Why weren’t we doing more?” He then voted for the Bush reforms that he once called “ill-advised.”
But Mr. Dodd wasn’t the only Democrat to heap abuse on the Bush reforms. Rep. Barney Frank of Massachusetts defended Fannie and Freddie as “fundamentally sound” and labeled the president’s proposals as “inane.” He later voted for the reforms. Sen. Charles Schumer of New York dismissed Mr. Bush’s “safety and soundness concerns” as “a straw man.” “If it ain’t broke, don’t fix it,” was the helpful advice of both Sen. Thomas Carper of Delaware and Rep. Maxine Waters of California. Rep. Gregory Meeks of New York berated a Bush official at a hearing, saying, “I am just pissed off” at the administration for raising the issue.
But when things started to fall apart, the tunes changed quickly. Suddenly, it was Bush’s watch that this happened on, and John McCain was the great deregulator. Free markets had failed, was the cry, regardless of the fact that everything was set in motion by massive market intervention. Nary a word was whispered by the media about the CRA, for example, or about the threats Congress made towards banks who threatened to only lend to, you know, people who could pay their mortgages.
It is nice to read the facts in a newspaper. Too bad there are so few reporters who can be troubled to write them.
Cross-posted at The Artful Doddger.

John McCain had the opportunity to educate Americans about the GSE fiasco, but he passed.
Martin Knight Friday, January 9th at 6:02AM EST (link)The stupid old fool just couldn’t bring himself to place the blame squarely where it belonged, because it wouldn’t be “nice” and “bipartisan” - his “friends” across the aisle wouldn’t be his friends anymore and he wouldn’t get invited to the Sunday Morning talk shows so Stephy and Blitzer can call him a “Maverick.”
Don’t blame the newspapers, they were out to elect Obama, we knew it, and by September (I think) our candidate knew it. They did what we knew they would do, essentially campaign for the Democrat by hiding inconvenient facts, as they have done in every election for the past four to five decades.
That we had no plan or infrastructure to deal with this sort of eventuality after all this time is our fault and our fault alone.
Then in Many Ways,
wennejunk Friday, January 9th at 7:19AM EST (link)It’s probably good he didn’t get elected.
Of course, he might have slowed the slide into the abyss ahead that Obama seems intent on pressing down pedal towards.
However, if he was unable/unwilling to show leadership of a quality and intensity needed to gain America’s attention on this issue when everyone was watching and weighing, he likely would not have been able to do so once he was in office.
There are only two kinds of people in the end: those who say to God, ‘Thy will be done,’ and those to whom God says, in the end, ‘Thy will be done.’ -C. S. Lewis
McCain's campaign manager was a Fannie Mae consultant
6eorge Jetson Friday, January 9th at 7:30AM EST (link)And so what do you think the campaign manager was telling McCain?
For all his talk of “serving his country”, McCain put some form of his own interest ahead of that of the country by his feeble and infrequent attempts to address the Fannie/Freddie issue with vigor. I couldn’t believe my ears when he passed on the issue in the first debate. Dumbfounded, at the time the only explanation I could come up with was that McCain was saving the big punch for later. But alas, he never threw it with any conviction.
And as far as the Democratic record on financial regulation, it’s not like they had a 40-1 levered Long Term Capital Management blow up on their regulatory watch in 1998 or anything like that.
While what you say is true
Justin_Case Friday, January 9th at 6:24AM EST (link)about McCain, it then raises the question of why didn’t the Administration and the Republican controlled Congress insist that reforms be made back in 2001?
To me, Karl Rove’s column is an example of too little, too late.
As one who still bears frustration towards the Bush Administration for its unwillingness to properly explain why the war in Iraq was/is a just cause and not illegal, I’m waiting with baited breath for a Rovian explanation in an upcoming WSJ article.
The Truth Doesn't Matter on Housing -
Achance Friday, January 9th at 6:33AM EST (link)The Ds got their legend out there and it is now a KnownFact that greedy Republicans and their crooked bankers caused all the problems and are all now sitting on a beach drawing 20% off the bailout money.
That said, I’m certainly no fan of the mortgage industry; even the good ones played fast and loose because they just wanted something they could tie a bow on and sell. I can’t believe some of the things I was offered and we have a generally conservative banking and mortage industry here - those that weren’t didn’t survive the Oil Price Crash of ‘86.
And Martin is right, the old fool had the chance and might have even been able to hold on to his lead if he’d gone out front on this issue. As it was, any hope of winning ended with the stupid suspend the campaign stunt and then just meekly going along.
In Vino Veritas
No, it's Franklin Raines and Jim Johnson that are sitting on the beach
6eorge Jetson Friday, January 9th at 7:55AM EST (link)having made hundreds and tens of millions in bonuses off the hedge funds that were disguised as Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac.
How these purported advocates of “affordable housing” that profited wildly as housing became very unaffordable get a free pass on destroying the wealth of lower income folk with their policies is beyond me. As usual, these Democratic leeches used the implied credit of the US government to obtain below market funding rates (the govt w/ it’s ability to tax is more credit worthy than, say, Citicorp). Further, Fannie & Freddie had the blessing of the govt to leverage itself up to levels questioned by Republicans but protected by Democrats.
Excerps from a prescient Fortune article dated 11/20/2007 Why were capital ratios so low for Fannie and Freddie?
I agree
CTVoter2010 Friday, January 9th at 12:19PM EST (link)with much that has been said, especially as it concerns the gross failure of Bush and McCain to coherently explain their positions on this, Iraq, and any number of other issues. But the fact that they failed in that way does not make the underlying problems their fault. It makes the truth that much harder to explain to the masses, but it doesn’t shift the blame.
As for why Bush and the R’s didn’t do something about it, it was a pretty small window between when Bush got settled in at the WH and 9/11. Could it have been done, probably, but there was no way to know that they only had a few months until their attention would be diverted and all political capital otherwise expended.
And Martin, I do blame the newspapers. Regardless of how bad the media is, that does not change what their responsibility is. The fact that they have replaced reporting with editorializing is not a reason to avoid holding them accountable. Under the guise of relaying facts, they consistently pass on Democratic talking points. Until they either report fairly or explicitly and officially acknowledge their role as liberal cheerleaders instead of reporters, it is their fault.
“…among his intimate friends he was better known by the sobriquet of ‘The Artful Dodger,’ [and] Oliver concluded that, being of a dissipated and careless turn, the moral precepts of his benefactor had hitherto been thrown away upon him.” - Oliver Twist
http://www.theartfuldoddger.blogspot.com
The reason why Bush and the R Congress didn't do anything about Fannie and Freddie ...
Martin Knight Friday, January 9th at 5:17PM EST (link)Ever heard of “New Tone”?
As of January 2005, Bush had 55 Senators and 231 Representatives wearing Rs behind their names. His Treasury Secretary, like his predecessor had done in 2001, 2002 and 2003 that year came before Congress to complain about the danger to the economy posed by the two GSEs.
Democrats, of course, like they’d done before, went ape that a cash cow of theirs was being threatened with oversight and of course, Republicans in Congress, particularly our “moderates”, desiring nothing more than to be loved by their friends across the aisle (and invited to their swanky cocktail parties), backed down.
And as for Bush, he followed the “New Tone” philosophy, which posits that the American people desire nothing more than to see Democrats and Republicans holding hands and singing Kumbayah in DC. He also backs down, and continued to back down over the next two years until it all came crashing down around his head.
Nail meet hammer.
mbecker908 Friday, January 9th at 8:00PM EST (link)Having a POTUS who effectively believed in nothing abhorrent to Democrats is precisely the killer. And not just with F/F. You can add in his comical, not-even-close-to-half-hearted attempt to “reform” social security. Or his outrage at the NYT over printing classified material. Or…
And as for blaming the newspapers/MSM ...
Martin Knight Friday, January 9th at 5:54PM EST (link)… what do you imagine their responsibility is? Let me answer that; none. The First Amendment’s “Freedom of the Press” clause applies to them no more and no less than it applies to you, which means they have no more responsibility than you do to tell the truth or be impartial relayers of fact.
In fact, looking at the history of journalism in America the idea of a non-partisan objective Press is relatively recent. Most, if not all, newspapers began their lives as party organs. i.e. one of the first things any new political party in 1700s and 1800s would do at its inception was establish a network of newspapers and staff them with loyalists. How do you imagine those papers reported the stories of the day/week/month/year?
The issue now is that what’s old is new again; the days of the partisan Press are back, and the GOP has been caught flat-footed. Most of Big Media - from the Big Three networks to the nation’s major national, regional and state newspapers - is now owned, run and staffed almost exclusively by liberals, Democrats and people who contribute to Democrats. Naturally they would pass on Democratic talking points as facts and be cheerleaders for liberal candidates and agendas.
I don’t begrudge them that because I believe in private property and the First Amendment.
The responsibility falls on us to make them pay. And we haven’t even begun to do that. The only time a Republican made the effort was the speech given by Spiro Agnew in Des Moines nearly forty years ago. Reagan was content to simply go around them instead of challenging them directly. Bush I and II didn’t even bother to do that and they both ended up being filleted.
After all this time, the fact that the GOP continues to operate as if we have a Press Corps that is not anything but an adjunct of the DNC by the time it gets to campaign season (and a PR ally before that) that we have to force our message through is now entirely our fault.
I DO blame the Treason Media
E Pluribus Unum Friday, January 9th at 6:01PM EST (link)The larger point is true - they have a right to be slimy, lying leftist Marxists who hate America. And the follow-up point is also true — that Republicans have been extremely cowardly and craven in response.
I say with you, make the bbbstards pay, hard. And I do blame them as the primary culprit in the downfall of the GOP and the ascension of this despicable crowd that now runs our nation and desires, post-haste, to drive it into the ground.
Carthago delenda est
Do your conservative t-shirt Christmas shopping at EPU Gear. Save the conservative muse, save the world.
You don't blame a slug for leaving a trail of slime behind it. It's in its nature.
Martin Knight Friday, January 9th at 6:15PM EST (link)The truth is I don’t expect any better from liberals in any position of power. That’s just how they roll.
Your point of view is correct
E Pluribus Unum Friday, January 9th at 6:19PM EST (link)But I’m possessed of a less than pure heart. I blame the slug, and I drop a great big concrete brick onto it.
I hope to do the same to the Treason Media, and I will curse them as they die ugly.
Carthago delenda est
Do your conservative t-shirt Christmas shopping at EPU Gear. Save the conservative muse, save the world.
I don't blame them either.
itrytobenice Friday, January 9th at 7:13PM EST (link)But I liberally (if you’ll excuse the term) apply salt and take care of the problem.
I’m doing everything I can to eliminate the market for the MSM. I cancelled all my subscriptions, I don’t read their websites and I do read their competition.
And I use Craig’s List. Just for a little extra salt.
The problem with America is stupidity. I’m not saying there should be capital punishment for stupidity, but why don’t we just take the safety labels off of everything and let the problem solve itself?
You are living up to your name.....
E Pluribus Unum Friday, January 9th at 7:18PM EST (link)HAH! I’ve been waiting for MONTHS for a good chance to say that!
Carthago delenda est
Do your conservative t-shirt Christmas shopping at EPU Gear. Save the conservative muse, save the world.
Well it's a lot nicer...
itrytobenice Friday, January 9th at 7:31PM EST (link)than a concrete block!!!!
Or is it torture? Oh dear.
The problem with America is stupidity. I’m not saying there should be capital punishment for stupidity, but why don’t we just take the safety labels off of everything and let the problem solve itself?
That is indeed the rub -nt
E Pluribus Unum Friday, January 9th at 7:34PM EST (link)Carthago delenda est
Do your conservative t-shirt Christmas shopping at EPU Gear. Save the conservative muse, save the world.
Equally at fault are the universities
bs Friday, January 9th at 6:17PM EST (link)who produce the reporters from J-school that slant their stories to the Left. The mush-filled brains that emerge from universities now are so thoroughly indoctrinated in leftist propaganda that they can’t help but write biased stuff.
I am convinced that the only way to sway the country back in the right direction is to recapture the education system, and I’ll be damned if I can tell you how that could happen.
Decorum is fo’ suckas - unless it’s one of the good guys
Start with State Boards of Regents in Red States.
Achance Friday, January 9th at 8:07PM EST (link)Nobody pays any attention to these appointments, but usually the Board of Regents is a gubernatorial appointment with legislative confirmation. We need to make it a Party priority to pay attention, the Left controls these by default. The “Education Community” suggests some Educrats and if they haven’t given to the CPUSA or something, the Gov sends their name to the Leg.. If a Republican gives it any thought at all, he picks some rich guy who might give an endowment to the U and rewards him with a regency.
Likewise, State Boards of Education and State Superintendents of Schools where they’re appointed, even where they’re elected; it is that important.
In Vino Veritas
The media is not a player
mbecker908 Friday, January 9th at 7:56PM EST (link)unless the guy with the bully pulpit allows them to be.
Example: Ronald Wilson Reagan. The beating he took from D’s and the media was 100 times worse than Bush ever got. Yet on every - repeat every - major issue he prevailed.
you're saying that the RNC/Politicians/Wealthy benefactors have to start up Republican newspapers?
LJ "Beaglescout" Miller Friday, January 9th at 6:36PM EST (link)How far does the Republican party need to go in order to match the Democrats for newspaper coverage? The newspaper business is tanking. Will a lively bunch of republican newspapers turn it around, or is this all about throwing good money after bad?
“Each of us has a natural right, from God, to defend his person, his liberty, and his property.”
At this point, with a few spare nickels
E Pluribus Unum Friday, January 9th at 7:35PM EST (link)we can buy *theirs*.
Carthago delenda est
Do your conservative t-shirt Christmas shopping at EPU Gear. Save the conservative muse, save the world.
Seattle Post Intelligencer
LJ "Beaglescout" Miller Saturday, January 10th at 1:47AM EST (link)It’s one of the most lib papers out there and it’s going up for sale. Know anyone with deep pockets who wants to do a turnaround on a big lib paper in the middle of a depression?
“Each of us has a natural right, from God, to defend his person, his liberty, and his property.”
They certainly have the constitutional right to say whatever they want
CTVoter2010 Friday, January 9th at 11:43PM EST (link)I don’t think anyone is saying otherwise. What I blame the media for is spreading their liberal talking points while parading around as noble, truth-seeking public servants.
I know it is BS, and you know it, but I truly believe much of the country does not. They don’t care what the historical foundation of the journalism industry is; they believe the job of the media is to disseminate facts and they believe what they hear.
Conservatives certainly bear responsibility for allowing the media to get away with it without adequately challenging them, and I don’t blame the media for fooling me; but I blame them for taking the rest of the country down with them. I agree we need to make them pay, and I am happy to help.
“…among his intimate friends he was better known by the sobriquet of ‘The Artful Dodger,’ [and] Oliver concluded that, being of a dissipated and careless turn, the moral precepts of his benefactor had hitherto been thrown away upon him.” - Oliver Twist
http://www.theartfuldoddger.blogspot.com
Wrong Again
VanishingNYRep Friday, January 9th at 4:01PM EST (link)You are not getting it. McCain never raised the issue because he doesn’t and can not talk economics. He is a national security guy. He votes conservatively on economic issue because he doesn’t know what else to do. There is no way he could have debated this isssue without making a fool of himself.
As for President Bush, he never insisted on reforming the GSEs because he was too preoccupied with the Iraq and Afganistan wars. Moreover, he never fought back against the Dems on any issue. I beleive that this was a result of the VP’s advise that good policy is good politicas and that he shouldn’t worry about bad press. Anyone who has ever runa campaign knows that in the ordianry person’s mind, the unanswered attack, not matter how farfetched becomes the truth. Witness the Katrina fiasco and the “Bush doesn’t like black people” lie. I am still mazed that people actually beleived it but they did and it was because the Administration didn’t respond to its critics.
As onservatives, we must take the fight to the liberal-dems at every level: School Board, City Council, county Comm, State Legislature. It is okay to fight and lose and election. Let’s not let the liberal-Dems win by default.
Nice Alliteration nt
davo119 Friday, January 9th at 7:56PM EST (link)Never give in! Never! Never! Never!
Thanks!
CTVoter2010 Friday, January 9th at 11:48PM EST (link)Thanks!
“…among his intimate friends he was better known by the sobriquet of ‘The Artful Dodger,’ [and] Oliver concluded that, being of a dissipated and careless turn, the moral precepts of his benefactor had hitherto been thrown away upon him.” - Oliver Twist
http://www.theartfuldoddger.blogspot.com