« BACK  |  PRINT

RS

FRONT PAGE CONTRIBUTOR

McCain and Obama: A Tale of Two Platforms

McCain's Forbearance, Obama's Abortion Extremism

A little compare-and-contrast regarding the party platforms. On the GOP side, John McCain has decided against a bitter battle to bend the party platform to match his own idiosyncratic views:

Republicans are inviting suggestions for their party platform this year, and thousands have responded online. But when a committee meets to draft the document in Minneapolis next week, one voice will be largely absent: John McCain’s.

The Republican standard-bearer is at odds with his party on such hot-button issues as global warming, immigration, campaign-finance overhaul, stem-cell research, drilling in the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge and a constitutional amendment banning gay marriage. Many party stalwarts are also deeply skeptical when it comes to judicial nominations, given his Senate record.

Instead of fighting with party activists to form the platform around his own ideas, Sen. McCain has taken a hands-off approach. He “is a voice in this process,” says Steven Duffield, executive director of the platform committee. But “this is ultimately a party platform,” he adds. Sen. McCain seems to agree. “The delegates are going through the process and we are going to let them work their will on the platform,” campaign spokeswoman Jill Hazelbaker said in an email in response to questions about drafting the party platform.

Meanwhile, Barack Obama’s own staff was principally involved in writing the Democrats’ platform:

Platform writers for Barack Obama and Hillary Rodham Clinton worked side-by-side Saturday as the Democratic Party developed a policy statement to promote nominee-in-waiting Obama and keep Clinton backers involved.

The 20-member drafting committee heard Friday and Saturday morning from scores of party regulars, policy experts and hard-luck Americans before beginning a draft of the platform, which goes before the full platform committee Aug. 9 in Pittsburgh.

The committee, meeting through Sunday, reviewed a 44-page document principally written by Karen Kornbluh, who has worked on Obama’s Senate staff. She said the draft included Obama and Clinton materials and was meant to highlight renewing core American goals.

As Ezra Klein notes, “[t]his whole process was quarterbacked by Obama’s Senate policy director, Karen Kornbluh…”

Now, on one level this is unsurprising; Obama’s trying to be a transformational figure and leader of his party, so you’d expect him to want his stamp put on the platform; McCain’s a long-time dissenter from various party orthodoxies who claimed the nomination without really being embraced by his party’s base, so he needs to avoid unnecessary battles over his long-term impact on the party’s direction. But the major reason why Obama’s role matters is that the Obama platform takes significant steps to strip away even the tepid Clinton-era nods in the platform towards rhetorical moderation on abortion. We may hear the media feed us the every-four-years perennial “Republican platform fight about abortion” stories anyway, but it’s the Democratic nominee who is leading his party further away from the center on the most divisive issue of the day.

COMMENTS

  • Jaded

    It’s for the WOMEN don’t cha know! He’s is no christian he is a child killer….and if someone doesn’t like what I just said…too bad….work it out in your own head.

  • Brian_M_Johnson
    • Tim_Schieferecke

      Of course fealty is always given by libs to the sacrament of abortion first so I guess it wouldn’t matter to him.

  • Haley37

    The Republican Party Platform for 2008 is pretty much meaningless unless the leader of the party – usually the president or presidential nominee – actively supports it.

    Who here honestly thinks McCain will give the platform a second thought once he’s in office?

    If I was McCain, I wouldn’t give much thought to it either. He’s going to do what he’s going to do anyway.

    This guy is an empty box of promises on the shopping aisle, and I’m not buying.

    I’m not saying other RS posters shouldn’t vote for him, I’m just saying read the warning label on the box.

    • aaronbg

      ….I can only stand so much pessimistic attitude in one week. I understand you are not pleased with McCain, but this is just getting ridiculous. McCain has purposefully stayed out of the creation of the platform so as not to be accused of steering it to the left. And as far as I am concerned I actually believe he will enforce the platform because of the basic fact that he understand the ideas of Duty. Honor and Integrity. He is not so delusional to think that he is in charge of the party but rather that he is part of the party and when the platform is set it is his duty to enforce it. He is a military man from a long line of military men. This leads me to believe that he is willing to follows orders, orders given to him by the people who are electing him and contributing to the platform.

      So I challenge you at this point to go one week without criticizing McCain for something he hasn’t even done yet. If you can’t go without criticizing McCain at least limit it to things he has already done instead of criticizing him on fears of what he might do.

      • CV_Gas

        John McCain is the Republican nominee for president. And before you start with GANG OF 14, I got it. Believe me, I got it. During the primary, I did not support his nomination, but you know what? The guy I wanted did not garner enough Republican support to move forward. So despite my reservations, I support John McCain for president of the United States of America., as do many others around here. I do this because whatever reservations I may have regarding John McCain, they don’t even remotely compare to those I would have if Deus Obamus became president. I’m sorry for being a bit gruff, but get over it, whoever you wanted instead of John McCain LOST.

        • Haley37

          Fair enough. I think I can make it a week.

          On the flip side, it is entertaining to watch the air coming out of the Obama ballon. I say that as an independent observer of the presidential race.

          Although I don’t like McCain one bit, Obama is not even qualified to clean my aquarium, much less run the country.

          This race is at least going to be entertaining to watch.

          One last thing. My negativity does stem from past issues, but David Brooks of the NYT (not a paper I usually puruse) did have an interesting article about McCain’s campaign. Go to realclearpolitics.com and click the date of TUESDAY, AUG 19. Look at the top for The Education of John McCain and give it a read.

          • Haley37

            on your calendar. Today is August 21. I will not write another disparaging remark about McCain until after August 28.

            Deal?

            One thing about our primaries. The GOP needs to look at pushing legislation in states with open primaries so as to close those to GOP voters only and ensure the integrity of future nominations.

            In the meantime, lets have some fun watching Obama tank in the polls.

          • CV_Gas
          • Haley37

            Tell you what, I’ll up the ante on my promise.

            From now until August 28, if I post one negative thing about McCain, I will happily donate $25 to a GOP candidate agreed upon by a group of my RS peers.

            What do you say Aaron, CV, Jaded?

            This is my olive branch to all of you and you get something more out of it than just my word to be nice.

          • aaronbg

            …But how about we go with you holding off criticism until he announces his running mate…that way if he chooses someone you like you can continue the streak and maybe even vote for McCain/Pro-Life 08.

            How’s that sound?

          • Haley37

            If you guy picks Mitt Romney, he might, maybe or very possibly get a second look from me.

            Thats not a commitment of support, just a promise to reconsider if Romney is in the VP slot. Just clarifying for the record and any who read these posts.

            Ironically, I plan on donating to Bob Schaffer anyway, so it’s a win-win for me and double the donation for your guy if I ‘go off’ on McCain before August 29.

            Let’s shake! :)

          • aaronbg

            n/t

          • CV_Gas

            to support so you could send money to them. I’m in the blue-blue state of Illinois and the guy running for my district (Oberweis) already lost to a Dim in the special. If you want to know how bad he is, this used to be Speaker Hastert’s district :-( Anyway, I am humbled by your deference. This is why I enjoy this forum. Try to have an engaging, rational discussion with a lib and they go all personal on you.