« BACK  |  PRINT

RS

FRONT PAGE CONTRIBUTOR

From The Department Of Completely Predictable Consequences

Tax, Spend and Consequences

New York Governor David Paterson discovers the gee-who-coulda-seen-this-coming fact that jacking up marginal tax rates is bad for the economy and not all that helpful to the budget:

[E]arly revenue figures suggest that taxing the wealthy more under this year’s state budget may have driven away richer New Yorkers. That could make the economic comeback for the state even harder.

“You heard the mantra, ‘Tax the rich, tax the rich,’ ” Gov. David Paterson said Wednesday at a gathering of newspaper editors at an Associated Press event in Syracuse. “We’ve done that. We’ve probably lost jobs and driven people out of the state.”

In a similar we-told-you-so vein, the Wall Street Journal notes a GAO report saying that the stimulus has had precisely the effect on state budgets that its critics among the GOP Governors warned it would:

Stimulus money is helping states plug budget holes, but state officials are worried about how they will sustain programs after the federal funds run out, according to a new Government Accountability Office report released Wednesday.

Around $90 billion of the $787 billion stimulus package was dedicated to state Medicaid programs. The money, which goes out quarterly to the states and is known as FMAP funds, has moved faster than stimulus dollars allocated to many other spending categories.

The GAO, the congressional watchdog charged with monitoring how states are handling their share of the stimulus package, found that most states it studied were using the Medicaid funds to cover increased caseloads and to maintain their current services and eligibility criteria. Some states were also using the funds to avoid cutting payments to hospitals and doctors.

State officials “expressed concern about the longer-term sustainability of their Medicaid programs after the increased FMAP funds are no longer available, beginning in January 2011,” the report said.

The report also found some states were using the money to free up other parts of their state budget that would otherwise have been used for Medicaid. Several states reported the funds were helping finance general state budget needs.

COMMENTS

  • itdiehard

    Social justice has been served and government is here to help you…

  • Taniwha

    …actually GLOAT when Rush Limbaugh moved, “if I’d have known he’d leave, I’d have raised his taxes long ago”?

    That really is weapons-grade cluelessness.

    • itdiehard

      share his wealth…

    • JoeG

      He said that had he know that this is all it would take to get Rush to leave, he would have raised the taxes sooner.

  • JoeG

    Oregon has no sales tax but an income tax.
    Washington has no income tax but has a sales tax.

    The largest metro area, Portland, is right on the border with Washington. People already move across the river to enjoy no income tax and shop in Oregon to avoid the sales tax.

    Now Oregon has added a extra tax for those earning over $125K. It is only accelerating the trend for folks to do the above.

    • itdiehard

      They raised the tax on millionaires and now there are fewer millionaires in Maryland… Maryland will eventual run out of the rich to TAX…

    • http://impudent.blognation.us/blog kyle8

      to try to force Washington to levy an income tax.

      • JoeG

        Sounds like taxation without representation to me.

        Several Oregon cities have enacted an income tax. The state courts ruled that you can’t tax non-residents because its outside the authority of local governments to do so. But not so with the state legislature.

  • UpLateAgain

    accomplishing its intent, and as time goes by it will become ever more effective.

    Unfortunately for us, that intent is not to ramp UP the economy, but rather to ramp it DOWN.

    You can’t get ‘social justice’ to take off when an economy is vibrant. People just don’t see a need for it.

    The whole idea of a bunch of ‘haves’ and a few ‘have-nots’ is unfair, unfair, unfair. We need EQUAL misery for all…. or, er ….. as it actually works out, a bunch of ‘have-nots’ with just a few ‘haves’.

    • izoneguy

      …..redistribution.

      I have a friend who is a liberal jew. Loves Obama, we get into heated arguments over the economy and Obama policies. Of course he thinks the stimulus is doing wonders and that ObamaCare is the salvation. So he calls me and is driving to Odessa, Texas to produce a video for Odessa on “economic development”. I will let you know how that goes. Odessa is as red as it gets. My friend better bite his lip when they start bashing Obama and the “stimulus”……

      Should be an interesting mix. Next time my buddy might send me out to the RED territories instead?

    • Dan McLaughlin

      I think the idea of giving $ the states become dependent on is like giving them heroin. The plan will be to make it politically impossible to resist giving them more.

      • UpLateAgain

        The problem is the money has to come from somewhere. Somebody has to produce the largess for the mooks to redistribute. The system isn’t closed, with a limited amount of goody to go around. Wealth is both created and destroyed. The theoretical idea behind a stimulus package is that it jump starts the producers of that largess. but if you are by-passing the producers and going straight to redistribution, at some point the cash flow stops.

        Obama and company of course know this (and I mean Obama and the entourage he brought it. Congress, for the most part, is clueless and just playing party politics). Once the cash runs out, then it is no longer a matter of redistributing wealth, it becomes a matter of providing subsistence. ( We’re now into our, what, third extension of jobless benefits?)

        This government has been doing everything it can to destroy wealth short of putting a gun to the ribs of those people that still have jobs and telling them to not go to work. None of this is accidental or incompetent. It is deliberate, organized, well thought out, and being passionately pursued.

  • Darin_H

    Well, we know that NY is on the wrong side of the Laffer curve.

    • Achance
      • Darin_H

        I figured y’all were talking about pliny and flyerhawk on the other thread, that I would make it complete :)

        • janis

          one of that other guy.

    • janis

      to invoke the name of some demon, even accidentally, for fear that they will show up and wreak havoc? Same thing with that name you mentioned here. :-)

      • Darin_H

        unlike the other names, I do believe that BR was hit with the blam stick.

    • bs

      he might return.

  • grinlap

    “the trouble with socialism is that eventually you run out of other people’s money”.

    • itdiehard

      nt…

  • peg_c

    (being able to move from state to state) must be a huge drag to the statists. They’re probably working on a fix for that right now.

    • JustLeaveMeAlone

      Can you say “mark of the Beast”? I knew that you could!

      • JustLeaveMeAlone

        I think y’all better move on down here to Texas quick as you can, where state income tax is unconstitutional. Before Bambi closes the borders.

  • Leopard1996