« BACK  |  PRINT

RS

MEMBER DIARY

Is Romney Winning New Jersey?

The latest Quinnipiac poll shows Obama leading Romney 49% to 39 % among registered voters. If we look at the trend of the polls in New Jersey as shown on RealClearPolitics.com we see Obama’s lead over the last three months going from +14 to +13 to now +10.

But we have to remember that these polls are all polls of registered voters, not likely voters. It is the likely voters that matter. If we were to look at the likely voters, then the latest Quinniapic poll would probably swing at least a couple percentage points to Romney. It would be more like Obama  47% – Romney 41%.

Then we need to look at the undecided voters. Dick Morris has discussed at length the fact that in the last eight presidential elections, except 2004, almost all the undecided votes go to the challenger. If that is the case then Romney would be winning 51% to 49% among registered voters and 53% to 47% among likely voters.

So this Quinnipiac poll really suggests that Romney may have a substantial lead in New Jersey. But there is another reason to think that Romney might be well ahead in the Garden State. The Quinnipiac poll consisted of 34% Democrats and 24% Republicans – a nine point advantage for Democrats. Since New Jersey often votes Democrat, it is safe to assume that there will be more Democrats than Republicans. But if the poll has exaggerated that number at all – even by one percentage point  – then Romney would have an even larger lead.

So, is Romney winning New Jersey? If the undecided voters hold true to form and vote for the challenger, then yes Romney is winning. Either way, New Jersey is definitely now in play.

COMMENTS

  • davenj1

    I can safely say that the Quinnipiac poll and others that may show Romney winning or trending that way in New Jersey are pure nonsense. NJ is not in play.

    • Dan Hellman

      This latest poll could very well be an aberration and just be thrown out. But there are four reasons to think it could be legit.

      1. It follows the trend of the two previous polls. On RealClearPolitics.com , the February poll had Obama at +14 with 52% and the March poll had Obama at +12 with 50%. This latest poll has Obama at +10 with 49%. It appears to show a trend.

      2. The poll matches the trend in the national polls which have the race tightening.

      3. Dick Morris is predicting a landslide and says that many states will be in play that normally would be rock-solid Democrat. If someone is undecided on Obama after three and a half years it is very unlikely they will vote for him in November.

      4. Other Democrats are panicking and sounding the alarm. James Carville is the latest because he knows what Dick Morris knows.

      You know New Jersey better than I do. But this is looking a lot like the 1980 campaign. No one expected Reagan to win in a landslide, but none of the undecideds went for Carter. Reagan ended up winning many traditionally Democratic states.

    • http://www.tooncesthecat.wordpress.com tooncesthecat

      But Wisconsin, Pennsylvania, and Michigan are definitely winnable.

      • Dan Hellman

        Toonces,

        You are more right than you know about those three states you mentioned. I am from Wisconsin and it is going for Romney.

        But what is wrong with my initial analysis of New Jersey? If the latest poll of registered voters is correct and Obama is at 49%, then his total percentage of likely voters is sure to be at least a couple points less than that.

        So if Obama has 47% of likely voters, how can he expect to get another 3% from the undecided voters in New Jersey to get him over 50% when historically undecideds go overwhelmingly against the incumbent president.

        Of course if the numbers change and he goes back over 50% in New Jersey, then I will change my analysis. But until then, I see no reason not to say that New Jersey is in play for Romney.

        Please feel free to let me know if you see a flaw in my analysis. Thanks.

      • renny

        but Whitman won here and Christie won here, and when Christie campaigns with Mitt, over the vast summer, I do not see why NJ couldn’t go Rep., as it did for Reagan in 84.

        It would be a long shot, but not an impossibility. I do think Mitt has WI, esp. as Scott looks to be up 5-8 pts. on Barrett on the recall, PA looks food for Reps., and OH and FL, also, and the o really needs two of them to win.

        • superpatriot

          Hi folks

          I’ve been doing some very pleasant calculations of electoral votes. It seems very likely that Indiana, Florida, and Ohio are all going for Romney.

          Anyone know how Virginia is looking.
          Seriously, if Romney wins Virginia, I think it would be safe to say Obama’s a one-term president.

        • The_Rebel

          then I guess MA could too. I mean, both states voted for Reagan in 1980 and 1984. And Mitt is from MA. Just saying.

          • Dave_A

            Romney’s the guy…