« BACK  |  PRINT

RS

MEMBER DIARY

The Senate Outlook After July

    Most of this is based upon recent polling data in an effort to estimate Republican gains in the Senate in 2010.  Of the 37 seats up for grabs, 19 are currently held by Democrats.  An analysis show the following:

Safe Democratic likely victories:  Oregon (Wyden), Hawaii (Inouye), Wisconsin (Feingold), West Virgina, Maryland (Mikulski), New York (Schumer and Gillibrand), Connecticut (Blumenthal replacing Dodd) and Vermont (Leahy).

Leaning Democrat held by Democrats: California (Boxer)

Toss-up states held by Democrats- Washington (Murray), Colorado (Bennett), Illinois (Burris/Obama), Pennsylvania (Specter) and Nevada (Reid)

Seats held by Democrats they will likely lose- Arkansas (Lincoln), North Dakota (Dorgan), Delaware (Kaufmann/Biden), Indiana (Bayh)

Safe Republican victories- Arizona, Alaska, Idaho, Utah, South Dakota, Kansas, Oklahoma, Louisiana, Iowa, Alabama, Georgia, South Carolina and New Hampshire

Seats by Republicans leaning Republican- Missouri, Kentucky, Ohio and North Carolina

Seats by Republicans that are toss-ups- Florida

There are no Republican seats leaning Democratic or that they will definitely lose.

     Assuming they win the four seats listed and defend all their seats, Republicans would pick up 4 seats under a sort of worst case scenario for the GOP in the Senate giving the Democrats a 55-45 margin.  The real worst case scenario would be to lose Florida and have Crist caucus with the Democrats and lose the seats in Missouri, Ohio, and Kentucky.  Assuming Republicans do not pick up seats anywhere else, that would maintain their 59-41 advantage in the Senate.

     Based on the most recent polling data after all the July polls, however, if the elections were held today, the Republicans would pick up seats in Colorado, Pennsylvania and Nevada besides the four minimum pick ups listed above.  That would give them a 7 seat pick up with the anticipated loss of Florida, based on the most recent polling data AND assuming Crist caucuses with the Democrats, Republicans would still pick up six seats while defending their vulnerable/competitive seats (Ohio, Kentucky, North Carolina, and Missouri).  In a realistic sense, the outlook is a 53-47 Democratic majority.

     This is not bad news for Republicans in the Senate.  The better balance among the parties would create greater bipartisanship and strengthen the hand of the Republican leadership in negotiations.  Assuming McConnell can keep toegther a Republican coalition, it would be almost impossible for Obama’s agenda to pass without bipartisanship in the truest sense.  Secondly, the gains this year set up future gains in the future where Republicans would be poised to target vulnerable Democrats in 2011 or 2012 and actually take over the Senate.  This, combined with the House becoming Republican this year, would make the last years of Obama’s Presidency difficult, if not impossible to enact his liberal agenda.  In short, he would have to pull a Clinton and veer sharply to the center or right.

     Most importantly, it is tantamount that Republicans build on their gains this year by having a clear agenda for the problems that confront this country in all areas and that bipartisan agreements with the more moderate Democrats be sought.  The new Republican leadership needs to show that they can work with Democrats to solve our Nation’s problems and not result to the chest-puffing tactics of the Democratic-controlled Congress under Pelosi.  In short, a Republican victory in November or even gains need to met with reality and a certain sense of humility- not a proclamation of a mandate (although in reality it probably is a referendum on Obama’s policies).  Perception is 90% of the game and perhaps less of the cockiness of the Democratic Party is what is needed here despite the anticipated Republican gains this fall.

COMMENTS

  • lukematthews

    This is a good thumbnail of the current projections. However, there are certainly political winds in this election. Boxer may well be toast. California is going to go far more red this November. Feingold is hanging on by a thread. McMahon is making a better run than expected in Connecticut. Gillibrand is showing cracks. If the results of the primaries are any indicators, the GOP is in for a big wave of voters that will wash away the Democratic shoreline. Republican primaries are far out-performing Democratic ones even in deep blue states. Independents are furious and are eager to vote out the Koolaid drinkers in The Party and the Regime.
    Remember Massachusetts!

    • 6eorge Jetson

      It is what it is. On the bright side, a Republican takeover of the House is at 60%, and has displayed a constant upward trend over the year. Something that we at RedState have felt all along. Maybe it just takes longer for the rest of America to catch on.

      http://www.intrade.com/

      Eighteen Republican Senate seats are being defended in the 37 Senate races. A bottom-up summation of the probability of victory in each results in an expectation of 23 Republican wins for a pickup of 5 seats. My gut says we get more

      Probability of
      Republican
      Victory                   Race
      0.99 Alabama (Incumbent: Richard Shelby – R)
      0.90 Alaska (Incumbent: Lisa Murkowski – R)
      0.88 Arizona (Incumbent: John McCain – R)
      0.92 Arkansas (Incumbent: Blanche Lincoln – D)
      0.38 California (Incumbent: Barbara Boxer – D)
      0.67 Colorado (Incumbent: Michael Bennet – D)
      0.18 Connecticut (Open Seat: Chris Dodd – D retiring)
      0.75 Delaware (Open Seat: Ted Kaufman – D retiring)
      0.43 Florida (Open Seat: George LeMieux – R retiring)
      0.90 Georgia (Incumbent: Johnny Isakson – R)
      0.10 Hawaii (Incumbent: Daniel Inouye – D)
      0.90 Idaho (Incumbent: Mike Crapo – R)
      0.50 Illinois (Open Seat: Roland Burris – D retiring)
      0.90 Indiana (Incumbent: Evan Bayh – D)
      0.88 Iowa (Incumbent: Chuck Grassley – R)
      0.99 Kansas (Incumbent: Sam Brownback – R)
      0.67 Kentucky (Open Seat: Jim Bunning – R retiring)
      0.90 Louisiana (Incumbent: David Vitter – R)
      0.08 Maryland (Incumbent: Barbara Mikulski – D)
      0.69 Missouri (Open Seat: Kit Bond – R retiring)
      0.42 Nevada (Incumbent: Harry Reid – D)
      0.75 New Hampshire (Open Seat: Judd Gregg – R retiring)
      0.08 New York (Incumbent: Chuck Schumer – D)
      0.14 New York (Incumbent: Kirsten Gillibrand – D)
      0.82 North Carolina (Incumbent: Richard Burr – R)
      0.96 North Dakota (Open Seat: Byron Dorgan – D retiring)
      0.60 Ohio (Open Seat: George Voinovich – R retiring)
      0.88 Oklahoma (Incumbent: Tom Coburn – R)
      0.12 Oregon (Incumbent: Ron Wyden – D)
      0.65 Pennsylvania (Incumbent: Arlen Specter – D)
      0.95 South Carolina (Incumbent: Jim DeMint – R)
      0.95 South Dakota (Incumbent: John Thune – R)
      0.95 Utah (Incumbent: R)
      0.08 Vermont (Incumbent: Patrick Leahy – D)
      0.41 Washington (Incumbent: Patty Murray – D)
      0.15 West Virginia (Open Seat)
      0.45 Wisconsin (Incumbent: Russ Feingold – D)

      22.97 Total: Aug 08 – 6:51AM IST

      • 6eorge Jetson

        the Dems had net gains of +6 in ’06 & +8 in ’08 which they will have to defend in ’12 & ’14.

        • 6eorge Jetson

          in 28 of the 37 races, for another perspective. (A touchdown dog in football has about a ~33% chance of winning).

          • 6eorge Jetson

            nt

      • IJB

        I think +5 is the *minimum* pick-up likely, at this point.

        Personally, I’ve penciled in 52 D-48 R as the likely outcome, though it could certainly go higher if Dem turnout utterly collapses worse than it did in ’94 (which is a possibility).

  • teresakoch

    it’s still early, but there are some rumblings that “officials” in state offices are being investigated for improprieties. Rumor has it that Manchin is the official at the center of these investigations…..

    • IJB

      I wouldn’t rate any of these as “Safe Dem”, that’s for sure!

  • Castor

    After the primaries Christ will lose Dems to the left and Repubs to the right.
    By the end of september Marco Rubio will have smooth sailing.

  • IJB

    I stopped reading your analysis right there.

    Even Cook has moved WI SEN to “toss-up”.

    Most of your other “Safe D” seats are equally problematic.

    You need more categories – probably “Likely D” and “Likely R”.

    I’d advise trying again…

  • proudgop

    who are you rooting for the Dems? I tend to think Green is better for us. He probably get more of the liberal Jewish bloc in Palm Beach

  • DONTREADONME

    to fix any of the damage created by this Congress, President and federal judges. I know I sound like a defeatist, but I have been out of the loop and checking in now and again to see what new turmoil has been created. I am shocked at the amount of chaos and bad legislation that has gone through in less than 2 years time, especially over the last 4 months.

    The only thing I see saving us from all of this garbage is the states, but even they are becoming impotent against the juggernaut that is the federal bureaucracy by the courts. God, I look at my kids and wonder if I will be telling them what America was like when we had some liberty.

    Anyway, keeping in line with this entry, 55-45 D-R is not something for me to get excited about; only more depressed at how much longer it will take before something can be done

  • davenj1

    Thanks for all the feedback on this. I generally look at polls from local papers in the states as well as the national polling services. Additionally, I get info from CQ Politics, Cook Report, Rothenberg report, etc. Some polls lean one way or another politically and I make sure I have at least 4 polls per month to get a decent, if not completely accurate picture. Since February, everything indicates at least a 6-seat pick up in the Senate and outright win in the House. The potential for more is there for Republicans. And i totally agree that after the primaries in Florida, Marco Rubio will surge ahead. His numbers in a 3-way race are competitive and he will most likely retain this seat for the Republicans.