Rep. Ed Markey of Massachusetts, ranking member of the House Natural Resources Committee, has a major obsession. Markey’s Great White Whale is called the Deepwater Royalty Relief Act of 1995 (details below the fold).
In Markey’s mind, several deepwater Gulf of Mexico operators have gotten over on the government to the tune of several billion dollars in oil and gas royalties. The operators counter that they’re honoring to the letter of certain leases that were granted in 1997 and 1998 to encourage exploration during a period of low oil prices.
The courts have blocked Interior from unwinding DWRRA. Congress has tried and failed to take away its benefits. A new tax to penalize the recalcitrant companies has been a centerpiece of President Obama’s budget proposals since he took office. Markey can’t let it go.
Here’s the part where Markey channels his internal Doctor Evil:
In response to this potential merger and the loss of taxpayer money to the Chinese government’s benefit, Rep. Markey today sent a letter to Secretary Tim Geithner highlighting the fact that Nexen has already drilled (sic) 32 million barrels of oil and 34 million cubic feet of gas for free without paying a dime to American taxpayers in royalties and that this giveaway could transfer directly to the Chinese government-owned company if the merger goes forward as planned.
Thirty-four million cubic feet of natural gas?! Why, at today’s prices, the government’s share of that would be worth almost$15,000.00!! (Actually, of course, the correct figure is 34 billion cubic feet. What’s a factor of 1,000 among friends?)
[Note to Rep. Markey: I am available to consult with you or your staff on proofreading or other technical matters. My consulting rates are quite steep, however; they have recently increased due to the expectation of tax increases. – SM]
The DWRRA authorized the Department of the Interior to create incentives for the development of deepwater oil and gas leases in the Gulf of Mexico during times of low prices (oil was generally in the $10 to $30 per barrel range in the late 1990s). By waiving the normal 12.5% royalty due to the Federal government on production, Interior created an economic incentive for exploration. The astronomical cost of deepwater drilling and developemnt may not have been justifiable without the relief.
Most of the leases called for an end to royalty relief if the price of oil exceeded $35/bbl. Not the 1997-98 vintages of leases, though. For those leases, relief ended only when a predetermined number of barrels had been produced.
In retrospect, it looks like a screwup. Oil has been consistently above $35/bbl since 2004, and the government has left a lot of money on the table. Some of the lessees (notably Shell, BP and ConocoPhillips) have voluntarily honored the economic provision at Interior’s request. A long list of smaller companies have not.
But if it was a screwup, it was a screwup under the watch of a Democratic president and a Democratic Secretary of the Interior (Bill Richardson).
In a similar case between private parties, the plain language of the lease contract would prevail. In a case where there were a contractual error that accrued to the government’s benefit — good luck suing the government. But in the case of the DWRRA, Interior sued the reluctant oil companies.
Share on Facebook 1 1 SHARES British writer Julie Bindel has released a new video via The Guardian this week that should be seen as ominous foreshadowing for those of us here in the United States. “Banning people from publicly stating their views does not make those views disappear. […] What it does do is blind us to the existence of the attitude that [the | Read More »
Share on Facebook 1 1 SHARES Marco Rubio’s concession speech tonight did not get full air time on CNN, but they showed the most important part. Listen to Senator Rubio humbly explain his loss: “I’m disappointed with tonight. I want you to understand, I want you to understand something. Our disappointment tonight is not on you, it’s on me. I did not do well on | Read More »
Share on Facebook 1 1 SHARES It sure seems that way. Christie is reportedly heading home to New Jersey to re-evaluate his candidacy. He was very clearly a dog backed into a corner in the New Hampshire debate, and he attacked who he saw as the biggest threat on the way to being the “Establishment” candidate – Marco Rubio. However, the strategy did not work, | Read More »
Share on Facebook 1 1 SHARES Sadly, it appears that New Hampshire may have muddied the GOP field, rather than clarifying it. Even though Kasich and Jeb do not have obvious paths forward to the nomination, they are going to convince themselves that they do, at least through Super Tuesday – and they will probably find donors who will indulge that belief. Somewhere, Donald Trump | Read More »
Share on Facebook 1 1 SHARES The GOP Establishment is bound to be looking at New Hampshire, a state where they perform well, seeing Donald Trump coming away with a major and distant first place, and weeping to themselves that their party has gone so terribly awry. There are a couple of things I’d like to say to them, but in the interest of keeping | Read More »