It's not easy to create a 12-4 map in a state that Obama won. Unfortunately, with there being 13 Republicans now, 1 of them has to go. I axed Bob Gibbs's 18th.
Kucinich (OH-10) and Sutton (OH-13) are also knocked off, and a new seat is created in Franklin County.
CD-1 (Chabot) - I cut this from 36% black to 21% black, replacing them with Republicans from Claremont County
CD-2 (Schmidt) - Weakened a bit to shore up CD-1. Added Scioto and Lawrence Counties.
CD-3 (Turner) - Adds a bit of heavy Republican territory to the east. I also used John Boehner to shore him up in Dayton a tad. If Mr. Speaker nixes that idea, well, Turner will have to take Trotwood back, but he's ok.
CD-4 (Jordan) - If he's not running for Senate, he comes back to a slightly weaker, but easily holdable district. The sections of Lorain county in his district actually voted ~54% McCain. The sections of Cuyahoga he has are ~50% McCain.
CD-5 (Latta) - There's a bit of an excess of Republicans here, but you can't do much with them.
CD-6 (Gibbs/Johnson) - This district is probably 50/50. There's really not much to do to make it safe; I think the GOP has to live with this one.
CD-7 (Austria) - About the same. Adds Democratic Athens County and some other Republican counties.
CD-8 (Boehner) - See above. Mostly unchanged.
CD-9 (Kaptur) - Adds heavily Democratic areas of Lorain County.
CD-10 (open) - Packed in Columbus seat. Safe Dem, no incumbent. I didn't really work on the specific borders that much.
CD-11 (Fudge) - Packed in Cleveland seat. Probably one of the most Democratic seats in the country outside of California. 50% black as I have it.
CD-12 (Tiberi) - He also staircases up to Stark County.
CD-13 (Ryan) - The old 17th, plus all of Akron and Cuyahoga Falls.
CD-14 (Latuorette) - Tricky. You can't take him west, so he goes South. The areas I added from Summit county (Tallmage, Richfield) are about 50% McCain. Boehner really needs to keep Latuorette in the House.
CD-15 (Stivers) - He doesn't live here, but the new CD-15 staircases up to Stark County.
CD-16 (Renacci) - Drops Stark County. Adds ~40% McCain areas of Cuyahoga County (Brooklyn, Parma). I did give him some Richland territory to compenate, but this district might have to swap areas with the 4th a bit.