« BACK  |  PRINT

RS

EDITOR OF REDSTATE

Palin Is Not Backing Off Her “Task From God” Statement. The Media Is Because The Media Got It Wrong.

This is a silly headline from the Politico.

Jonathan Martin’s title is “Palin backs off “task from God” statement.”

It looks to me like the media is backing off.

As characterized by the media, Palin allegedly said the troops to Iraq were on a “task from God.”

But that is not what Palin said. And she is not backing off what she said. She is correcting the media (not that they ever think they need correction).

As Moe noted, Palin said, according to the transcript, “Pray for our military men and women who are striving to do what is right. Also, for this country, that our leaders, our national leaders, are sending them out on a task that is from God,” she exhorted the congregants. “That’s what we have to make sure that we’re praying for, that there is a plan and that that plan is God’s plan.”

So, we have:

  1. Pray for our military men and women who are striving to do what is right;

  2. Pray … that our leaders … are sending them out on a task that is from God.

She even then clarified that she wanted them to pray that they were doing what was in God’s plan and not their own plan.

It’s a humbling thing the secularists in the media don’t seem to understand: Sarah Palin believes God is sovereign.

And clarifying that her words were meant to echo Abraham Lincoln is not backing down.

Let’s accept this for what it is: the media seized on this as a gotcha moment and now are having to back down from it, but they can’t admit that they got it wrong.

Apparently, if you are a mentally retarded atheist, you too can get a well paying job. You can go work at the New York Times or Washington Post or ABC News or NBC and call yourself a journalist.

COMMENTS

  • Wintergreen

    but we ought to leave people with legit mental handicaps out of the insults.

  • theotherside

    I’m a frequent reader of DailyKos and TPM, but I also check out RedState to get alternative view points. I think you’re missing some of the point why her church comments drew attention in the first place.

    Palin also made an additional comment in church which are consistent with her statements with Gibson that she wouldn’t presume to know God’s will.

    “I think God’s will has to be done in unifying people and companies to get that gas line built, so pray for that,”

    Granted, getting that line build means jobs and prosperity for some in Alaska, which is presumably good, but I think many people are disturbed by injecting religion into policy and government initiatives.

  • Wintergreen

    about that pipeline quote if he was so worried about her faith.

    The one he brought up didn’t even include the full sentence it was taken from. They stripped a clause out of a sentence she said and tried to force a distorted view on her.

    It was incredibly dishonest on Gibson’s part.

  • mobius2702

    “I think God’s will has to be done in unifying people and companies to get that gas line built, so pray for that,”

    I don’t want to get into a theological discussion over this for two reasons:

    1) This is a political blog, not a religion blog

    2) I don’t have the religious chops to handle this any deeper than what I am about to type…

    The statement quoted above has been widely quoted, and widely misunderstood.

    We mere mortals may desire that pipeline, but before everything can come together to make it happen, it has to be God’s will.

    She isn’t presuming to know that the pipeline is God’s will. She’s asking the congregants to pray that it is God’s will. If it is God’s will, then it is up to Christians to get it done.

    The whole Thy will be done aspect of Christianity; that Christians are servants of God.

    That may scare some, but I’d rather serve the Lord than the state, and I’d rather my leaders approach decisions as servants of God than servants of Special Interests.

  • VA_mom

    Sarah Palin was offering sincere prayers during her church ceremonies. Separation of church and state does not mean you have to pretend you don’t have a faith or values, and what she said showed she is a woman of deep humility and faith. In the interview, Gibson misquoted Palin, she called him on it, and he LIED saying “your exact words.” If they were her “exact words,” why didn’t he just show the video of her saying the prayer and then have his “gotcha” momment. I guess its just harder to twist someone’s actual words, so its ok to change them slightly during an interview…

  • Jack_Savage

    Maybe he should use those glasses to read more carefully.

    Is there just no end to this? Will there ever be an end to it? WIll the press ever act responsibly again? Ever?

  • dld1717

    Only people who view God as bad will find this negative

  • olderthangandalf

    I thought the Lincoln reference put it in perspective perfectly. She was completely in line with the best parts of the American tradition in that quotation.

    One thing the Palin nomination has made very, very clear is the truly surprising degree to which the left and mainstream media just don’t understand people of faith.

  • XRenown

    I’m an ordained minister and mostly agree with what you said; however, the statement, if you rearrange it reads:

    I think God’s will has to be done, so pray for that, in unifying people and companies to get that gas line built

    I believe she clearly thinks this is what God’s will is. With that said, I don’t see anything wrong with praying that God’s will be done with regard to unifying people and companies for a political purpose.

    The bottom line is God is sovereign to Gov. Palin and she ultimately submits the matter to Him. If it is His will, unification occurs and a pipeline gets built. If it is not His will, unification may not occur and a pipeline may not get built.

    It isn’t scary or weird. It’s a humble heart working to make something happen and giving it to God to bless or not bless. This is biblical, just read the books of Samuel and Kings concerning David and Solomon whenever they decide to accomplish difficult things. This is just a present day application.

    The original commenters point though is well taken; but I would encourage that individual to consider the merits of Gov. Palin’s words and actions.

  • WarmackLA

    The utter hypocrisy of the left never surprizes me any more. This group, who so ardently exclaim and supposedly defend “separation of Church and state, turn right around (FLIP FLOP) on the issue of religion when they think it serves their purpose. By the way, hypocrisy isn’t saying one thing and doing another. Hypocrisy is actually claiming to have attained a higher level than one has actually achieved. Their hypocrisy is seen in their claiming to be the defenders of freedom and liberty, while they have never crawled out of the gutter of partisian politics and self-serving ridicule in order to advance their agenda. They (the leftist media) cry “foul” if anyone brings up the religious positions or acquaintances of Obama (i.e., False Prophets Wright and Flagler), yet they try to create fear by claiming Governor Palin believes God has a plan. Truly God is Sovereign and He does have a plan. Our comfort is that God is in control no matter who He choses to put in the oval office. We must do what we feel is right and vote for the persons we feel are capable to lead our country and then pray and trust God to bless and protect this great country we are so blessed to be citizens of.