« BACK  |  PRINT

RS

EDITOR OF REDSTATE

At play in the field of tea parties

Put down the tea bags and launch a coup.

The tea party movement is in danger of imploding.

Go re-read that first sentence again please.

The implosion is not because there is no momentum. It is not because there is no desire for more. It is not because of a lack of enthusiasm. To be clear, there is plenty of enthusiasm, plenty of desire for more, and plenty of momentum.

The tea party movement is in danger of implosion because like many truly grassroots movements, there are a host of competing egos and entities all claiming the title of “leader” and in the desire to be leader, they are not willing to work with each other. Some are using it to advance their own agendas. Some entities, which otherwise are known for nothing, have tried to claim the tea party movement as their own. Other groups, which do massively good work and just want to help, are being shut out by the so called grassroots leaders who want all the glory and are deeply suspicious of credible organizations willing to help.

The tea party movement was and is a truly organic movement. The moment the left started screaming that they were astroturf, however, some of the new organizers ran as far away from the professional organizations willing to help out as they possibly could. That was a mistake. As I mentioned, there are some organizations out to establish themselves on the backs of the tea party activists. But there are many established organizations that are simply willing to help out with forms, insurance, technology, etc.

At the same time, a number of the individuals involved in the movement have deemed themselves indispensable to the effort. No one is indispensable and those who think they are should be driven off the stage. The indispensable people are those who showed up to the protests, giving up hours on the job or time with families. And the so called leaders of the movement will fail the movement when they begin to think this effort is about them and not about the people and the passion.

I would suggest all the players sit down and see if they can get some focus. If not, the movement will be hijacked. It should not come to that when there is as much passion as there is. So what is my suggestion?

Stop having tea parties and launch a coup. Go below the fold to find out what I mean.What I am seeing, besides some rather embarrassing attempts at self-aggrandizement by some of the “leaders” of the movement is simply an effort to have more tea parties. That’s going to get rather mundane after a while. And mostly these new tea party efforts are just efforts by a few organizations to fill their email files.

Instead, the tea party movement needs to go underground and launch a coup.

No, I’m not advocating a coup against the country. I’m advocating a coup against the Republican Party. And not so much an overthrowal as an infiltration and reform.

Raise your hand if you have been to a tea party. Now, raise your hand if you have been to a local Republican Party meeting. I bet those of you raising your hands to the former outnumber the latter. And that is the problem.

Real change comes not from throwing tea bags at the steps of city hall, but by accumulating political power to effect change. And it is extremely easy to do so at the local level. As a long time activist within the political party and now an elected Republican, I can assure you that very few people ever turn out for a Republican precinct meeting in most areas.

Those who turn out to the precinct meetings elect the precinct leaders. Then they go to the county meetings and elect the county leaders. Then they go to the state and elect the state leaders. Along the way, those people get to vet potential candidates, come up with positions for the party, etc. They accumulate influence and then power.

We are at a point in the calendar where most of the local Republican leadership has been put in place. But that actually is a good thing. It allows truly committed tea party activists to infiltrate, learn the business of the local party, make connections, and establish credibility. There will, as time goes on, be plenty of opportunities to get inserted into the party apparatus at the local level.

Now I know many tea party activists don’t want to be considered Republicans. But it is time to get a clue: ballot access rules and the laws of the fifty states make it virtually impossible for a third party to ever get off the ground. Therefore, you are playing with the two parties that exist nationwide: the Dems and the GOP.

Between the two, the GOP is, at the grassroots level, more in tune with the tea party movement. And the way to get the national leadership to get back in tune with the local grassroots is to take over the local party apparatus.

It will take some time. But the tea parties are never going to be treated seriously long term unless the energy is harnessed toward the accumulation of power. The best way to do that is to infiltrate the GOP and start cleaning it up.

Likewise, the tea parties are going to go nowhere as long as there is a leadership vacuum caused by equally large competing egos. Keeping the passion alive with more tea parties is all well and good, but the people I saw turning out in Macon and Atlanta have jobs and families. They can’t turn out every month to protest on the town square at noon. They can, however, involve themselves in their local precinct one evening a month.

The tea parties should not be about the people organizing them. The tea parties should be about the passion of people across America who want their country back. And the best way to get it back is to start acquiring political clout.

I am going to have more on this later because there are some tea party leaders, like Jenny Beth Martin in Atlanta, and others along with some organizations like Americans for Prosperity, who should be elevated because they fundamentally get it and care more about the cause than themselves. The good guys need to supported and I don’t want to paint with so broad a brush as to label all the leaders and organizations within the tea party movement as bad.

The key point here is that everyone should put down the tea bags and show up at their next local GOP meeting and start freaking out the establishment by taking it over. Oh, and while you are at it, find out when your next town or city council meeting is, get a group together, and show up there.

More later.

COMMENTS

  • http://www.hakubi.us/ Neil Stevens

    People showed up, and then a bunch of egotistical jerks tried to hijack it for personal gain. Then the movement imploded.

    It’s sorta like how the College Republicans could be useful except for the egotistical jerks who hijack it for personal gain. The maturity level of the self-appointed leaders seems to be about the same.

  • http://www.hakubi.us/ Neil Stevens

    I know of a monthly meeting in my county. The only thing keeping me from getting there is the distance, or I’d be there every month for certain.

  • Jonah Shumate

    A local group is meeting this coming Monday to talk about the next steps, and I will pass this along, Erick!

  • http://www.fredsnews.com Fred Maidment

    …an important way to energize the grassroots, but you’re right. There needs to be more than just demonstrations. If we wish to move back away from Socialism, we must get involved.

    Great post, Erick. Gwinnett GOP breakfast this Saturday. Guess I’ll have to get up early…

  • http://andrightlyso.com/ civil_truth
  • http://janicecantore.com Janice Cantore

    The tea parties were the only thing in this country that were non partisan. Obama certainly isn’t. Is anyone else out there truly P***** off at how he belittled and marginalized the tea parties yesterday? I have never in my lifetime heard a president intentionally insult half the country and kick them to the curb like he did at that town meeting. Is anyone out there listening???

    As for the tea parties imploding, it does not surprise me because the republican party just does not seem to get why they lost and why people are sick of them and don’t beleive them. The spineless of course will try to hitch their wagons to the energy and power of the tea partys. But the republican party is not the only place there is a disconnect, to all those democrats who attended tea parties because they are angry about taxes, who will you vote for in 2010 and 2012? You will still vote for a democrat, no matter what. Obama and Reid and Pelosi will feed you excrement sandwiches for four years and you will say thank you, can I have some more. I know this because I live in california. This state is in the toilet and califonians will keep flushing by voting democrat. On one hand I’m frustrated, on the other hand, there are no republicans with cojones in this state so what are we going to do?

    Republicans can only fight among themselves, destroying each other with petty infighting, they never fight for princiles against the other party.

  • jewells45

    You are absolutely right. I plan on checking into when the next meeting is and being there.

  • http://andrightlyso.com/ civil_truth

    I wanted to do a subtitle on my last diary (which would have shortened the title I wrote) but couldn’t find any location on the new diary (or editing) page to do so.

    I’m asking this here because I see that this diary has a subtitle.

  • Thunder Pig

    I say keep the Washington based groups out of the Tea Parties, and have no big march on DC. Thses bigger and bigger marches are a mistake.

    These Tea Parties should be kept local, and used to organize on the local level.

    Bigger is not better. Locally, our Tea Party participants are organizing and getting involved in local politics, and we are taking over the Republican Party.

    As far as the Tea Party Coalition…certain people got big heads and deals with websites and stars in their eyes. Got too famous too fast.

    Freedom Works should be focused on educating voters, not leading marches. Same goes for AFP and AFA and all those other organizations who are trying to build up an email list or donor pool.

    Grass Roots does not begin in Washington or the state capitals.

    Those are my opinions, and the Tea Parties have opened my eyes to the utter hypocrisy in the leadership elites in the Republican Party and those who hang with them.

  • 10ksnooker

    Want the tea party movement to go away? hmmm, let me think, I think I have it, Washington politicians …

  • http://xmmlbchat.blogspot.com katesmith

    This is the last person who should be allowed to leech onto this movement. He’s had all the access in the world in recent years and has done the opposite of what we needed. He’s a big part of the problem, won’t get off the stage on his own. There can be no grass roots movement if it’s just going to allow Gingrich to hijack it. I agree going to local GOP meetings is a way to begin.

  • http://www.erickerickson.org Erick Erickson

    Go down to custom fields, enter it in, then use the drop down menu to designate the field as a subtitle.

  • http://impudent.blognation.us/blog kyle8

    But the man is simply brilliant. Had we not allowed him to be run out of congress by made up attacks we might not be in the trouble we are now.

    No he is not perfect but he is the closest thing we have to an Idea man.

  • E Pluribus Unum

    to a section called ‘Custom Fields’. In the drop-down box there is a choice called ‘subtitle’. Write your subtitle in the ‘value’ section, skip the ‘key’ section. *don’t* click ‘Add Custom Field’. by typing in *this* field, it’s added already.

  • http://andrightlyso.com/ civil_truth
  • djemi

    Yeah the grassroots NEEDS to take control

  • farstar99

    you never will, and the Left will permanently own cyberspace and the country.

  • http://andrightlyso.com/ civil_truth

    First, he folds under pressure – at least he did in Congress, rather than finish the job, he compromised away possible victory.

    Secondly, he has an overly high regard for his brillance and comes across as expecting that everyone else will be dazzled by his light.

    Thirdly, he has a character issue going back the way he treated his wife, and thus do not want to entrust him with leadership. Nor has he been able to sell me with this new-found dalliance with religion.

    As a background consultant, Newt may have value. But I don’t want him to be the public face of the Republican Party.

  • Kate_Shanahan

    but he is not a front man. Turns people off. I like his mind, but not his manner.

  • http://impudent.blognation.us/blog kyle8

    Still, we are all not perfect, no one is, Ronald Reagan was not perfect.

    But who else is there in the movement who is coming out with new ideas to deal with hard issues? Who?, I don’t see them.

    I think he is a great asset. For as long as he lives, which might not be much longer, (he is old after all).

    Our other Idea men are all dead. Buckley, Milton Friedman. We need the intellectuals or we will not succeed in the arena of ideas.

  • Elizabeth

    Erick, is there any way you folks could add a Wiki capability to RedState, so that it could start functioning as an organized clearinghouse for political information at the local level. There are probably plenty of us who would be willing to do research at the local level (local party meeting dates, local tea parties or other events, info on local ballot initiatives, judges etc.,), but it would really help if we could coordinate our work and make it more accessible.

    While a blog is a great format for carrying on a conversation, it is not a good format for providing a semi-permanent source of information.

    Another reason I have long thought a Wiki would be useful for this site is that it would be a nice place to contain detailed arguments about a variety of issues. For example, if I got into a conversation with my neighbor about school choice, I could look up the RedState Wiki page on school choice and immediately gain access to a whole list of strong arguments backed up by solid data.

    Anyway, just a thought (but a persistent one).

  • MacAoidh

    …there is a meeting of the Baton Rouge Tea Party group tonight and I was thinking about making the exact same argument.

    The group here hates Republicans with the same fervor they hate Democrats, but they don’t seem to understand that the people they regard as their absolute worst enemies – the Marxist/Fascist New Left moonbats who want to turn America into Venezuela without the oil – were in the exact same situation vis-a-vis the Democrat Party until George Soros and MoveOn.org took that party away from the Clintons and made it a dominant political force when the opportunity arose.

    The GOP is every bit as ripe for such a takeover as the Democrat Party was in the early part of this decade – and the road map has already been laid out by the other side how to put it into effect. More, the intellectual bankruptcy of the Beltway GOP mob as evidenced by the Specter defection and the attendant recriminations against the Club For Growth and other conservatives not only makes a takeover necessary, but morally imperative as well.

    I will do my part to make this message known. I encourage all other Redstate.com readers to do the same.

  • Finrod

    I would only add that new users should have to be on the site some amount of time (a month, maybe?) before they could edit the wiki, else we’ll get dKos trolls and mobys defacing it every other week.

  • deevee

    “Oh, and while you are at it, find out when your next town or city council meeting is, get a group together, and show up there.”

    I would add county board meeting.

    Though the position is non partisan ( in Wisconsin), county supervisors bring their conservative or liberal view and vote accordingly. Being awash in liberal and wishy-washy county supervisors it would help to have conservative taxpayer attendance at the meetings and/or calling and talking to local elected officials to stop the big government voting .

    It sure would be nice to have backing, though I know I am in a very liberal county.

  • Elizabeth

    Only people who’ve established themselves as respectful users of this site should have editing privileges on the Wiki.

  • http://www.erickerickson.org Erick Erickson

    You did think about running for it.

  • http://moelane.com/ Moe Lane

    NT

  • fstrat76

    Erick, you are correct in one sense, that people are trying to hijack the movement. I’m not so sure that infiltrating the GOP is the correct maneuver yet, but to get the GOP and independents aligned with the grass roots. I know we at http://teapartyrevolution.com are not affiliated with anyone, are not hijacked, but are working more on helping the grass roots to organize under a platform if you will. If we merge with other grass roots organizations later, we are all for it. Its not about us but about the movement. This takes time to build.
    – Mike

  • Aaron Gardner

    My own personal trek started with Drudge years ago and then Politico and then I found RedState…through the encouragement I found here and the knowledge I accrued, I began to feel confident enough to go to State, County and Town meetings here in VT.

    I am trying to make as many events as I can this year and hope it leads to even more in the years to follow.

    Thanks for this great diary calling the soldiers to task!!

  • PatHMV

    If I hear one more Republican “leader” try to claim that the “tea” in tea parties stands for “Taxed Enough Already,” I’m going to puke. Yeah, I think we’re taxed enough already, but do these folks think that the biggest problem facing the GOP is that the American public doesn’t realize conservatives are for tax cuts? The tea parties I saw were much more about keeping the government from nationalizing large segments of the economy, keeping the government from bailing out companies and individuals who made bad decisions, etc. Taxes were part of it, but mostly in the sense of explaining how much tax money will be required to be paid by the next several generations to pay for this profligate borrowing.

    I’ve yet to see a single nationally prominent GOP politician do a respectable job of putting their finger on that pulse. Most of these consultant-driven power grabbers want to exploit the movement for their same old tired cliches. That’s poison.

  • AKSteveB

    The Real Culture War Is Over Capitalism
    Tea parties, ‘ethical populism,’ and the moral case against redistribution.

    By ARTHUR C. BROOKS
    There is a major cultural schism developing in America. But it’s not over abortion, same-sex marriage or home schooling, as important as these issues are. The new divide centers on free enterprise — the principle at the core of American culture.

    full article at
    http://online.wsj.com/article/SB124104689179070747.html

  • jenuinejen

    Thanks for the kind words, Erick! Your ideas about hitting GOP meetings and city and county government meetings are right on.

    It is important to remember that our movement is only 9 weeks old. We are in a unique situation in that we had 850+ Tea Party Coordinators come together on April 15th to host Tea Parties around the country in less than 8 weeks time.

    As information to the Redstate readers, the TeaPartyPatriots.org is where the Tea Party Coordinators and Tea Party Participants are joining online to build the movement. We want to make sure this is a movement and not simply a moment in time. Tea Party Patriots is looking to create and build future events and also to build an organizational structure to support a movement.

    As Tea Party Patriots builds this organization, it is doing so in a way that honors and respects each of the 850+ Tea Party Coordinators and gives them a place on the National Leadership Council. Tea Party Patriots would not exist without the individual coordinators. The Tea Parties would never have happened without the individual coordinators. Contrary to what some in the media say, this has been a true grassroots, bottom-up movement. Tea Party Patriots is doing all it can to insure that the organizational structure continues to be bottom-up and not top-down.

    If people have specific ideas about what they want to see happen within Tea Party Patriots, they can go to our idea board and submit an idea. At the same time, they can leave comments on other ideas so we can build on them and make the ideas better. Erick your ideas and the ideas of others like you are exactly what we need so that we can put our passion into action and carry the movement forward.

  • crux

    “Opportunity is missed by most because it is dressed in overalls and looks like work” – Thomas Edison

  • aesthete

    Another idea would be to have “stickies”, or blog posts that permanently or semi-permanently stay up to inform people. I’ve seen this on other forums, and it seems to work quite well, as it combines the “conversation” aspect of a forum with the semi-permanence of a wiki. That way, instead of having a daily post which will get buried about donating to a certain race, we could have a link to such a page that would stay up until it is no longer needed.

  • 1stRichard

    I am a tea party organizer and experienced what you are saying first hand last night at a state GOP diner. There were two of us and no more. I stood up and looked behind me, no one was there. We had better stop thinking this is only a social event to meet new people or plagiarize for membership. This is a fight and we are fighting a war, this is the cold hard simple fact. Participation is no longer an option, it is now mandatory boots on the ground. The number of boots I am seeing is truly pathetic.

    Individualism, if you are a conservative all of you had better start practicing what you preach. We are individuals as so given in our constitutional right. We are not lead by anyone but our selves and it is your free choice. You are responsible for your actions or from what I am seeing a lack of action. This is our constitutional right and the freedom that protects us from oppression. It seems ?We the People? and ?freedom is not free? has become more of a clich? than a call to arms. It can not be said enough, you know the term ?use it or lose it?, well we had better start using it because we are coming real close to losing it all. All of us need make an individual commitment to put boots on the ground and stop thinking this is only a social event. This is a boots on the ground fight and a do or die reality, not a virtual reality. The real fight is out there and not in here.

    At what point does it become ?We the Government? and no longer ?We the People?? The real threat comes from our own government and its own corporate greed. Higher taxes, regulations, fees, all have pushed out individual private capitalism and individual opportunity. These are individual freedoms as in you and me that are about to be lost. Manufacturing across the nation has dropped to its lowest levels and so has your jobs in response to this government monopolization. Government was never intended to be the largest employer and it must never be allowed to be the largest employer. We have separation of church and state for a reason, fear of oppression. The same applies to our government becoming a corporation, a self serving institution and oppressor.

    Where is the tipping point in all this, will all the people finally start to revolt and participate because they found nothing remaining? That seems too late to be acceptable?.

  • Praying

    I think you must have been describing what I see happening due North of you in the Volunteer State. There is absolutely no sense in fracturing and dividing this incredible strength and unity we discovered all across America during the past 2 months, but I get discouraged when I hear the M.O. of “the next Tea Party”.

    I was one of the organizers in my city – I’ve tried to move from DEMONSTRATION to ACTIVISM – sending out emails about what issues are before congress and the senate, and in our state legislature. Encouraging people to WRITE, FAX, EMAIL, or CALL their congress critter. But you bring up a very important point – it will do us no good to bemoan the horrible state of our local and regional GOP groups – it is up to us to roll up our sleeves and dive in and direct the change. To push, prod, mold, and direct our organization back to it’s principles, because there are ultimately two choices in this country – them, or us. And we’ve clearly rejected the Obamabats “them”. So we need to make the “us” work for us.

    We have been able to make a very little tiny dent in our local GOP – earlier this month, the Knoxville GOP finally rolled out a new, improved website. They hadn’t updated their website since JULY 2008!!! I was appalled! It’s a little tiny step, but at least folks can find them now. It’s a heck of a lot easier to change something when you can locate it! Thanks again.

  • RedInABleuState

    If you do take on this challenge, can I suggest that you get involved and work? I can’t tell you the number of times I’ve talked with people who want to get involved with the party/campaign/candidate and, when asked, only want to sit in on policy and campaign meetings to “give advice.”

    Those people who make the most impact are the people who, forgive the phrase, “infiltrate from within.” Get involved. Be the one who will do the work — writing letters, making phone calls, helping with events. When they’ve shown to be the people to depend on, they get invited to the table and, oftentimes, take over. And, really, few people do so you can “shine” quite easily and soon.

    I’ve seen several successful young candidates get involved in this way. Because they’ve worked side by side with other volunteers, they’ve only strengthened their ties to accomplishing real political success.

  • RedInABleuState

    …and excellent post, Erick. Thanks for pushing the discussion. Much needed.

  • jackbenimble

    Personally I think the country is best served if the TEA Party movement remains absolutely independent from all of the political parties. It has far more power and credibility and puts far more fear in the minds of establishment politicians as a grassroots group that is mad as hell and determined to hold the feet to the fire of ALL politicians who put special interests in front of American interests. And while Democrats are worse, Republicans have been absolutely disgusting on that front which is why they got kicked out of power.

    I don’t mind Erick’s advice about Tea Party Activists attending Republican meetings. But I think they should do so as motivated citizens rather than as TEA Party activists. I think we should try to force our will on the Republican Party and try to accumulate power. But I’m not at all sure that the result would be a coup. I think it is equally likely that they will just be absorbed into the “borg”.

    Afterall, we have been down this path before and we worked our asses off through the 90′s to accumulate power and look at the wothless batch of GOP politicians and the worthless policies that we got for our efforts. Its clear to me that once they gain power, our politicians no longer fear us. The primary process, which is really our only tool of discipline, is rigged so the incumbant, no matter how crappy, almost always wins.

    I think what is needed is more of a STICK to BEAT our politicians into line with rather then being part of the Party than ENABLE them while they SHAFT us. I think the TEA Party movement has the potential to be this stick.

    I think the Tea Party movement should be equally about activism at Democrat meetings. A lot of the people who have shown up at the Tea Party rallies are centrist Democrats and independents. The common value that all of us share is some attachment to the free enterprise system and a very strong belief in fiscal sanity which absolutely went out the window under President Bush and has spiraled far worse ever since. I think these people could play a role in wrenching the Democratic Party away from George Soros and back towards the center and some measure of sanity.

    I think every politician regardless of Party should fear the Tea Party movement and I think the Tea Party movement should be largely about either forcing fiscal sanity on or taking down and the worst of the worst regardless of party.

    At the last TEA Party I attended I carried a No Amnesty sign. For the next one I am thinking I’ll get a forked willow stick out of my yard and I’ll go to Walmart and buy a stuffed donkey and a stuffed elephant and hehead them and impate the heads on the prongs of my forked stick. With the sign below them being simply, “Heads on a Stick”.

  • Common_Cents

    Everyone is ordering filet mignon on a menu with no prices. They have no idea how huge the bill will be.

    It’s not about tax cuts, it’s about reducing federal government and restoring state and local.

  • Common_Cents