« BACK  |  PRINT

RS

EDITOR OF REDSTATE

Had He Chosen Differently, John Cornyn Could Be Leading Now

Preaching only has meaning if the preacher lives by his own sermon.

Senator John Cornyn has been on the receiving end of a lot of punches lately over the NRSC’s decision to endorse Charlie Crist over Marco Rubio in the Florida Senate race.

A lot of it is fair criticism, especially considering only days before he endorsed Crist, Senator Cornyn said the NRSC would stay neutral. Not all of the criticism is fair, however. I would crawl over broken glass to get John Cornyn re-elected to the Senate. He is a great leader, a genuinely good person, and an articulate spokesman for the GOP.

But he has badly miscalculated on the Rubio matter and his miscalculation has been made greater by his failure to endorse Ted Cruz in the Texas Republican primary for Texas Attorney General — a position Cornyn himself once held.

John Cornyn is known to believe the GOP must engage in effective outreach to the Hispanic community in order to expand its coalition. He has, in the past, encouraged Hispanic involvement in the GOP and has tried to encourage good Hispanic Republicans to seek office.

Right now, Senate Republicans are running scared of the Sotomayor nomination because they don’t want to be seen as burning bridges with the Hispanic community. The Senate Republican leadership, typically feckless and cowardly the moment controversy arises, is gun shy.

It did not have to be that way. Had Cornyn practiced what he regularly preaches, the GOP would not be in the box.

Were Marco Rubio the GOP’s preferred candidate for the United States Senate, Rubio would be in a position to serve as a credible GOP voice on Sotomayor. Had the NRSC only made a different choice, the choices Republicans Senators now make regarding Sotomayor would be easier.

Likewise, had Senator Cornyn endorsed Ted Cruz, he would have even greater authority on the issue of Hispanics being welcome in the Republican Party.

While some have argued Ted Cruz is not significantly accomplished enough to be Attorney General, and therefore not worth big name Republicans like Cornyn bothering with him, arguably his opponent in the Republican primary is less so. Cruz is the only Hispanic to have ever served as a law clerk to the Chief Justice of the United States. He served for five years as Solicitor General of Texas, a position John Cornyn created when Cornyn was Attorney General. Cruz is an immigrant living the American dream.

He would be an articulate voice the Republicans could use to combat the media’s charges of racism should the GOP get a spine and oppose the Sotomayor nomination.

Had John Cornyn only practiced what he preached, he could be leading the GOP on a path out of the wilderness with a more diverse group of candidates and elected officials.

There is still time. He could both endorse a guy like Ted Cruz and move the NRSC to being neutral in Florida or at least publicly pledging to spend not one penny, directly or indirectly, to help Charlie Crist — a white Pennsylvania transplant running against Rubio, the articulate Hispanic candidate who embodies all that Cornyn says the GOP needs.

The GOP could oppose Sotomayor without alienating Hispanics if only they would, you know, start supporting Hispanic candidates. John Cornyn could lead the way.

COMMENTS

  • bk

    but it’s faded a lot lately with the NRSC business if nothing else.

  • Aaron Gardner

    dugg and tweeted and shared on FB

    Other’s can DIGG here.

  • Mike gamecock DeVine

    to call Miguel Estrada as a witness against Sotomayor.

  • eburke

    This is *precisely* what happens when expediency, cowardice and ‘prevailing wisdom’ triumphs over intellectual honesty and principle. It almost *always* comes back to bite you.

    Once again, by sticking their finger in the air, and buying into the “Beltway” mentality, the GOP has, for the countless time, toasted a golden opportunity.

    When oh when will we (actually ‘they’) ever learn?

  • http://deafconservative.wordpress.com Cheetah772
  • TxCon

    when they get to DC? It is a sad phenomenon.

  • victor_cocchia

    very well written, as usual, and right on the point. Outreach to the hispanic community is paramount now for the Republican party, and the conservative movement for that matter.

    I do believe though that the outreach has to be to candidates that are the embodiment of the conservative movement and both of these candidates, Rubio and Cruz, are just that. Cornyn was way off base by getting involved with someone like Crist (he saw the expedient way to keep the seat as the prevailing motivation over choosing a solid conservative).

    The Republican party, and conservatives, are in a very precarious situation right now due to core issues that are at odds with hispanic interests right now, and the only way to show that we are taking a balanced view of the issues is to include more qualified hispanics in both the debate, and backing them as candidates. In this we will demonstrate that we are acting out of, and by our principles, and not based on any perceived differences.

  • redloft

    If you want to seriously question her qualifications and minimize the possibility of upsetting the Hispanic constituency, than we ought to focus on getting Mel Martinez out in front of the debate. After all, he actually gets to vote on her. Trying to bring this back to Cornyn vs. Rubio is a stretch.

  • http://www.erickerickson.org Erick Erickson

    And knowing what we know about Martinez, he will probably support her.

  • redloft

    but don’t you think pressuring Martinez to oppose her is a rational course of action and could give Republicans better traction on this issue? The idea that Cornyn could annoint Rubio as a credible voice is not realistic. Seriously, nobody outside of Florida (South Florida to be specific) could care less what Marco Rubio thinks of Judge Sotomayer.

  • redloft

    issue an endorsement for someone running in a state primary for Attorney General. That would be a major abuse of that committee. Of course, Cornyn could himself endorse, but not on behalf of the NRSC. The Rubio/Crist situation and Ted Cruz situation is apples and oranges.

  • http://www.erickerickson.org Erick Erickson

    I’m talking Cornyn himself.

  • http://www.erickerickson.org Erick Erickson

    To be so shortsighted to say:

    nobody outside of Florida (South Florida to be specific) could care less what Marco Rubio thinks of Judge Sotomayer.

    No one outside Florida cares what Mel Martinez thinks unless the GOP puts him up to reflect their views.

    And do you really think Martinez cares? He’s on his way out. Exactly what pressure can be brought to bear, especially when he’s been whining in the press about conservatives for the past year?

  • http://www.ssce.net/Web-Articles/Web-articles-indexed-authors.html#authors-l JLenardDetroit

    Any and every Candidate for a Senate seat has every reason/right to voice opinion on SoSo and one of Latino/Hispanic origin has even MORE right (in fact, from the Republican/Conservative viewpoint a REQUIREMENT) to speak out since the Democrats and the Liberal MSM will be doing the usual RACE-baiting if criticism comes from someone other than that “background” because she has “such a compelling story” as we hear endlessly trying to AVOID any real discussion of her Liberal Activism from the Bench.

    All of this is in play:
    SCOTUS Empathy – SCOTUS Empathy
    +2001 Redistributive Justice video Obama’s 2001 Redistributive Justice video
    +Identity Politics – Identity Politics
    +Hispanic SCOTUS nominee – first Hispanic on SCOTUS?
    +SoSo NOT the first (Benjamin Cardozo) – Yahoo: Is Sotomayor the First (or Second) Hispanic Pick for the Supreme Court? A:second (First was a Republican appointment)
    +Obama Legislation list – the 14 Legislative agenda items (and other things) Obama wants to distract from
    +O failure – How Obama’s FAILURES are the country’s SUCCESSES – since we have to spell it out

    And since this is related, seems to have to be an hourly rather than daily thing now ;-) lol….. Crist/Rubio SINGLE LINK Crist/Rubio discussion [multiple sub-links]

    Though I THANK YOU for the “tone” of this Diary… it is IMO much improved (allows us to set forth the ability to still work together on common goals (standing up about working together) of/in the GOP (still Conservative) Platform. Keep the pressure on Cornyn/NRSC as a whole, Erick, I’m with you… with some occasional exceptions (tone especially). CONSERVATISM is the right direction/cause!!!!

    Lastly, a bit of an aside yet related…. repeal the 17th? YES please (old BigGator Diary). Let’s have the debate on going back to picking Senators the old way, or at least each State determining for themselves if we shouldn’t (at least debate) change how we pick our U.S.Senators.

  • redloft

    For the record, I do not, nor have I ever worked for the NRSC. I happen to think that a sitting Hispanic US Senator opposing Sotomayor’s nomination might draw interest outside of Florida. It certainly has a better chance of gaining national recognition than Marco Rubio.

    And do I think Martinez actually cares? Probably not . But the fact that he is on his way out might actually play in our favor. He isn’t running for re-elect so he might be less worried about upsetting an important constituency in Florida.

  • http://www.ssce.net/Web-Articles/Web-articles-indexed-authors.html#authors-l JLenardDetroit

    well… and Moe …. he can/should insult those he BLAM-sticks :) lol

    I want you to remain your high degree of esteem and respect with the “respectful dismissals”

    Regards, wish I could be coming to the get-together in GA.

  • Leopard1996

    In the fact that Cormyn and the NSRC endorsing more liberal candidates for Senate, despite the fact that we feel their time has passed and no longer represent us is poking us right in the eye. I am not a Social conservative by any means, but I am for small/efficient government, and from what I can see neither Specter or Chist fits that mode. Specter from what I have seen not at all. Christ from what I have read will just be a slower slide to government control.

  • Carol Tarasewicz

    I got a call Wed from NRSC asking for my annual support. I told man I was not going to participate this year. It was apparent that he thought I meant it because it is not an election year, man went on to tell me that it will be for 2010 and 2012 elections. I told him I wasn’t giving because I did not approve of what NRSC did in FL, endorse RINO Christ over Rubio. I asked to be removed from list. If I see someone I want to contribute to, if I can I will. I am not givingto NRSC.

  • Carol Tarasewicz

    I’m sorry, I forgot to thank you for the education I am getting about candidates here. Thanks to all of you!

  • http://www.the41stvote.org rcov092

    he would have a hard time finding a position in a law firm doing heavy Federal Government business if he jumps up and shoves his finger in the Dem’s eye on this. Sorry his principle are not what stands him upright.