« BACK  |  PRINT

RS

EDITOR OF REDSTATE

What a Republican Suicide Looks Like [updated]

There are two candidates in NY-23 worth focusing on (there are actually several Republicans vying for a party nomination to run against one Democrat).

One candidate is pro-life, supports traditional marriage, and is pretty fiscally responsible.

The other is pro-abortion, supports gay marriage, and is pretty fiscally reckless.

You’d think the first candidate is the Republican and the second is the Democrat. You would be wrong.

In New York’s 23rd congressional district, Republicans are leaning toward endorsing New York Assemblywoman Dede Scozzafava as their candidate for the special election there. The election is being held to replace Republican Congressman John McHugh, who Obama appointed Army Secretary.

Scozzafava is both a socially and fiscally liberal loser. She cannot beat the Democrat who is both a social and (mostly) fiscal conservative and is a powerful chairman in the State Senate.

Scozzafava has burned every bridge possible with every conservative interest group.

If Scozzafava is the nominee, the New York Conservative Party will not support her — and they deliver vital support and money most often to Republican candidates.

If Scozzafava is the GOP candidate, I will support and encourage all of you to support the Democrat, who will vote will us more often than Scozzafava ever would.

Most crucially, if the GOP does choose Scozzafava to be their candidate in NY-23, the Democrats will go into the election on a timetable of their choosing with a candidate who will win, thus propelling a media narrative during the healthcare debate that Obama remains popular.

In fact, the media narrative from a Democrat win in this district at this time will be devastating for the GOP as it seeks to hold back Obama on healthcare.

This is what Republican suicide looks like.

[updated]: I hear that the RNC will not spend one red cent in NY-23 if Scozzafava is the nominee. Good! Note this is praise for Michael Steele and him team. Well done. I hope the NRCC does the same.

COMMENTS

  • http://twitter.com/ActionAlert mhblatt

    It’s good that the Republican is at least rational enough to support gay marriage and abortion–to support freedom–even if it isn’t politically beneficial. This might not be the right time and election to have that rational Republican run, but at least it’s a start for what we should be doing with our party. Too often we will throw out the moderates, and then you end up with Democrats having a 77-seat majority with lots of representatives who support gun rights but somehow were able to stay in the party. We don’t let people be Republicans if they don’t check down the line of views. And worst of all, it’s the social issues–the pointless ones that we take the wrong position on–that are often given the most dogmatic emphasis.

  • http://www.hakubi.us/ Neil Stevens

    Next post, apologize to all the people you just called ‘irrational’ merely because you disagree with them.

  • penguin2

    but they are critical to a solid foundation for society. And as far the rigidity of Republicans, they actually have more tolerance and acceptance of the human condition, whatever it may be, instead of trying to strip an individual of who they are as individuals and make them into robots to Statism.

  • roscopico

    I take the LOOOOOOOOONNNG way home from work.

    Get your act straight, NY, CA, FL.

    I’m D@MN sick of it.

    Get a candidate, not a squish. There are many things that make reasonable people go crazy, but what things might make crazy people go reasonable? I hope the NY (R) party figures it out.

    Shape up, northeast. I humbly propose a purge. No “moderation”, just pure, sweet, prudent liberty.

  • http://twitter.com/ActionAlert mhblatt

    I’m making my next post and (surprisingly) I’m not apologizing any more than I did when I called Mark Kirk and Russ Carnahan idiots. Apparently you want me to apologize for disagreeing with you. No, I’m not John Kerry, so I think I’m going to keep my position.

    As for Republicans being more accepting, I’d like to see pro-abortion Republican speak at the RNC. It’s more likely they’d get thrown out of the party by Rush and by the bloggers, then they wouldn’t get another Red Cent in campaign contributions.

  • Darin_H

    Insert Curly Bill.. Nice knowing ya.

  • roscopico

    There are truths which are immutable.

    And I have the wrong position?

    I presume you liked the “review” of Dr. Levin’s Manifesto in the recent Weekly Standard. I presume you loved the review as well.

    Are you “Colon” Powell, Chris Buckley, or perhaps Peter Berkowitz IRL?

    Don’t blame me for asking.

  • Jack_Savage

    I’ll wait until an anti-abortion Democrat delivers a keynote, thank you very much.

    And BTW, does the name “Joe Lieberman” ring a bell with you?

  • http://www.hakubi.us/ Neil Stevens
  • http://www.hakubi.us/ Neil Stevens

    If you don’t like the results of various primaries, do better in them.

  • http://www.hakubi.us/ Neil Stevens

    G’bye.

  • SirGladiator

    I find it fascinating that in a Republican district the Republicans could possibly nominate an ultra liberal to go up against a Conservative Democrat. You’d like to think that by this point we would have learned our lesson to stop nominating liberals, and nominate Conservatives. This could end up being Sarah Palin’s ‘Conservative Democrat’ that she said she wanted to campaign for, and since its a Republican district it would seem to be a good one for her to come in and make a huge difference. Certainly if the Republicans do nominate the liberal I too hope the Democrat wins. We need Conservatives in Congress, party label is secondary to that.

  • AceInTX

    of the entire party membership holding guns to their own heads and pulling the trigger…

    What I see is more like Tienanmen Square where we’re standing in front of the leftist leadership’s tanks with our groceries while our own leadership plots our utter annihilation by their own hand!

  • Big Apple Infidel

    The Republican party in NY State has been a basket case on life support for years. Shame on Pataki, Guiliani and Bloomberg for doing nothing to build the party. While none of these 3 could be considered conservative and all embrace various liberal positions (especially former Democrat Bloomberg), their long-term tenure in the Governor’s mansion and NYC City Hall was marked by concern for themselves with absolutely no effort to grow the party.

    This was a terribly missed opportunity considering the amazing fiscal and crime turn-around that occurred, especially during the period when Pataki and Guiliani were both in office at the same time. Rebuilding the base has to be one of the most important goals going forward and nothing is being done about that in NY State.

  • AceInTX

    2006 and 2008…

    Ever heard of the maverick John McCain…or the favored candidate in Florida Charlie Crist, or the money our party wasted on Link Chaffee, or the pull out the stops race by Santorum and Bush to save Snarlen Arlen?

    Oh…and I suppose we all forced Collin Powell and the other supposed conservative clowns in the media like WF Buckley Jr to endorse Obama.

    please let us know when you regain your grip on reality!

  • roscopico

    and I agree with the premises in your sig.

    I am active, and don’t wish to be equated with the Stalinists. It is disheartening to see R’s in the northeast that haven’t learned the lesson of either the last national election or the Quisling surrender of spectre, snowe, and collins w/r/t the porkulus.

    I do hope they quit supporting “moderates”.

    Pale pastels or bold colors, to me there is no choice.

    Best wishes,
    roscopico

  • AceInTX
  • AceInTX

    Correct me if I’m wrong, but didn’t Rudy Giuliani, Arnold Schwarzenegger, Tom Ridge etc keynote every single night at the 2004 Republican Convention…and don’t tell me the 2008 Conventiona was a parade of radical right wingers…

    get a grip on reality man!

  • roscopico

    Colin Powell?
    Chris Buckley?
    Meghan McCain?
    Peter Berkowitz (my new favorite)? (sorry I don’t know how to embed link)
    http://www.weeklystandard.com/Content/Public/Articles/000/000/016/747thgnk.asp

    Pale Pastels?

    And as it turns out, there are more conservatives than there are Republicans…
    Conservatives can have the party, if they so desire.

    Again, I don’t like to be equated with J.Stalin.
    I don’t like squishes, either. Maybe the Colin Powell’s of the world would be happier after the purge… they might finally be “moderate” democrats.

  • bk

     

  • randy streu

    I’m looking for something solid to send on with regard to this.