The race has now been called for Democrat Bill Owens.
This is a huge win for conservatives.
“Whaaaa. . . ?” you say.
There are two big victories at work in New York’s 23rd Congressional District.
First, the GOP now must recognize it will either lose without conservatives or will win with conservatives. In 2008, many conservatives sat home instead of voting for John McCain. Now, in NY-23, conservatives rallied and destroyed the Republican candidate the establishment chose.
I have said all along that the goal of activists must be to defeat Scozzafava. Doug Hoffman winning would just be gravy. A Hoffman win is not in the cards, but we did exactly what we set out to do — crush the establishment backed GOP candidate.
And make no mistake, despite the Beltway spin, we know for certain based on statements from the local Republican parties, that they chose Scozzafava based on advice from the Washington crowd.
So we have demonstrated to the GOP that it must not take conservatives for granted. The GOP spent $900,000.00 on a Republican who dropped out and endorsed the Democrat. Were we to combine Scozzafava and Hoffman’s votes, Hoffman would have won.
Secondly, and just as importantly, there has all of a sudden been a huge movement among some activists to go the third party route. We see in NY-23 that this is not possible as third parties are not viable.
Third parties lack funding and ability for a host of reasons. Conservatives are going to have to work from within the GOP. The GOP had better pay attention.
For all intents and purposes, NY-23 is a trial run for Florida. And in Florida, the conservative candidate is operating inside the GOP. If John Cornyn and the NRSC do not want to see Florida go the way of NY-23, they better stand down.

I hope this
fotophun Wednesday, November 4th at 12:11AM EST (link)Scuzzy lady sinks back into oblivion
AND in my opinion she should be made tp or sued to get the money back that was spent on her
this money was donated by real Republicans, and she was a Rino all the way
Completely agree Erick -nt
RealQuiet Wednesday, November 4th at 12:11AM EST (link)absolutely the right analysis
JLenardDetroit Wednesday, November 4th at 12:31AM EST (link)We celebrate tonight, knowing that tomorrow….
the work to fight the same battles in different territories begins all over again… The fight is still great/large to ensure the Republican Party has the RIGHT (yep, double meaning) Candidates for 2010… The Left-Republicans won’t just concede anything…. We must parlay this into momentum to control the GOP with more and more Conservatives working into positions of control/authority….
But for tonight - WE CELEBRATE!!!
and tomorrow we setup for the same battles (2010 prep)
and agree with Real below…. donations and work to Candidates and Conservative PACs directly, not the Party
(RS:Help) (JLD) (Hollyweird) (Brain-deads) (SPIN-cycle) (Obamaocare) (Party of kNOw) (Conservatism) (TEApeats) (respectful) (Reco) (Quotes) (removeRINOs.com) (RSmas)
+ 0bama Lies & your Bank acct will Die! (4/15 Truthers)
+ Heil “O” Hell No Obamao is NOT MY PRESIDENT! “No U won’t”
+ I want “O” to FAIL (here, here, & whole Diary (Ofail) here, is why)
“The first Liberal was Satan” - a Rush caller (other Quotes)
Ayep
OccamsRazor Wednesday, November 4th at 1:23AM EST (link)‘The God King’ CAN be hurt?!!!
I don't feel like we won
kaym1246 Wednesday, November 4th at 2:41AM EST (link)Erik, on the fundamentals we may have won but it didn’t translate to a WIN.
Why?
How was it that the polling showed Hoffman up 10 points and he finishes 5 points down?
Who is the polling company and what were they doing?
What happened to the area that didn’t get to vote? Was there voter fraud - ie, more votes than voters? When will the mail in ballots be counted?
I’m ticked.
Really really ticked about Hoffman not winning when the polls said he would.
WHAT HAPPENED? You need to do some indepth analysis on this to get me to give money again to anyone.
~Feelings...Nothing but Feelings~
OccamsRazor Wednesday, November 4th at 2:43AM EST (link).
Yeah, I've got a feeling
voxoreason Wednesday, November 4th at 7:51AM EST (link)The feeling that dem corruption is a fact of life, not a sign of paranoia (which is free and often useful: ACORN thugs have been caught on video beating up too many people TRYING to enjoy their right to assemble and petition the gov’t; these people can’t be trusted).
In NJ, they found “voters” who had not signed up to vote…but had submitted a vote (or two), anyway! Feelings? Yeah: betrayed by the media, which most have realized and acclimated themselves to.
RedState was the only place I could find the Corzine campaign assistant deputy director drug bust. ABC thinks that they’re like God: they giveth and taketh away. I hope this info made the rounds in NJ early enough to affect the vote.
So you'll only give your blood, sweat and tears
eburke Wednesday, November 4th at 10:11AM EST (link)if you’re assured of victory? Good thing our Founding Fathers didn’t start the American Revolution with that perspective.
FWIW–I sent Doug a Ben Franklin and would do it again tomorrow in a heartbeat.
“All that need be done for evil to triumph is for good men to do nothing.”
“Dead fish go with the flow” ~ izoneguy
“We have a Statue of Liberty not a Statue of Necessity” ~ ColdWarrior
No more donating to GOP organizations
RealQuiet Wednesday, November 4th at 12:12AM EST (link)Donate solely to the candidate, not the party.
unless you're both (literally/figuratively) sending them your 2 cents.
JLenardDetroit Wednesday, November 4th at 12:58AM EST (link)You may not have seen these discussions yet….
We cannot let the Party think we are not willing to help fund them and leaving only funds coming from Moderates and an excuse to cater to them. We have to send them a message that we want to fund them but expect to see something first rather than our continued unmet expectations with our funds.
Daily Dimes Dichotomy - creating an NRSC: Daily Dimes Dichotomy
+Monthly 2 cent checks - I’m sending MONTHLY 2 cent checks with MEMO
+RNC called - RNC called, I hung up!
+Party of NO - Republicans must be the Party of NO [to Bigger Govt.] not the Party of SLOW[er Liberal Incremental-ism]
(RS:Help) (JLD) (Hollyweird) (Brain-deads) (SPIN-cycle) (Obamaocare) (Party of kNOw) (Conservatism) (TEApeats) (respectful) (Reco) (Quotes) (removeRINOs.com) (RSmas)
+ 0bama Lies & your Bank acct will Die! (4/15 Truthers)
+ Heil “O” Hell No Obamao is NOT MY PRESIDENT! “No U won’t”
+ I want “O” to FAIL (here, here, & whole Diary (Ofail) here, is why)
“The first Liberal was Satan” - a Rush caller (other Quotes)
Nice Analysis Erick
treeofliberty Wednesday, November 4th at 12:12AM EST (link)Though I am a bit disappointed and surprised we didn’t go 3 for 3 (what happened to those polls showing Hoffman winning the race easily?) I will take heart in winning NJ and VA and also that Hoffman will be back in 2010.
Basically the Democrats were barely able to eek out a victory against a divided Republican Party and a conservative candidate no one had heard of 6 weeks ago.
If Hoffman runs in 2010 and we oppose Owens on a united front I believe we’ll take back this seat easily.
I'm not so sure...
gator_hoo Wednesday, November 4th at 1:02AM EST (link)I agree completely that the message was sent, but I don’t know if anybody will have heard it.
I think it hurts a lot that we didn’t go 3 for 3. For the great win in NJ, the Dems can simply rebut - “We won a congressional district that has gone Republican since the Civil War.”
I honestly don’t think the GOP establishment cares - they are selling the “moderate” tab as pragmatic, but I think it is ideological - or at least pragmatic in terms of “I get to not do much and keep my job” and not in terms of “We have to run moderate candidates in these areas.”
It was a good night...
writeblock Wednesday, November 4th at 1:04AM EST (link)We won huge in VA and big in NJ. What few are commenting on is that McDonnell is a true conservative, a Reaganite, a terrific campaigner, and now a GOP megastar with no negatives attached to his name whatsoever–and he can only serve one term. 2012 anyone?
writeblock- That is a distinct possibility
Scope Wednesday, November 4th at 10:11AM EST (link)McDonnell, a real Reagan Conservative, with a quiet but solid social issue background, won in a landslide. As you say, he has no negatives, unless of course you want to go the losing route of Deeds and bring up “the thesis” again. He put together a terrific winning campaign team (except for that one former McCain person), he is charasmatic, a great speaker, confident, and will be the best thing that happened to Virginia in the last decade. I know that he will do what he told us he would, to the best of his ability. Rather than thinking Hucka, Romney, Pawlenty and etc., think Bob McDonnell.
Best line I read over at NRO Horserace section-
“Early turnout indicates that Cuccinelli is the winner of the 2013 Governor’s race as well.”
Thank you our good Lord, it is a bright and promising day in Virginia.
In 2012...
soljerblue Wednesday, November 4th at 11:59AM EST (link)Palin-O’Donnell
It's indeed important to be realistic
OccamsRazor Wednesday, November 4th at 1:30AM EST (link)pragmatic and focused. There is NO doubt in most of RedStaters minds that yes, we are still WAY behind in a larger picture sense. I take away hope in multiple ways today:
1.) We won battles today momentum would’ve naturally dictated otherwise.
2.) The democrats are burying their heads in the sand about it.
3.) *smirk* “The arc of the moral universe is [indeed] justice”
For the next few hours, enjoy.
he lags by 4000 odd votes.
antisocial Wednesday, November 4th at 12:14AM EST (link)and about 14% is not in. I would wait until at least 96% of the votes are in.
Your point is well taken.
No you can’t - Moe Lane
——————————
The Emperor has no clothes!!!
——————————
Republicans who lost the Crap-and-Raid fight in the House -
Mary Bomo Mac (CA-45)
Mike Castle (DE)
Mark Kirk (IL-10)
Frank A. LoBiondo (NJ-02)
Chris Smith (NJ-04)
Leonard Lance (NJ-07)
John M. McHugh (NY-23)
Dave Reichert (WA-08)
Watertown times reports - Conservative concedes behind by only 4,284 votes
antisocial Wednesday, November 4th at 12:19AM EST (link)very disappointing…
No you can’t - Moe Lane
——————————
The Emperor has no clothes!!!
——————————
Republicans who lost the Crap-and-Raid fight in the House -
Mary Bomo Mac (CA-45)
Mike Castle (DE)
Mark Kirk (IL-10)
Frank A. LoBiondo (NJ-02)
Chris Smith (NJ-04)
Leonard Lance (NJ-07)
John M. McHugh (NY-23)
Dave Reichert (WA-08)
That said, Erick I feel real sorry for the people of NY-23...
DONTREADONME Wednesday, November 4th at 12:17AM EST (link)you had a chance to change something, yet you chose the same old same old party loyalists. What have the D’s done for the NY-23? I know Plattsburgh is a shell of its former self as a military town, Utica and Syracuse are basically disaster areas of anemic job growth and massive population loss, accept for the college students of course which depend on Government. Sad really; however, my wife left district 23 of NY to live with me in VA, and we can say my wife has had the job opportunities in VA that she would never have had in NY.
She is a director, she moved up with no college degree. Try doing that in upstate New York without a college degree. I left MD for VA for a job in the high tech defense industry and R&D and I have never looked back. Shame really, I feel real sorry for those people because the teet of Government, then pull themselves up by the boot straps educate themselves, save money for the hard times and invest to get ahead in the world. Oh, well at least we showed that scuzzi couldn’t have given a damn about those who voted for Hoffman. I think the GOP is listening now.
“The UN is right? you can’t be any more “un”; Than you are right now, the UN is undone, Another mushroom cloud, another smoking gun, The threat is real, the Locust King has come, Don’t tell me the truth; I don’t like what they’ve done, Just give me ammo for the United Abominations”-Megadeth
DTOM, I think despite Hoffman's apparent loss
TNJim Wednesday, November 4th at 12:24AM EST (link)We have indeed caught the attention of the GOP establishment with the events that led up to tonight. No. More. Libs with R’s beside their names. No. More. Squishes.
I hope they’re listening now. They better be.
“No. You can’t” -Moe Lane
or at least, they got the message we are your base percentage of the vote-nt
DONTREADONME Wednesday, November 4th at 12:30AM EST (link)“The UN is right? you can’t be any more “un”; Than you are right now, the UN is undone, Another mushroom cloud, another smoking gun, The threat is real, the Locust King has come, Don’t tell me the truth; I don’t like what they’ve done, Just give me ammo for the United Abominations”-Megadeth
a direct re-match between those 2 would be nice...
JLenardDetroit Wednesday, November 4th at 1:05AM EST (link)kinda a smaller scale Toomey/disreSpecter repeat we’re getting. Would certainly give Hoffman plenty of time, but he might not be up to an actual long campaign.
(RS:Help) (JLD) (Hollyweird) (Brain-deads) (SPIN-cycle) (Obamaocare) (Party of kNOw) (Conservatism) (TEApeats) (respectful) (Reco) (Quotes) (removeRINOs.com) (RSmas)
+ 0bama Lies & your Bank acct will Die! (4/15 Truthers)
+ Heil “O” Hell No Obamao is NOT MY PRESIDENT! “No U won’t”
+ I want “O” to FAIL (here, here, & whole Diary (Ofail) here, is why)
“The first Liberal was Satan” - a Rush caller (other Quotes)
Yeah. And without Snotzalotza (whatever)
TNJim Wednesday, November 4th at 1:38AM EST (link)in there to take 5% of the vote.
“No. You can’t” -Moe Lane
For what its worth
Illinicon Wednesday, November 4th at 12:20AM EST (link)Owens is underperforming Obama’s results in the district from last year. Also isnt it ironic that the first or second media outlet (i dont know if MSNBC has called it) was Fox, while AP, CNN and Politico have not called it as of yet. Given the historically Republican nature of the district I am sure we will get it back next year when we have a unified base.
Jindal/Thompson ‘12
Bringing clear Conservative change to America.
Third parties
ktsub Wednesday, November 4th at 12:21AM EST (link)Sink conservatives, there is no getting around the fact that taking even a single percentage from the Republican or conservative, the Democrats will win. Must work within the GOP. I myself and sending a donation to the Republican Governors Assocation, tonight is a night to celebrate and the RGA did an outstanding job (IMO). Way to go Christie and McDonnell…I am proud of the GOP tonight.
I loved watching PMSNBC tonight, they looked like they ate a live frog.
And the end result is that Bela Pelosi grows in strength
corky Wednesday, November 4th at 12:21AM EST (link)We sure showed them!
I happen to be a guy who doesn’t get up every morning hating my country. Roger Ailes
Had Dede won, Pelosi would still have an extra vote
Illinicon Wednesday, November 4th at 12:26AM EST (link)The only difference is now the MSM cant get away with calling healthcare bi-partisan when the Acorn Republican who is to the left of the blue dogs would have voted for it.
Jindal/Thompson ‘12
Bringing clear Conservative change to America.
Heh, good point
corky Wednesday, November 4th at 12:37AM EST (link)I don’t pretend to understand every single little pro and con about this issue but I do think you’re overthinking it a bit…the ultimate result, is a vote for everything Pelosi wants instead of some of what she wants. I’d rather the latter.
Maybe Hoffman, or someone like him, will run in 2010 and take it back. At least we learned that this district had a little more wiggle room to put a more conservative candidate in place.
I happen to be a guy who doesn’t get up every morning hating my country. Roger Ailes
corky, take a powder man, Pelosi gets what she wants anyway...
DONTREADONME Wednesday, November 4th at 12:27AM EST (link)dude, its people like you that can’t understand what happened tonight. The conservative garnered 45%+ of the vote (we still have not seen the military ballot form deployments in Afghanistan 10th mountain division). Sheesh, man the Democrat would have won anyway, no way scuzzi would have voted against the stimulus bill, she would be the one R to give the D’s the bipartisan BS they spill.
“The UN is right? you can’t be any more “un”; Than you are right now, the UN is undone, Another mushroom cloud, another smoking gun, The threat is real, the Locust King has come, Don’t tell me the truth; I don’t like what they’ve done, Just give me ammo for the United Abominations”-Megadeth
You do have a point
corky Wednesday, November 4th at 12:34AM EST (link)that, in the short term, it might not have made a modicum of difference. Like I said before, though, I think Hoffman wins this if he’s the nominee from the beginning.
I’m just worried that this stuff will happen in 2010 when we NEED RINO’s to take back the house…
I happen to be a guy who doesn’t get up every morning hating my country. Roger Ailes
I am just trying...
DONTREADONME Wednesday, November 4th at 12:46AM EST (link)to say to you and help corky, Please read, I promise this is good stuff nothing negative.
If we are going to thrust our weight around to experiment as the base of the GOP, why not in a special election. I think we learned something tonight a conservative foundation with adaptations for the electorate could have won the day up there. So let it be done in 2010, the electorate is definitely showed a distaste tonight.
Listen I am not trying to say lets banish the truely moderate R’s its the RINOs (there’s a difference to me), but sometimes I can not throw my support behind certain candidates, then again its not my district. That said I have to support the candidate that I think brings the right ideas to the country and to his/her district, and you have to support those you perfer from the GOP. That’s why I have engaged you tonight. I am just trying to express a different angle on all of this, the MSM loves to spin but they forget there are two sides to every story, and this one win or lose can be thought of as a positive. In the end, Owens has to answer to NY-23 and I am not sure they will like it too much when he falls in lockstep behind the Nanny.
That’s all man, just a little back and forth. I am happy, I got the delegate I voted for tonight in VA, threw out the moderate and brought in a conservative. And this district VA-11 went to a liberal Democrat that votes in line with Nancy Pelosi everytime.
“The UN is right? you can’t be any more “un”; Than you are right now, the UN is undone, Another mushroom cloud, another smoking gun, The threat is real, the Locust King has come, Don’t tell me the truth; I don’t like what they’ve done, Just give me ammo for the United Abominations”-Megadeth
darn it I hate when I do not finish a thought...
DONTREADONME Wednesday, November 4th at 12:50AM EST (link)VA-11 is a house seat that is currently occupied by a san fransico type liberal, who was elected on the coat tails of 0bama, this district just voted for a number of candidates that are either one conservative or a Democrat that acted like a conservative. That tells me that in VA-11 in 2010 there is a chance for the D to switch back to an R, which was lost with the retirement in 2008.
“The UN is right? you can’t be any more “un”; Than you are right now, the UN is undone, Another mushroom cloud, another smoking gun, The threat is real, the Locust King has come, Don’t tell me the truth; I don’t like what they’ve done, Just give me ammo for the United Abominations”-Megadeth
I've read everything you've said
corky Wednesday, November 4th at 1:03AM EST (link)and appreciate the discourse. I enjoy conversing with people that disagree with me, yet aren’t disagreeable.
We certainly DID learn a lot through this experiment. Perhaps the learning experience was worth giving the Dems another seat.
Let’s just not lose sight of the fact that, ultimately, the outcome sucked!
I happen to be a guy who doesn’t get up every morning hating my country. Roger Ailes
lastly, I am a...
DONTREADONME Wednesday, November 4th at 1:22AM EST (link)or was a big time contributor the RNC, RNSC and RNCC; however, I have stopped and will only donate direct until the GOP actually come remotely close to supporting causes I believe in. If they shift 40% (for scuzzi) of policy stances to the D’s, I pretty much do not see the point in financing campaigns that are counter to my principles. Yes I only give up to below $250 to keep my identity secret but I do donate that quite often to various candidates and what used to be the GOP RNC. So, when I spend money which I did to the RNCC and the RNC I get a little irritated when I see a Scuzzi defended as the candidate while Hoffman gets the shaft. Does that further clarify where I come from? I am sure you wouldn’t like it if you gave 250 of your money to a candidate that is attacking your principles?
“The UN is right? you can’t be any more “un”; Than you are right now, the UN is undone, Another mushroom cloud, another smoking gun, The threat is real, the Locust King has come, Don’t tell me the truth; I don’t like what they’ve done, Just give me ammo for the United Abominations”-Megadeth
Gay Marriage opposition takes 4 pt. lead in Maine
WarEagle01 Wednesday, November 4th at 12:23AM EST (link)with 79% in
http://www.forbes.com/feeds/ap/2009/11/04/politics-us-gay-marriage-maine_7082410.html
http://elections.nytimes.com/2009/results/other.html
“A wise, doughy leg with rich tingly experiences will always reach better conclusions than will a more tanned, muscular leg that hasn’t felt those thrills.” –Chris Matthews’ Leg
This is the most important vote of the night!
ZeusKingoftheGods Wednesday, November 4th at 1:45AM EST (link)Way to go Mainers!
Erick
seesalrun Wednesday, November 4th at 12:25AM EST (link)although we wish we can touch and feel all, we can’t undo a 20 year assault. Go to sleep now knowing that America is awake and all knowing and will not rest until the Republic for WHICH IT STANDS is not a memory, but the touchstone to all that reside.
We won tonight. Hoffman lost for a multitude of reasons.
Others won.
We need to take them all to task and make our Government work for us.
Did Obama hug Corzine enough times to
redneck_hippie Wednesday, November 4th at 12:25AM EST (link)have picked up the stink of a rotting corpse?
“We must not lose our faculty to dare, especially in dark days.” - Churchill in March, 1942.
Remember NY-23.
uh
seesalrun Wednesday, November 4th at 12:31AM EST (link)yeah the narcissistic stench was too much even for Jersey.
Next!
Very disappointing.
shadowtax Wednesday, November 4th at 12:25AM EST (link)Unless we have a miracle in CA-10, the Dems get one more House seat. I hope the general trend in these elections is enough to stop the more radical proposals of the Congress, but I fear otherwise. Maybe the upside is that the Democrats will believe their own spin, fail to adjust, and get creamed in 2010. In the short term though, there will be some very tough legislative battles.
Very well said
corky Wednesday, November 4th at 12:28AM EST (link)RINOs still vote for the GOP for speakership. That is 99% of what matters.
I happen to be a guy who doesn’t get up every morning hating my country. Roger Ailes
In the small picture...you're right. In the larger picture...
eburke Wednesday, November 4th at 10:23AM EST (link)I respectfully but passionately disagree.
First, Dede wasn’t a moderate…she was a liberal. Owens ran and campaigned to her *right*. Thus, I doubt seriously that she would oppose anything that the Pelosi gang put together that is of any consequence to the nation: government spending…card check…public option…cap & trade…etc. So from a policy standpoint we actually may be better off with Owens than we would have been with Scuzzy ’cause he actually campaigned *against* a public option. Time, certainly, will tell.
The big picture is that the media won’t be able in the long-term to keep cloaking socialist policies under the patina of ‘bi-partisanship’ which is actually the big picture reason as to why liberal Republicans in the long term do more harm than good - they serve to blur the lines in the ‘uninformed’ voter’s mind between which party stands for freedom and which one stands for government nannyism.
And in Scuzzy’s case, I’m not sure you’ve even got the ’small’ picture right. Anyone who could endorse the Dem candidate after the GOP plunked $900K into her campaign reveals herself to be petty and of zero moral certitude. I’m not sure that Dede, if she had won last night and was reelected in 2010, would’ve voted for the GOP speaker or just switched parties ala Snarlin’ Arlen.
“All that need be done for evil to triumph is for good men to do nothing.”
“Dead fish go with the flow” ~ izoneguy
“We have a Statue of Liberty not a Statue of Necessity” ~ ColdWarrior
corky- Do you realize
Scope Wednesday, November 4th at 10:25AM EST (link)that your support of RINO’s is exactly why the Republicans are now at war with the Conservative portion of the party. Do you realize that your thinking is what keeps the war going on. As long as they have people who only see R rather than the candidate, they will keep their noses in the air.
corky- Do you realize
Scope Wednesday, November 4th at 10:25AM EST (link)that your support of RINO’s is exactly why the Republicans are now at war with the Conservative portion of the party. Do you realize that your thinking is what keeps the war going on. As long as they have people who only see R rather than the candidate, they will keep their noses in the air.
Everything's That's Old is New Again
SSranger Wednesday, November 4th at 12:26AM EST (link)Economics—repressive taxation was a principal locomotive force driving the American revolution. The Obama administration’s desperate effort to coolly downplay the political significance of the gubernatorial elections in New Jersey and Virginia certainly flies in the face of Samuel Adams’ prescient words during our nation’s founding: “It does not require a majority to prevail, but rather an irate, tireless minority keen to set brush fires in people’s minds.”
The brush fires have begun.
United we stand, divided we fall
Freedoms Truth Wednesday, November 4th at 12:27AM EST (link)This is not a victory, but an instructive lesson.
The analysis is correct on the two key lessons:
1. RINOs and liberal Republicans make for bad candidates and destroy Republican unity.
2. Third party candidates on the conservative side have a hard time winning and will ultimately be harmful for conservative unity
ERGO …
3. THE WAY FOR GOP VICTORY IS THE VA GOV WAY - TO GET SOLID CONSERVATIVE CANDIDATES AS THEIR NOMINEE and unite behind him. United we stand, divided we fall.
This does not mean that we would have been better off without Hoffman in the race, as Erick points out. Defumigating the liberals in our party is the first step to defeating them in the other party.
Freedoms Truth,
Travis Monitor - http://travismonitor.blogspot.com
Austin, TX
n/t
rec0n Wednesday, November 4th at 11:07AM EST (link)I’m no political expert - but shouldn’t #2 read:
‘Third party candidates have a hard time winning’ w/ a period at the end?
I am comparitively new to watching politics across the nation as closely as I have been, but by and large they seem to be pawns. On the whole they just seem to suck votes from one candidate or another. Sometimes it works for us, other times against us.
NY23 was an oddball race, and in my mind booting Scozzafava WAS a win. I agree with other posters here-getting RINO’s like her OUT of our party is of prime importance. Better to have a Dem win than Scozzafava in place masquerading as a ‘moderate’ Republican to drive the party numbers down even further.At least Owens has the integrity to declare himself a Democrat. I can handle that.
And according to Rasmussen, Democrats outnumber Republicans - obviously because the GOP keeps finding people like Dede to irritate the base. But more importantly, Conservatives outnumber Democrats. We may have lost an oddball election, but the GOP better not kid themselves about where the momentum is.
If Owens is foolish enough to follow Pelosi on Obamacare
treeofliberty Wednesday, November 4th at 12:27AM EST (link)he will not only lose but be CRUSHED Creigh Deeds-like in 2010.
Against a divided Republican vote he still only “won” by some 4000 votes with many thousands of absentee ballots yet to be counted.
If he wants to go ultra left that’s fine: he’s already toast so you might as well stick a fork in him.
Great Analysis!
andysmith Wednesday, November 4th at 12:28AM EST (link)I REALLY wanted Hoffman to win this one, but there’s a silver lining to this one. Aside from your points, he nearly pulled off a win, got the backing of some prominent national conservatives with guts, and established himself to run in 2010 if he wants to.
The silver lining is all for naught, however, if Michael Steele as well as the chairs for the senate and congressional committees for the RNC don’t realize that you can’t run left to win elections. The fact that Dede practically spent a million dollars to endorse the Democrat proves that you can’t trust liberals, even if they have an (R) next to their name. If the GOP leadership doesn’t get this, then we’re screwed for the next three years.
For Hoffman, continue to build on your successful business track record, become a quick study to the national issues, and bring in some big guns to prep for 2010. This mess won’t be fixed by next year, so the gains you made now won’t go unnoticed. You have RedState backing you up!
“Government does not solve problems; it subsidizes them. ”
“Government’s first duty is to protect the people, not run their lives. ”
“Governments tend not to solve problems, only to rearrange them.”
“I have wondered at times what the Ten Commandments would have looked like if Moses had run them through the US Congress.”
-The great Ronald Reagan
http://www.visibleunderground.blogspot.com
And Kudos to You
SSranger Wednesday, November 4th at 12:36AM EST (link)Your’s is also a terrific analysis, Andy.
Ah, if only Reagan were here and we had Pattons in the field . . . .
oh a big ol group hug
seesalrun Wednesday, November 4th at 12:30AM EST (link)to you Red State for all you do, keep off the diversity folks yeah, but great job in keeping us all informed.
Can I hear a “yeah” RED STATE?
Not sure I agree with your analysis, Erick
CodeRedinPA Wednesday, November 4th at 12:32AM EST (link)Just floating this on the air.
One could just as soon add Dede’s share to Owens’ totals and spin it the opposite way since she was a Hail Mary DIABLO meant to appeal to Liberals that would have otherwise voted Democrat.
To my eye: given her politics, I don’t think there is any reliable way to figure which way her voters would break except for Owens.
Either way, we’re going to have to listen to Democrats and liberal pundits try to “help” the GOP back into power by dangling the stupid strategy of being more like them to be relevant again.
…and you can be sure the GOP brain trust will read the outcome here incorrectly
“Look at what it got us in NY-23″ is not as sexy to the so-called brains of the operation as “You know, it might just work in most other districts….”
That stated
CodeRedinPA Wednesday, November 4th at 12:35AM EST (link)I pray to God above that everyone else here is correct and I continue to suck eggs….
EoM
A Minor Contrarian Point Of View:
Swamp_Yankee Wednesday, November 4th at 12:34AM EST (link)I Support Erick
But Look,
NY-23 is a GOP district. On their worst day they went a whopping +5 for Obama. They have not elected a Democrat in something like 50 years. By contrast, middle Maine went +18 for Obama.
This was not a war against moderates. Dede was not a moderate Republican. I dont even think she was a liberal Republican. She was a liberal, period. She’s the type who became a Republican to get get ahead. I know her ilk. Being GOP was the cool thing to do growing up and she wanted to impress, which was allabout being GOP back in those days.
The victory is the voice: I AM BASE HEAR ME ROAR. The victory is not translating this into a ‘RINO’ wipeout. Hoffman couldnt win a GOP district in a GOP seat in a GOP year. Someone, please tell me the strategy for winning Illiinois and Connecticutt seats by running primaries against them.
Under perfect circumstances, NY-23 is a draw. I’m a conservative. And I’m educated. And I’m a New Englander. Those who think- — just preach the gospel of conservatism to them, and they will come are morons.
God bless you all. But the hard work starts at home, in church, in schools, in the arts, in the media and pop culture , Think twice before you can start a revolution against Olympia Snowe. I said it before. use her.
P.S. I’ve bee drinking quite a bit. No work tomorrow. Don’t mind anything I say. It was a wonderful effort, the right move in a chess game, but some are using the Hoffman teffort for utter ridiculousmess.
Not Dead Yet!
Extremely well put
warkarma Wednesday, November 4th at 1:32AM EST (link)Of all the races tonight, IMO this one mattered the most, and it’s the biggest upset. That seat’s been Republican for decades. The same goes here in the Pacific Northwest, where I live. For Washington being a blue state, there are conservative districts, but the conservative message has to be delivered differently in order to resonate.
Remember Chris Gregoire vs. Dino Rossi last year? He refused to use the term Republican throughout his campaign, and addressed (very well at that) issues that matter to Northwesteners: environment, quality of life, and yes, taxes. He didn’t win, but the race was extremely close (within 1% if I recall).
Minor correction
warkarma Wednesday, November 4th at 1:34AM EST (link)Wikipedia lists Chris Gregoire’s margin of victory as 53% to 47%. However, I swear I remember local news outlets calling 51 to 49. I could be mistake.
Count me a moron...
mschmitt Wednesday, November 4th at 7:36AM EST (link)“Those who think — just preach the gospel of conservatism to them, and they will come are morons.”
Not even the most vapid minded liberal consciously chooses their own enslavement into tyranny. That they seem to do so willingly is only proof of their lack of understanding of conservatism and the motives of certain elected leaders.
Defeat the RINOs. Just as the (modern) Democrat politician, the RINO views you as mere cattle. In my opinion, it is time to recognize that the RINO is much more dangerous to your liberty than any Pelosi Democrat; because THEY are cunning enough to recognize that a starved calf dies uselessly in the field, but the herd which is fed will continue marching without resistance to their own slaughter.
I choose freedom for myself and my family. For those who do likewise, it is imperative that they educate-educate-educate people on conservatism.
It is equally imperative to reject any politician which chooses to “moderate” in matters of YOUR LIBERTY.
another way of saying it mschmitt is this
kyle8 Wednesday, November 4th at 7:51AM EST (link)We have the more left wing Democrat party of all time in power now. In order to win we have to present a true alternative.
If we do so, and if there are clear differences in the party, and if we hammer our message of individual rights and free markets we WILL win, if, for no other reason that we know that liberalism will fail.
But every time the waters are muddied, every time there is no clear difference in the parties, every time a Big government Republican gains power, then we start losing, and we lose big time.
“Nothing works like freedom, Nothing succeeds like liberty”
Kyle
Swamp Yankee- I picked up one sentence
Scope Wednesday, November 4th at 10:35AM EST (link)from your post to highlight-
(Scozzafava) was not just a Liberal Republican, she was a Liberal period. She’s the type who became a Republican, just to get ahead.
In other words, she is a McCain Republican. Didn’t he decide to run as a Republican back all those years ago, because it was the only way to win in AZ., and to get ahead. He is not a Liberal Republican, he is a Liberal period.
Swamp Yankee- I picked up one sentence
Scope Wednesday, November 4th at 10:35AM EST (link)from your post to highlight-
(Scozzafava) was not just a Liberal Republican, she was a Liberal period. She’s the type who became a Republican, just to get ahead.
In other words, she is a McCain Republican. Didn’t he decide to run as a Republican back all those years ago, because it was the only way to win in AZ., and to get ahead. He is not a Liberal Republican, he is a Liberal period.
Amazing
vamoose Wednesday, November 4th at 12:36AM EST (link)The Owens win is another vote for Pelosi/Obama and their leftist agenda. I find it amazing that Obama knows the value of one representative but doesn’t know the value of $1 trillion dollars. One more vote in the house is precious, but $1 trillion dollars blown on a phony stimulus is no big thing.
vamoose- As said above
Scope Wednesday, November 4th at 10:44AM EST (link)and I totally agree, one more “extra” vote for Pelosi is no big deal. She already has an overwhelming majority who can pass anything she wants to pass. And, I understand that Owens is against the public option which Pelosi promised will be in her healthcare legislation.
This was a true victory for conservatism. No one ever heard of the citizen, accountant, Doug Hoffman one month ago, yet with the help of Conservatives like Fred Thompson and Sarah Palin and many others, he was only beat by 3% or 4,000 votes. He was beat by a small margin, even though the establishment Republicans funded a Liberal Republican, and, she endorsed and worked for the Democrat. The endorsement part was a welcome slap in the face to those elie R’s, that want to be just like the Democrats when they grow up.
Hoffman just conceded; any news on CA-10? nt
ColdWarrior Wednesday, November 4th at 12:37AM EST (link)nt
American first, conservative second and Republican precinct committeeman by necessity.
http://www.theprecinctproject.wordpress.com, so you can say, “I became a precinct committeeman before it was cool.”
“Elections have consequences, my friends.” — John McCain
Sorry, Erick, I think you missed the mark.
Paul Seale Wednesday, November 4th at 12:40AM EST (link)Erick,
This was a win for Pelosi plain and simple.
Yes, we were able to rally - but to what end?
While I think we all know Scozzafava would have been a vote for Pelosi - Rush put it best.. third party stuff like this ensures Democrat majority for years to come.
The problem, in a nut shell, is that the GOP leadership failed to pick the right candidate instead of running a primary. Still, even at that, Scozzafava probably would have lost and endorsed the Democrat.
Im not sure where this really leaves us - except tackling the problem of Scozzafavas and Jeffords present to us. These are people who are bitter losers and are without principle - who only seek what is in their best interest.
Any guesses on what Scozzafava’s new Czar post will be?
Where it leaves us? Better off!
illinoisconservative Wednesday, November 4th at 7:01AM EST (link)This couldn’t have happened at a better time. We are one year away from what may be one of the most important elections in our history. We can take back Congress next year and stifle Obama’s plans for his last 2 years. But we can only do that if we are united.
This loss, while disappointing, is sobering. But it is worth one seat in an off year election if it shows how utterly futile third party runs for office will be. At the same time it show the GOP that conservatives will not allow liberals to run under the name of the Republican party.
The GOP has hopefully learned that to get the base excited, they need to run candidates that are real conservatives. We can still perhaps argue what a real conservative is, but if we take nothing else from tonight, let’s take the lesson that in VA and NJ attacking Dems on fiscal responsibility, taxes and spending beyond our means has worked.. and, at least in the case of VA, that message has drawn in Independent voters as well.
Erick - Congratulations on your success with this!
Read Chesterton in New Improved Jersey Wednesday, November 4th at 12:41AM EST (link)I hope the light you have shed on the problem of GOP endorsed liberals is taken to heart by the party at all levels.
Please forgive my presuming on you this way, but may I make a polite suggestion regarding the overuse of the term “And make no mistake” in your editorial work? It comes across as a finger wagging, much in the way that CAPS come across as yelling. When I get caught using it, my reviewers send it back with the word “hackneyed” scrawled across it. Your phraseology is always clear enough and strong enough to stand on its own without that flag in front of your salient points.
Oh, and thanks for RedState!
“Nature is not our mother: Nature is our sister. We can be proud of her beauty, since we have the same father; but she has no authority over us; we have to admire, but not to imitate.” - G. K. Chesterton, “Orthodoxy,” Chapter VIII.
There is no time to form a third party, anyway
Dave Wednesday, November 4th at 12:47AM EST (link)By the time it would become viable to any real degree, we would be a banana republic, and would be learning the words to a certain Harry Bellefonte song as our new national anthem.
-Dave
Our elected representatives have failed us.
Tuesday November 2, 2010 is 52 weeks away
Finrod Wednesday, November 4th at 12:49AM EST (link)NY-23, along with every other House seat, will be up for re-election that day.
—
Finrod’s First Law of Bandwidth:
A picture may be worth a thousand words, but it takes the bandwidth of ten thousand.
Isn't this an indication that early ballots and unnecessary
Flagstaff Wednesday, November 4th at 12:49AM EST (link)absentee ballots should not by so “liberally” distributed?
How many of the votes for Scozzy would have been pulled back if they hadn’t already been dropped in the mailbox as a vote for the “Republican”? How many of those were cast by people who thought that they were casting a Republican party vote with their votes for Scozzy?
Your analysis was exactly right, Erick. We are no worse off with Owens winning than we would have been had Scozzy won. The lesson is obvious that had the conservative Republican been put up in the first place, he would have won (given the same support from the big conservative names). Those big names better be ready next year to provide similar support for less accomplished conservative Republican candidates.
Finally, how did the results vary so far from that final poll? Is there something fishy going on? Was that poll released to hold down conservative turnout?
Pluto, the Ninth Planet - Forever!
To recap that Siena Research Inst. 11/01/09 poll:
Flagstaff Wednesday, November 4th at 1:00AM EST (link)Hoffman 41%
Owens 36%
Undecided 18%
Total 95%
606 likely voters, MOE+/- 4%
Any Democrat would contest it if he lost after seeing those results. Hoffman should be very careful before he gives up for good. BTW, Scozzy got the missing 5% of the vote, apparently.
Pluto, the Ninth Planet - Forever!
Or, Hoffman peaked two days too soon. nt
Flagstaff Wednesday, November 4th at 1:03AM EST (link)Pluto, the Ninth Planet - Forever!
Late deciders went to Owens
Flagstaff Friday, November 6th at 11:05PM EST (link)by 2.6 to 1 over Hoffman. That’s troubling and it must be corrected. That’s what put Owens over the top.
Pluto, the Ninth Planet - Forever!
NY-23
OccamsRazor Wednesday, November 4th at 1:17AM EST (link)Was our party’s trial balloon. We know where we stand.
After today, the GOP better play ball, because all of America is swingin’ for the fences.
It's also a win for conservatives because we
ZeusKingoftheGods Wednesday, November 4th at 1:56AM EST (link)made sure that the least liberal of two liberals won least liberal of Scozzafava & Owens won. Just imagine how horrible tonight would feel if the far-left liberal Scozzafava would have been able to hang on & win.
I really can imagine her mounting a Primary campaign against Owens next year saying that he’s not liberal enough for Democrats.
A DEDE WIN WOULD HAVE BEEN FAR WORSE THAN AN OWENS WIN!
It’s possible that the liberal label didn’t stick on him as well since he wasn’t even a registered Democrat & since she was registered as a seething RINO.
We can't have our cake...
The Grognard Wednesday, November 4th at 1:57AM EST (link)…and eat it too.
On the one hand, we lost a very solid Republican district by backing a third party candidate (Hoffman) rather than the Republican candidate (Scozzafava). On the other hand, a message has been sent to the GOP leadership, both locally and nationally; namely, don’t run ultra-liberals as Repulicans. It is this messge I believe the base has been trying to shout from the rooftops since the losses in 2006.
Some may decry the support given an independent or third party candidate, as happened here with Hoffman, just as many have been angry about GOP voters staying home in 2006 and 2008.
But how else does the base get across to those in power within the party that they don’t like the candidates that are being put up, or the direction that the party is taking?
People are going to vote their conscience, or they are going to stay home, its that simple. If the GOP goes off the rails, and does not support its own platform (at least nominally) in each race, then the GOP is going to keep losing. Republican voters were saying this in the run up to 2006, and the party did not listen. GOP voters were saying this in the run up to 2008, and the GOP did not listen.
The question is, do they hear us now?
How else do we send a message to the GOP country club that we want the party to tack back to the right, other than refusing to support their candidates, keeping back our donations, and voting for someone other than the GOP candidate? I’d rather lose voting for a real Republican than win with a Scozzafava.
Sometimes we have to lose in the short term to win in the long term.
That doesn’t mean that every candidate has to be perfectly conservative, with a 100% ACU rating. But they need to be at least conservative in some things. Don’t we have a party platform for a reason? To work with candidates that agree with at least some of the platform? Or is it all lip service.
Scozzafava was not conservative in any way. She was a leftist to the left of the Democrat she was supposed to be running against, and the GOP establishment tried to push her onto the voters of NY 23. And what happened? The GOP lost.
We can’t have our cake and eat it too. If we want to send the message that a particular GOP candidate is no good, or that the direction of the party is headed the wrong way, then we need to take our lumps and lose sometimes to get the message across.
NY 23 was a good hill to die on. It was a special election that we can easily win next year if we run even a half-way decent candidate. If we’d all gotten in line here and voted for Scozzafava, then we’d have a REPUBLICAN voting for Cap and Trade, Obamacare, Card check, and everything else the Dems are trying to Rahm through. Let Owens take the heat for voting for that crap.
We can't have our cake...
The Grognard Wednesday, November 4th at 1:57AM EST (link)…and eat it too.
On the one hand, we lost a very solid Republican district by backing a third party candidate (Hoffman) rather than the Republican candidate (Scozzafava). On the other hand, a message has been sent to the GOP leadership, both locally and nationally; namely, don’t run ultra-liberals as Repulicans. It is this messge I believe the base has been trying to shout from the rooftops since the losses in 2006.
Some may decry the support given an independent or third party candidate, as happened here with Hoffman, just as many have been angry about GOP voters staying home in 2006 and 2008.
But how else does the base get across to those in power within the party that they don’t like the candidates that are being put up, or the direction that the party is taking?
People are going to vote their conscience, or they are going to stay home, its that simple. If the GOP goes off the rails, and does not support its own platform (at least nominally) in each race, then the GOP is going to keep losing. Republican voters were saying this in the run up to 2006, and the party did not listen. GOP voters were saying this in the run up to 2008, and the GOP did not listen.
The question is, do they hear us now?
How else do we send a message to the GOP country club that we want the party to tack back to the right, other than refusing to support their candidates, keeping back our donations, and voting for someone other than the GOP candidate? I’d rather lose voting for a real Republican than win with a Scozzafava.
Sometimes we have to lose in the short term to win in the long term.
That doesn’t mean that every candidate has to be perfectly conservative, with a 100% ACU rating. But they need to be at least conservative in some things. Don’t we have a party platform for a reason? To work with candidates that agree with at least some of the platform? Or is it all lip service.
Scozzafava was not conservative in any way. She was a leftist to the left of the Democrat she was supposed to be running against, and the GOP establishment tried to push her onto the voters of NY 23. And what happened? The GOP lost.
We can’t have our cake and eat it too. If we want to send the message that a particular GOP candidate is no good, or that the direction of the party is headed the wrong way, then we need to take our lumps and lose sometimes to get the message across.
NY 23 was a good hill to die on. It was a special election that we can easily win next year if we run even a half-way decent candidate. If we’d all gotten in line here and voted for Scozzafava, then we’d have a REPUBLICAN voting for Cap and Trade, Obamacare, Card check, and everything else the Dems are trying to Rahm through. Let Owens take the heat for voting for that crap.
Checking In On the Fringe
comic65 Wednesday, November 4th at 1:58AM EST (link)Just thought I’d see how the election was being spun on this extremist site. Congratulations on the big victories this evening … undeniable progress for a party in the middle of civil war.
Not all of us Dems are happy with all of the gov’t spending, but heck, it was the policies of Bush (and every Prez since Carter) that got us to this crappy point … and I’d rather gov’t spending go to internal spending as opposed to funding a war on a country that didn’t attack us, a glutonous military and tax breaks for the wealthy and corps. Furthermore, the simple answers to complex problems the Far Right offers are just TIRED!
And as long as the Far Right continues to have conservative social policy litmus tests for all of your candidates, you’ll never get the support of moderate Dems, like me, that would like to see more fiscal responsibility. Like it or not, the country is governed from the middle, not the extremes.
Hmmmmm … will this comment be posted, or will it disappear as so many of my comments at this site do.
Late Night?
ZeusKingoftheGods Wednesday, November 4th at 2:16AM EST (link)I wouldn’t be able to sleep either if I was a lib & faced the smackdown that libs did tonight.
Sorry Douche
Leopard1996 Wednesday, November 4th at 4:48AM EST (link)Let me educate you like I educated another POS earlier tonight.
Dede was not conservative or even republican at all except she has an R after her name.
1. She supports card check which would kill any type of employment in this country when a company being faced with forced unionization to pay non-market labor rates or send their jobs elsewhere what are they going to do? Those jobs are gone, and there aren’t enough windmill jobs to replace them, and even those jobs would probably go to Mexico after a short while thanks to forced unionization.
2. She supported the Stimulus, which as we can see has done nothing but push any econ growth from the fourth quarter into the 3rd, and when the end of year numbers come in, we are going to be in the same garbage we were in before 3rd quarter
3. She was a huge proponent of Cap and Trade, climate bill garbage which would have been a job killer for this country.
Add that to the social issues, she would have only succeeded in giving bi-partisan cover for the failed solutions that you and your folks tend to propose.
“The accumluated filth of all their sex and murder will foam up about their waists and all the whores and politicians will look up and shout, “Save Us!”….and I’ll look down and whisper, “No”…The Watchmen
That's remarkably good one-handed typing.
Achance Wednesday, November 4th at 4:58AM EST (link)Does your mother know what you’re doing in front of that keyboard late at night?
In Vino Veritas
LOL,
Leopard1996 Wednesday, November 4th at 5:02AM EST (link)Isn’t this one of the things you warned me about. THat was awesome.
“The accumluated filth of all their sex and murder will foam up about their waists and all the whores and politicians will look up and shout, “Save Us!”….and I’ll look down and whisper, “No”…The Watchmen
Read Frank Rich, much?
aesthete Wednesday, November 4th at 10:56AM EST (link)“as long as the Far Right continues to have conservative social policy litmus tests”
Do they go to a central depot for their talking points, or are they mailed to their doorsteps? Inquiring minds and all that jazz…
Guilt is a rope that wears thin.
-Ayn Rand
“I am a freeman in a free state!”
-Last words of Dumnorix, chieftan of the Aedui, 54 BC
In a way, I'm not sure Hoffman wanted to win...
Eddie S Wednesday, November 4th at 2:02AM EST (link)In all the analysis of Hoffman’s campaign, I have yet to see anyone make note of the fact that the man was inarticulate at best, and painfully awkward in public if we are to be brutally honest. The fact that he garnered so much of the vote is a testament to his positions and the mood of the district, because I cannot seriously think that anyone saw him in action and thought “wow, that’s the guy I want in Congress.”
I’m not sure he really wanted to win the race, or expected to be a real contender when he started this. He seemed awfully eager to concede this evening as soon as he could.
If only the Republicans in New York hadn’t played such stupid games with their choice for the election, there’d be another Republican representative in the House. They lost this through their own high-handedness.
You are way off
Hooah_Mac Wednesday, November 4th at 2:04AM EST (link)I’ll post more in my post-mortem tomorrow, but if you had been here and met the guy you would see it differently.
“You can call yourself a Republican, but if you’ve lost the support of Fred Thompson, you are an unholy thing that will be destroyed by a rain of fire.” -IMAO
That could be...
Eddie S Wednesday, November 4th at 10:47AM EST (link)You might be right, I could be “way off.” Not being local to the race, I can only base my observations on videos of the candidate.
I also disagree with your assessment..
ZeusKingoftheGods Wednesday, November 4th at 2:19AM EST (link)… of course he wanted to win. He had the perfect storm of events against him in that last weekend with everything that Scozzafava, the RINO beastophile did. She was a Dem plant, planted by the Republican Party establishment.
My Guess Is That the adminstration
OccamsRazor Wednesday, November 4th at 2:52AM EST (link)took serious aim at what we we’re doing here. They used slight of hand thuggery to defeat Hoffmann, and took their eye off the medium sized prizes, which’ll hurt them in the bigger picture-a referendum.
The goal posts just moved right today based off of our battle plan, blueprinted over the past 8 months.
Look at the bright side...
harlan Wednesday, November 4th at 2:59AM EST (link)…for the folks of NY 23, Bill Owens will be a more conservative representative than the faux republican would have been.
Dede was a horrendous selection for the RNC. ptooey!
Just awful. The republican hubris involved in that choice is just stunning.
Kudos to Doug Hoffman for going the distance for the real home team.
Newt can kiss it. Fie on his beltways.
Win the War
Whitehorse Wednesday, November 4th at 3:32AM EST (link)I see NY-23 as a battle lost, but far more damage to the supposed “winners.” This shows the “establishment” that, as many have said, we aren’t going to stand for bad candidates - & Scozzafava was the worst Republican candidate I’ve seen be taken seriously. For praticality, Republican leadership should see that running candidates vulnerable to challenge from the right is dangerous. One would think the Dems who won in 2006 running as conservative would have awakened them?
NY-23 also shows that a solid ground game is essential, especially juxtaposed to Virginia.
I also agree that FL is the next stop, & we have the chance to do it right - win in the primary.
To BO: Guess What? WE WON TODAY.
OccamsRazor Wednesday, November 4th at 4:58AM EST (link)And WE (The American PEOPLE) are going to ALL countrywide amusingly chuckle at Gibbs’ retort in a few hours.
Retracted Here -nt
OccamsRazor Wednesday, November 4th at 5:02AM EST (link)On My Own Terms.
Owens is a Blue Dog
nunleigh Wednesday, November 4th at 5:50AM EST (link)Bill Owens is a military man and has always been an Independent. Chances are he will vote more conservative than Scozzafava would have. He is a “Blue Dog” Democrat, and If he wants to keep his “lucky” win in a Republican NY district, he will have to vote accordingly. If not Hoffman, I say we are lucky to have Owens and not Scozzafava. That being said, Newt Gingrich has completely lost my respect with all of his last minute campaigning and justification for Scozzafava, and from what I am reading on the blogs, I am not alone. I hope someone will let him know he need not bother spending any time or money on himself in 2012.
Military Doesn't Necessarily Make the Man, but ...
SSranger Wednesday, November 4th at 11:06AM EST (link). . . There may be hope in Owens. My estimation of Gingrich (and RNC Chairman Steele) dropped like a grenade. Neither would get my vote if they ran for dog catcher.
Their shifty endorsement—pushing—of ringer Republican Scozzafava, who exited the race, then announced support for the opposing Democrat, tells me all I need to know about their real brand of politics.
Just as I knew fellow soldier Colin Powell was a ringer Republican the instant he got down and boogied at a party of fellow OBAMA supporters. And sure as hell, the good general from the Bronx wouldn’t get my vote. Leftists entrenched throughout the American polity aren’t the only practitioners of political smoke and mirrors.
We lost...
martellus Wednesday, November 4th at 5:59AM EST (link)The Republicans lost tonight in NY 23. Try to understand this it is the first rule of politics in Congressional elections.
The first vote that a member of the House or the Senate casts is for the Speaker of the House or the Majority Leader. There are many who argue that it is the most critical vote they cast.
Bill Owens will vote for Nancy Pelosi. We lost.
Oh yes for all of those people who trashed Newt Gingrich he has done more for Republicans and conservatives then anyone posting on this blog.
The Hammer
Newt Did NOT Do His Homework on Manchurian Scozzafava
Ausonius Wednesday, November 4th at 6:31AM EST (link)He and other Republicans, who blindly endorsed proven Dem-Manchurian Candidate ScuzzyBaby, lost the election for a Conservative.
Bill Owens will vote for Pelosi, and ScuzzyBaby e n d o r s e d him!!!
Basic Mathematics at work! We suspect Hoffman would not have voted for Pelosi or the Dem agenda: the evidence demonstrates that ScuzzyBaby would have caved to the Dems.
As a result, your first sentence needs some rethinking.
No rethinking...
martellus Wednesday, November 4th at 6:49AM EST (link)Bill Owens will vote for Nancy Pelosi. He is a big time pro union democrat.
We are now one vote further away from taking the majority in the House. The first vote any member takes is for their leader.
The Hammer
So you're already conceding the 2010 race to Owens?
6eorge Jetson Wednesday, November 4th at 8:18AM EST (link)nt
Hold off on that Mammogram for 10 years
Dede is a big time pro union activist- the vote would have been the same
archer52 Wednesday, November 4th at 8:25AM EST (link)You saw her character. THAT is what you should take away from this experience.
I wonder if she was a stealth democrat…
I'd rather be opposing a French legion than
The_Gadfly Wednesday, November 4th at 8:50AM EST (link)having one responsible for defending my flank.
We’ve been called racists enough now that it shouldn’t bother us any more.
-AChance, http://www.redstate.com/moe_lane/2009/11/03/what-men-may-do-we-have-done/#comment-24463
If NY23 was a beat down for Conservatives, what do you call what happened to Progressives in NJ and VA?
inspired by ColdWarrior, http://www.redstate.com/hooah_mac/2009/11/04/ny-23-the-agony-of-defeat-not-so-much/#comment-156
Newt is done
treeofliberty Wednesday, November 4th at 6:49AM EST (link)He should realize he has no chance of winning the GOP nomination in ‘12, none!
I get a bit annoyed when Hannity, who seems to have him on his show every other day, gives him a pass on this but Hannity always striked me as more of a cheerleader for the GOP than a conservative warrior like Mark Levin or Rush.
treeofliberty- Stop watching the idiot Hannity
Scope Wednesday, November 4th at 11:02AM EST (link)He obviously has Newt and McCain on contract as his regulars. He time and again shouts that he is a Reagan Conservative, yet he hugs the worst RINO’s the Republicans have ever seen. Problem is, Hannity doesn’t have the intelligence to talk his way out of a hat, and the RINO’s know that. Not many credible Republicans go on his show.
treeofliberty- Stop watching the idiot Hannity
Scope Wednesday, November 4th at 11:02AM EST (link)He obviously has Newt and McCain on contract as his regulars. He time and again shouts that he is a Reagan Conservative, yet he hugs the worst RINO’s the Republicans have ever seen. Problem is, Hannity doesn’t have the intelligence to talk his way out of a hat, and the RINO’s know that. Not many credible Republicans go on his show.
Hannity's a hypocrite
aesthete Wednesday, November 4th at 11:09AM EST (link)He rails against Obama’s spending after having praised GOP spending over the past 8 years. I have no idea how he’s still considered conservative.
Guilt is a rope that wears thin.
-Ayn Rand
“I am a freeman in a free state!”
-Last words of Dumnorix, chieftan of the Aedui, 54 BC
aesthete- And, how is Hannity still rated 3rd
Scope Wednesday, November 4th at 11:27AM EST (link)with his radio and tv shows? It seems that he appeals to the moderates, and, the not very bright.
Hannity rated 3rd is something I'll never understand...
treeofliberty Wednesday, November 4th at 11:25PM EST (link)How Mark Levin is not 2nd only to MAYBE Rush is astonishing to me…
If Newt is "done", then
Jackal4444 Wednesday, November 4th at 10:01PM EST (link)the GOP will the the poorer for it — we will have lost one of the most insightful and effective conservative advocates on the last 30 years. As Martellus said, “Newt Gingrich…has done more for Republicans and conservatives then anyone posting on this blog.”
YOU LOST
kyle8 Wednesday, November 4th at 7:04AM EST (link)we, meaning conservatives, won. Now it might be a pyrric victory, but that is just the way things are, we have to first defeat the fellow travelers in our own party and take it back before we can even pretend to do anything against democrats.
Personally, I would prefer that the republican party dissolve in chaos and anarchy and we start all over before we elect one more left winger who calls themselves a republican.
How can you ever win a war when the enemy is among you?
“Nothing works like freedom, Nothing succeeds like liberty”
Kyle
Not exactly...
mschmitt Wednesday, November 4th at 8:08AM EST (link)The Republicans didn’t have numbers regardless of what happened in the off-year elections. Let’s talk about this again in 2010.
… And Newt was my guy in ‘94; he’s been a champ through the years, but Newt is out for Newt right now. He is the one re-branding himself; not us.
Bill Owens won't get a chance to vote for Pelosi...
Neil Stevens Wednesday, November 4th at 8:49AM EST (link)…If Republicans unite and beat him next year.
We’ll see what you Scozzafava Republicrats do.
Want to run for conservatives? Give.
There Is No Crisis
No one will have to vote for Pelosi
Scope Wednesday, November 4th at 11:06AM EST (link)as Speaker in 2010, because she will be back in the minority party. We just need to choose the new R Speaker more wisely than those that believe they are up next right now.
the lesson here
hoosierdad Wednesday, November 4th at 6:00AM EST (link)I think the lesson for the GOP is that when you support RINO’s, you end up benefitting the Democrats no matter the election result. I am angry about the $900,000 the Republican Party poured into electing a Democrat.
Unfortunately, that's not the lesson the NRCC will take
nycenterright Wednesday, November 4th at 8:43AM EST (link)Just as every time someone here suggests running a moderate someone inevitably replies “Why, because it worked so well with McCain?” the NRCC is probably going to use this result as a club against Rubio and other Conservatives. Comparisons to Hoffman will abound.
WE said this at the start TWO weeks ago!...
JadedByPolitics Wednesday, November 4th at 6:18AM EST (link)Redstate brought Hoffman to the forefront TWO weeks ago and for that short a period of time it was a tsunami
WE have everything to be PROUD of in this election and the GOP has everything to be AFRAID of! I have always said they can work with us or they can work against us but they CANNOT have it both ways!
I will note that BOTH Governors in VA and NJ made acceptance speeches outlining PERSONAL RESPONSIBILITY!!! They DID NOT talk about BIGGER government EVER!!!
GOP run people who will CUT spending and taxes and GOVERNMENT and you have a winning formula ANYTHING else is a loss!
Whoever has his enemy at his mercy &
does not destroy him is his own enemy
Marco Rubio 2010
nunleigh Wednesday, November 4th at 6:54AM EST (link)I just email my Texas Senator, John Cornyn, and told him to support Florida’s Marco Rubio for the Senate now, and forget about Charlie Crist. Everyone needs to be looking at Marco. This guy is smart, conservative, and awesome. He has my money and support. Presidential? I think so! Check him out!
http://www.marcorubio.com/
http://www.CharlieAndObama.com
I feel sorry for the people
becolt Wednesday, November 4th at 7:30AM EST (link)who voted on absentee ballots for Scuzzy before she dropped out of the race. Seriously. These people thought they were voting for someone who would at the very least be IN the race, and I bet most of them would’ve been voting for the conservative had they know it was a two man race.
What of the Military ballots? There were 10,000 or so of them. Counted?
I saw last night there were also questions of ACORN style fraud, any news on that?
That election was simply a mess.
clement Wednesday, November 4th at 8:39AM EST (link)The way I see it
Scozzafava still in the race = Hoffman win with a slight plurality (looks like a good chunk of her vote went Owens)
Hoffman running on the Republican line = Hoffman win. I just can’t see many of her votes getting cast for HER after all this, those votes had to be people just voting party line.
I am pissed at the RNCC for this, someone in leadership needs to take the blame, heads need to roll.
Absolutely.
becolt Wednesday, November 4th at 8:47AM EST (link)I think the RNC etc have pretty much been infiltrated, its a tactic that works for the libs–who look at politics as an actual war.
I wonder how many polling stations put up a sign that Dede was no longer running…
No third party because....?
offendedman Wednesday, November 4th at 8:45AM EST (link)Erick, what makes you say third parties aren’t viable? Hoffman went from unknown to within 5 points of a win in 30 days. Had he been in from the start, he might very well have won.
Without at least the THREAT of a third party, the GOP will just roll its fat, squishy self over and scream “SERVICE ME WITH YOUR DOLLARS AGAIN, YOU HELPLESS PROLES! YOU HAVE NOWHERE ELSE TO GO!”
Not a pretty thought.
Alternatively, maybe it’s time to put the GOP out of its misery entirely, and start over with the Conservative party. That would keep us at two parties.
Stop right there, offendedman
Neil Stevens Wednesday, November 4th at 8:47AM EST (link)There was no primary in NY-23. It was a special, one-off case.
If you want to go on a crusade against the Republican party, you are not going to use this site to do it. Your account will be disabled if you try.
Mgmt.
Want to run for conservatives? Give.
There Is No Crisis
Imagery
proudgop Wednesday, November 4th at 9:07AM EST (link)I am a New Yorker and this just pains me to no end; seeing the entire state now has just 2 congress Republicans in entire delegation.
First, please have primaries in future and let chips fall where they will and then please unity people.
Second, Imagery. We have let the media and the Dems to degree make it seem like if you support abortion or gay marriage ( for example) you aren’t welcomed in the party. We need to fight against this. If this was the case people like me wouldn’t be fighting for this party.
Third, I refuse to give up in places like NY. Republicans can win we have some great opportunities of taking some congress seats back. Will they be deemed socially liberal by some you? yes but thats just where NY is at this time
NY Republicans did get some wins in parts of state yesterday. We won some major races, picked up county races, heck even in NYC Republicans won some Republican wins on city council. The party is not dead here but in many parts they do not need to run a very different campaign then many republicans do in other states
I am disappointed by this loss I don’t want such turmoil and the media to portray the party and all its wings fighting each other.
What's weird to me is that majorities are not required
bk Wednesday, November 4th at 9:32AM EST (link)People used to make fun of Louisiana’s “jungle” primaries, but in the end someone needed to win a majority in a runoff. Yesterday we saw all these races where in theory you could win with 34% of the vote.
We generally never require a majority
Neil Stevens Wednesday, November 4th at 9:38AM EST (link)It only looks that way when the only candidates getting votes are a Democrat and a Republican.
The reason Louisiana’s jungle primaries are bad in a two-party environment is that it lets people who aren’t a member of a party run on that line, then it lets people who aren’t members of a party vote such a person into the general.
The jungle primary only made sense in the one party environment the state had for a long, long time.
Want to run for conservatives? Give.
There Is No Crisis
Do you usually have runoffs for primary elections
bk Wednesday, November 4th at 9:54AM EST (link)or just do it based on a plurality as well? If there are primary runoffs, it seems the same logic should apply at the general election level.
Usually no runoffs in partisan elections
Neil Stevens Wednesday, November 4th at 9:57AM EST (link)I generally only see runoffs in non-partisan elections, but in those cases there are no primaries.
Want to run for conservatives? Give.
There Is No Crisis
A more civilized comment
offendedman Wednesday, November 4th at 12:20PM EST (link)Neil-
First, it wasn’t my intention to attack the GOP per se, nor did I realize that was an explicit “no-no” on this site. (I’ll make a note of that for future posts.)
Let me dial down the rhetoric and try again:
Alexander Hamilton said “Those who stand for nothing fall for anything.” I believe this is the terrible mistake the GOP is making right now, and has been making for years, in fact. They are “standing for nothing” by moving to the center and adopting a bland, pablum-flavored position they think will appeal to more people but actually gets them less votes. We saw that clearly, I think, in NY-23.
By abandoning their conservative principles and nominating “centrists” in an attempt to appeal to more voters they actually appeal to fewer and fewer voters every time.
Liberals don’t vote for their “centrist” candidates because they (liberals) are mostly Democrats and, given a choice between “Democrat Lite”, aka Republican, and “Democrat” most will, unsurprisingly, take the “Democrat”.
Conservatives don’t vote for them because, well, why should they? Why should they vote for a candidate who is anathema to many of their beliefs? Why not stay home?
It seems to me that by nominating candidates who have no conservative positions, no conservative views, and in some cases (like McCain on immigration and Scozzafava on card check) are actually hostile to the conservative viewpoint, the GOP is shooting itself in the foot.
People who demand that we stand by the GOP, no matter what, are “enabling” this behavior, not correcting it. By being so strongly against third parties or even the threat of a third party, you send the message that it’s OK to go to the center, the left, up, down, “whatever, GOP - We still love you!”
I have two problems with this: 1) as I pointed out, it reinforces the “bad behavior” of abandoning principle and running to the center to try and get votes. 2) It isn’t working. I would be a lot more tolerant of this if the GOP was sweeping the country, but it’s not. Conservatism, tea-party style, is sweeping the country, and the GOP seems to be stiff-arming it instead of embracing it. Rejecting your own base is a sure way to commit ballot-box suicide.
I hope to see the GOP pull out of this “suicide spiral” and become the party of fiscal and moral conservatism again. But if it continues the way it is, I have no intention of “going down with the ship.” I have no inherent animus to the GOP, but my loyalty is to the USA. And my interest is in preserving the future of my country, not any particular party.
I hope I have communicated my views more effectively and with less rancor.
Nice try
Neil Stevens Wednesday, November 4th at 12:27PM EST (link)But I’m serious: If you’re going to advocate in the future people leaving the GOP in general elections as a general rule, for punishing the party or any other reason, you’re going to get banned.
If you don’t like it, go post somewhere else.
Want to run for conservatives? Give.
There Is No Crisis
I love this site, but this is some serious spin...
Hoosier Economist Wednesday, November 4th at 9:22AM EST (link)Come on now…”conservatives win”? What exactly did conservatives win with the NY-23 results - another Democrat seat in congress?
Was it a good thing that the moderate was chucked in lieu of a conservative? Absolutely. Was it a good thing that ANOTHER Democrat joins what will now be a parade (coerced or not) to vote for the Democrat bill in the House (regardless of support for the public option)? Absolutely NOT.
I love the spirit, but let’s not call an apple an orange. Conservatives won two HUGE governors seats last night, but NY-23 hurts - especially with votes on health care just around the corner.
If we spun this as much as the left is spinning
bk Wednesday, November 4th at 9:29AM EST (link)we’d be saying that NY-23 was good news for the GOP because the R-endorsed candidate won.
Here's my spin
Anteater Wednesday, November 4th at 9:44AM EST (link)We won the major contests and lost two house seats that we can compete for again next year.
It is a blessing in disguise that we didn’t make a clean sweep last night! Hopefully it will lull House Dems into thinking that they are still alright and that they can still win in 2010. We don’t want them making any major adjustments.
Another blessing in disguise is that the third-party pandora’s box was not opened last night. Now Hoffman can run as a Republican in 2010.
Another possible (legit) spin in our favor
bk Wednesday, November 4th at 9:59AM EST (link)is that at least in VA if not in NJ, the results last night will help with upcoming redistricting, and that is a potential benefit for 10 years.
I don't think this is a good morning for either side...
Hoosier Economist Wednesday, November 4th at 9:45AM EST (link)It’s terrific to take the NJ and VA governor seats, but it’s NEVER a “win” to lose a seat in congress to the opposition party.
Open your eyes Hoosier, even if she won it would have been a victory for the opposition party. nt
nessa Wednesday, November 4th at 9:55AM EST (link)“If you love wealth more than liberty, the tranquility of servitude better than the animating contest of freedom, depart from us in peace. We ask not your counsel nor your arms. Crouch down and lick the hand that feeds you. May your chains rest lightly upon you and may posterity forget that you were our countrymen.”—Samuel Adams
Contributor to The Minority Report
But losing the NY-23 seat under these weird circumstances
bk Wednesday, November 4th at 9:57AM EST (link)would seem to be more than offset by the fear it could strike into the hearts of some blue dogs.
That's what I'm thinking, too, bk. I have a Blue Dog
janis Wednesday, November 4th at 10:09AM EST (link)as my own rep and I’m hoping that he, along with all the others, is having a very bad morning after a very bad night. Mine is Bart Gordon, Sixth District in Tennessee. Let’s see how fast he wants to vote “Yes” on the health care thing and cap and tax when he represents a conservative district.
In the clear cold light of day this morning, the Blue Dogs are looking more like dead dogs.
Nope!
scubadiver49er Wednesday, November 4th at 12:08PM EST (link)If the “R-endorsed” candidate had won, the Dems would have won. Scozzi would have voted FOR any legislation presented by Pelosi, and then both she AND BHO would then get to scream “bipartisanship” as loud as they can!! IMHO, it would have been great if Hoffman had won, but hopefully Steele & Sessions get the message here, and get going, to take this seat back in 2010. The next best thing to Hoffman winning did happen here.
I was being sarcastic
bk Wednesday, November 4th at 12:42PM EST (link)By the R-endorsed candidate I didn’t mean R party endorsement but rather endorsement by the R candidate, which wasn’t clear from the way I said it. I was trying to poke fun at how the Dems were trying to find ANYTHING to spin in a positive light, such as Madcow opening her show Monday with the “good” news that a Republican would not win NY-23. They were grasping at straws like crazy and still are.
Dede a moderate? No and at least Owens is a skunk in skunk's clothing.
nessa Wednesday, November 4th at 9:34AM EST (link)Dede’s value as a republican was undeniably demonstrated when she cast her lot with Owens. She would have been another Rino, a worse Rino than almost any I can think of. The others may be susceptible to greed or pork, they may even be idiots but they were not democrats who lied just so they could sneak in and sabotage us from the inside. Hell, even benedict arlen just ran as a republican so he could get re-elected. Thats a damn sight more honesty than Dede can claim.
“If you love wealth more than liberty, the tranquility of servitude better than the animating contest of freedom, depart from us in peace. We ask not your counsel nor your arms. Crouch down and lick the hand that feeds you. May your chains rest lightly upon you and may posterity forget that you were our countrymen.”—Samuel Adams
Contributor to The Minority Report
You over estimate what one more D rep can do at this point.
janis Wednesday, November 4th at 9:45AM EST (link)After the walloping the Dems took in Virginia and especially in heavily Dem New Jersey, the rest of the Dem congressmen are going to be looking very hard at whether they want to see the same thing happen to their own jobs a year from now.
We did win in NY-23 because now the GOP knows what we can do if we disagree with them this strongly. They are now on notice that their jobs can be dispensed with, too, and others more capable and more principled can be installed there.
its loss
proudgop Wednesday, November 4th at 10:08AM EST (link)Pelosi has another person in her camp
I think Hoffman not even being resident of district hurt him; Republicans need nominee in the district.
Do you have evidence of that?
Neil Stevens Wednesday, November 4th at 10:11AM EST (link)Or are you just engaging in post-election potshots at the man who defeated your gal fair and square?
Want to run for conservatives? Give.
There Is No Crisis
Neil, I heard that about Hoffman as well on Fox last night.
janis Wednesday, November 4th at 10:35AM EST (link)But he was a resident up until they redrew the lines from what I understood them to say. So proudgop is still just taking potshots, as usual.
I addressed this issue and others ...
randy streu Wednesday, November 4th at 10:41AM EST (link)check the side bar for my latest.
Blogging also at
SLC Republitarian
The Minority Report
Your analysis of the situation lost all credibility when
eburke Wednesday, November 4th at 10:39AM EST (link)you penned this phrase “the moderate was chucked”.
Despite the bleatings of the Pravda media, Dede wasn’t a moderate. Being a moderate means sometimes siding with liberals and sometimes with conservatives. With the exception of gun control, Dede was through and through a liberal.
And if you don’t think that Dede would’ve voted for the current version of the House bill, then you really haven’t been paying attention.
Oh, and btw, the *Democrat* campaigned *against* the public option.
“All that need be done for evil to triumph is for good men to do nothing.”
“Dead fish go with the flow” ~ izoneguy
“We have a Statue of Liberty not a Statue of Necessity” ~ ColdWarrior
Hoffman did Win
dclamage Wednesday, November 4th at 9:29AM EST (link)But ACORN and the Working Families Party committed their usual election fraud via absentee ballot-stuffing to hand a win to the Democrat.
Clearly, anywhere in the country ACORN and its Working Families Party exists, we should be screaming ELECTION FRAUD!
– Dan Clamage
Sorry
cooperscopy Wednesday, November 4th at 10:04AM EST (link)That’s good spin, but you can’t count a democrat pick up as a win. There were many reasons why Hoffman didn’t quite make it across the finish line. One would be Scozzafavas endorsement of Owens, and her union support going to Owens. I actually think if she’d stayed in the race Hoffman would have had a better chance. Her and Owens would have split the union and liberal vote, making Hoffman the plurality winner…
Ron Victor
Short term thinking (nt)
Neil Stevens Wednesday, November 4th at 10:07AM EST (link)Want to run for conservatives? Give.
There Is No Crisis
Inside GOP
cooperscopy Wednesday, November 4th at 10:13AM EST (link)You are right that conservatives must work within the republican party. The problem with this race was no primary process. 2010 will be very different…
Ron Victor
Cooperscopy may have
realskinny Wednesday, November 4th at 11:51AM EST (link)a point about why Scuzzy dropped out. She didn’t want to split union vote. Her campaign office was in AFL-CIO office. Hoffman probably would have won if she had stayed in race.
Main lesson here is Conservatives need to follow Coldwarrior’s advice and get involved in local Rep party positions so we can influence choice of candidates. Giving money to good candidates helps but if we want good candidates we have to get off our rears and get involved.
Heads You Win, Tails They Lose.
joeyess Wednesday, November 4th at 4:21PM EST (link)Let me see if I have this straight:
1. Drum out the GOP candidate with a right wing kook that’s not even from the district? Check!
2. Democrat opponent wins seat held by GOP for the first time since Reconstruction. Check!
3. Call it a “win”. Check!
USA!!!! USA!!!! USA!!!!
Oh, and………….. WOLVERINES!!!!!!!! also.
moron alert! clean-up required! nt
Vegas_Rick Wednesday, November 4th at 4:36PM EST (link)“Nothing in this world can take the place of persistence. Talent will not; nothing is more common than unsuccessful people with talent. Genius will not; unrewarded genius is almost a proverb. Education will not; the world is full of educated derelicts. Persistence and determination alone are omnipotent. The slogan ‘press on’ has solved and always will solve the problems of the human race.” Calvin Coolidge.
VegasRick .... I second. TROLL! TROLL! TROLL! nt
Rod_Patrick Wednesday, November 4th at 4:42PM EST (link)So it doesn't matter that the Democrat won...
afriscam Wednesday, November 4th at 4:50PM EST (link)… it’s a win for Republicans? I like the way you think, Erick.
The Republicans need many more “wins” like this to earn a place in the dumpster of history. They will be in good company, with “trickle-down economics” and “separate but equal” to keep them warm.
The “third party route” you push is splitting voters away from the Republicans because the biggest 3rd party is the Independents, who used to vote Republican far more often than Democratic. Not anymore.
Independents now see the Republicans have become the worst kind of Liberals, burning through money, troops, goodwill and the Constitution at a rate that makes Democrats look like the love children of Hetty Green and Jack Benny. (Famous misers, for those under 60.)
The GOP lost in a district they have held since the Civil War, for two reasons. Changing demographics (less WASPs per acre) and changing the GOP from a pro-business party to a pro-death funeral party.
Look at the new Republican values. Torture, race-baiting, warrantless wiretapping, protecting companies from lawsuits by rape victims, wife-swapping, coke-snorting, child prostitution rings and death squads, secret prisons, clinic bombings, assassinations, prison without trial and of course, war, war, endless war.
The GOP should change their logo to the “Totenkopf” death’s head favored by the Nazi SS. Maybe they could dig up the corpse of the benzedrine-addicted sociopath and rape-fantasy writer Ayn Rand to run her on the “I ? Serial Killers” ticket with Edward Wycoff.
Oh, wait, that would be truth in advertising. Never mind.
Dude, I understand that VA and NJ hurts
Hooah_Mac Wednesday, November 4th at 11:17PM EST (link)You’ll get over it, I promise.
“You can call yourself a Republican, but if you’ve lost the support of Fred Thompson, you are an unholy thing that will be destroyed by a rain of fire.” -IMAO
come on, do I detect sour grapes here, troll? using the term WASP...
DONTREADONME Thursday, November 5th at 12:52AM EST (link)to me is derogatory. Next as Hooah said, the pain subsides once you realize how your problem solving skills and rational thought processes are equivalent of a 10 grade inner city school public education, or you went to Ivy league school and just graduated.
“The UN is right? you can’t be any more “un”; Than you are right now, the UN is undone, Another mushroom cloud, another smoking gun, The threat is real, the Locust King has come, Don’t tell me the truth; I don’t like what they’ve done, Just give me ammo for the United Abominations”-Megadeth
Get better glasses: you're quoting from the Democratic platform
civil_truth Thursday, November 5th at 1:15AM EST (link)Torture, race-baiting, warrantless wiretapping, protecting companies from lawsuits by rape victims, wife-swapping, coke-snorting, child prostitution rings and death squads, secret prisons, clinic bombings, assassinations, prison without trial and of course, war, war, endless war.
No matter how you dress it up, a donkey is still an a**.
And Rightly So!
Let's give this political genius a pat on the back.
Xasteius Thursday, November 5th at 1:33AM EST (link)Don’t leave the party, hijack it back!
Eternal vigilance is the price of freedom.
When I grow up, I don’t want to be Reagan. I want to be Art Chance.
~Aaron Gardner
totenkoph thats funny!
kyle8 Thursday, November 5th at 6:42AM EST (link)coming from the party of abortion and euthanasia. Oh yeah, and also the party of lies and personal assaults, and union thuggery and welfare plantation mentality, and marxist economics.
Go ahead and spin it anyway you like, we might still be the stupid party but you are the evil party and you lost big time in these last elections. You can only win when the people are angry and your candidates lie and tell the public they are centrists.
“Nothing works like freedom, Nothing succeeds like liberty”
Kyle
From Doug Hoffman's website ...
joayn Wednesday, November 4th at 11:40PM EST (link)America has changed
by Doug Hoffman, posted election night 09
America has changed, and you have helped. Although we did not succeed in winning this election, we have succeeded in making sure political parties and special interests no longer take the people for granted. I believe we have sent a powerful message and laid the groundwork for future conservative campaigns.
I congratulate Bill Owens on a hard won victory. In our tradition of free elections, our country continues. And although Bill Owens has won, I believe America is turning the page to a new dawn.
The ideas of freedom, sound fiscal management and citizen government have sprung back into our consciousness. Our founding fathers would be proud of New York 23. It was here that our principles, those that have been the foundation of our nation, came back to life with a vengeance. And it was here that the people rose up against the political bosses who tried to impose their will. It was here that people reached out to control their own destinies again.
Despite the election results, I am optimistic for our future, because now I know that I am not alone in wanting to repair our great nation. Throughout this campaign I have been inspired by the outpouring of support and the intensity of that support.
I’ve met many different people in this campaign, from many walks of life and many professions; each with a different personal story to share. Yet we are all united in the belief that by participating in democracy, we could inspire change.
I urge that no one feel defeated, for this was only one of many elections. We came close, we put our agenda in front of the nation and the nation took notice. The worse thing we could do now, is not continue forward. Next year there are other elections and other candidates who have drawn inspiration from our efforts.
I would like to thank all of you who placed your faith in me, who worked tirelessly and shared your enthusiasm with those around you. You are all patriots, you have all stood up for your country and I am honored to stand among you.
Thank you,
Doug Hoffman
Eric, Stop selling us a big sack of crap
martyinaz Thursday, November 5th at 3:26AM EST (link)We won nothing in NY 23. We gave up a Republican seat to a Democrat.. Is that what you call winning? We are losers. And, I am a sore loser. You show me a good loser, and I’ll show you a REAL loser. One more vote for the Democrats, gosh, as a conservative I feel all warm and fuzzy now..
Eric, Stop selling us a big sack of crap
martyinaz Thursday, November 5th at 3:26AM EST (link)We won nothing in NY 23. We gave up a Republican seat to a Democrat.. Is that what you call winning? We are losers. And, I am a sore loser. You show me a good loser, and I’ll show you a REAL loser. One more vote for the Democrats, gosh, as a conservative I feel all warm and fuzzy now..
Martyinaz...
snowshooze Thursday, November 5th at 4:01AM EST (link)Marty, I understand and feel the loss as well, but you should see the wisdom and the light of letting a loser like Scozzifava fail, and although Hoffman did not prevail as we all had hoped for, we did in fact…win.
Ok…we didn’t get our guy. Understood. But we wound up with a Democrat more conservative than our party line.
It is in all honesty, a hard sell…but we accomplished the elimination of a RHINO sellout. THAT, IN ITSELF, IS A WIN.
Small, though it may be, still a win of sorts.
Stay on board, help us re-form, from within, the conservative ideal.
In this game, we have to play long. I was no happier than you to see the loss, but dang, for a third party with a total sellout by the GOP nominee… we did well.If Scozzifava had backed Hoffman, we may well have had the alternative outcome.If the GOP and RNCC would have backed him, it would have been sealed.
Be that as it may, the conservatives have shown their viability, and will continue to do so. We need you, and everyone else who wants to put this country back on track, to stand together and fight for the future. We have to work together, and from inside the GOP to pull it. Yes, there are other parties…but our best shot comes from internal reform. We must expunge the political opportunists such as McCain, Snowe and Steele, even if it should cost us a few bottom line seats, in order to rally and consolidate the conservative movement which is ours.If our strategy is based upon our ideals, the path to victory will lay itself out before us.
Keep the faith.
Sincerely,
Alaska Mark
Alaska Mark aka snowshooze
martyinaz Thursday, November 5th at 11:20AM EST (link)Friend, you are talking sense to me and I hear you. God, how I wish I could vote Libertarian, and know it would mean something. Since I was 20, I was an advocate of Austrian Economics and limited government. So, I am by all counts a true Libertarian. The problem has always been I had to pick the lesser taskmaster; that’s the one who would deliver only ten lashes instead of 20. I would rather be free of our government, and receive NO lashes. But alas, we have a two party system. And voting my true conscience would only water down the chances of getting the lesser taskmaster.
Can conservatives live with moderates? I have for all my life. Do I like it? Absolutely not. And, I often remain a sore loser. It is very hard for me to crawl off and just lick my wounds. I have to unload on someone, and Eric was the target of choice today.
Sometimes I feel our position is hopeless. Honorable , but hopeless. Between the liberals and a liberal biased media, we must fight on too many fronts. And, when we then fight among ourselves, we are really in trouble. Where was the GOP when Hoffman came onto the scene? Where were the funds he needed to put up a better fight? How did Scorzzafava get into Congress in the first place as a Republican?… See what I mean? This is the stuff I dwell on, and at times, it seems a hopeless battle. To change the Republican party is going to be a major undertaking. But you are right. We have to do it.
First let me say that "REPLY TO THIS" is your friend
Richard Mullins Thursday, November 5th at 11:32AM EST (link)and secondly, I happy you seems to understand things now. We won anyway because of the fact that the Democrats assault on the GOP in the form of DeDe Scozzafava lost out.
For more on my views, go my wordpress site:
http://rpmullins.wordpress.com
For more on Happy jet airlines, go here:
http://happyjetairlines.wordpress.com
For a good dose of satire go here:
http://thesquash.wordpress.com
For more of I like to do a lot:
http://www.flickr.com/photos/42008626@N03