« BACK  |  PRINT

RS

MEMBER DIARY

The proximity of 911 Anniversaries to Election Days: An example of Providence? [updated]

Defending Real America from Obama's Ideal

By Mike DeVine, Legal Editor for The Minority Report and The HinzSight Report

If a President won’t defend America, it won’t be defended. I think this adage is driven home at a most opportune time before we choose Commanders in Chief.

Does anyone doubt that President Bush benefited from the third anniversary remembrance of the September 11, 2001 terrorist attacks against John “international test” Kerry? And does anyone doubt the significance of the Saddleback contrast between John “defeat evil” McCain and Barack “evil on the streets of America” Obama with the images of Planes crashing into the WTC towers above those streets?

I think not.


Recently, Obama was again asked about evil, and again chose to wax not so eloquent on our need to be humble given that we have done evil in the name of fighting evil? Of course, the MSM in the tank for The One “reporter” failed to follow up on what Barack meant (maybe it is the evil of lipstick, Abu Ghraib?).

Obama, see if you can hear this above the din of your 20-year pew-parked in a Hate Whitey America church butt:

Humility hasn’t prevented more 911 attacks and if you, Terrorist William Ayers and Rev. Wright see any moral equivalence between evil attacks on America and humanity from Pearl Harbor thru Saddam’s attacks on Kuwait and our troops enforcing the cease-fire bought with American blood versus the sins of individual Americans in operations in response thereto, then I would suggest you sue Harvard for educational malpractice.

Don’t worry, we won’t question your patriotism. But we do need to define and distinguish it from those, like McCain-Palin, that love their Country, as is. You know, people that don’t make a production of ceasing to wear the flag post-911. People that don’t suggest displays of the flag are cheap patriotism as compared to the leftist “real” patriotism of criticizing our nation as it removes a megalomaniacal mass murderer of over 400,000 in the dead of night and over a million in wars; and helps millions of purple-fingered Iraqis vote for civilized freedom.

Michael Novak captures the problem of the “ideal” vs. the “real” here:

Now we know why Obama took the American flag off his lapel. On July 24, in Berlin, he told us. The American flag is too small to contain him. He is not comfortable being an American citizen, only fully comfortable as a citizen of the world.

But “citizen of the world” is a utopian, unreal, angelic, inhuman term, an abstraction of the sort that leads to immense bloodshed as human irregularities are hacked off and angularity is loudly planed away.

The Berlin speech…explains why Obama is more likely to praise an “ideal” America than the real America. He is bewitched by abstractions and lofty ideals. That is how he touches the secret chords of the heart of so many millions, the teenage romanticism of a world without different real interests, without the clashes of culture, the force of political arguments about who gets what, when, and how.

This conflict between global citizenship and pledging allegiance solely to the flag of the United States and the Republic for which it stands, suggests that we go back again to Senator Obama’s ambivalence about the flag in his lapel.

Obama himself said he wore a flag in his lapel after September 11, 2001, but then did not wear it for several years. Why? On reflection, he judged that wearing a flag in the lapel would be an inadequate symbol of patriotism (HT: Byron York, July 1). That Obama did not wear his flag in his lapel is true. Obama not only was not wearing it, but had a policy statement about why he was not wearing it.

Real patriotism, he clarified, is loving the ideals of a country and dissenting from policies not in line with those ideals.

Here Obama points to a huge divide between left-wingers and ordinary Americans. Ordinary Americans do not love a mere “ideal” out in never-never land. They love the land, the soil, the mountains, the plains, the history, the bloody battles, the mistakes, the rises and falls, the real human history of an altogether human people, the particular, imperfect people of the United States. Left-wingers, by contrast, are continually judging the real country harshly. They often judge it so harshly that their attitudes toward their leaders, their neighbors and the real country as a whole sometimes seem almost like hatred for the country itself.

But the United States is still, blessedly, largely a center-right country in this respect. Obama’s stated positions about why he took the flag out of his lapel, and what he means by patriotism, slightly incline a large number to vote against him. Therefore we can count on Obama showing up on more and more stages so thick with American flags you would think you were at a Ronald Reagan rally – and with the stars and stripes starkly visible on the left lapel of his neat, dark suit. That flag will certainly appear in his lapel a great many more times until the first Tuesday in November. A center-right country will demand it.

Our annual remembrances of 911 remind us of the all too real evil in the world seeking to destroy the real America. Rev. Wright can’t even understand that our necessary actions against the Empire of Japan were justified. Obama praises Real Red China, overlooking their gross sins and lack of any ideals (save Confucius and love for the elderly) over millennia, while denigrating the greatest nation in history, which United States is defined by increasing achievement and application of its ideals both at home and in self-sacrifice abroad so that all free people on Earth, including the one Barack sees in the mirror.

Thank you Providence (the real one), that if America had to suffer an attack from evil abroad, that it occurred in close proximity to the day when we choose the leader charged with defending us and waging war against those that harm America.

The Real America.

The America that disciples of Rev. Wright and Saul Alinsky would slight with stammering while in search of the Marxist Utopia.

The America that McCain and Palin would most assuredly defend.

[update]

As we remember the perpetrators, victims and heroes of 911, let us also remember those that have kept us safe since then, and also remember those (mostly all Bushlied Democrats) that have opposed the efforts at home and abroad that have kept us safe whether it be intelligence gathering via cell phone calls; interrogation of KSM and other terrorists; and/or our war against them in Afghanistan and in Iraq where UBL declared the main front, expended resources originally intended for the Lower Forty-Eight.

Mike DeVine’s Charlotte Observer columns
Legal Editor for The Minority and HinzSight Reports
“The way to stop discrimination on the basis of race is to stop discriminating on the basis of race.” – The Chief Justice
Race 4 2008
“One man with courage makes a majority.” – Andrew Jackson

Tags: , ,
Get Alerts

COMMENTS

  • ekevlar11

    If I’m on, I always read your entertaining, and enlightening blogs. I find your argument in this blog interesting. The difference oftentimes between the Democratic party and the Republican party comes down often to the ideal versus the real.

    But I think your argument goes sideways in the end. I don’t know where you stand on the Democrat chair’s comments that absentee witnessed that God brought the hurricane to disrupt the RNC. If you consider it wrong for a Democratic chair to state that God brought a hurricane during the RNC, then wouldn’t thanking God for his benevolence to place 9/11 so close to the election be as unreasonable?

  • gamecock

    5

  • StephC

    I can’t thank God for 9/11 for your argument. Sorry. Like ekevlar, that’s not much different than “God bringing the hurricane…”

    Since this tragedy, many of us are much more vigilant while others have forgotten or downplay its significance.

    I can thank him for showing Americans what they can do and be during times of great strife. That’s what people need to learn and remember. That it wasn’t government who showed them that but a tragedy of national proportions.

  • gamecock

    to facilitate the liberals exhibition of their true colors via Fowler.

    But ekev’, Gamecock, just as Washington, Adams, Lincoln, FDR and Reagan do believe that God’s hand has been at work in the Founding and prospering of this nation. Has God protected us from all evil? Of course not. But do I find it beyond the pale that God would leave a silver lining around dark clouds.

    I don’t rule it out.

  • gamecock

    Just because a democrat invokes God’s providence for a substantively obtuse reason does not rule out God’s Providence for his purposes.

    Gamecock will not let my own SC’s Don Fowler (btw, I know all the Fowlers from my hometown and 18 yrs in the dem party) rob me of expounding as did Reagan and Washington.

    If StephC wants to be cynical and surrender any Hope, then that just means God’s not finished with me yet in showing her the light!

    love ya gal

  • gamecock

    Luck (silver lining in dark cloud)

  • ekevlar11

    Yep, not saying I believe it will happen…but there are 50 odd days still left with lots still to come.

    What will your stance on the silver lining around the clouds be then if Obama wins? Will your providence argument have to be turned on its head to show that God’s Providence brought the election to the Democrats? And if you now call it luck and Obama wins…then the closeness of the dates would have been auspicious for Obama?

    How about God’s will be done and leave it at that.

  • StephC

    while I don’t rule out Providence I look for a greater meaning than showing the Dems up is all. I suppose, if that is a by-product it’s alright to thank God for that, too.

    Just as we have to fight wars sometimes to keep from being conquered I suppose this, too, is a war from within that has to be fought. I’d much prefer persuasion but then I’m a pacifist at heart… unless I’m pushed beyond a certain point, which will have me come out swinging. 9/11 did that to a lot of us, didn’t it?

  • StephC

    If such were to take place, it simply means there is more to learn.

  • aaronbg

    How is that for a comment title…;^)

    If the close proximity of 9/11 to the elections does indeed result in either a McCain win or an Obama win it will be due to God’s providence. As well Gustav was indeed God’s providence. I will explain how on both accounts.

    First Gustav…The storm itself was a bad thing, with the possibility of death and extreme damage. The actions of Fowler taking glee in the disastrous affects and attributing them to God’s providence was, however wrong. The affects related to Gustav that should be attributed to God’s providence is the nation wide showing of the strength and humility of those who are Republicans. In a time when “Republicans” are thought to be corrupt and greedy, they were shown to be solid leaders and generous philanthropists.

    Now on to the elections. If McCain were to win the election it would have to be attributable to God’s providence as he was nearly out of the race just over a year ago. Nothing else need be said here. If Obama wins the election the proof of God’s providence will be seen on Nov 4 2012.

    How is that Gamecock…..;^)

  • gamecock

    ‘k?

  • gamecock

    It just so happens that dems have been on the wrong side of Liberty since at least the early 1970s. They intentionally left Vietnam to slaughter; opposed Reagan’s cold war to free millions from communist tyranny; opposed the Contras; embraced the leftist nuclear freeze; opposed freeing Kuwait; yelled Bushlied since 2004…

    This is not about showing up Dems, pre se. Its about defeating the enemies of freedom.

  • gamecock

    and not crass political purposes. I’m sure you didn’t mean to suggest otherwise.

    They aid and abet the enemies of freedom.

  • gamecock

    Washington had to cross it.

  • gamecock

    5

  • c17wife

    Much like I believe God had His hand in Florida in 2000. He knew what was coming and He knew what we would need, even if we didn’t know it ourselves.
    I used to have a great debate with a Christian brother of mine over why in the world we had to put up with 8 years of Bubba. My thought was God threw up his hands and said “Fine, y’all get what you deserve.” My bro had other ideas though. He felt like our 8 years of Bubba forced issues to the front that might not have otherwise been out there. I’m slowly coming to terms with that thought process.
    Speaking of God, I feel something really moving in this election the past few weeks. Since Saddleback really. Maybe it is wishful thinking, but at times I have a true peace that we are going to come out of this okay. And then other times I am in a fit of sheer PANIC over OMG! What if Obama really wins?!??!??! So, I guess I still have some work to do. :>)

  • gamecock

    5

  • gamecock

    As we remember the perpetrators, victims and heroes of 911, let us also remember those that have kept us safe since then, and also remember those (mostly all Bushlied Democrats) that have opposed the efforts at home and abroad that have kept us safe whether it be intelligence gathering via cell phone calls; interrogation of KSM and other terrorists; and/or our war against them in Afghanistan and in Iraq where UBL declared the main front, expended resources originally intended for the Lower Forty-Eight.

    I give the Democrats no quarter.

  • Finrod

    One of my favorite geek sayings is:

    “Never try to apply a Star Trek solution to a Babylon 5 problem.”

    Your bit about ideal vs. real made me realize that this applies to politics as well: Barack Obama is a Star Trek candidate for a Babylon 5 world.

  • StephC

    I trust more ot Providence than I do politicians, :-) .

  • gamecock

    Although I have been saying for years that libs may love America, but not the real one. At least, it would be impossible to get a jury enough evidence to convict them of patriotism beyond a reasonable doubt.

    No, they love an imaginary America that they wouldn’t mind arising from defeat at the hands of enemies we caused to hate us.

  • ekevlar11

    That said…relying on Providence doesn’t stop us from fighting for what we think is right.

    Keep up the fight!

    Donate, make calls, visit your local Republican HQ and volunteer.

    We can’t just look for the silver lining, we have to build it for our children.

  • redneck_hippie

    as usual. The Libs do not pay attention to the strict literal meaning of utopia.

    We former democrats/independents understand the mindset. I and many others leave communicating it to your capable fingers.

    I began with the ideal (yelch) of McGovern and Carter. Somewhere later I gained a little wisdom. Something about living, and studying history, must’ve done the trick.

  • gamecock

    soul of wit.

    thanks man

  • gamecock

    is rowing the boat ashore!

  • Oz

    I was reflecting on the fact that every election from now on will have, seven weeks prior, a reminder of the need for a strong leader.

    This will always be trouble for the liberal Zero-Bama’s of the world.

  • gamecock

    you get it, i.e. me (a dixie hyroglyphic writ rooster)