Susannahs: Clearing the GC palate (semi-open thread)


The main purpose of this blog is to initiate debate on a number of issues Gamecock has been unable to address over the past two weeks due to an increase in legal work in my day job. I want to get some ideas out there and get reactions and input from my fellow bloggers. I provide links and my propositions and/or questions on several issues, that I have not seen addressed on specific points, after the immediate introductory remarks below.

Introductory remarks

(Some may want to skip these semi-biographical and explanatory remarks and go immediately to the issues section below):

I have never done a blog like this before for several reasons. I am shamelessly into self promotion (I am a lifelong free market capitalist, self-employed entrepreneur) and have been pursuing a goal of a second career (writing) since 2003 that would pay all my bills by 2013. I am progressing nicely. And it is hard to use a potpourri semi-open thread to advance same in the way one can market a regular column.

But, I am also an issues/substance/ideas guy and also crave input on many issues, and simply must clear the palate now given how busy my day job legal carer has gotten lately thanks to re-fis and investor business law.

Why call this set of issues “Susannahs”?

I name this intended ongoing series (Other column DeVine-Gamecock categories: “Foghorn Leghorns” that call out the drive-bys for their fog and planting the truth with legs on the ground) and “Cockstradamas” forecasts) after TMR frontpager and regular Redstate blogger since Gamecock discovered her, Susannah as a tribute to her good will, hard work, insightfulness and since she likes open threads. (I have never done an open thread because I am a serial, hit-and-run thread-jacker and have never called threadjack on my columns. I am very tolerant).

Moreover, I also share a major characteristic with Susannah. She is a former? democrat that appears to have had a conservative epiphany. Now to the

Issues (aka Susannahs):

1) Federal and State (NC) cigarette tax hikes break Obama’s promise that the bottom 95% of taxpayers would not have taxes raised

These taxes make one of the main affordable pleasures of the poor and lower income essentially a luxury item. These folks are already unable to take vacations and afford many things most of us take for granted. Now they are being targeted to fund government subsidies for middle class and corporate welfare.

The Charlotte Observer has been on a mission for years to make smoking tobacco illegal but recently published an editorial opposing blue laws that restrict sales of bottles of spirits on Sunday because they “limit personal freedom.” Yet, they support President Obama’s Big Brother government that massively limit liberty 24/7, seven days a week.

2) Ever heard of “iPS” (”induced pluripotent stem cells”)?

We must make iPS a household word. Of all unlikely columnists, Kathleen Parker wrote a monumental column on the subject recently that reinforces my long advanced contention that the purpose of the proponents of ECS (Embryonic stem cell research) is the legitimization of abortion and not saving lives given that iPS produces pluripotent (able to become any other type of stem cell) stem cells from adult skin cells.

iPS makes ECS obsolete.

Moreover, to-date, only adult stem cells have produced any useful treatments for disease, after decades of research.

3) Teachable moment via School system layoffs of non-teachers

I have long contended that education budgets are bloated due to the salaries of administrative personnel. The Charlotte-Mecklenburg School System (CMS) recently announced recession related layoffs of 500+ employees, none of whom are classroom teachers.

We have a chance to provide proof that these paper pushers are not necessary.

4) Newt shamelessly echos Hillary’s unpatriotic Blame America First exoneration of Mexican Drug gang violence

Just saw Newt on O’Reilly. Had already planned column against Hillary’s cloaked attack on the Second Amendment by blaming American gun laws for border violence by Mexican drug gangs.

Just for the record I recently announced that I lean toward ending the drug war in the US and have found the William F. Buckley libertarian argument more persuasive after so long a war. But that does not translate into making it a point of foreign policy to blame the source of the guns and drug users for murder by the gun users.

4) The new American Frontier that will determine America’s fate

Two quotes.

First quote:

Geithner on MTP:

Geithner said Washington alone was equipped to salvage the economy.

“The market will not solve this. And the great risk for us is we do too little, not that we do too much,” he said.

TIME and the market are the ONLY things that can solve the economic crisis. Yes, given the debt the government and We the People ran up the past 25, but especially the past 10 years, we were going to be in for a hard time until people could save enough money to risk money again. But Obama is making Hoover/FDR mistakes that prolonged the Great Depression by causing investors to go on strike, in addition to much more draconian “mistakes) (they intend them to use the crisis as an opportunity to impose their leftist vision, i.e. government directed economy - see tyranny) with their breach of NAFTA re Mexican trucks; tax hikes; massive deficit spending; and takeovers of private businesses.

The Americans that created the Shining City on the Hill carved it out of a rough, no bailout frontier. If we are to preserve it, we will have to be very strong.

Second quote:

[Mark] Levin quotes Ronald Reagan: “Freedom is never more than one generation away from extinction. We didn’t pass it to our children in the bloodstream. It must be fought for, protected, and handed on for them to do the same, or one day we will spend our sunset years telling our children and our children’s children what it was once like in the United States where men were free.”

Rush asked Levin on his show Monday, (paraphrase) “Why, if the yearning of the human heart is for God given liberty, do people tend toward socialism/statism”?

My answer: Sin

Yes, man yearns for that liberty, but as CS Lewis and Whittaker Chambers, especially points out in “Witness”, the tendency toward tyranny began in the Garden of Eden when the serpent offered Adam and Eve the apple so “Ye shall be as Gods.”

Man rejected God as his director and chose to be his own God.

more later

Discuss

Mike DeVine’s Charlotte Observer, Examiner.com and Minority Report columns

“One man with courage makes a majority.” - Andrew Jackson

Originally published by Mike DeVine, Legal Editor for The Minority Report


RSS feed | Trackback URI

28 Comments Leave a comment

OK--I have to recco this....

Susannah Monday, March 30th at 11:24PM EDT (link)

…simply for the name. :-)

Now, about cigarette taxes–I have mixed feelings on this. While I’m not a huge fan of “sin taxes”, I am also not a huge fan of smoking. (I will finish medical school in eight weeks, so as a future doctor, it would look bad on my part if I wasn’t at least, somewhat, happy about anything that would prevent future smokers, and thus, many future patients with painful, chronic illnesses.)

Oh, and about Newt and Hillary, I understand what they were saying–I think. I don’t think that they were, literally, blaming America (although it probably came out wrong). I think that they were saying that people who buy and use illegal drugs and think to themselves, “Hey, I’m not hurting anyone”, are really kidding themselves. That maybe, when you buy or use illegal drugs, you are putting money into the pockets of corrupt drug dealers in Mexico who kidnap, torture, and decapitate people. In other words, “Hey Sparky, take some personal responsibility and get off of the coke, because you’re putting your money into the pockets of some very bad people who even hurt fellow Americans and are screwing up our borders”. Just my thoughts.

To quote Gamecock, “more later” when I have the time. By the way, these are good topics for debate. :-)

yo ive a question

Gyorc Nacain Tuesday, March 31st at 2:07AM EDT (link)

so you started posting here at some point during the past election cycle, saying you were a Democrat, for Hillary and then for McCain. In the blog gamecock refers to you as a “former? democrat”. Do you still consider yourself a Democrat, albeit one who is against Pres. Obama, or do you consider yourself something else? I guess I have no real reason for asking, just curious…

To answer your question....

Susannah Tuesday, March 31st at 2:45PM EDT (link)

I was what you’d call a moderate/”Hillary” Democrat. I guess (to quote Gamecock), I had sort of a “conservative epiphany” during the last election (brought about, in a large part, by the tactics of the far-left)–although I’m probably still not as conservative a lot of the people on RS are. However, that’s OK–RS is a big-tent and we have a kinds here. Anyway, I hope that answers your question. :-)

Future reality muggings will drive you further to the right! - smile - nt

Mike gamecock DeVine Tuesday, March 31st at 2:47PM EDT (link)

Mike DeVine’s Examiner.com, Charlotte Observer and The Minority Report columns
“One man with courage makes a majority.” - Andrew Jackson

 
 
 

why do they pass sin taxes?

pilgrim Tuesday, March 31st at 9:10AM EDT (link)

They claim they do it so one will sin no more, but that is a lie. They do the sin taxes because they are the easiest taxes to get passed. As a future medical doctor, Susannah, you can be opposed to smoking and also be opposed to expanding the government with additional taxes. There would be no conflict there between the two.

The scary part is that now new sins are being created to raise more taxes. Harry Reid is saying that coal makes you sick, and oil makes you sick. For me, coal from the power plant keeps the lights on at my house, and oil keeps my truck running. Obama says US citizens use up too much of the world’s resources (water for example.) This quest to take liberty away from individuals is what really makes me sick.

It is a great advantage to a president, and a major source of safety to the country, for him to know that he is not a great man.Calvin Coolidge

Amen, and smoking bans strike at what the Framers considered the Key to Liberty: Private property rights-nt

Mike gamecock DeVine Tuesday, March 31st at 9:17AM EDT (link)

Mike DeVine’s Examiner.com, Charlotte Observer and The Minority Report columns
“One man with courage makes a majority.” - Andrew Jackson

 

Cigarette taxes

Gyorc Nacain Tuesday, March 31st at 4:03PM EDT (link)

I agree that the reason “sin taxes” are passed is because it is easy. Same way places have tourism taxes of various sorts - it doesn’t affect the people who actually vote for them. But it doesn’t make them wrong. I think most Economists would agree that taxing cigarettes lowers their use…in an extreme example, if you taxed them until they cost $2 million then nobody would buy them. It may not have a huge effect, but it has one. And I think there is a justification in having such a tax. They strain health care resources, and are annoying/harmful to people in the vicinity, when they’re on public space, and etc. I mean, for example you can believe in freedom and also believe there should be laws to keep some guy from opening up a toxic waste dump next to your house. Same idea here, but less so.

 
 

GC is a frequent guest on local public radio against smoking bans

Mike gamecock DeVine Tuesday, March 31st at 10:11AM EDT (link)

I haven’t smoked a cigarette in 28 years.

see prior column below

main points
private property rights and if this was about health, advocates would be for masks for waiters

You make good points on the drug war

Mike DeVine’s Examiner.com, Charlotte Observer and The Minority Report columns
“One man with courage makes a majority.” - Andrew Jackson

Oh Gamecock, as far as smoking bans in the workplace go....

Susannah Tuesday, March 31st at 3:18PM EDT (link)

I’m with Huckabee and Brownback on this one–in other words, I’m for them. And, not because I am a future doctor, but because of my own rights as a patient with severe allergies to cigarette smoke (I have allergies to dust, pollen, smoke and must use a nasal steroid spray at night and take Allegra during the day). If I go into a restaurant with people smoking, I, literally, have to leave because my eyes will water, my nose will become extremely congested, I will get a bad headache, I will cough, have trouble breathing, and just be all around miserable. One time, when I was in a smokey Mexican restaurant during Happy Hour, I had to go to the ER, because I had an asthma-like reaction where I couldn’t breathe (I don’t actually have asthma, though, because that’s the only time where I actually wheezed and experienced chest tightness due to smoke–that place was so smokey that it was like a fog).

Oh, and on a side note, I was at a Halloween party one year that was held in a bar where I dressed up like Elvira (it was a rented costume). Well then, some drunken idiot burned a whole in my costume with his cigarette (and burned me as well), so I wound up having to Elvira every year for the next ten years for Halloween, because I had to buy the stupid costume (due to the damage done by the idiot’s cigarette).

Oh, and not to mention, every time that I where a nice outfit out to an establishment that allows smoking (which I try to avoid, if at all possible), I ALWAYS have to get it dry-cleaned the next day (because the outfit stinks of cigarette smoke). And, the offending smoker who got my new outfit smelly in the first place is never around to pay my cleaning bill.

So, in conclusion, I don’t think that I should be forced to undergo a painful allergy attack (or worse, that an asthmatic child should have to undergo an asthma attack and wind up in the hospital), or have to be Elvira every year for Halloween, all because some irresponsible jerk can’t take personal responsibility and go outside to smoke his cigarette. Being considerate of others should be a conservative talking point, in my humble opinion.

OK, now, I have to go study. Great debate, though. :-)

Random fact...

Gyorc Nacain Tuesday, March 31st at 4:06PM EDT (link)

…apparently, smoking on the street is illegal in Tokyo. Not due to health reasons, but because the streets are crowded enough that people being burned by careless people throwing away butts is a problem. Especially for children, who are less likely to be seen, and more likely to be burned in the face (shudder) due to their low height.

Then again, this might be an urban legend or something.

Well I've been burned in the shoulder a couple of times....

Susannah Tuesday, March 31st at 4:17PM EDT (link)

….while out in college, but, then again, I’m pretty short (around 5′3).

I remember one time at a football game when I was in college, there was this guy with our group of friends (I didn’t know him–he was a friend of a friend). Well, he got drunk and burned some small child in the face accidentally with his cigarette. Needless to say, the kid’s dad was pissed and we had to run out of there in a hurry. To say that I was not entertained with that dufus would be the understatement of the century.

 
 
 
 

gamecock smoking column links

Mike gamecock DeVine Tuesday, March 31st at 10:12AM EDT (link)
 

Just a quibble my good cock

kyle8 Monday, March 30th at 11:35PM EDT (link)

We are apprehensive of any sort of “blame America first ” reasoning and rightfully so, but I think in this case, there is at least some blame to go our way.

Sure it’s not our fault Mexico is corrupt. nor will I apologize for our second amendment rights.

But by not policing our border, and by totally ignoring the demand side of the drug trade (or my god at least trying something, anything else after many decades of frustration) we have certainly not helped the situation.

“Nothing works like freedom, Nothing succeeds like liberty”
Kyle

agreed with all you say and with much of what Newt and Hillary have said, but

Mike gamecock DeVine Monday, March 30th at 11:48PM EDT (link)

(and Newt emphasized your points, Hillary did not)

I think Hillary’s message sent a terrible message that undermines US interests and seemed to emphasize our gun laws, not border patrols. It also seemed like the left’s excuses for the terrorists on 911 and Obama’s recent blaming of America for Iran’s terrorism since 1979.

Mike DeVine’s Examiner.com, Charlotte Observer and The Minority Report columns
“One man with courage makes a majority.” - Andrew Jackson

well yeah

kyle8 Tuesday, March 31st at 12:04AM EDT (link)

absolutely nothing good will come out of this administration, but that sort of goes without saying.

we have to be prepared to just have arguments among ourselves because the spoiled immature brats who now make up the left are incapable of any coherent thought.

“Nothing works like freedom, Nothing succeeds like liberty”
Kyle

 
 

Just imagine

Maggie_in_Indiana Tuesday, March 31st at 8:51AM EDT (link)

that we had only to fight the domestic supply of drugs. Really how much does come over the borders? Stepping up our law enforcement within our borders may just really work and put the bad guys in jail for longer sentences and keep them there the full length of their sentences. Look there’s talk of legalizing pot,for whatever reason,now there’s real incentive to stop the traffic.(rolling eyes) Put your life on the line for a drug that may very well become legal before you get the suppliers and pushers in court. In most states you get a ticket to appear for a joint,with a fine of $50 and court costs. Big deal. How about like the old days ,go to jail ,bail,court,fines and time. The war on drugs just faded away and no body noticed.

Maggie in Indiana

Maggie, last year I finally started to lean toward a more libertarian position on the drug war

Mike gamecock DeVine Tuesday, March 31st at 9:00AM EDT (link)

see this
http://www.parade.com/news/2009/03/why-we-must-fix-our-prisons.html

I will be writing a column on the matter soon.

Mike DeVine’s Examiner.com, Charlotte Observer and The Minority Report columns
“One man with courage makes a majority.” - Andrew Jackson

 
 
 

Government, not God,

Steph C Tuesday, March 31st at 9:52AM EDT (link)

decides what sin is. God said, all things in moderation, as did Christ when he enumerated the 10 commandments as the only real law.

Indeed, the governments around the world now encourage a breaking of the 10 commandments rather than adherence, simply for the money and power it brings to that centralized body. We asuage our sins through taxes much as a Catholic goes to confession to be forgiven. Just as there are Catholics who abuse that system to absolve themselves of their most heinous deeds, there are those who will pay any amount of taxes to assuage their guilt in the Protestant parts of the world.

I know it’s not a popular way of looking at things but I could care less about alcohol, tobacco, and other drugs; whether they should be outlawed. That being said, they should never ever be used as an excuse for breaking one of the 10 commandments, thereby lightening the sentencing should someone be harmed because of another’s usage of any of it. The people doing the harm chose to do these other things in excess to a degree that harm was caused.

Everything in your list of issues can be brought back to the 10 commandments, even the stem cell research, if you think about it.

I’m waiting for one of you awesome writers to make the argument that we must resist this taxation of everything in order to save government from the deadly sins of greed, envy, and gluttony… well, probably the whole litany of the 7 deadly sins but you get the idea.

“[I]f the public are bound to yield obedience to laws to which they cannot give their approbation, they are slaves to those who make such laws and enforce them.” –Candidus in the Boston Gazette, 1772
Hillbilly Politics

 

People dont like socialism, children do.

Alberta Tuesday, March 31st at 11:15AM EDT (link)

I think its that simple. Our culture allows people the ability to never grow up; Our institutions have been hijacked, and now they try to make Daddy Government seem like a natural condition. Responsibility has been made vile.

Do you know any adults, anybody with the ‘ancient’ notions of Responsibility, Duty, Honour, who agree or believe in the hosts of phantoms and phantasmagories that make up the lefts ideas?

Sir, my concern is not whether God is on our side; my greatest concern is to be on God’s side, for God is always right.
Abraham Lincoln

 

Reverend Jesse Jackson and Newsweek also jumped on the gun grabbing blame the 2nd amendment for Mexican violence

batmasters0n Tuesday, March 31st at 4:42PM EDT (link)

Drug cartels can afford any type of advanced weaponry they choose American , Russian , French , Israeli whatever one cartel guy made Forbes list now it’s absurd to even consider the dope kingpin not being able to get any armament on earth with that much cash

in JAcksons own article LINK below he mentions UZIS and AK47 neither of which are American made.

They think violence and drugs will evaporate if we hand in our guns to uncle sam the left mentality on guns is almost childlike

Big guns making drug war tougher

http://www.suntimes.com/news/jackson/1502974,CST-EDT-jesse31.article

 

This got my attension

djemi Tuesday, March 31st at 5:38PM EDT (link)

http://www.theatlantic.com/doc/200903u/netanyahu

But I have to say I’m not surprised

“If I can’t shoot rabbits,then I can’t shoot fascist”
“With age, comes Wisdom, but only if you are paying Attention, son” my ‘Old Man’
RS Help files (h/t JLenardDetroit) Grassroots in Michigan
Moes Strategy

Interesting column, thanks for posting it. Oh, and watch this movie trailer...

Susannah Tuesday, March 31st at 6:38PM EDT (link)

Since this is a semi-open thread, I thought that people might find this interesting. It is the trailer to “Where the Wild Things Are”. It looks like a cool movie. I loved the book as a child. I posted this trailer in the comments section of my open thread on The Minority Report the other day, but I thought that some of you here might be interested in seeing it as well.

OK–we can now go back to discussing cigarrette bans and the Mexican drug war.

Great one Suzi, and btw, I never call thread jack and never ask for anyone to be banned

Mike gamecock DeVine Tuesday, March 31st at 7:43PM EDT (link)

unless they use profanity

Mike DeVine’s Examiner.com, Charlotte Observer and The Minority Report columns
“One man with courage makes a majority.” - Andrew Jackson

Good....

Susannah Tuesday, March 31st at 7:53PM EDT (link)

I’m glad that you like it. :-)

 
 

Thanks for the Wild Things clip Susannah

Kate_Shanahan Tuesday, March 31st at 8:13PM EDT (link)

I can’t wait. I read the book to my kids incessantly. Funny how some things trigger a soaring feeling.

I’ll probably be the oldest person at the movie.

Kate

“It is the American vice, the democratic disease which expresses its tyranny by reducing everything unique to the level of the herd.” Henry Miller

You're welcome.....

Susannah Tuesday, March 31st at 8:27PM EDT (link)

You won’t be the only adult there–I’ll definitely be there. I just loved that book.

 
 

Nice one

djemi Wednesday, April 1st at 7:00AM EDT (link)

nt

“If I can’t shoot rabbits,then I can’t shoot fascist”
“With age, comes Wisdom, but only if you are paying Attention, son” my ‘Old Man’
RS Help files (h/t JLenardDetroit) Grassroots in Michigan
Moes Strategy

 
 
 

The American Frontier

Kate_Shanahan Tuesday, March 31st at 8:23PM EDT (link)

From what I’ve seen, the warriors are a wimpy lot. I’m more comfortable with Reagan Democrats, or people like Evan Bayh and and couple of other Indiana politicians, or Sam Nunn, Zell Miller. That’s the kind of Republican value system that needs to be revived.

I realize the 2010 elections are important, but rebuilding the conservative movement and attracting people who are good street fighters, who aren’t afraid of what their friends or the country club will think of them is more important in a fight like this. This is no longer simple electioneering.

Kate

“It is the American vice, the democratic disease which expresses its tyranny by reducing everything unique to the level of the herd.” Henry Miller

 

Leave a Comment

 

Be respectful, or be banned. No Profanity.