« BACK  |  PRINT

RS

MEMBER DIARY

All politics are not local

Effect of D.C. party policies on the economy outweigh state policies and voting for “the man”

Even as a young Democrat in the 1980s, I disagreed with former Speaker of the House Tip O’Neill’s supposed axiom, no matter one’s definition of “local”. Then, as now, Democrats were facing an electorate suffering the consequences of policies enacted by their super-majorities in both houses of Congress and signed into law by their President. Clearly guilty beyond a reasonable doubt of economic and national security malfeasance based upon the relevant facts, one can understand the trial lawyer-like resort to avert the gaze of the jury to “local” facts irrelevant to the job description.

I voted the party as a Democrat from 1980-1998 because I favored liberal policies. Since my 2000 conservative epiphany, I have voted for Republicans because I favor conservative policies. The job of a member of Congress is to vote on issues that affect my wallet and national security.

I base my votes on how they will vote on issues that impact my life and that of the nation, rather than who I “like” as a person; campaign ads; so-called “smarts”; or other irrelevant factors usually even including ethics and character, except for executive positions as will discussed below. I also choose my barber based on how well he cuts my hair rather than on the quality of the patter.

In short, I vote the party, not the man. This is true at the national and state levels, but more so at the national level given the structural constraints of cities and states that can’t print money. Character doesn’t matter so much, it seems to me, in legislative positions given the publishing of laws and recorded votes. Character does matter in executive positions given the discretionary power of such offices.

That said, what matters most are the policies favored by parties as that is what affects our lives directly. Poor policies that wreck the economy or invite aggression from foreign enemies aren’t made more palatable when enacted by “good people” or those we like to watch in TV.

Moreover, I have always considered presidential and congressional elections to be much more important than state and local elections due to the determinative effect of national policies on the economy that dwarf the effects of policies of states, given the emasculation of state’s rights and the near all-encompassing power of the federal government since the 1930s.

Rare are the states that can avoid a recession brought on by failed economic policies emanating from Washington.

I said all that to say this: Nothing has been more important to me in politics since 2000 than that the failed liberal policies of the Democratic Party be utterly discredited in the electorate’s mind, once and for all, and that they be defeated at the polls.

I converted based on the success of Reagan’s monetary, economic, social and national security policies. When a liberal and a Democrat, it was always clear to me what both parties stood for. I was a Democrat because I was a liberal. When I was mugged by reality and became a conservative, I joined the GOP.

These facts are why it is so frustrating to me that so many Americans have had to be re-educated away from the obvious lie that there has been no difference between the parties except by degrees. I suspect this is the case because of the domination of American politics by the Democrats for most of our history. It has been the default party for too long. After all, it was good enough for Grandma and America has done all right, or so the thought process may go.

I would argue that America has done all right for so long due due to the conservative movement push backs made increasingly necessary by a JFK-less Democrat Party that started selling its soul to the Left soon after his assassination. Moreover, it seems we have reached a Big Government tipping point this past decade especially since ObamaDems tripled the deficit in two years.

Is the GOP perfect? No, and as a conservative I have to accept that all choices since Eve bit the apple are between lessers of evils. But liberals have made the Democratic Party their home for decades. They aren’t leaving it.

The GOP would be better with a responsible opposition. There has been no responsible opposition party for many years and I think the electorate is beginning to realize this after the past 20 months of rule by leftists.

The path to redemption for the Democratic Party can only be trod after a deserved liberal comeuppance election that is likely next Tuesday. We need good liberals. They are good at spotting fires that need putting out. Its too bad they didn’t declare victory 35 years ago on civil rights and the safety net for the truly needy, rather than going to seed.

The present duty is to rebuke them utterly. I will be voting, with but one or two exceptions for Republicans only, at the local, state and national levels. America can only begin to heal after the Democratic Party is rebuked.

NObama, NoDems…except Barnes

The Rule: Vote out the Ds!

Now, I hope my exception proves the rule, as I now lean toward voting for Democrat Roy Barnes for Georgia governor based upon his performance in the office before his re-election defeat soon after the turn of the century; lack of any great differences in policy proposals with Republican Nathan Deal; a general liking of divided government and the fact of a Republican General Assembly in the Peach State; and the fact that Deal has been in Washington for the past 28 years.

But I remain persuadable on this race, so committed am I to the proposition that party trumps the man. Feel free to persuade me.

Mike DeVine

“One man with courage makes a majority.” – Andrew Jackson

Charlotte ObserverThe Minority Report and Examiner.com archives

www.devinelawvista.com

COMMENTS

  • http://thesandsinstitute.org Vassar Bushmills

    I think I’ll come down there and vote for Barnes myself. I want my first vote for a Democrat to be illegal. (All my other firsts were.)

  • http://www.redstate.com/etcartman Kenny Solomon

    Good’un as always, Mike.

    Gonna pull a quote from you: “Poor policies that wreck the economy or invite aggression for foreign enemies…….”

    Here’s two perfect examples, although one says they’re local, that’s the last thing they are:

    ….and yes, these are the same two things I and others have been rambling on about for quite a while…… They’re here – don’t think they’re not.

    ICLEI — http://www.iclei.org — Local Governments For Sustainability.
    Sustainable Development ‘green’ mandates and legislation on a global basis through local means and apperances.

    ICR2P — http://www.responsibilitytoprotect.org
    The International Coalition For The Responsibility To Protect. — Global treaties enacted through elections and mandates on a national basis. The first pair to be enacted will be ‘The Small Arms Treaty’ and ‘The Convention On The Rights Of The Child’.

    Best fasten your seat belts. Between the Totalitarian Marxist Jihadists here in our country and the multitude of freedom-haters and anti-Americans around the world, the ride is gonna get pretty bumpy.

  • Castor

    1.Redistricting
    2.Redistricting
    3.Redistricting

  • penguin2

    Of course, this one particularly stands out in my mind as to the challenge and task we presently face.

    I said all that to say this: Nothing has been more important to me in politics since 2000 than that the failed liberal policies of the Democratic Party be utterly discredited in the electorate?s mind once and for all, and that they be defeated at the polls.

    Conscience is a voter’s guide for party or man…..

  • qixlqatl

    I’d walk down the streets of h@!! with dynamite in my pockets to get to the polls vote against him.

    If he has any redeeming qualities, I don’t know what they are.

    We can primary ND in ’14 if we must, redistricting won’t happen again until ’20.

  • Lloyd Davis

    now i see the wisdom of voting the party. When someone elects a “conservative Democrat”, no matter how conservative they might be, that means they will always caucus with the Democrats. The result is the nutcases like Reid, Pelosi, Obama, etc. will set the agenda with the so-called conservative being forced to abandon his beliefs to have any real power. It never fails. The people who thought they were getting a conservative end up with a tax-and-spender.

    The only choice is vote out all Democrats. They are not needed for this nation to survive.

    ………………………………………………………………………………………………………
    ?Never say sorry – it?s a sign of weakness?
    John Wayne

  • JSobieski

    5. Republican bench
    6. Perpetuating myths about conservative democrats at the state level, leading to more false unicorn . . er Blue Dog D’s in future Congresses.

  • JSobieski

    I wouldn’t vote D in any election higher than mayor. Of course living in Michigan, I don’t really have any credible D options.

    Vote R and you build our bench. Vote D and you build their bench.

  • http://www.examiner.com/x-1597-Charlotte-Law--Politics-Examiner Mike gamecock DeVine
  • http://www.examiner.com/x-1597-Charlotte-Law--Politics-Examiner Mike gamecock DeVine
  • http://www.examiner.com/x-1597-Charlotte-Law--Politics-Examiner Mike gamecock DeVine

    have time to do a more detailed explanation of my reasoning at this point. I remain persuadable on the matter.

  • http://www.examiner.com/x-1597-Charlotte-Law--Politics-Examiner Mike gamecock DeVine
  • http://www.examiner.com/x-1597-Charlotte-Law--Politics-Examiner Mike gamecock DeVine

    for apologizing to teachers for standing up to them in his first term, but Deal is from a family of teachers and his positions are rather weak as well.

  • http://www.examiner.com/x-1597-Charlotte-Law--Politics-Examiner Mike gamecock DeVine
  • http://www.examiner.com/x-1597-Charlotte-Law--Politics-Examiner Mike gamecock DeVine

    http://blogs.ajc.com/political-insider-jim-galloway/2010/10/22/poll-by-gop-firm-democrats-jim-marshall-sanford-bishop-on-verge-of-losing-seats/

    http://www.peachpundit.com/2010/10/22/new-polls-show-scott-and-keown-ahead/

    The huge lead against fake conservative Dem Marshall and that Bishop trails in 40% Black district. It warms my heart.

  • http://www.examiner.com/x-1597-Charlotte-Law--Politics-Examiner Mike gamecock DeVine

    Below is a recent AJC article outlining much of Roy’s accomplishments in his first term when Democrats still controlled the Legislature. He stood up to the teachers, cut property taxes and favored business-friendly policies. I also favored the new flag.

    Yes, he has sucked up to teachers in this campaign but budget realities will prevent any significant pay-off. Deal’s positions are not much better or worse than Barnes on education, transportation, jobs attraction and taxes.

    The fact of the GOP-dominated legislature temper any re-districting problems and having a Democrat governor may cause the GOP to be more conservative by contrast. Barnes is not a doctrinaire liberal by any stretch of the imagination.

    Deal is a creature of Washington. A legislator with no executive experience.

    All that said, I certainly agree that your reasons and many others justify a vote for the Republican.

    more later

  • http://www.examiner.com/x-1597-Charlotte-Law--Politics-Examiner Mike gamecock DeVine

    very selective and limited use of same. The arguments between Webster, Calhoun, Clay etc made me supportive of tariffs more generally for a new country with infant industries which doesn’t apply to us now and hasn’t since the 19th Century. I also agree that tariffs for national security purposes must be narrowly tailored, actually necessary and actually effective to be justified.

    more later

  • JSobieski

    Manufacturing output has increased in the US over the past 60 years faster than the economy generally. However, the productivity gains from automation result in job losses. Every year, good year or bad, the % of the labor pool with a manufacturing job decreases.

    Even China loses manufacturing jobs as they automate.

    What is true is that there are types of goods that we don’t make over here any more. Its also true that in the area of skilled tradespeople, we are in danger of becoming a third world country.

    There are advanced positions in tool & die making and a welding that continue to go unfilled in the US because we don’t have people to fill those jobs. All the “smart” people go to college, and too many of the rest just don’t invest in skills.

  • texasgalt

    Vote straight R. I already have. :-)

    Redistricting and the foot of the cross. . .

  • distantvoter

    Every Democrat victory anywhere gives Obama and the left a little more cover that the problem isn’t their policies. The more widespread the D-debacle, the better, the harder it is for them to spin. They should win NOTHING in red territory, and we need to flip lots of blue territory to the red.

  • rbdwiggins

    toward the elusive 290, but in the meantime, every seat gained increases the legitimacy and perception of mandate.

    Besides, I’d rather not fund a congressional staff with loyalties to a legislative agenda that seeks to undermine our Republic from within.

  • http://www.examiner.com/x-1597-Charlotte-Law--Politics-Examiner Mike gamecock DeVine

    is going to win anyway….smile