« BACK  |  PRINT

RS

MEMBER DIARY

Can Michigan show the country how to save itself?

One of the great things about the United States Constitution that few people realize and even fewer understand is the idea of federalism. On the most basic level federalism is the notion that there are distinct spheres of influence and responsibility between the federal and state governments. James Madison thought that that notion of federalism was crystal clear in the original document itself that he originally opposed a Bill of Rights. He believed the federal government was already limited by the fact that it could do only those things explicitly detailed in the document. John Hancock, Patrick Adams and others insisted and eventually the Bill of Rights was added with the federal perspective enshrined in the 10th Amendment.

The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people.

Aside from limiting the powers of the federal government – at least in theory, as Obamacare demonstrated – the federalist system does something quite extraordinary, or at least it’s supposed to. What is that thing? Experimentation! Fundamentally federalism has given us 50 different testing grounds for new ideas. The notion being that when one state does something – good or bad – the others will notice and act accordingly.

A big part of the problem with the federal government becoming involved in so many areas of our lives is that it kills one of the great legacies left to us by George Mason and friends. They understood that in most cases it is the people closest to problems who are best equipped to handle them. As true as that was with a population of 4 million people it is exponentially more so with one of 310 million.

As such, now that the elections are over and the march towards 2012 is on, now is the perfect time to take to experimenting. And in our center ring I would like to suggest Michigan step up and take a page out of Rahm Emanuel’s book that says “You never want a serious crisis to go to waste” and take a shot at leading the country in a different direction.

Why Michigan? Because the state is a basket case. Detroit has gotten so bad that the government is considering turning a quarter of the city into farmland! Importantly, unlike the brain dead voters in the People’s Republic of California, the people of Michigan have shown themselves to recognize bad ideas when they see them. After eight disastrous years of Jennifer Granholm, Michigan’s citizens voted 2 to 1 to make businessman Rick Snyder their Governor. In addition, they gave Republicans the majority of seats in the state legislature and they made the GOP the majority of their Congressional delegation.

Michigan is one of those states that is in the middle of the pack in terms of freedom – economic and otherwise. According to the Mercatus Center at George Mason University the state is #17 out of 50 states in terms of overall taxes although on corporate taxes it’s #48. It’s #22 on government spending and believe it or not, #1 in regulatory freedom. Overall, the state comes in at #15 overall in the Center’s 2010 Economic Freedom rankings. Given that middle tier of economic freedom, Michigan should be somewhere in the middle of the economic road relative to the rest of the country.

Alas it is not. The state has lost an average of 500,000 jobs in the last five years and today it sits with an unemployment rate of 13.5%, behind only real estate ravaged Nevada. As bad as Michigan is right now, it would have been exponentially worse had not Barack Obama’s imperial federal government taken billions of dollars from non-Michigander’s to give to General Motors and Chrysler and then in turn give the UAW unearned ownership in the companies they ruined – of course at the expense of secured creditors. Without Obama Michigan under the Democrats would have made some third world countries look like Germany by comparison. It may actually be the worst state in the country in terms of economic prospects. It is this chaos that creates the opportunity that Governor Snyder has in front of him.

He should seize upon this morass to demonstrate exactly what can be done when you let people vote with their feet. The first thing he and the new GOP legislature should do is eliminate all state and local income taxes. The second is to make Michigan a right to work state. Immediately after doing so the state should auction off all of that abandoned real estate in Detroit. (There are five states with no income taxes that are also right to work states: Florida, Nevada, South Dakota, Texas and Wyoming. Florida and Nevada have surging populations but have been decimated by federal housing policy. South Dakota has the second lowest unemployment rate in the country, Wyoming the 8th and Texas created more jobs over the last decade than all of the other states combined.)

Doing these things would immediately make Michigan a kind of job magnet – to the extent any company in America wants to create jobs given the Federal government’s leftist policies. The state’s relatively low level of regulation, combined with a reasonably priced (aka non-union) skilled labor force, low real estate prices and no income taxes would make for a very compelling locale for investors and corporations.

Governor Snyder has an opportunity to do for Michigan what Rudy Giuliani did for New York City in the 1990’s. He has the opportunity to take a state that has been turned from arguably the most powerful economic engine in the country into a banana republic by decades of mismanagement and turn it around. By essentially turning the state into an Enterprise Zone he will give companies a reason to invest in the state, he will give citizens a reason to stay, and like Giuliani’s New York, a Michigan turnaround can become a shining example for other states as they seek to climb out of their own economic swamps. The Founding Father’s federalism is alive and well and one can only hope that success in the Wolverine State will show Washington what might work on a national scale.

COMMENTS

  • dog_nut

    has the guts. He may fool me like C. Christie did, but I don’t think he has the cajones to make MI right to work. The oppressives here, including the two (dying) newspapers, would beat the drum every day. Remember how they did it to Engler with the mental hospitals? Big John didn’t blink, but Snyder is not an experienced pol like John. Hopefully Engler will put dummy Stabenow out as Senator in 2012.

    • gafisher

      … US. The voters have given Snyder the ability and (given the new legislative makeup) the authority to fix Michigan; now we need to supply the ambition and, dare we say it, audacity to do so if he lacks those attributes on his own. Getting out the vote was just the start; now we need to get out the word that we won’t settle for unnecessary compromise.

  • conservativecurmudgeon

    He put the uber-wonk and former DEMOCRAT Majority leader of the Michigan House Andy Dillion in as his Budget Director, and appointed Dick (yes, you heard his name correctly) Posthumous –the failed 2004 GOP Gubernatorial candidate in as his legislative liaison.

    If this is the sort of go-along-to-get along moldy-middle squishiness we can expect, it will be William Milliken all over again, who was a complete disaster for Michigan. Milliken, it is instructive to remember, was George Romney’s Lieutenant Governor, and was chosen to “balance” the 1968 ticket–idealogically and geographically. Romney, the former President of American Motors was a serious conservative. Milliken was a spineless pol from Traverse City, who got into politics because his daddy’s department store business bored him. When Romney went off to run Nixon’s HUD, MIlliken was promoted, and Michigan was never the same.

    Michigan suffered three horrible recessions under Milliken, who was overly circumspect to the riot-ravaged Detroit, and its loathsome Mayor-for-Life, the commie-symp Coleman Young. Together, they caved and caved and caved to UAW, the poverty pimps and proto-environmentalists, in those years, forever propping up the share price of GM and ticking off the wealth-earners. Milliken’s approach was if it’s good for government, it’s good for the people… Never the other way around.

    Milliken gave us a Department of Natural Resources that went from being the folks who managed the State Parks, to the folks who told you what you could do with your property, and when. Taxes went higher, and higher, and higher until his genius of a budget director, William Miller figured that the best way to make the budget balance was to end the fiscal year in October. Easy. Just get rid of two months.

    Snyder appears to be cut from the same bolt of cloth. The big difference, unlike the 1970′s,( upon which my hope rests), is that Lansing is now controlled completely by Republicans: Governor, House, Senate, Supreme Court, Attorney General and Secretary of State. This should embolden a Snyder, but I fear he will find a middle that clearly doesn’t exist…except at the Detroit Free Press.

    Snyder has already telegraphed that “Right to Work” is something that he might –or might not– sign, should it magically appear on his desk. But, he won’t stump for it. He’s not said specifically that increased revenue is off the table. And, of course, our “environment” remains sacrosanct.

    I hope and pray something big comes out of Lansing as you’ve outlined, but Snyder is too reminiscent of Milliken. Yeah, he’ll suggest getting rid of the Income Tax. Right after he appoints Peter Pan to the Commission on Aging.

    • JSobieski

      I think Snyder is a Milliken, but Dillon is no ordinary Democrat (there is a reason why he lost the D primary for governor) and Posthumous does know where the bodies are burried.

      Snyder might surprise people a tad, but that is because so many of us have almost no expectations.

  • michael_j_lambert

    but then I saw that there are 5 states without them. And since I was going to argue for keeping half the current lowest income tax, I suppose my proposal would actually fit with your suggestions.

    Lots of people in Detroit and Flint would get mad about making Michigan a right to work state, but seeing as Detroit and Flint are pretty much the best examples of “driven into the ground city” in the world, I don’t think their opinions have much merit.