« BACK  |  PRINT

RS

MEMBER DIARY

The bailout bill, tipping points and conservatism

The fork in the road is before us, and conservatism is the harder road to take

“In the end they will lay their freedom at our feet and say to us, ‘Make us your slaves, but feed us.’” Dosteovsky’s Grand Inquisitor

In accepting the bailout bill, both Main Street and Wall Street have laid their freedom at the feet of the government. In my view, the bill will long be viewed as a tipping point for America, the point at which Main Street traded liberty for financial security, and Wall Street traded short-term solvency for future regulation of an unprecedented scope and intensity.


However, as Malcolm Gladwell pointed out in his book of the same name, a tipping point can be positive or negative – it is simply the level at which the momentum for change becomes unstoppable. Which change will it be? Will it be one of even more regulation and slavery, or, *if the bailout fails *and the citizens of the United States finally come to realize that market stability and financial security cannot be purchased, even for $700 billion, will it be the change in the form of the clarion call of Barry Goldwater?

“I have little interest in streamlining government or in making it more efficient, for I mean to reduce its size. I do not undertake to promote welfare, for I propose to extend freedom. My aim is not to pass laws, but to repeal them. It is not to inaugurate new programs, but to cancel old ones that do violence to the Constitution or that have failed their purpose, or that impose on the people an unwarranted financial burden. I will not attempt to discover whether legislation is “needed” before I have first determined whether it is constitutionally permissible. And if I should later be attacked for neglecting my constituents “interests, ” I shall reply that I was informed that their main interest is liberty and that in that cause I am doing the very best I can.” Barry Goldwater

As I was listening to analysis of the bailout bill on Bloomberg Radio, one commentator said something I will not soon forget. He noted that Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac were not the only government sponsored enterprises – in reality, *all banks *are GSE’s. Highly regulated, with the FDIC as a permanent backstop, banks are simply not independent. And that comment got me thinking.

We have come to a point in America where no one is responsible for their decisions. No one. Not the homeowners who do not pay their mortgages, not the Ivy League geniuses who came up with mortgage backed securities, not the rating agencies that rated them as AAA paper, not the GSE’s who guaranteed them, and not the banks that bought them. Gains have been privatized, and losses have been socialized.

Through this bailout bill, and Social Security, and Medicare, and Medicaid, and unemployment insurance, and welfare, and housing assistance, and mortgage interest deductibility, and a host of other federal, state and local programs, every individual in America is a government sponsored enterprise. Every last one of us. The dream of the socialists and communists that run the Democrat party has been fully realized, and they are now aided and abetted by the votes in Congress of the last defenders of freedom – the Republican Party. The damage that has just been done is incalculable and will only be reversed by citizens not yet born. The premise that irresponsibility should be subsidized has just been accepted – the only things left to work out are the details.

“A democracy cannot exist as a permanent form of government. It can only exist until the voters discover that they can vote themselves money from the public treasure. From that moment on the majority always votes for the candidates promising the most money from the public treasury, with the result that a democracy always collapses over loose fiscal policy followed by a dictatorship. The average age of the world’s great civilizations has been two hundred years. These nations have progressed through the following sequence: from bondage to spiritual faith, from spiritual faith to great courage, from courage to liberty, from liberty to abundance, from abundance to selfishness, from selfishness to complacency from complacency to apathy, from apathy to dependency, from dependency back to bondage” Alexander Tyler, writing about the fall of the Athenian Republic.

Ironically, by accepting the bailout bill, the American people actually thought they were voting themselves money from the public treasury. Through this “asset purchase plan”, the markets would stabilize, credit would flow, and our jobs and 401(k)’s would be saved. And why shouldn’t we do this? The Greatest Generation now votes to bankrupt their grandchildren through entitlements, the narcissistic baby boomers self-righteously demand the public’s money to satisfy their altruistic desires, and the upcoming generation expects to either start their first job at a six-figure salary or move back in with Mom. Why shouldn’t those who have been pulling the wagon for so long use the public’s money to ensure their security?

“…from dependency back to bondage.”

I tremble for my country, and my family. I will spend the next few days praying that John McCain will, finally, heed Barry Goldwater’s words and issue a challenge and not the outline of another program. I will pray that John McCain points the finger for the economic crisis at the government, where it belongs, and points out that Barack Obama’s Marxist philosophy and life’s work – what little work there is – have prepared him only to finally close the lock to the golden chains that now encircle us.

May God Almighty help us all.

COMMENTS

  • speciallist

    Here is one of many things we can control immediately…we must protect America from…

    The Death of Journalism…We the people Must fight against the Old media…call out their lies, loud and often..

    the King is Dead…long live the King

  • c17wife

    God almighty help us indeed.
    Thing is, I think he may have lost patience with us and is ready to let us reap what we have sown.
    I’m committed to praying everyday for this election.
    I am not praying for John McCain to win this thing though. I’m praying that God’s will would be done across this nation, in every race.
    It is my belief that God would have a remain a free society, complete with personal responsibility. That is also my prayer.

    • Jack_Savage

      You are exactly right – God’s will be done. And when I think it actually might, I shudder even more.

  • speciallist

    NEW YORK (AP) ? Wall Street tumbled Monday, joining a selloff around the world as fears grew that the financial crisis will cascade through economies globally despite bailout efforts by the U.S. and other governments. The Dow Jones industrials skidded more than 400 points and fell below 10,000 for the first time in four years, while the credit markets remained under strain.

    The markets have come to the sobering realization that the Bush administration’s $700 billion rescue plan won’t work quickly to unfreeze the credit markets, and that many banks are still having difficulty gaining access to cash. That’s caused investors to exit stocks and move money into the relative safety of government debt.”

    “Over the weekend, governments across Europe rushed to prop up failing banks. The German government and financial industry agreed on a $68 billion bailout for commercial-property lender Hypo Real Estate Holding AG, while France’s BNP Paribas agreed to acquire a 75 percent stake in Fortis’s Belgium bank after a government rescue failed.”

    • Jack_Savage

      Can you imagine the howling that would have occurred if this happened and the bailout had not passed?

      Can you imagine the surge in the polls John McCain would have had if he had said “The bailout will not help the markets, the taxpayers did not cause this problem, and I refuse to vote to throw their good money after bad, unlike Barack Obama and the Democrats.”?

      • birdmojo

        This is a soft landing compared to what we would have had without the bailout.

        • Jack_Savage

          Can you imagine the howling that would have occurred if this happened and the bailout had not passed?

          Can you imagine the surge in the polls John McCain would have had if he had said “The bailout will not help the markets, the taxpayers did not cause this problem, and I refuse to vote to throw their good money after bad, unlike Barack Obama and the Democrats.”?

          • izoneguy

            Hide your women & children! Obama is riding into town with his tax hikes ablazing! The dows performance is due to the fact that investors are folding their hands until Nov 5. If Obama gets elected then get ready for all financial hell to break loose.
            Dow on Nov 5th – my prediction – 6666

          • speciallist

            n/p

          • izoneguy

            n/t

          • Jack_Savage

            A think this is a “perfect storm”, and the major component (which no one will talk about) is that the financial sector and world economy is in the process of digesting and discounting an Obama presidency (which they, ironically, helped cause).

            I truly believe that this would have happened, bailout or no bailout. The effect of the $700 billion will be minimal, but the effects of the precedent and principle behind it will be with us for many years to come.

          • birdmojo

            People used to know when I was being sarcastic.

            I think that the bailout is bad for several reasons (and that the Republicans should have thought that the bailout was bad for a handful more):

            1) As Zoot pointed out in another thread, this was a perfect opportunity for McCain to differentiate himself. Imagine if he had come out and played the populist card of “no bailouts for bad business decisions. We didn’t bail you out when you bought pets.com, we won’t bail out Wall Street when they bought mortgage-backed securities!” It could have been a great way to distance himself from the White House, he could have run against Congress… ah, well.

            2) Personally, I think that we are going to have a constriction (“wringing out the rot”) with or without a bailout. I would have prefered one without because, hey. Those are my tax dollars you’re throwing after bad… and we’re going to have it whether or not we throw money at it.

            3) The Moral Hazard issue isn’t only the whole privitize the profits, socialize the losses thing, it’s the whole training the American People to see the Federal Government as the thing that will help you. He ain’t your momma, he’s your uncle.

            But we’ve been through this a hundred times.

            Things will be bad at some point in the future.
            Things will be good at some point in the future.
            Keep thinking “This too shall pass” and you’ll be okay.

          • JSobieski

            it would be a Thompson-Palin ticket

          • Herodotus

            P.S. When did you get so much faith in the Federal government?

          • Jack_Savage

            This is a “soft landing” – I’m using that one. I am the one who needs to get the sarcasm meter re-calibrated.

            I appreciate your confidence and sage advice, as well as the points you made. However, it seems that for me the only thing that is going to pass in the next few weeks are these boulders making their way around my digestive system.

          • Uma_Richie

            I obviously don’t have a knowledge of economics beyond the intro course, but isn’t this part of the whole correction process that we needed?

          • birdmojo

            Could prevent martial law.

          • Jack_Savage

            And after it is over, the little matter of taxpayer-owned bad debt will need to be settled.