« BACK  |  PRINT

RS

MEMBER DIARY

According to Sherrod Brown, Union Reform is Unchristian

Sherrod Brown (D-OH) isn’t merely the most extreme Progressive in the U.S. Senate, he’s also a religious scholar. Week in and week out, Sherrod preaches the Gospel of Progressivism: Greater love hath no man than he who gives generously from his neighbor’s purse.

Sherrod delivered a stirring speech on the Senate floor during the smear campaign against public union reform in Ohio:

In order to meet the week’s quota, Sherrod was obligated to say government union reform goes “against workers on behalf of the richest people in our country.” Too invested to stop at his usual class warfare, Sherrod had the audacity to attack Governor Kasich, Governor Walker, and Governor Christie for failing to meet what he claims as a Catholic standard.

Not to put too fine a point on it, Sherrod’s sermon about “fairness, and equality, and egalitarianism” has nothing to do with any of these things – and everything to do with union power.

This clip only gets more outrageous with additional context: Sherrod Brown is an ardent supporter of government-funded abortion. Paraphrasing Sherrod, I’m not gonna judge his faith – but I’m appalled at my senator’s willingness to cite Catholic literature for a partisan attack on conservatives. A certain carpenter would have something to say about the blameless guy throwing the first stone.

I don’t recall adherence to the AFL-CIO line as part of my Methodist confirmation. My maternal grandparents’ Lutheran church has never mentioned unsustainable government spending as a moral obligation (though in fairness I’ve only been there for Christmas Eve services).

Help me out, Catholic readers: Does Sherrod have a point, or is this just another low in a career of union pandering?

Transcript of the above C-SPAN 2 clip:

SHERROD BROWN: The Bible talks a lot about poverty, and a lot about fairness, and equality, and egalitarianism, if you will, and for them to go against workers on behalf of the richest people in our country – and that’s really what they’re doing in the governor’s office in Columbus, in Madison, in, in Trenton and other places. It runs counter, at least to my faith; I’m not gonna judge their faith, they can – they worship what god they worship, and they read what scripture they read – but, when you look at what, what my faith means, and whether – I’m, I’m, as I say, I’m a Lutheran, I’m not a Catholic, but you look at Leo the 13th and, and, and what he said about what Catholicism means for workers and fairness, uh, you know it’s, it’s, it’s uh, point, match, whatever – point, set, match.

Cross-posted from Big Government and that hero.

COMMENTS

  • acat

    this kind of stupid to go unpunished?

    I’m pointing this out because you keep asking the few libertarian-minded folk on Red State to defend the actions of Ron Paul. This guy is talking in the name of your religion, referencing your holy book.

    Your turn.

    Mew

  • kipling

    He makes a vague reference to the Bible, quotes the leftist talking points of fairness, equality, and egalitarianism, and mentions as proof Leo 13th.

    Mr. Brown is blowing smoke. He cites only religious doctrines that support his liberal state, which he worships as a god.

    If he wants to claim a Biblical mandate then let us get down to brass tacks. Otherwise he is blowing smoke and knows nothing.

  • Menlo

    Based on the quote, it seems he can’t put together a coherent thought or a complete sentence.

    I’d be content to simply be able to figure out the subject and verb.

  • runner12

    Yes, the Bible speaks about giving too the poor as Christians and individuals, but forced giving and redistribution is not found in the Bible anywhere. In fact, the Bible is all about free will.

    Secondly, the Bible never speaks about “fairness.” It speaks about justice and truth. There is a big difference between these concepts. Jesus also stated in Matthew 26:11 that the “poor will always be with us.” So the social justice utopia promoted by the Left is not backed by Christian teaching. This is not to say that Christians do not have a responsibility to help the poor, we do. But it is to be done from the heart and out of compassion for our fellow man, not because the government says so.

    Christianity is all about personal responsibility to both God and man, based on a personal faith.