« BACK  |  PRINT

RS

FRONT PAGE CONTRIBUTOR

Farewell to the Architect of the ‘Slow Bleed’ Strategy

An Ex-Marine Departs This World Long After Having Departed the Corps

Here are my few brief, and probably socially unacceptable, words about a Congressman and Ex-Marine who passed away yesterday: John Murtha. In the interest of time, space, and not prolonging nausea, I won’t delve into this corrupt late Congressman’s role in ABSCAM, nor will I spend time lamenting, on behalf of the people of his district, the loss of the Pork King of Congress as their benefactor and representative.

I won’t even go too far into the Haditha Incident, in which Murtha (a military veteran who had long since cast his lot with those who believe that murder, atrocity, and shame are the rule of the military, not the exception) went onto national television, armed with nothing but a deep-seated hatred of America and her military (in place of, you know, facts), and accused several United States Marines of the cold-blooded murder of Iraqi civilians.

I want to use the little digital ink I’ll give the undeserving Murtha on a far worse issue.

Let’s journey back to February 2007. At this time, the U.S. was approaching its 4th anniversary in Iraq, the military death toll had passed 3,000, and Iraqi civilians were caught in the middle of a furious sectarian battle that had been kicked into overdrive by the bombing of the Golden Mosque in Samarra.

General David Petraeus had just been tapped to take over Multinational Force-Iraq, and was ramping up a “surge” in troops there in preparation for the implementation of his counterinsurgency doctrine in the theater — a comprehensive overhaul of Iraq war strategy that would ultimately prove to be incredibly successful. Democrats in the House had just passed a non-binding resolution condemning the “surge” in troops (Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid called this a “symbolic victory in the fight over the Iraq War,” despite the fact that the Senate version of the resolution fell 4 votes short of cloture. Secretary of Defense Robert Gates said “It’s pretty clear that a resolution that in effect says that the general going out to take command of the arena shouldn’t have the resources he thinks he needs to be successful certainly emboldens the enemy and our adversaries”).

This was the setting for perhaps the most insidious move of Jack Murtha’s career, if not his life: the design and introduction of what he called a “Slow Bleed Strategy” designed to deprive soldiers, sailors, airmen and Marines in Iraq of the supplies — bullets, armor, etc. — they needed not only to push forward in Iraq, but to keep themselves alive while there. The rationale behind Murtha’s aptly — if appallingly — named Slow Bleed Strategy was that, if the supply chain to our troops in combat could be forced to dry up, enough of America’s warfighters would be killed in action that President Bush would have no choice but to “redeploy” our military men and women out of Iraq and back to America.

That’s right: Murtha became one of the only leaders in the history of warfare to advocate, rather than fight to the death to prevent, the drying up of his own military’s lanes of resupply. Not even Benedict Arnold attempted an act so  insidious that it was more worthy of an enemy sleeper agent than a sitting Member of Congress.

Murtha announced this Slow Bleed Strategy in mid-February of ’07, announcing at a press conference that House Democratic leaders had joined forces with several leftist “anti-war” groups (such as the “Win without war coalition,” “Americans against the escalation of the war in Iraq,” and others) in a combined legislative- and multimillion-dollar advertising campaign whose purpose would be to undermine the President’s authority as Commander in Chief of the nation’s fighting forces by “limiting the administration’s options” through the passage of legislation and the inclusion of several stipulations for receipt of funding in appropriations bills.

In other words, as mentioned above, Murtha’s plan was to force the President to withdraw our troops from Iraq, either immediately or after thousands more had been killed due to a termination of resupply efforts.

Jack Murtha used the fractured home front to push his agenda of ending a war he disagreed with at any cost — both human and political. As a leader within the party in control of the legislative branch of government, he sought to “slowly bleed” the war effort until it was dry of funds with which to purchase bullets, body armor, and other supplies, while also seeking to whip the American public into such an “anti-war,” anti-military frenzy that the dwindling number of surviving Iraq war veterans would be even more reviled than his fellow Vietnam veterans were in their day.

That, more than AbScam, billions in Pork, or even the reckless and irresponsible (if not treasonous) Haditha accusation, is what Jack Murtha should be remembered for, and it is why I personally, along with many, many others, will not lose one moment of sleep, nor waste one breath in false condolence or respect, over the loss of such a “man.”

Get Alerts

COMMENTS

  • http://www.erickerickson.org Erick Erickson

    I agree with you.

  • ChicaGOP

    Murtha died from complications of a cut intestine. In other words, he died as he lived…. full of crap.

    • http://www.erickerickson.org Erick Erickson

      We do want some amount of respect for the dead around here.

      • Scope

        that he showed our military members and leaders, and our former President, which is exactly none. The tears and sadness can be reserved for his Progressive anti-war activists, and, thankfully he even failed them..

      • ChicaGOP

        …that every death is tragic. That damage he caused as a mouthpiece of our enemies certainly resulted in the deaths of our deployed men and women in uniform, and his vocal lack of respect for their sacrifice is a matter of record.

        I’m sure peope loved him. But I’m equally sure that better men and women have died because of him. Therefore his passing is only a “tragedy” in the abstract, as far as I’m concerned.

        • lockedandloaded

          Years ago while beginning a discussion of the Greek stage in a theatre class, the prof posed the question whether different deaths were in fact tragedy, or just a pathetic end. Very thought-provoking, esp. when considering the death of a young child, for instance. The prof wanted to make the point that many things don’t rise to the level of tragedy that the Greek dramas would endear.
          For me, it’s quite easy to see Murtha’s death as a pathetic end. However, the tragedy remains: the voters of Pennsylvania sent this cretin back to Washington after his betrayal of the honorable men and women who would come to their defense.

          “I’m gratified because of the things we’re able to do working with the people in this congressional district who keep sending me back, regardless of what I say.”
          Jack Murtha

          • ChicaGOP

            I learned that the classical defintion of tragedy is the downfall or death of an innocent or noble figure; that’s why Hamlet’s death is tragic and Claudius’ is not – and I think Murtha definitely fit the profile of the latter.

          • ChicaGOP

            I learned that the classical defintion of tragedy is the downfall or death of an innocent or noble figure; that’s why Hamlet’s death is tragic and Claudius’ is not – and I think Murtha definitely fit the profile of the latter.

    • gemimail

      As I understand it, while preforming gall bladder surgery, the surgeon apparently nicked his intestine. This was preformed at Bethesda Naval Hospital presumably by a Naval or Marine surgeon. Given his actions towards the military perhaps someone in the surgery room decided to make sure he did no further harm to the military. While unlikely, it is not beyond the realm of possibility.

      • momofthecastle

        ..that get innocent folks (read “doctor”) in trouble. While I am not losing much sleep over his death — I don’t watch the news, so I wouldn’t have know but for this site — Let’s not say things that someone opposed to our point of view might take to the news, and thus cause an investigation into a doctor’s mistake. They have a tough enough time already.

        • Scope

          but, it only took a matter of a few hours for the Dem Rep Cohn from Tenn. to blast this very personal and private medical info on Fox, and say that it was malpractice. That was his argument for why Tort reform was not a good idea. So, to say his death may not have been an accident, as egregious as it is, is not much worse than turning a few hour old death into a political cause.

        • edwlstr

          a lady down the road had the same end. I’m really sorry she died. It is a routine operation and has routine errors like both these people experienced. I will miss the lady.

  • makemyday

    we could get the surgeon involved reassigned to the WH?

    • america1st
  • http://andrightlyso.com/ civil_truth

    Thanks for fleshing this out. Haditha was bad enough, but “Slow Bleed” was murderous malice for personal and political gain. Hard to find any mitigation when Murtha is judged before the bar of history – and he’d better have a good defense attorney for his appearance before the heavenly Judge.

    • itrytobenice
  • penguin2

    about or remember. The media covers up everything because they are of the same bent toward this country. To see America go down.

    Thank you for reminding us of the real damage from afar that the man did. As you said, it was the most grievous of all.

    • theBlur

      And call him a champion of the military on the Hill. Funny, from what I gather, most retired Marines I know have nothing but disgust for the man. Like some have commented, it is usually not nice to celebrate the demise of a living human being, but not unlike those videos of the terrorist Taliban in Afghanistan getting drilled from a mile away, in his case I am not unhappy.

  • RedBeard

    Excellent analysis, and of a critical subject not well covered, if at all covered, by our beloved mainstream media.

    Murtha was a thoroughly disreputable character from start to finish. No amount of polishing can give this man a positive legacy.

    While not as crucial as the subject at hand, here is a video that might be useful just to show Murtha’s arrogance and utter disregard for rules, decorum, and representative government:

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ywgUCdefSW8

  • dpddj

    the surgeon at the National Naval Medical Center, in Bethesda, Md. a thank you card for doing those servicemen and women a deed that may offset some of the damage Murtha did to them and our country. I have more sympathy for the guilt the surgeon is feeling than I do for him. Having said all that, my condolences go to his family.

    • Duke

      I suspect he’s out lawyer-shopping about now.

    • tankertodd

      I think of that scene in the new “V” series where the doctor takes out the bad guy on the table – he whispers to him “greetings from the Fifth Column” before slipping him the poison.
      Yeah it’s mean but this guy was a BAD guy. A bad American. A bad person. The country is truly better off with Murtha dead unfortunately.

    • mbecker908

      At least as much – more actually – than any of the brass than that either Murtha or Kerry came back from Vietnam with. At least he did something worthwhile and – IMO – heroic.

      Interesting that Kerry and Murtha have a total of five purple hearts and not a day in the dispensary let alone a night in the hospital.

      • nessa

        …scumbag. I know one young man who wouldn’t go to the medics after his vehicle was blown up under him because he picked the small piece of shrapnel out of his back himself. He said getting a PH for that would cheapen the award.

        Kerry was scheduled to tour the HQ in Afghanistan while I was there. The helicopter he and sound bite Biden were on was forced to make an emergency landing in a snow storm. You have no idea how it pained me to send out the QRF to pick them up. Personally, if MG (now LTG) Rodriguez hadn’t been on it with them I’d have opted for leaving them there. The Taliban who lived at the foot of the mountain would have given them a ride, hehe, a ride to somewhere.

        • mbecker908
  • dpddj

    the surgeon at the National Naval Medical Center, in Bethesda, Md. a thank you card for doing those servicemen and women a deed that may offset some of the damage Murtha did to them and our country. I have more sympathy for the guilt the surgeon is feeling than I do for him. Having said all that, my condolences go to his family.

  • angryred

    But I just can’t be happy that he is dead, it is very un-Christian certainly not very pro life.

    Say what you will about the man, death is not kind, even to people like Murtha.

    Now it is between him and his maker-

    That being said, what is Pennsylvania’s policy for replacing him? Election/appointment? I’d like to know where we are, moving forward.

    • E Pluribus Unum

      Benedict Murtha had had his way to some extent. the Democrats GREATLY hindered the war effort by carrying out the Slow Bleed doctrine. It is folly not to recognize that a notable number of patriots died – our young soldiers – who otherwise would not have. I’m guessing it’s in the mid-to high hundreds, as in 500-750. That’s 500 families in America deprived of their son, husband, and brother, all because of this low-down dirty thief.

      Benedict Murtha, while still alive, was a continuing and significant threat to our soldiers in Afghanistan. So I submit that welcoming his death is profoundly pro-life.

      As to un-Christian, an argument can be made for that, but I believe it’s a myopic argument.

      • angryred

        I just can’t dance on any one’s grave. I dont care who-

        • E Pluribus Unum

          Just so you know the motivations of those who choose otherwise. It’s not normally my style. I even held my tongue on Teddy Kennedy, at least in public. But this guy…..

        • mbecker908

          But I had a chat with Franz and was a strong proponent of yellow snow.

          • realskinny

            Spreading some used Budweiser on his grave sounds appropriate.

          • mbecker908
        • rightwingmom52

          Being a Christian, sometimes I struggle with praying for my enemies, including Obama, left-wingers, terrorists, abortionists, Hollywood, etc. (not necessarily in that order). Often I have to send up a prayer seeking forgiveness when I fall short of doing so, but I liken the deaths of Ted Kennedy and John Murtha to Tiller the Killer. I simply believe that in the long run many more lives are saved by their deaths (and I’m not justifying Tiller’s murder). While I feel sympathy for their grieving loved ones, the bulk of my sympathy goes to the soldiers, unborn babies and others who were adversely affected through no fault of their own by the choices Kennedy, Murtha and Tiller made. I can’t help but feel the world is a better place without them and I have no doubt about the justice they will meet in the hereafter.

  • vrwcnut

    that a similar policy adopted by the Dems caused the fall of South Viet Nam?
    Briefly, our “Peace with honor” deal stipulated that the NVA would stay out and that if that proviso were violated, we would again help the South. In point of fact when the NVA began their final offensive, our Congress cut off all financial support for the South which quickly collapsed. A form of victory for the Dems.
    Maybe that’s where our departed hero came up with his slow bleed strategy.

    • RedBeard

      My buddies who never came home paid the ultimate price for a failed political agenda. So did more than 58,000 others, America’s finest, turned into pawns.

      Never again, we swore. But here we are, trying to repeat the mistakes of history. ;-(

  • ratziel

    The U.S.M.C. has a saying that there is no such thing as an ex-marine , only former marines. As a former marine myself , I think Murtha definitely deserves the title “Ex-marine”.

  • itrytobenice

    As a nation, we should reserve honor for those who have shown honor.

    Murtha doesn’t make the cut.

  • winterhawk

    was a terrible man. Driven by glory for himself.

  • peg_c

    I didn’t attend the funeral, but I sent a nice letter saying that I approved of it.

  • thomasgipper

    The Father told Colonel Brighton in Lawrence of Arabia, “nil nisi bonum” (don’t speak ill of the dead). That rule should ordinarily apply, to private individuals and to political opponents with whom we have reasonable disagreement. But for a public official, who was a mean, nasty bully (easily seen by anyone watching Murtha’s tv interviews with eyes-open), who engaged in fraud & corruption, and who sold out our troops’ safety to score political points, the rule can and should be suspended. The public should not be deceived, even for a day, as to what this man was.

  • qixlqatl

    Speaks untold volumes of his lack of character. Every Marine I have any contact with speaks of him with the same disgust, and I know and have known quite a few Marines. Further condemnation is unnecessary.

  • http://pocketchangeproductions.net/ anotherindyfilmguy

    Does not necessarily mean lie to cover up the evil that they did in their lives. There is no love for a man who was such a traitor as this man was. Not because there was no love for fellow humans but because by his actions he has driven all possible positive emotions from the hearts of those whom he has betrayed.

  • JadedByPolitics

    Reid and Feingold and many more Democrats. Democrats have always HATED our military don’t EVER FORGET IT

    • http://jeffemanuel.net Jeff Emanuel

      ..that, even with the current knowledge that the Petraeus Plan worked like a charm, he’d still oppose it for purely political reasons.

      • JadedByPolitics

        American HATING monsters! They have spent the last 50 years trying to DESTROY our military and by doing so our country and the fact that ANYONE would vote for the destruction of our country sickens me.

        WE now have the internet, FOX News and talk radio and in such there should be NO reason that anyone would EVER vote for a Democrat unless they HATE their country!

  • http://www.scragged.com petrarch

    Murtha was a scoundrel, no question about it, and we are better off as a nation with him no longer holding power or office.

    Regarding the “Slow Bleed” strategy, as disloyal as it was to our serving soldiers, was that not at least somewhat in keeping with the Constitutional design as to how our government would work regarding declarations of war? Congress declares war; thereafter, the President alone is commander in chief. But Congress still holds the purse-strings, and if they want to stop a war that the President wants to continue, the Constitutionally appropriate means for them to do that would, indeed, be to defund it.

    Now, the underhanded way in which Murtha went about it was disingenuous and murderous. But the basic idea of Congress refusing to appropriate the necessary funds to carry on a war that it wants stopped, would seem to be correct Constitutionally, would it not?

    I rather doubt that the Founders ever thought the issue would seriously arise, or that neither Congress nor the President would be willing to back down. In the event, it was Congress that backed down; the soldiers got their money and equipment, as they should have.

    • mbecker908
    • vrwcnut

      but terribly wrong in timing. Certainly Congress has a Constitutional role in balancing the President’s power. But rather than posturing after our sons and daughters are in harm’s way, they should make their stand on principle when the deployment is proposed. Congress hasn’t had the necessary personal equipment to actually declare war since 1941 so they should either quietly discourage the Pres or deny funds in advance.
      Once the troops hit the beach, its game on till the opposition taps out.

      Once upon a time (bPC) it was, “Nuke ‘em till they glow then shoot ‘em in the dark.” Psalm 144:1

    • silverwolf

      Hmm

  • traversecityconservative

    I’m right there with you on this one. When I heard about it, I thought, “who cares?” and that was my nicest reaction. Kudos for his military service but that’s all.

  • docbratton

    Jack Murtha was a pork-barrelling inter-generational thief at best. A traitor at worst. If he’s buried in Arlington, perhaps they can put next to the other shovel-ready project.

  • bobojake
  • dudette

    —and all because fatso Murtha hated for the military. I am from that town Oceanside where the families kept vigil outside Camp Pendleton and it was a disaster for the men & their families and cost them financially as well as in other ways. Murtha can make sense of it all with his Maker, I for one am glad that he and Kennedy that gin soaked sack of Bandini are gone to fairer pastures and not hurting us anymore.

  • rick554

    This ex-MARINE , along with John Kerry , gave political cover to the cut-and-runners back in 1974 to vote to abandon the South Viets. With his vote ,he condemned millions to an agonizing death ,some of whom were my friends. My disgust for him is decades old.
    My Son was in Iraq when I heard about his “slow bleed” plan. I trust the LORD handle this person now.

  • qurys

    I was surprised at all the condolences I heard yesterday. Perhaps a personal condolence if you are acquainted with the family is in order….but beyond that I am surprised (well maybe not really surprised!) at the inability of our leaders to point to a person’s political “contributions” and give him a fair and accurate “eulogy”. If we cannot tell the truth when they are dead…we certainly cannot when they are alive.

  • miroco

    I have always tried to pretend at least a modicum of respect for even the worst of those who have passed. The dead are still dead, I adopted this philosophy for the living. Sometimes I make exceptions, this traitor is one of those.

  • leehazel

    This is something I was never able to get my arms around. Murtha was a United States Marine. These men and women make up a fighting force almost unique in history. They certainly occupy a deep and abiding place in the hearts of those of us who have known or are now engaged in combat.

    The instance that you cite as Murtha’s “Slow Bleed” Strategy should have resulted in charges of Treason being brought. Even Congressional “immunity” can only stretch so far. His later involvement in the Haditha incident just underlines his Treasonous activities as regards our military personnel.

    Frankly, I hope he roasts for eternity. I would even go there to light the fire.

    Murtha epitomizes the need for Term Limits or some other effective way to eliminate this type of criminal from our legislative halls. This is needed in some form when the public voting mechanism is broken.

    PC is Thought Control
    LEE

  • taliesin319

    When I was a child I asked my father why he was not going to the wake of a neighbor, He said, : Mr. C was a brutal, unfeeling man particularly in regard to his family. He said only women would be there and they would go only to comfort his long suffering wife and children. He then said, remember this, dying never improved anyone. A tyrant alive is a tyrant dead. Murtha’s death will not improve him but at least he can no longer harm our defenders.