« BACK  |  PRINT

RS

MEMBER DIARY

Upton Talks Tough, But He Has To Be As Tough As Sarah

Fred Upton got the post he wanted in the House, as Chair of the House Energy and Commerce Committee. Boehner gave him the job over massive objections from conservatives. Perhaps if Upton cries, he will convince some of them that he’s going to be a real stalwart.

JGillman of RightMichigan voices the concern that so many are thinking. Now that Upton got the post over all the objections, will he do what needs doing?

Judging from some of his responses to criticism, I’d say that’s a definite no.

He said he was going to Washington to repeal that healthcare law, then he agreed to support the insertion of Pitt’s Protect Life Act, and Smith’s No Taxpayer Funding for Abortion Act into the law. That’s called nibbling around the edges. The way the genius Republican leadership has been going, if the acts do end up being inserted, they will become known as the Stupak amendment for criminy’s sake. Why in the world would you say you were going to repeal it, but first change it a little to make it better, then repeal it? Does that make sense? Not only that, but Upton’s record on abortion is abysmal, so this move is actually a sop to the conservatives, because Upton is a liberal, not a conservative.

So, forgive me if I have no faith in him. The problem is, his very state is at the center of one of the largest battles for survival it has ever seen. He needs boot camp, and he needs it fast.

If everyone is feeling calmed by the Republicans taking over Michigan, let me jar you. There are far too many of those Republicans that buy into the Climate Change/Global Warming hoax, and thanks to their bipartisan efforts, Granholm has pinned the state down to the most destructive energy paths we have ever seen, and we don’t have the money to comply with it.

What are we doing here?

Fred, pal, listen. I don’t believe you have it in you to be tough on the EPA after your family’s company Whirlpool got such a tidy sum helping us all green the planet. I don’t believe you are strong enough to fight the Sierra Club, and the Environmental Law people and on and on. You are not a real “get your hands dirty” kind of guy, and your tough talk isn’t fooling anybody. But if you really want to save your career, your state and your country, you’ll find the strength.

Do you know what you should do? Talk to Sarah Palin. Palin knows a lot about energy, it is one of her signature issues. Oh, and I was just joking about crying earlier, don’t cry. Sarah wouldn’t cry.

COMMENTS

  • jimmyneutron

    and I have zero faith in this person as a conservative or a leader in our cause. I don’t think he knows the words, much less the tune. If he wants our support or respect, he will need to earn it like everyone else.

    I was very unhappy when the new speaker handed this post over to Upton – as others have said it is like putting the fox in charge of the hen house. Please those of your from Michigan hold this mans feet firmly to the fire.

    • http://jenkuznicki.com/ jenniferkuznicki

      http://jennerationx.com/category/fred-upton/

  • bobmontgomery

    ..but we were informed on these pages of much more, as you have alluded to. So. It wasn’t just one issue, it was many. And the Fredster is an adult, not a juvenile delinquent. Yes, he is an example of the culture, and we can’t go around executing everybody, but there are people out there who get it. Tim Geithnerwas NOT the only person in America capable of being the Secretary of the Treasury and Fred Upton was NOT the only person in the Republican Party capable of being chairman of Energy and Commerce. Just because Fred “knows how to get things done”, doesn’t mean he will.
    Personally, I am looking for people to lead the Congress who say things like BP is owed an apology for the way they were demonized by the Obama administration. BP may not have done everything right, but BP has been in business for a long time. I do not want any official of my government to use language like ‘putting a boot on their neck.” I

    • http://jenkuznicki.com/ jenniferkuznicki

      http://jennerationx.com/2010/11/fred-upton-thomas-edison-and-whirlpool/

      • reddog53

        see the link: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thomas_Edison.

        Or did I miss a more subtle point here?

        • http://jenkuznicki.com/ jenniferkuznicki

          or check ThomasEdison.com

        • http://jenkuznicki.com/ jenniferkuznicki

          “Thomas Alva Edison was born on February 11, 1847 in Milan, Ohio; the seventh and last child of Samuel and Nancy Edison. When Edison was seven his family moved to Port Huron, Michigan. Edison lived here until he struck out on his own at the age of sixteen.”

          about.com– http://inventors.about.com/od/estartinventors/a/Edison_Bio.htm

        • bobmontgomery

          ….that there is more irony, hypocrisy, comedy, inanity and ignorance in this whole, environmental whacko, climate-mongering charade, not to mention ulterior motive, than one could quantify. In the first place, while everybody is qualified to hold office, what makes people who are successful and good at what they do want to mock the Peter Principle and descend to a level of incompetence, as in become a politician? Why does the successful investor, Buffet, think it’s a good idea to set an example of giving your money away, leaving less and less and less and eventually nothing with which to put to use and advantage millions or perhaps billions of people. And I would bet you Fred Upton doesn’t really believe in all that crapola any more than Jay Rockefeller does; they want to be seen as heroic.FRED, YOU ARE HURTING PEOPLE!
          ad infinitum, ad nauseum.

    • http://jenkuznicki.com/ jenniferkuznicki

      http://jennerationx.com/2010/11/fred-upton-thomas-edison-and-michigan/

  • E Pluribus Unum

    Boehner has been talking tough (and so has Upton), but this was an easy choice, and Boehner did it to smack down Barton for the crack about BP getting “shaken down” by the Obamanistas.

    This will eventually cost us, because Upton has not become a new born-again conservative. He’ll eventually revert to his squishy form.

    • http://jenkuznicki.com/ jenniferkuznicki

      I agree. Hi again, EPU:)