Republican vice presidential candidate Gov. Sarah Palin has taken enough heat to melt the Artic Circle over this exchange with CBS’ Katie Couric:
Couric: You’ve cited Alaska’s proximity to Russia as part of your foreign policy experience. What did you mean by that?
Sarah Palin: That Alaska has a very narrow maritime border between a foreign country, Russia, and, on our other side, the land-boundary that we have with Canada. It’s funny that a comment like that was kinda made to … I don’t know, you know … reporters.
Couric: Mocked? Palin: Yeah, mocked, I guess that’s the word, yeah.
Couric: Well, explain to me why that enhances your foreign-policy credentials.
Palin: Well, it certainly does, because our, our next-door neighbors are foreign countries, there in the state that I am the executive of. And there…
Couric: Have you ever been involved in any negotiations, for example, with the Russians?
Palin: We have trade missions back and forth, we do. It’s very important when you consider even national security issues with Russia. As Putin rears his head and comes into the air space of the United States of America, where do they go? It’s Alaska. It’s just right over the border. It is from Alaska that we send those out to make sure that an eye is being kept on this very powerful nation, Russia, because they are right there, they are right next to our state.
Russia has a long history of probing the edges of U.S. airspace with flights of their TU-95 Bear bombers and other Soviet-era aircraft. These flights have increased significantly over the past two years. In one such flight in March, one of the Russian bombers buzzed an American aircraft carrier:
Two U.S. Air Force F-15s escorted two Russian Bear long-range bombers out of an air exclusion zone off the coast of Alaska, U.S. military officials said Wednesday.
U.S. radar picked up the Russian turbo-prop Tupolev-95 planes about 500 miles off the Alaska coast.
The U.S. fighters from Elmendorf Air Force Base were dispatched to meet the bombers and escorted them out of the area without incident, the officials said.
The United States maintains the air exclusion zone off the coast of Alaska, barring unidentified aircraft or aircraft that don’t file flight plans inside that area…
Then, four Bear bombers flew near the aircraft carrier USS Nimitz, with one of them flying about 2,000 feet from the Nimitz’s deck.
From NRO’s Jonah Goldberg:
I don’t dispute that [Gov. Palin] has more national security bona fides than the press is making it seem… Alaskan governors deal a lot more with international and national security issues than, say the Governor of Arkansas. There are all sorts of treaty issues, missile defense stuff, bases, etc up there. The military is a very big presence. Also, while I think there are political drawbacks to the fact that Alaska’s government lives pretty much entirely off oil revenues, understanding of international energy markets requires a grasp of international affairs as well.
Alaska’s unique role in our national security and homeland defense is a matter of fact. And Alaska’s governor is required to have more than just a passing knowledge of those facts. As it was pointed out on the milblog blackfive.net:
Alaska is the first line of defense in our missile interceptor defense system. The 49th Missile Defense Battalion of the Alaska National Guard is the unit that protects the entire nation from ballistic missile attacks. It’s on permanent active duty, unlike other Guard units.
As governor of Alaska, Palin is briefed on highly classified military issues, homeland security, and counterterrorism… She’s also the commander in chief of the Alaska State Defense Force (ASDF), a federally recognized militia incorporated into Homeland Security’s counterterrorism plans.
Palin is privy to military and intelligence secrets that are vital to the entire country’s defense.
As some comments to the Blackfive post reveal:
She doesn’t directly command troops in national defense activities, and she’s not briefed on each and every incursion or development by the U.S. army as it happens, both of which are true. Nobody says she’s commanding the 49th Missile Defense Battalion, for God’s sake, or getting briefings every time a Russain TU-55 strays into Alaskan airspace..
However, my point is that she’s privy to military and intelligence secrets no other governor is. She has to be. There’s no way she could function as governor if she weren’t.
All you have to do is read the Alaska Department of Military and Veterans Affairs Strategic Plan 2008-2012: Securing the State, Defending the Nation, a PDF here.
The document quotes Maj. Gen. Craig E. Campbell, who serves in the dual roles of Commissioner of Alaska’s Department of Military and Veterans Affairs and Adjutant General of Alaska’s National Guard:
Our vision statement, “Securing the State, Defending the Nation” is a vision of keeping Alaska and the United States a safe place to live. It sets the tone for how we conduct our day-to-day affairs, falls in line with Governor Palin’s priorities, and recognizes the unique missions and contributions of each of the DMVA’s components.
So the plan, which is designed to make Alaska and the rest of the Unites States safer, was drawn up according to criteria laid out by Gov. Palin.
But national security is about much more than Russian bombers and national defense plans. It is increasingly being recognized that national security is also about energy. Which brings to mind some foreign policy experience Gov. Palin has with another of our nation’s neighbors – Canada.
Palin pushed a deal through her state’s legislature for a major pipeline project to bring natural gas from Alaska’s Northern Slope to the lower 48. This Palin accomplishment required her to be involved in dealings with Canada’s government and TransCanada, a major pipeline and energy company.
Indeed, Alaska’s ties to Canada, like Alaska’s ties to Russia, are economic and cultural in scope and both significant and long in standing. As with Russia, Palin’s state government must deal with the Canadians over fishing rights, matters of trade, foreign consulates and cultural cooperation.
Prior to being introduced to several leaders of countries which are among the U.S.’s staunchest allies recently in New York, Gov. Palin said she had not met with foreign heads of state, although she had met with one. But she has met a number of Consul Generals and trade representatives, as we can plainly see. Gov. Palin also addressed delegates from 14 countries at the 2007 Artic Energy summit.
So Sarah Palin’s foreign policy experience, while not at the “expert” level of say, former Senator Fred Thompson, is, however, more “hands on” than Thompson’s considerable knowledge of the subject. Gov. Palin’s foreign policy creds are without a doubt more substantial than those of Senator Barrack Obama.
- JP
h/t: Tom W.
Jeff Emanuel
Neil Stevens
Caleb Howe
Interesting that she met with
wiseprince (Diary) Sunday, September 28th at 7:28PM EDT (link)a foreign leader and didn’t mention it. This goes to one of the points that has been made: Sarah is playing by their rules. The article that you linked to that said Gov. Palin met with Iceland leader said
that is probably the case. Gov. Palin thought to herself “They don’t care about Iceland, that isn’t relevant”.
She should be thinking and knowing that everything she’s done is relevant and can be used to tell America about who she is and how she would Govern. The fact that she meets with people and has experiences others don’t have is actually a real benefit
Free Sarah Palin!
[Subscribe Now](http://feeds.feedburner.com/~r/voicesinthewilderness/UQcm/~6/1)
One more note
wiseprince (Diary) Sunday, September 28th at 7:33PM EDT (link)It’s quite frustrating that I have to read about these experiences on blogs. McCain, Palin and the surrogates seem to be leaving out ALL of the relevant experiences and focusing on the experiences she doesn’t have
[Subscribe Now](http://feeds.feedburner.com/~r/voicesinthewilderness/UQcm/~6/1)
Sarah Palin would be great
David123 (Diary) Sunday, September 28th at 7:33PM EDT (link)on foreign policy for the reasons you stated, and others.
Three other advantages she has:
She’s got a strong love of country and a strong sense of right and wrong. America is not morally equivalent to Syria, the Soviet Union, or some other dictatorship. Sarah Palin praised Ronald Reagan and Margaret Thatcher for their conduct in office – so she’s following good examples. Some so-called “experts” seem to think the United Nations is better than the United States or that we need a permission slip from the UN to defend ourselves.
She learns quickly
She is a strong, dynamic woman. Most of our enemies regard women as little better than slaves. Having her as VP could change the world-view of our enemies or inspire women in those countries to stop putting up with oppression.
David123
Yep, give her a chance to be herself!
dbecraft Sunday, September 28th at 7:36PM EDT (link)Formally known as Deagle… “Golf is a way of life…”
Russians want Alaska back
Harod (Diary) Sunday, September 28th at 7:47PM EDT (link)Someday i think we could have Russians drilling in ANWR.
Indeed, while the U.N. is settling that, it could possibly entertain claims from those in Russia who want Alaska back.
Former Rep. Tom Campbell actually looked into rumors that there was “something amiss” with the U.S. side of the 1867 treaty by which Russia sold Alaska to the U.S. He found that the sale was legal but that the U.S. had failed to pay the $7.2 million purchase price on time. Campbell ascertained that the payment took place three months and 10 days late, and that the Russians were owed lost interest.
There is actually a point of view which holds that Russia had no right to sell the land, or the U.S. to buy it, and that the interests of Native Alaskans were ignored. “Native Alaskans never made treaties with Russia or the United States selling their lands, nor did Russia or the United States conquer all of Alaska militarily,” wrote Russel Lawrence Barsh in the study, “The International Legal Status of Native Alaska.”
http://www.aim.org/aim-column/should-un-broker-return-of-alaska-to-russia/
This is ridiculous
gatlinggun6 Sunday, September 28th at 10:42PM EDT (link)Why don’t we just stop it and admit that Palin has no foreign policy or national security experience, none! It’s plain silly telling the American people Russia’s proximity to Alaska gives her some foreign policy credentials. Similarly it’s ludicrous to say she has national security experience because there’s a military installation in Alaska from which patrols are flown over the Bering Sea. No governor has national responsibilities.
Does anyone hear talk of foreign policy or national security experience by the governors of CA, AZ, NM and TX simply because they border Mexico and have large military installations? What about Charlie Crist of FL, Cuba is only 90 miles away with thousands of expat Cubans. What about the governor of VA, after all the Pentagon is located in VA. What about the governor of CO, those planes in AK are dispatched by NORAD that’s based in Colorado Springs, CO.
I doubt that Palin or any other governor has the necessary national security clearances to know exactly what goes on at those bases in AK or anywhere else.
Further as far as we know she has not even participated in a trade mission, altho she was offered the opportunity to do so.
After bitterly complaining about Obama’s lack of experience we risk being called hypocrites for trying to lift Palin into something she is not. Arguably she is the most under qualified VP pick in modern times.
what a reckless person McCain is. He has made a mockery of his slogan Country First. Country be damned, Palin’s pick is a cynical McCain first choice.
If we wanted a woman on the ticket there are plenty of smart articulate Republican women with plenty of experience and world views. There’s Kay Bailey Hutchinson and Elizabeth Dole to name two.
Picking Palin shows how little McCain actually thinks of women. Instead of an accomplished woman he chose a figure head, a sort of skirt to sit by the door. I thought we are the Party that hates Affirmative Action, yet we sit here doing mental gyrations trying to justify Affirmative Action run amok with the Palin pick.
No wonder Barbara Tuchman begins her book the March to Folly with a quote by our second President John Adams: “government is at a stand; little better practiced now than three or four thousand years ago.” That was true then and it’s true now.
Why? because we engage in this sort of foolishness. Would we be ecstatic over a guy with as few credentials as Palin? Of course not! My daughter, a working mom, is smart, articulate, and graduated with honors from one University in 4 years with a degree in International Relations. Further, she spent time in the military as an officer, and has traveled world wide. She has a well developed world view. Her credentials are more substantial than Palin’s by any measure. So why in the hell would I want a VP who is not nearly as smart, knowledgeable or articulate as my daughter?
Stop the folly now and send her back to AK where she belongs.
Heh... can't we say the same about all of
dbecraft Sunday, September 28th at 10:49PM EDT (link)the candidates – President or Vice President candidates? Well, if you won’t, I will…they are all amateurs…
Formally known as Deagle… “Golf is a way of life…”
Sorry, you are not only way out of line...
dbecraft Sunday, September 28th at 10:58PM EDT (link)but a bit silly also…
It’s one thing to think that Biden or McCain has experience (when they don’t) – well, they have been in the Congress for a long period of time – does not mean experience. Actually, the fact that they have spent their lives in Congress means that they have little or no experience – that is why thwy are seldom elected to the office of President.
Now they do have the ability of oratory, that comes with experience and the office. Mercy, if we use that as a guideline, Biden is the most qualified even though he makes more gaffs than a combination of all Senators combined.
Oh well, people will think what they will…
I think it is well past time to quit thinking in these terms and think about those that have the qualities to make good decisions in office. Not that it will persuade those that love oratory, but it is my opinion.
Oh well, time to elect another used car salesman…
Formally known as Deagle… “Golf is a way of life…”
Has your daughter...
Josh Painter (Diary) Monday, September 29th at 7:23AM EDT (link)Ever addressed energy summits with attendees from eight nations in Anchorage and even more countries in Dallas?
Has your daughter ever sat down with the leader of Iceland to discuss geothermal energy and how Alaska, using lessons learned from Iceland, can tap into its geothermal potential?
Has your daughter, as Commander of a state’s national guard, ever been required to present her Guard’s top echelon with a set of requirements for a national defense plan?
Has your daughter ever had to discuss fishing rights with officials from Russia and Canada?
Has she ever hosted a trade mission?
Has she negotiated a multi-billion-dollar pieline deal with Canadians?
No?
Then leave your daughter out of this, and read the original post next time.
Thanks,
“An armed society is a polite society” – Robert A. Heinlein, “Beyond This Horizon” (1942)
MSM is still living in their old shell
ridewind (Diary) Monday, September 29th at 8:17AM EDT (link)This is not a far fetch view.
With the recent Russian presence coming to the Mexico Gulf, anyone who look at where the Russian Putin is putting his military pulse: near the oil.
Before Palin was nominated, one can see the conviction in her eyes whenever she talk about oil, gas in Alaska and its importance as part of energy security. At those rare interview, the press listens because she was non-partisan.
Now that she is in the campaign, the press is treating her as BO’s partisan enemy. And the blind Mccain campaign is not letting her shine in HER own way.
I am worried. If she did not come on the campaign there is at least a governor with the correct energy conviction to fight for oil security. Now I am afraid BO will go all out to destroy her even as a future governor.
** MSM will insist Russia will dare not attack Alaska as it will mean a direct assault on America and invite an all out war. But Russia don’t need to. They just need to park all their troops near enough to all the oil fields and create a strangle hold effect and they will be able to keep the oil price high. I wish for the sake of the world, MSM will for once look sanely at the much larger issues at hand.
Possibly a typical Putin strategy
Harod (Diary) Monday, September 29th at 9:56AM EDT (link)Not that long ago it looked like a attack on Iran was around the corner then the Russians invaded Georgia. So we became pre-occupied with Georgia now Putin is starting fires in the Carribean and Venezuela.
The only thing else we need is another 6 day war and Chinese moving on Taiwan and we will be in WWIII, allies vs. the axis..
That is why energy security is #1 for peace
ridewind (Diary) Monday, September 29th at 1:01PM EDT (link)Oil experts are rightfully concern about hurricanes crossing that gulf with all the rigs there.
With world oil production peaking and America so reliant on foreign oil, there is genuine vulnerabilities here excalating beyond just economy to national security. Just imagine at first strike that Alaskan pipes and gulf rigs taken out. (Unfortunately, this for national security cannot be spelt out clearly to the liberals who will need things spell out to even be thinking rationally)
So a constant Russian presence near both will be 10 times worse than the occasional hurricanes.
the Werewolves
Harod (Diary) Monday, September 29th at 1:21PM EDT (link)I agree with you 100% ride. In WWII Hitler figured out he wasnt going to be able to bomb American fuel supplies so he sent the Nazi terrorist (werewolves).
The Soviets figured out he same thing so they sent subversives so now we are just about the the point we cant afford to defend ourselves..
This was why Palin impress me
ridewind (Diary) Tuesday, September 30th at 10:14AM EDT (link)I had no idea who she was. I only accidentally read about her last year. But her conviction of why America needs their own oil as part of national security set me thinking hard.
Of course the Obama camp argues about alternative energy. But the fact is to deploy alternative energy nation wide will need at least another 2 decades, for the economy that is.
But from national security perspective, it will almost impossible for the army to operate without oil…..
In fact I will go as far to say she is the only one in both tickets who GETS it.
No my daughter is still in it
gatlinggun6 Wednesday, February 4th at 12:04AM EDT (link)Did Palin ever graduate from any university Magna Cum Laude?
Did Palin ever defend her country in Armed Combat and lead troops in a hostile fire zone?
Did Palin ever meet with foreign attaches and top military brass of any foreign country?
Did Palin ever help write any part of a NATO top secret defense plan?
Did Palin ever take a bunch of young men and women and actually survey and build a road instead of asking someone to pay for it?
Did Palin ever take a bunch of young men and women and actually build a bridge rather than ask someone to pay for it?
Has Palin ever sat down with foreign civilian and military leaders and spoke to them in their own language without a translator?
Did Palin ever train thousands of young men and women to defend the nation?
Has Palin ever actually met and conducted exercises with those Russians she claimed to have seen from from Alaska?
I could go on and on but the fact is my daughter is an accomplished public speaker who is not limited to the English language.
Intellectually she may daughter rings around Palin. You listed not one thing significant that Palin has done. While Alaska may be the largest state in the union, the fact is the governor controls only a small part of that territory. Well over 50% of Alaska is owned, controlled and operated by the Federal Government.
Besides all that, Palin is the governor of the only socialist leaning state in the union. Less you doubt that look at the charter of Alaska, and look at how they extort petroleum corporations to pay citizens of Alaska for something most of them did not work for.
Report says Iran still active in Iraq
Harod (Diary) Wednesday, October 1st at 10:00AM EDT (link)Iran still active in Iraq even though they have a $89 billion budget surplus, stop the madness
“Iranian influence in illegal militias known as “special groups” continues to plague Iraqi security efforts, the report says.
“Malign Iranian influence continues to pose the most significant threat to long-term stability in Iraq,” the report reads. “Despite continued Iranian promises to the contrary, it appears clear that Iran continues to fund, train, arm, and direct [special groups] intent on destabilizing the situation in Iraq.”
“The nearly 100,000 Sons of Iraq helping with local security are slowly transitioning into the traditional Iraqi security forces, but the process needs to be faster and more efficient, according to the report.”
http://www.defenselink.mil/news/newsarticle.aspx?id=51345
Its all about oil
ridewind (Diary) Thursday, October 2nd at 11:28AM EDT (link)That was why the French was helping Iraqi to operate the oil fields before the war, why Iran keep up this indirect influence, and why Bush wanted the troops in (but it was a bad chess move which alleniates US).
Guess what Iran is more pro? US or Russia?
Then it become crystal clear where are the last pieces of friendly oil: Alaska and Mexican gulf.
Palin knew about the vulnerabilities of friendly oil
ridewind (Diary) Thursday, October 2nd at 11:38AM EDT (link)Most people might think it too tempting for Palin not to say yes for the VP nomination, I hold a different view. She has been making all the necessary legislative moves to prepare Alaska ANWR or rather to prevent drilling to be disallowed there. I do not think she will sacrifice these framework for a ceremonial VP role.
Although she has been largely pragmatic and non-partisan sort of, why did she make such a gamble with her own political gamble to be VP-nominated and get into this partisan fight? It could be very likely that she knew with the Dem congress, it will be almost next to impossible to get the drill pact passed unless a Dem can get Alaska corrupted again. Therefore she needs to get into the White House by raising this drill pact above the congress.
It might just be my guess but the facts do not contradict because throughout the campaign she said it a few times Mccain had a different view but she is sticking to her request for ANWR, reiterating this is her #1 issue.