An independent counsel hired by Alaska’s state personnel board has dismissed an ethics complaint filed by Sondra Tompkins of Anchorage. The complaint had alleged that Gov. Sarah Palin’s role in SarahPAC, her political action committee, posed a “conflict” with her official duties as governor.
“I find that the complaint does not allege facts which constitute a violation of the Ethics Act. Therefore an investigation is not warranted. Pursuant to my authority…the complaint is hereby dismissed,” independent counsel Thomas Daniel concluded today.
Tomkins’ complaint claimed that Palin abdicated her governor duties at the end of the legislative session, when the governor went to Indiana to address a Right to Life banquet and to attend a breakfast for families with Down syndrome children.
But the independent counsel found that:
“…the fact that the Governor traveled to Indiana to attend a dinner (and a breakfast meeting the next morning) did not take significant time, if any, away from the Governor’s duties… the Governor has staff members who interface with the Legislature, and the Governor herself can communicate with members of the Legislature by phone or email, even when she is in another state.”
The complaint maintained that Gov. Palin in essence has a contract with the political action committee (which paid for the Indiana trip) to act in its interests on national issues which do not match Alaska’s interests.
But Counsel Daniels determined that such is not the case:
“The real purpose of a leadership PAC is to allow nationally prominent political leaders to solicit funds to pay for the expenses associated with traveling and speaking on national issues. It is not at all clear that this will be incompatible with Governor Palin’s normal duties as Governor, which include expressing her opinion on a broad range of issues of concern to Alaskans and the nation,” he wrote.
As Sarah Palin’s supporters have said all along, this complaint, and the dozen or so others like it filed by the governor’s political enemies, are frivolous.
- JP
Steve Maley
Neil Stevens
Daniel Horowitz
Which one?
Erick Brockway (Diary) Friday, May 8th at 10:53PM EST (link)Kidding.
The damage is done with SP having to shovel out money to defend herself every few weeks, not to mention the tax money to investigate every stupid charge.
Note to lefties;
“Don’t be afraid to see what you see.” -Ronald Reagan
Activists taking Action
Join the RedState Strike Force
There is no reason she has to spend a nickel of her own money.
mbecker908 (Diary) Saturday, May 9th at 12:32AM EST (link)And there is no earthly reason she needs to suck money out of the Republican Party into a PAC to pay legal fees either. The State of AK should be defending these complaints. If she’s got private counsel I would really want to know why.
Come on, don't be silly!
Gary (Diary) Saturday, May 9th at 1:23AM EST (link)You know the answer to this!
If she was using a state lawyer, one of those worthless witches up there would file an ethics complaint for THAT!
This is a VERY evil group of liberals. More than most liberals.
That’s OK though, it will backfire on them. This sort of thing always does.
Freedom is never more than one generation away from extinction. We didn’t pass it to our children in the bloodstream. It must be fought for, protected, and handed on for them to do the same.
_____Ronald Reagan
OK, you're fundamentally ignorant.
mbecker908 (Diary) Saturday, May 9th at 1:47AM EST (link)She’s a state official. The state is legally obligated to defend her against said complaints. There is absolutely no ethics problem, even remotely, on this.
Palin has legal debts from all the allegations
Erick Brockway (Diary) Saturday, May 9th at 2:49AM EST (link)Maybe Palin is supposed to be represented by the state of Alaska, but according to the ADN as of March 20,
she was in debt $500k to an Anchorage law firm. According to WSJ the fund was set up by supporters
late last month.
Note to lefties;
“Don’t be afraid to see what you see.” -Ronald Reagan
Activists taking Action
Join the RedState Strike Force
You're right, but Gary's right too.
jo_davi (Diary) Saturday, May 9th at 9:44AM EST (link)She is entitled to state representative, but these people are willing to file complaints like this one or the one where they felt that her because she wore a hat to campaign rally somehow meant she was advertising product. When, in actuality, she was just cold that day. If they are willing to to go through all this trouble for such crap, then they are surely willing to try and file a complaint against her for using a state’s lawyer, and find some type of legalese to justify it. I wouldn’t underestimate their ignorance or hatred.
Besides it’s smart of her. If she has her own lawyer, they can not say that she forced some state’s attorney to do her bidding (ala Troopergate) or any other nonsense like that. Though I’m sure they’ll find a way to go after her lawyer. She’s using private money to pay for the trips and private money to pay for a lawyer. She’s staying far away from any future ethics complaints.
Hogwash.
mbecker908 (Diary) Saturday, May 9th at 11:10AM EST (link)She’s got her own attorney because the her position on the yahoo emails is by and large indefensible.
As Achance has said – over and over – the ethics complaints are BS. With the exception of the email flap. That’s the real deal and she walked right into the bear trap that she herself set.
Another complaint against Palin was dismissed today.
Josh Painter (Diary) Friday, May 8th at 11:12PM EST (link)State election regulators rejected a complaint that Gov. Palin broke the law last year when she took a position on a controversial ballot initiative on mining.
Brian Kraft’s complaint charged that it was wrong and illegal for Palin to answer a reporter’s question six days before the election in front of TV cameras by saying that she would “vote no” on the measure.
The Alaska Public Offices Commission issued a written order Friday saying that “it is concerned with the free speech implications of a ruling that attempts to regulate what the Governor can say.”
http://community.adn.com/adn/node/141024
- JP
“An armed society is a polite society” – Robert A. Heinlein, “Beyond This Horizon” (1942)
Like the song?
SteveLA (Diary) Friday, May 8th at 11:57PM EST (link)Josh
So is it like the song?
99 ethics complaints in court
99 Sara Palin ethics complaints
Take one to court, smash it apart
98 Sara Palin ethics complaints in court
And yes…this was a joke, and no none of these stupid ethics complaints are worth the paper they are printed on.
______________________________________
Competency over ideological purity and litmus tests
5 x 5! I like the song nt
David123 (Diary) Saturday, May 9th at 12:23AM EST (link)David123
Tort or Torte?
crux Friday, May 8th at 11:32PM EST (link)Tort: Any wrongful act for which a civil action will lie.
Torte: A sticky cake made of nuts, fruits, egg whites, and very little if any substance.
These frivolous lawsuits are the reason why we don’t have many good people in politics anymore. It’s ob
yup
gekster (Diary) Saturday, May 9th at 1:38AM EST (link)They say Republicans are for the rich, Democrats are for the poor.
If they need more voters,
then they have to make more of who they are for.
We are there in the various Tea Party groups, leaderless, but not rudderless.
We steer always toward the Constitutional principles this nation was founded upon.
Erick Brockway
Ok folks, 2012 is here. Get involved
cont.
crux Friday, May 8th at 11:36PM EST (link)It’s obvious that these lawsuits are a part of a concerted plan to wear down the Governor. “The Art of War” – hundreds of little cuts eventually wear down and weaken the enemy.
Fortunately for us, Governor Palin is strong, and will outlast the tortes who are only revealing their game plan too soon. I call it the Palin derangement syndrome – PDS.
I expect the rest to fail
Piney Saturday, May 9th at 12:38AM EST (link)Thanks for the update, Josh. I am hopeful the rest of the attempts to drown our Gov fail as well.
1 down and a dozen more to go, unfortunately.
Most of them are crap.
Achance (Diary) Saturday, May 9th at 1:19AM EST (link)The ones on email and travel aren’t. I think she owned up on the travel ones and paid for some kid and Todd travel. The per diem ones are pushing it, but that is more a political than ethics issue. She WILL lose the email ones unless the complainants just run out of money or stamina. Alaska’s Public Records Act simply will not allow you to keep anything from the public that you did while a public officer and the private account dodge is just that, a dodge. Those will prove to be embarassing to her since they will demonstrate that she is perhaps not so angelic as some of you have made her out to be.
And there’s always the question of why she isn’t asking the State for indemnification and defense. If you’re doing something in the course of your duties and withing the law, the State is obligated to substitute itself as the defendant and indemnifiy you. Inquiring minds and all that.
In Vino Veritas
Come on Art, grow up.
Gary (Diary) Saturday, May 9th at 1:30AM EST (link)Man, stop with the nonsense.
This is just like you rantin’ on per diems and nonsense, but leaving out the fact that Palin has reduced the overall expense to run her office by $1million over that of either Murkowski or Knowles.
Not sure what happened to you when you worked up there, but there sure seems to be more of a personal vendetta, that a philosophical difference.
Sad.
Freedom is never more than one generation away from extinction. We didn’t pass it to our children in the bloodstream. It must be fought for, protected, and handed on for them to do the same.
_____Ronald Reagan
Do you actually KNOW anything about the rules
mbecker908 (Diary) Saturday, May 9th at 1:45AM EST (link)as they pertain to use of private email accounts for public business? Because that’s exactly what happened. And it runs counter to the ethics rules that the Governor herself put into place.
This has nothing to do with anybody having an axe to grind. Lord knows I don’t, hell I don’t even care. But I am smart enough (minimum double digit IQ) to look at the rules and compare them to facts of what she did in the case in question. She’s got a big problem.
Come on, Gary, get a brain.
Achance (Diary) Saturday, May 9th at 6:22AM EST (link)The State of Alaska publishes this thing called the Comprehensive Annual Financial Report. It is so comprehensive it even wins awards from whatever organizations give awards for stuff like that. You can read it online even, not that a Palinbot is likely to: http://fin.admin.state.ak.us/dof/financial_reports/cafr_toc.jsp
You can find travel expenses by SFY for each State Public Officer, including me through June 30, 2006, at: http://fin.admin.state.ak.us/dof/financial_reports/ctep_toc.jsp
State Fiscal Years (SFY) run July 1 – June 30. SFY 06 ended June 30, 2006, the last full year of the Murkowski Administration. All you have to do is go read the CAFRs and you will see that Gov. Palin has presided over astounding increases in the State’s operating and capital budgets. She has then used the line item veto to reward friends and punish enemies and bragged about her budget cuts.
Knowles travelled a lot, but he didn’t haul his wife and kids around with him. Murkowski travelled a lot but when he took his wife he paid for it. Before I became an appointee, I travelled more than the Governor lots of years and since I wasn’t an appointee had to prepare and answer for all my travel expense reimbursement requests, so I know those rules like a Baptist minister knows the New Testament, and Gov. Palin is subject to the same rules. The Gov is just a working bureaucrat and the only rules that don’t apply are time and attendence rules. I would not have dared take my wife or kids with me on State travel, even though my wife was a high level State employee with specific expertise that I could have justified for some purposes. Ethics Act complaints come with the territory if you are at all visible. I spent some quality time with the Department of Administration’s Ethics Supervisor in my last year over a trip I took at no cost to the State and paid for by a Board I sat on because it crossed over two pay periods and some clerk didn’t process my leave correctly. I’ve also had some very frank and informative discussions with the Palin Administration’s Ethics Attorney since I left the government over my work for some of my clients; they like to huff and puff but they couldn’t blow my house down. The Administration isn’t at all reticent to threaten Ethics complaints, it just doesn’t like getting them.
In any event, her handling of the Com. Moneghan/Tpr. Wooten thing was just plain stupid and she laid herself open for what followed. Most of her legal bills are from that though if she were confident she was right, she could have asked the State to defend her. She chose to engage expensive outside counsel. The emails are going to come out unless the State’s superior resources simply wear down the complainants. I know that game because I used to play it with some enthusiasm. Somebody would threaten to sue me and I’d simply say, “The State has 500 or so lawyers who’re going to get paid whether they do anything or not this week, you’ve given them something to do.’ The personal email dodge is just that, a dodge. If you’re a State Officer, it doesn’t matter how and where you conduct State business, it is public record. As to the per diem issue, I must assume that somebody has carefully measured and found that it is more than 50 miles from her home to the Attwood Building. I’ve never measured it, but I know that it is 49.7 miles from the nearby Palmer Correctional Center to the Anchorage Jail, a few blocks from the Attwood, so she’s technically entitled to the per diem. It’s simply an in your face to Juneau and a sop to the Capitol movers in her district.
I don’t know why all the Palinbots assume something happened to me. I was two years past retirement age, bored out of my mind, hated the people in the Commissioner’s Office and politicians generally, and didn’t want to go through another election and transition. I knew Murkowski was going to lose and I also knew that it was highly unlikely that either Knowles or Palin would fire me on taking office. Plus, I had return rights to the classified service if I’d really wanted to stay. It was time to go home and call going to the mailbox once a month working.
In Vino Veritas
fishy business
investedinterest Saturday, May 9th at 9:59AM EST (link)What’s the big deal about these emails? Did she use inappropriate words in her emails? Everyone curses! Is it something much worst? GOP dumps her BAD?
PS: She needs a speaking coach! She writes brilliantly but she needs a speech coach! She needs to the lose glasses! It would be great to leave the image of 08 behind ahahaha!!
Why hasn’t she written any op ed’s? Is it because she doesn’t feel comfortable tacking on national issues just yet ?
Maybe you folks should chat it up with the gov.
http://twitter.com/AKGovSarahPalin
Sincerely,
Palindrome for life.
Don't know for sure. I've seen pieces of what are
Achance (Diary) Saturday, May 9th at 1:04PM EST (link)purported to be leaked copies, but I don’t know if they’re real. If they’re real, they might damage that angelic image a bit, but as you say, almost everyone uses some colorful language from time to time. Anyway, I know we fought some bloody battles with “free internet for everyone” Democrats and with the unions back in the ’90s to try to have some control over employee use of email and the internet. Her AG and Commissioner of Administration have pretty much undone all that work to try to cover for her use of email.
In Vino Veritas
emails
investedinterest Saturday, May 9th at 9:57AM EST (link)What’s the big deal about these emails? Did she use inappropriate words in her emails? Everyone curses! Is it something much worst? GOP dumps her BAD?
PS: She needs a speaking coach! She writes brilliantly but she needs a speech coach! She needs to the lose glasses! It would be great to leave the image of 08 behind ahahaha!!
Why hasn’t she written any op ed’s? Is it because she doesn’t feel comfortable tacking on national issues just yet ?
Maybe you folks should chat it up with the gov.
http://twitter.com/AKGovSarahPalin
Sincerely,
Palindrome for life.
Do these complaints mean that Alaska is the most ETHICAL state in the Nation or just exact opposite? Just asking. nt
Rod_Patrick (Diary) Saturday, May 9th at 10:14AM EST (link)Attention Alaska voters: Stand by for an invasion of skunks!
Outrider Saturday, May 9th at 1:17PM EST (link)Ridiculous ethics complaints filed by some mumu clad basement blogger are nothing compared to what’s going to happen to your fair state if Gov. Palin decides to run for reelection. For the first time in anyone’s memory, an Alaska election is going to have national significance. The entire (and I mean entire ) DNC / MSM / Clinton / Obama / ACORN smear machine is going to descend on Alaska like the four horsemen of the apocalypse . For whatever reason, “they” seem to be truly afraid of her.
I remember what happened when this same bunch elected that nit wit Edwards to the Senate. They will flood Alaska with millions of dollars. They will lie, steal, bribe, threaten, cheat, etc., etc. These jokers play for keeps. They make Tammany Hall and Cook County Illinois look like Boy Scout Troops. I predict you will have more dead people and non-Alaskans voting that you can imagine. It is like a tsunami; written descriptions cannot adequately convey the experience. Palin supporters from all over the country will try to mount counter attacks. Alaska will be awash in out of state money, political torpedoes, and media yahoos of every stripe and description. I hope she and her people are preparing, or at least thinking about, how deal with this.
In January, 1998, Lauch Faircloth was a well respected senator and articulate voice for conservative principles. He enjoyed very high approval ratings. He had the full support and resources of the Helms machine, the NC GOP, the RNC, the blue dogs, and most national conservative organizations. Edwards was an unknown. Faircloth was consistently ahead in all poling until “they” came to town. Edwards won by 4 points.
Just a heads up.
This is a vision of the future.
davo119 Saturday, May 9th at 4:53PM EST (link)The hard left socialists and “Early 20th century Progressives” ala HC are in a full court press to entrench themselves for 100 years. They aren’t stupid and they are well funded.
When Sarah Palin came on the scene she was immediately recognized for the threat she was. Two weeks after being selected she was pulling in crowds comparable to The One who had been putting in 18 hour days for two years to get the same public response. And now six months after the election she is still under a blitzkrieg of legal and media attacks for ridiculous trivialities.
She really is what kept the Obama campaign from a 50 state sweep and is the only one on the scene who can effectively challenge him.
The left has been planning this since the humiliation of the Gingridge revolution. They take no prisoners and shoot the wounded. I hope her faith is strong because she is going to need it.
Never give in! Never! Never! Never!
Not really a worry in Alaska
civil truth (Diary) Saturday, May 9th at 5:12PM EST (link)The locals will take their tourist dollars gladly and then vote as the d**n please. Sarah’s going to suceed or fail based on how well she is able to work with the legislature and get things accomplished in challenging economic times. On the other hand, if these out-of=staters can find enough bodies in the tundra and get them registered to vote, then they might make a significant diference.
The greatest evil…is conceived and ordered (moved, seconded, carried, and minuted) in clean, carpeted, warmed, and well-lighted offices, by quiet men with white collars and cut fingernails and smooth-shaven cheeks who do not need to raise their voice. Hence, naturally enough, my symbol for Hell is something like the bureaucracy of a police state or the offices of a thoroughly nasty business concern. -C.S. Lewis
http://www.gmsplace.com/
Hard to vote dead people here.
Achance (Diary) Saturday, May 9th at 5:25PM EST (link)The precincts are small enough that precinct workers would catch on in most places. The real worry is a simply overwhelming media campaign that can’t be matched by the Rs. The Ds here are very good at campaigning to the right of Republicans and then governing left, and, of course, when people get tired of the Rs, they’ve forgotten how much they hated the Ds. But with enough money, they could just overwhelm the R with some chimera of a candidate or a re-invented Jerkowitz or Croft.
In Vino Veritas