« BACK  |  PRINT

RS

MEMBER DIARY

What’s So Bad About this Statement?

A lot of criticism has been leveled at RNC Chairman Michael Steele for his comments that he wants to GOP to go “hip-hop.” While most of the criticism has been leveled by liberals, there has been conservative opposition. My question to conservatives is, have you read EXACTLY what Chairman Steele said?

“We want to convey that the modern-day GOP looks like the conservative party that stands on principles. But we want to apply them to urban-suburban hip-hop settings”

What is so wrong with this statement? What sounds so silly about it? This is EXACTLY what we SHOULD be doing. The problem with the 2008 election was that we sought to expand our support by reaching out to moderate Republicans and Indepedents. This strategy didn’t work. We need to expand the conservative base of the Republican Party by going to places that we haven’t gone before. This is what Steele is saying. We need to do more than make new Republicans, we need to make new conservatives. As Rush said, most Americans lives their lives in one way or another as conservatives. African-Americans and Hispanics are no exception, conservatism agrees more with the world view of these cultures than you think. A few months back, I was recently at a gathering of young Republicans in Orange County, CA. Everyone seemed nice enough, but the guest speaker, a campaign representative for the gubenatorial campaign of Steve Poizner basically said we need to write off the black and hispanic vote, because if we try and get them we’ll loose our base. First of all, I don’t know what this guy thinks the base of the Republican Party is, does he think we’re a bunch of bigots? That we won’t welcome blacks and hispanics into our party? I don’t think I’ve ever been that insulted in my entire life. Secondly, I thought it was rather condescending of this gentleman to assume that blacks and hispanics can only be won by offering them handouts. The problem with these voters is not that we’re “not giving them hand outs” the problem is we’re not taking our message to them and making it relevant to their lives. School choice, abortion, traditional marriage, entrepenuership, social security reform, these are all things black and hispanic voters care deeply about and are more likely to agree with the Republican Party on, the problem is we haven’t showed these voters we care about them.

As for those conservatives who say they’re embarrassed by Steele’s comments, they’re falling right into the trap of the left. The left set the same trap for Sarah Palin and Bobby Jindal, and it’s why we have conservatives moping with their heads down that two of our leading candidates for president in 2012 are “embarrassing.” Palin and Jinal are not embarrasing to me, (I’d like that to be the ticket in 2012, to be honest with you.) they’re good conservatives, and competent people, not based on the way they speak but on the way they have successfully governed their states. The left is laughing at Steele’s comments not because they think it sounded funny, as it did to some conservatives, the left is laughing at Steele’s comments because they genuinely believe that when it comes to issues of race Republicans are ignorant at best, absolutely down and out racist at worst and they lean to the latter. They do not believe the conservative message of limited government, national security, and family values is compatible with the lives of minorities. They, like Jenine Garofalo, believe minorities in the GOP suffer from Stockholm Syndrome. This is all a load of crock, of course and it’s high time the GOP did it’s best and make a genuine effort to  make some inroads with these voters.

We need to  win over minorities, not just because it will help us win elections, but because conservative principles and policies will geuinely make the lives of minorities better. Making a message relevant doesn’t mean principles have to change, Michael Steele is absolutely right, let’s inject some “hip hop” into conservatism and make it more relevant to minorities and young people.

Get Alerts

COMMENTS

  • Aaron Gardner

    It is easily misunderstood.

    Even you ended up changing it with your last sentence.

    let?s inject some ?hip hop? into conservatism and make it more relevant to minorities and young people.

    We don’t need hip hop injected into conservatism, in fact in your diary you argue that those demos already live a conservative lifestyle, therefore we already have the inroad, sans injection.

    What we need to focus on is conservatism, plain and simple. We need to bridge the gap between how they are living and how they are voting. If they choose not to listen there is really nothing we can do about that.

    • Josh LeGuern

      Republicans and conservatism is portrayed as being an ideology for old, white people.

      What I am saying, what Steele is saying, is we need to change that. Making something relevant doesn’t mean you have to change the essence or the principles behind it.

      –”If they choose not to listen there is really nothing we can do about that.”– This statment is a problem, Aaron, it indicates you don’t care what minorities think or how they might feel about certain aspects of the way the movement presents itself.

      It’s because we’re not “a speakin the language,” we’re not presenting figures who are relevant to these people, we aren’t even making attempts to do so. It’s not principles that have to change it’s presentation.

      If Michael Steele wants to present conservatism in a hip-hop setting and context, beautiful. I don’t care how people come to conservatism, I just want people to know how great conservatives are.

      • Aaron Gardner

        ??If they choose not to listen there is really nothing we can do about that.?? This statment is a problem, Aaron, it indicates you don?t care what minorities think or how they might feel about certain aspects of the way the movement presents itself.

        You took that quote out of the larger context of what was said, go back and read the two sentences that preceded it.

        You need to quit focusing on the micro targeting message and stick to the good old meat and potatoes conservative message of smaller govt, lower taxes and a strong vibrant free market, and a strong national defense.

        The message is transcendent, the problem is our messengers lack integrity, therefore the voters don’t trust them to do what they say they will do.

        If you continue to just race bait then I won’t have a discussion with you.

        • Josh LeGuern

          … and there is no such thing as mass marketing any more. People want to feel like they belong, that’s why even big brand names are failing left and right, business gets this, I just really want the conservative base to get it too.

          I want conservatism to win, Aaron. I focus a lot on race because I think it is an area where I think the Republican Party and the Conservative movement need improvement on. Blogs like RedState are here to talk about ideas and how to progress our ideas and our party, right?

          I agree that conservatism is trancendant, but it still needs to be made relevant to other people. I’m not advocating changes to what we stand for, I’m not calling for moderation, I am calling for good ol’ fashion conservatism aimed at minorities and youth, because they’re the future and growing populations in this country.

          My point was Michael Steele calling for hip-hop in the conservative movement isn’t a statment aimed at changing conservatism, it is aimed at making it relevant to an audience who probably agrees with it, but it’s just not something that they have related to because of the image and caricature the left has created of the conservative movement.

          I don’t think I’m race baiting, because I don’t think conservatism is a trap and I don’t think I’m teasing anyone, I think conservatism is liberating, I think it makes everyone’s life better and we need to put a more friendly face on it for these voters.

          I hope this clears some things up, because I think you and I may have a misunderstanding, because I agree with your posts alot of the time, just not the ones that are in response to my articles, lol.

          • Aaron Gardner

            And in essence I agree with what you are saying, just not how you or Steele are saying it.

            Go back and read the very first line of my first comment in this thread. That is the problem with the statement, as evidence by our discussion.

            Instead of using the ambiguous lefty phrases like hip hop conservative Steele should have articulated some of the common bonds between conservatism and the black community, like family, hard word and the such. And then he needs to acknowledge that we have the integrity to follow through if elected to represent the community, because that is where we failed you in the past.

            Anyhow, I know your intentions are good, but I think sometimes you have to take a step back from the polished marketing message and just get simple and broad in order to form a coalition.

            That’s why campaigns that run on principle rather than marketing are in general more successful. President Obama ran on a combination of both, he ran on integrity but it was all just marketing, not real integrity.

            You know what I mean.

            But like I said in response to the original question of what is so wrong with Steele’s statement:

            It is easily misunderstood

  • Uma Richie

    I was only 8, but I liked Ronald Reagan because his “Peace through Strength” foreign policy made sense to me. His cabinet was for the most part old white men. Nothing cool about them, but I trusted them to run the country.

    A few years later, along came Alex P. Keaton on Family Ties. He made me want to be a Republican. He made being a Republican cool. I don’t know if I was alone in this.

    I don’t think it would work to have the party take an unnatural stab at being hip, but I don’t foresee NBC handing the GOP another Republican character whom young people would wish to emulate.

    I guess we need to find a young someone like Meghan McCain who wants to step into the political limelight, but who unlike Meghan (and her dad) , doesn’t try to win over voters by criticizing the base of her own party.

    • Aaron Gardner

      I loved that he was a Republican and I was only 4 in 1980. NBC was a different animal back then, Family Ties, Cosby…they just don’t make shows like that anymore…Roseanne destroyed that genre.

      • Uma Richie

        nt

    • Rod_Patrick

      Yeah, Uma. that was a very good conservative show. It was so cool then to be an open republican in public.

      I miss those days.

    • robmikpet

      he is an African-Amercian libertarian and is really funny and culterally attuned.

      • Rod_Patrick

        To Mr. Murdoch:

        Please, Sir.

        Can you give Zonation at least 1-hour stint.

        Zo is our fav AA coz he can rap in a conservative way!

        Bro. Zonation, You rock!!!!

        • robmikpet

          Put him in New York a 21st Century friends (but a comedy) and parade in front of him for scorn and ridicule the leftist, appeasement, chardonnay sipping weirdos that think they are so smart but whose true intellect is as deep as the shallow end of a kiddie pool.

          • Rod_Patrick

            If Steele wants to go hiphop, he should recruit Zonation.

  • Common_Cents

    We do need a new image, that doesn’t mean a lurch left for moderates but rather new packaging for our content. Many see conservatism as medicine, tastes bad but is good for you. In this short attention span day and time we need to adapt. We need to sell the benefits of conservatism, FIRST to the REPUBLICAN party! secondly to more and more voters.

  • Praying

    are definitely demographics the Republic party should reach out to. You are correct in that these groups are fundamentally conservative, and besides, it was the democrats that were the party of the KKK and the welfare state that has basically destroyed more than 2 generations of blacks in this country. It was the African Americans and Hispanics who overwhelmingly supported the Ban on Gay Marriage in California, in spite of having been duped by the “hope and change” (and promise of welfare checks) from the Democrats.

    And I think the youth are going to find conservative values more and more to their liking – it will take a few years away from the liberal incubators (the University) and the realization that THEY are the ones who are going to foot the bill for the largest single expansion of government in history. They are starting to get it – and they are starting to get angry.

    We would be very wise to welcome these groups into the “tent” of conservatism. This time I think history will be on our side- the backlash from the past 50 days is already growing, I’d imagine that if this continues, there will be a real revolution.