« BACK  |  PRINT

RS

MEMBER DIARY

$18 Million to Redesign Recovery.gov

Reminiscent of the no-bid, cost-plus contracts awarded in the Bush administration to defense contractors, ABC News reported last night the Obama Administration awarded a five-year $18 million contract to Smartronix, a Maryland-based IT firm with connections to House Majority Leader Steny Hoyer, for the redesign of Recovery.gov.

Launched in February to track the expenditures of the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009, Recovery.gov was to be the pinnacle of web-enabled transparency, according to President Barack Obama.

“The site is the tip of the iceberg for the effort that will go into taking spending tracking and accountability to the next level,” one administration official said of their intended level of transparency.

But now, it seems, the administration has failed to deliver on two pledges central to the Obama campaign’s rhetoric: fiscal responsibility and unrivaled transparency.

An acerbic Ed Morrissey asks, “Since when does it cost $18 million for a website, even one with a database requiring updates on a quarterly basis?”

Not often.

FedSpending.org, launched in October 2006 with a meager three-year $334,272 grant from the Sunlight Foundation, is a voluminous online database of all federal grants and contracts. And, unlike Recovery.gov, the website monitors the entire federal budget, and does so at a fraction of the projected cost of Recovery.gov.

Of course, the revelation that the private sector outperforms the federal government is nothing new. Recovery.org, a project of Onvia, monitors the flow of recovery funds from the federal government to private businesses in real-time, unlike its overpriced government counterpart which reports spending 100 days after-the-fact, thereby enabling wasteful or fraudulent spending.

Onvia’s CEO Mike Pickett estimated in May his company spent approximately $20,000 to build Recovery.org’s tracking infrastructure, a far cry from the inflated contract awarded by Obama’s White House.

By contrast, spending $18 million on redesigning an already-functioning website makes Ted Stevens’ $315 million “Bridge to Nowhere” project appear like a fiscally-sound endeavor.

Assuming, however, that the White House got a bargain on Recovery.gov’s redesign, the public is still, largely, in the dark on both how and where that $18 million will be spent, which, in and of itself, is comically ironic when one considers the intended aim of the website, that is, to provide information to the public to monitor stimulus spending.

Assuming, as the generous people we are, again that the White House got a bargain on Recovery.gov’s redesign and now that Smartronix will make the rebuilding process open and transparent, there is still the troubling issue of why. Why was Smartronix awarded the contract?

The Washington Examiner’s David Freddoso notes an important political connection between the Maryland-based firm and Congressman Hoyer as a potential explanation. Smartronix’s President and Vice President have together given $19,000 to Hoyer’s campaign coffers since 1999, according to FEC reports.

You scratch my back, and I’ll scratch yours make sure you get a $18 million contract to redesign a government website.

Uneasy with the prospect of the White House awarding offensively high contracts to the politically well-connected, Republican National Committee Chairman Michael Steele goes in for the kill.

“Vice President Biden warned us that there would be ‘waste’ in the stimulus bill. The Obama administration is devoting $18 million dollars to create a government website to show Americans just where their hard-earned tax dollars are being spent. This is unreal and outrageous.”

“If the Obama administration is willing to devote $18 million in taxpayer dollars to a website, imagine what government-run health care will charge taxpayers for an MRI,” he said.

Cross-posted at Skepticians.com.

Follow James on Twitter.

COMMENTS

  • http://www.marklaiminger.org Lammo

    Wasn’t it an iceberg that sank the Titanic? No? Oh well. Pay no attention to those people rearranging the deck chairs.

    • http://theminorityreportblog.com David Hinz

      ahh, yes…an unscripted moment of truth. Nine-tenths of an iceberg is submerged below the water — out of sight.

  • briancobbs

    to Recovery.gov. Here is the link to report Recovery Act fraud: http://www.recovery.gov/?q=content/agency-fraud-hotlines

    Although I’m not sure which agency to report it to…DOJ?

    • ColdWarrior

      I sent an e-mail to fraudnet@gao.gov sending them the link.

      Here’s some more info:

      Report allegations of fraud, waste, abuse, or mismanagement of federal funds to GAO?s FraudNET.

      How to submit allegations:
      Fill out a FraudNET form
      Send an e-mail to fraudnet@gao.gov
      Call 1-800-424-5454 (an automated answering system)
      Send a fax to FraudNET at 202-512-3086
      Write to:

      GAO FraudNET
      441 G Street NW
      Mail Stop 4T21
      Washington, DC 20548
      What information to submit:
      Provide as much detail as possible. You do not need to provide your name.

      http://www.gao.gov/fraudnet/fraudnet.htm

      I’m sure they’ll “get right on it.” (Wink, wink. Nod, nod.)

      Thank you.

      • ocleverone

        ;)

        • TNJim

          We report, they decide.

    • http://www.the41stvote.org rcov092

      you all are fooled by the one. You are pissed about 1$18.0 for a website. (I will do it for 250K) and missing the whole point. Hell with such a major project, probably will not be able to go live until… say 2013.

  • nessa

    Millions for the Murtha Memorial Airport/Hair Care/Tire Center is fine, billions for ACORN is cool, this is another wise investment in transparency from our benevelont leader.

  • nessa

    Millions for the Murtha Memorial Airport/Hair Care/Tire Center is fine, billions for ACORN is cool, this is another wise investment in transparency from our benevelont leader.

  • Kowalski

    You cite figures like $20,000 and compare them with $18 million and say that’s “a far cry.”

    It’s a factor of almost 1,000. It’s almost three orders of magnitude.

    You’re being far too kind about the cost. The next step is to watch the site like a hawk. Because my guess is that for $18 million dollars it’s not going to work very well, either.

    • Kowalski

      When I talk about the difference in expenses between two things that should be roughly comparable, a “far cry” is something like 25%. The difference between $20,000 and $18 million dollars is Ninety Thousand Percent (90,000%)

      This is the Obama transparency calculus.

      • DONTREADONME

        you know you have moved beyond comparable, and you have moved beyond inefficiency and moved into fraud.

        • Kowalski

          .

  • http://fairfaxgardener.blogspot.com ddstrain

    it drives me absolutely insane seeing what we are paying for. I’m in Virginia and I spent a couple hours looking over the “stimulus” projects in Virginia. I’d say most is completely unnecessary spending.

    For example the Army art collection apparently needs some art conservation services. Don’t we already employ a battalion’s worth (or more) or art conservation types at the National Portrait, Sackler and Freer Gallerieas and the rest of the Smithsonian organization. Why do we need to spend money on outside servics when we already have the people employed.

    Hell, we’re paying basically $250,000 per mile to repave and do other “safety” work on a 4 mile stretch of road that will “employ” an estimated 12 people for what 2 weeks, month tops? That sure sounds like long term stimulus there.

    Also, I see all kinds of facilities looking to buy trucks. WHY?!?!?! This government has hundreds of “surplus” vehicles out there that they can just move. I went to govliquidation.com and founds dozens and dozens of military vehicles that would fit the bill….on sale for $150 each. Sure they need work, but why spend $15,000-$30,000 on a new truck when we can transfer a truck FREE and put $5,000 into it to get it up and running (at a local auto repair shop that employs mechanics and contributes to the tax base). Same goes for office furniture, computer equipment, etc etc etc.

    On most of the projects that list a dollar amount and estimated jobs, it looks like we are paying about $100,000 per short-term (less than a month) job.

    I’m just fuming at the waste going on…this is pathetic. Just cut our taxes and let’s get some real stimulus moving TOMORROW.

  • http://www.ssce.net/Web-Articles/Web-articles-indexed-authors.html#authors-l JLenardDetroit

    from here
    …General Motors now toying with the idea of becoming GREEN MOTORS, almost LITERALLY?. They are kicking about the idea of changing their logo from the Blue background to a Green background?. Yep, makes perfect sense – fits its Liberal Government Masters? demands/desires and WA$TE$ tons more on an un-necessary change coming out of Bankruptcy.

  • bobojake

    Take it out of obama Whitehouse expense budget.

    • http://www.accutel.com/ jackmeijer

      Though a short comment. I found your comment most apt to the post. Your suggestion should sort of some problems in the government. check this one another government leak… seems like http://www.datopia.com/

  • antisocial

    including DR fail over/ licenses/Infrastructure/maintenance and still be a millionaire after taxes……

    That is another example why government can not manage anything without running into losses.

  • drealoth

    $18 million over five years is $3.6 million per year, which for web design work at that level I think that is about standard. That is not to say that they should be spending $18 million on a website, but I don’t think that the $18 million for what would probably prove to be a very high traffic website is outrageous.

    • http://www.accutel.com/ jackmeijer

      Your comment sounds like the ultimate truth. Are we even going to survive to see our government’s lavish website. may be they should do something like this http://www.datopia.com/

  • http://aposematic.wordpress.com aposematic

    Smaetronix must be a union shop!

  • http://locomotivebreath1901.blogspot.com/ locomotivebreath1901

    Can we at least get dinner & a movie before being shagged so hard (again)???