« BACK  |  PRINT

RS

MEMBER DIARY

Zero-Tolerance Idiocy Continues

The Columbus Dispatch has the details:

A Northland High School student could be expelled after playing with a Nerf foam-dart gun in school.

Devon Smith, 14, said he could not resist firing the toy at a friend after a classmate brought it to class.

“He was shooting at another one of my friends, and I moved closer, and I had a shot and missed somebody,” Smith said.

Smith was suspended from school and faces an expulsion hearing this morning.

Columbus City Schools spokesman Michael Straughter said he couldn’t discuss Smith’s case. But he said the district follows the state’s zero-tolerance policy, as well as the Gun-Free School Act.

Under the act, students who bring dangerous weapons to school or possess them are expelled for at least a year.

The act includes lookalike weapons.

Sean Smith Sr., Devon’s father, said he understood the rules, but he wondered whether the district was making the right decision in considering expulsion.

“I believe the crime should fit the punishment,” he said.

Does a Nerf gun really fall into the category for lookalike weapons? Is anyone going to mistake it for a real one? No and no.

Should the kid have gotten in trouble? Sure, but expelled for firing a Nerf gun? Sheesh. Just when you think this kind of over-reaction is a thing of the past a new case comes along. People just seem incapable of using common sense anymore.

COMMENTS

  • Next93

    Here’s the problem I have with all of these zero-tolerance stories: If these idiots can make a hash like this out of applying a clearly defined policy, how bad are they going to be at using any sort of discretionary authority?

    The reason these policies were instituted in the first place is because the morons in charge of our public schools proved themselves completely irresponsible when allowed to exercise any measure of judgement. Back in the 70′s, a generation of young idealistic teachers entered the system with the goal of “saving the world, one kid at a time”. Thier “project kids” quickly figured out that there would always be one more “second chance”, and that they could get away with anything, short of murder as long as they were on school grounds.

    Personally, I suspect that the authorities intentionally stage these sorts of things and make sure they get plenty of coverage in an attempt to get the rules changed, so that they can get back to the “good old days” of turning our schools into jungles where the “at risk” predators can do whatever they want.

    • http://andrightlyso.com/ civil_truth

      “Make the punishment fit the crime”.

      It’s this all or nothing, one-size-fits-all definitions and punishments that is hurting a lot of kids.

      At its root, it’s bureaucratic cowardice.

      • http://beaglescout.wordpress.com LJ “Beaglescout” Miller

        Governments and businesses all across the US have CYA policies that define mandatory sentences for every single specific “crime.” Rather than using the principles of good behavior as the rules that need to be followed, we have become a nation of serfs enslaved by the letter of the law, with no idea whatsoever of its spirit. When law can be summarized as “everything that is not mandated is prohibited” then the people live in slavery. We may not live in that place now, but we’re moving there fast. And anyone who lives in a Muslim country already lives under that regime.

        • Next93

          It’s not the law itself, it’s the tort system.

          We Americans have never had a secret police service, because we have the trial lawyers and the insurance companies instead. Try uttering the phrase “we could get sued” in any group, and the conversation immediately stops; the commisar has entered the room. The fear of lawsuits infuses nearly every aspect of our lives, and we tie ourselves in knots every day in superstitious (and useless) attempts to ward off the Bar Association stazi.

          It’s reached the point in this country where the tort system is more about legalized extortion than it is about justice, and a law degree is nothing more than a license to steal. At any time, you can be slapped with a lawsuit by anyone for any reason, and even if it has no merit, the mere act of getting it vacated will very likely result in the loss of everything you’ve spent your life building.

          No one who lives with that kind of sword hanging over his head can truly claim to be free.

        • zsmvf6

          Well, sort of.

          • http://andrightlyso.com/ civil_truth

            Looks like something worth watching, if the producers didn’t flinch at following the implications of the nanny state to its logical consequences.

          • zsmvf6

            I can’t say any more; it’d spoil the movie. :)

          • http://andrightlyso.com/ civil_truth

            Thank you for not spoiling the plot.

  • pac_NY

    … “Educators Gone Stupid”.

    I am extremely grateful that I decided to take my progeny out of public school a decade ago. Not a moment too soon, it seems.