« BACK  |  PRINT

RS

MEMBER DIARY

The NRA Blew It

Well, there’s one thing about apocalyptic predictons: they often become apocalyptic realities. After watching the news conference today, I can conclusively say that the National Rifle Association needs new leaders – from top to bottom – not because of what they said, but because of how they said it, which was one of the most pathetic things I’ve ever witnessed. I thought about cueing up “The Exorcist” while I was watching it at the Wall Street Journal’s website. Max von Sydow would have been refreshing watching Wayne LaPierre today.

The room looked like a funeral home. They were 15 minutes late. They couldn’t get their words together. The timing combined with how they orchestrated it made it seem like they had to push each other into the room and then slink out of the room. Wayne LaPierre looked like he’d been up for four or five days. He was pallid and when he first started speaking he didn’t sound empathetic, he sounded ghastly, like he was announcing the end of the world. He looked like he was in a cold sweat with all the blood drained from his body. David Keene couldn’t even put his words together from behind the rims of his glasses. His introduction was merciful only because it was short. He looked like he’d been up for six days. Longer than LaPierre.

How did Medea Benjamin get a seat in the room? Does anyone at the NRA watch the news and know what Medea Benjamin looks like? What was she doing at this event?

I think somehow they also thought they were going to get applause when they walked in and left the room. The applause in a setting like this always serves to set the tone, and they should have known they weren’t going to get any, but they did the speaker roll-out and exit like they thought LaPierre was going to stroll up there with an enthusiastic audience and leave to at least polite applause. David Keene looked like he really believed he was going to get applause when he introduced LaPierre. These guys are used to preaching to the choir and it was painfully evident. Dead silence.

Then they slunk away into the shadows. NO questions taken or answered? Nobody willing to even speak, ready to face reporters with questions? It looked male-menopausal from one end to the other. There were a few moments at the beginning that I thought LaPierre was just going to have a heart attack and collapse right there at the podium. I really thought he was going to keel over. They had a week to prepare for this and the only thing missing was the background death dirge music.

Worst press conference I’ve ever seen, and not just because they let the protestors sit in the front row.

These people don’t have the slightest idea of how to make their case before a skeptical and increasingly liberal public. They’re washed up and they’re hurting themselves. It’s not their ideas – it’s the presentation of those ideas by these toupeed old white males who are positively hated in this culture right now but they still cannot face the music. Yeah it’s unfair. Yeah, it’s prejudice. But your face and your message and how you present it matters as much as the message itself. It’s ironic that the Washington Post didn’t cover it live on their website because it would have helped the WaPo to stream every minute of it – that’s how bad it was. I had to turn it off several times.

They blew it in just about every way imaginable, and they have more than one foot in the grave. It was a very disappointing thing to watch: the cultural shift has taken place, the apocalypse has come, and these guys just don’t get it. They need some serious media consultancy. They need new thinking, new faces, and a lot better media strategy – with much more articulate spokespeople who are a lot younger. The Old Grave White Men aren’t going to win this time: the culture has changed. And everyone is going to suffer.

Someone needs to come in and do a Harley Davidson on the NRA.

I was very disappointed watching that news conference – which it wasn’t – it was just a painful slog from one end to the other. What LaPierre said in the abstract was helpful, but he really did look and sound like he was delivering the message from a funeral home, as the undertaker of something already dead. The world has changed guys, culturally you are just not the people who are going to make the effective messages any more. At least, not if you keep doing things this way.

Very sad. They’d better straighten themselves out fast.

I don’t think they have anyone in their organization who knows how to present themselves to the media. They shouldn’t just have answered questions – they should have let the Q&A go on for an hour, at least. By slinking away into the back room of their facility they looked like they were retreating into their sarcophagus. I think they did. Wayne LaPierre talked about some substantive things, but this railing on and on about “monsters” and “demons” was just pathetic.

They don’t know how to communicate with the public except for their own captive audiences. When they’re forced to make a statement – which is what this looked like – they do it looking like they have a gun to their heads.

LaPierre seemed to find his footing a couple of times and then it just kept dwindling away. And in the end, watching them leave the podium and slink away into the back room was the dumbest thing they could have done. Really an F minus overall.

Does this sound harsh? It’s nothing like what the NRA is getting from the Left. I expected them to at least have their stuff together today, not to make a “fun and happy” presser by any stretch of the imagination but at least look and sound like they had their act together and they understood they have a constituency out here who needed to see some competency and evidence of aplomb. Instead they let their long-awaited press conference be hijacked by Code Pink and looked like a bad remake of No Country for Old Men.

[Update: OK I'll try to be charitable. A lot of the ideas were good, but setting themselves up against the video game industry was a ding-dong idea. You let OTHER people handle the video game industry, guys. You've got your own problems. I think they were going for sombre and respectful (not respective!!) but what they created instead was a lot different, most importantly because they couldn't even control their own press event. And not being prepared to at least answer a few questions was boneheaded. What you needed was three or four people who seemed to be *eager* and *ready* to answer questions, almost like they were hoping for the chance to answer them. What we got was some guys slinking off stage after their presser was hijacked by Code Pink. We're in big trouble.]

Get Alerts

COMMENTS

  • Viet71

    I read (Leftist) reviews of the news conference today. None of them went to style. All went to characterizing LaPierre’s words: that he wanted to fight guns with guns; that he wanted more guns in the classroom. Blatant misreporting.

    My take is that even if LaPierre et al had been on their game it wouldn’t have mattered to the Leftist press.

    What’s interesting to me of what you write is LaPierre’s burnt out appearance. What reason does he or any other NRA member have to feel but sadness and anger; there’s no cause for remorse. NRA didn’t put the Bushmaster in Adam Lanza’s hands.

    Hate to say it, but the known information indicates his mother did.

    • eltuba

      True about the leftist press. But this time around the the traditional left wing anti-gun groups aren’t the ones to worry about. It’s the people who were formally agnostic on gun issues the NRA should have been addressing. Like it or not there are millions of Mommies out there who rarely thought about gun issues. Like it or not, today most of those Mommies want anything that looks like an “assault rifle” gone. It’s not about logic, it’s not about facts, and it’s not about constitutional scholarship. It’s about the fact that right now the NRA doesn’t have a narrative to compete with more four foot long coffins than the average mortician expects to sell in a lifetime. Today the NRA did nothing positive to protect anyone’s right to bear arms.

      • Viet71

        I don’t know about your data.

        I do know gun stores, especially in the N.E., are selling out of AR-15 type rifles. I also know women are the largest set of new NRA members.

        • ww2nd95

          I think they blew it completely. Sure gun stores might be selling out right now, but that won’t last. However the image of little kids being blown away isn’t going away anytime soon and the NRA did nothing, at least from my POV, to offer anything, other then bashing video games/Hollywood, which has been an argument, and talked about for years now to no avail. Sure violent games/movies do nothing to help society, but then again, that’s not Hollywood’s or EA Games’ responsibility. I think that argument is a loser. That has to do with society as a whole. People enjoy violence in games/moves, like it or not, and I don’t think that’s going to change anytime soon.

          And I agree with Kowalski on not answering questions. I think that was a serious mistake. They had a week to prepare and they weren’t prepared.

        • eltuba

          Gun owners and anti-gun people have one thing in common. Guns are a part of their political lives. There is a huge population in the country for whom guns were not an important issue. It’s that population which will be the deciding force in any national change in gun laws. The NRA’s been doing a good job of fighting the professional anti-gunners for years. Based on today’s performance I don’t think it has the foggiest clue as to how to handle the rest of the populations reaction to Sandy Hook.

    • kowalski

      His mother may have or not. No indication yet as to how he got the weapons. There’s been nothing official about whether they were locked up or not. We know she took Adam to shooting ranges, that’s true, but the question of whether or not those guns – some of them, or all of them – were “available” to him in the sense that they weren’t locked up somewhere has not been answered. In fact nobody has even broached the question, to my knowledge.

      Was there a gun vault at the Lanza household? Did Adam Lanza open it? We don’t know, even though the police have been through the house with a fine-toothed comb. You’d think they’d be able to spot a gun vault. If they have, they haven’t talked about it, and they haven’t talked about what condition it was in when they found it.

      The NRA missed a huge opportunity today because they let their press conference get turned into a CIRCUS and they didn’t present themselves well. It’s true that no matter what, the lefties in the media would have portrayed it negatively, but at least if they had done a better job, the rest of us could have distributed the uninterrupted video. The best pictures from this presser are the protestors!

      Not answering questions was a horrendous mistake. We castigate this President for not holding press conferences where he answers questions. We distrust people who aren’t willing to answer questions at press conferences they call themselves. The NRA should have had several people ready to answer media questions: instead they weren’t even as well prepared as Jay Carney.

      What it looked like was:

      “Well, we were silent. And now we’re giving you our [crash! bang! here come the protestors]….somethingorother. And we blame video [crash! bang! Medea!]…and thank you for coming, now we’re going to not answer any more questions.”

      They did it badly. They tried for sombre and respectful but what they got was distant, out-of-touch, and worse – out of control of their own press conference. Medea must be smiling right now, I know she is. That’s the worst thing that could have happened.

      • Viet71

        Kowalski,

        Cut to the chase.

        He had access to the weapons. He shot his mother four times in the head.

        Screw words. Look at actions.

        • kowalski

          I’m trying to. I know that a lot of people who are looking at this crime in the aftermath want to know what his actions were – at his house, before he went to the school.

          Did his mother have a gun vault? Were the guns locked in there? Was the gun vault broken into or somehow subverted by her son? Did he know the combination?

          Those are important questions because one of the options on the table right now for legislation – one of the sensible ones, I think – is going to be more restrictive laws about people keeping their guns secured – to keep them out of the reach of people who shouldn’t have easy access to them.

          We have a lot of weapons being sold right now. If they’re not being secured, there is a real risk of them being stolen. And then they’re going to be fenced. And then someone is going to shoot someone with them. Probably not someone who you want to have in command of that firepower.

          By the way, if anyone wants to know – I’ve decided to buy a gun vault from this company:

          http://www.sturdysafe.com/

          They make some very well-made gun vaults right here in the good old USA. I want one of their smaller models:

          http://www.sturdysafe.com/model2723.htm

          It’s going to cost me a little over $2,000 once all is said and done. Saving for it right now.

          Also by the way, I just got a disturbing phone call – my mother’s car was robbed **TONIGHT** in the parking lot of the local WalMart. All the perps got was a jacket. Be careful out there though – because there are people walking around in the parking lots, and they’re looking to steal. She left the car unlocked for less than 5 minutes to go back inside the store and retrieve the rest of her things, forgot to press the key fob. Came back out and the merchandise she had placed in the back of the car was gone.

          No joke.

          Happy holidays and stay safe. If you bring your brand-new AR15 out of WalMart and put it in your car in the parking lot, I wouldn’t advise leaving it on the back seat while you go back inside. You had better make sure that gun is secured.

          • dimfi

            I gotta agree with you Kowalski. That wasn’t a press conference nearly as much as a 30-minute infomercial with a very unconvincing spokesperson. LaPierre looked and sounded apologetic and reluctant to believe his own position. And I was struck by his refusal to take questions…WHENEVER I see a politician do that I think he must be a) pushing an indefensible position or b) not very good at thinking on his feet. Since the NRA has a legitimate position I can only conclude Wayne can’t think on his feet.
            And eltuba is right, gun fanciers and anti-gunners have made up their minds on this issue long ago. It’s the vast majority of Americans who have been relatively ambivalent on this issue who need education. But ambivalence doesn’t mean they don’t have a gut reaction and I think if the NRA did some polling on a group of middle-of-the-road Americans who saw today’s performance they wouldn’t like the results.

          • bantamwait

            kowalski, I got an $800 generator stolen from the back of my car on the eve of Hurricane Sandy. All they left me was the cardboard box.

  • deltawing

    I am tired of the idea that “white guys” are on the way out, and that we should hand over the podium to a more politically correct breed of human being. Would LaPierre’s ideas have been any more valid if he had brown skin or a different set of genitalia? Identity politics has gotten out of control.

    • kowalski

      Yes I think they would have been received better today, particularly if they were on hand to answer some questions after the main statements had been made.

      Now go and spin around and flip over backward and call me whatever you want.

      They need to change the mix. It’s not just one old white guy followed by another old white guy. Wayne LaPierre wasn’t anyone’s media darling going back all the way to the Clinton Administration. It’s more than two decades since LaPierre assumed his leadership position at the NRA. I remember watching him during the gun ban debates in 1994, and he didn’t stop it then, either.

      The NRA knows it needs some newer and fresher faces. This isn’t an outside criticism – it’s also an insider reality that they’re aware of. Wayne LaPierre isn’t as young as he used to be – and it shows.

      http://www.nydailynews.com/news/politics/climbed-nra-ranks-article-1.1225206

  • Martin Knight

    Don’t you know? Conservatives don’t do messaging! It’s so … uncouth, so unserious! What are we? Liberals? You actually expect us to worry about imaging and presentation? About engaging the media, safeguarding our reputations and defending our positions?

    Hah!

    If the public doesn’t like the way we present our message, tough!

    • kowalski

      Heh. Thanks for the humor today, Martin ;) .

    • deltawing

      The NRA isn’t a conservative organization. They’re a nonpartisan gun rights organization. They’ve supported many pro-gun Dems throughout the years.

      • Martin Knight

        Whoosh!!

  • Don T.

    Yeah, yours is a pretty harsh assessment. I think you have a few points about the visuals, and not enough on the ideas presented. Me and a bunch of folks were waiting to see a full on cave by the NRA, and we didn’t see that. The NRA is doing a full court press to present some actual plans that could very shortly provide actual security to schools. I think you were expecting way too much from this press conference. We should remember, everyone in the room, all those press people, pretty much hates everything about the NRA. I thought it was a good start, but not perfect certainly. I think this was an opening shot in a long battle, and this press conference was as much a message to NRA membership, that says, we aren’t laying down and giving up and we aren’t apologizing for firearms. One nonstarter for me is LaPierre asking for a lot of federal money to throw at schools. States are going to have to do most of the heavy lifting and figure out how to do school security in a smart, fiscally responsible way.

    • kowalski

      I accept the criticism. People here will tell you that I am always – historically – most disturbed by people on our side when they screw things up in an important setting. I’m probably too upset about it. I am harder on our side than the other side, probably. But that’s because I really *count* on our people to have their stuff together when everything counts. I’m crestfallen when they don’t, in a very big way. It’s hard for me to advocate for Conservtives in a Liberal state when the Liberals can say: “Well, we made your guys look like chumps today. Not only do you make me sick, you make me laugh.”

      What infuriates me is that we have these opportunities and then somehow we just don’t manage them properly. Why is it that the Democrats have gotten so much better at this than us? Why do they manage the press and public opinion so much better? I just don’t understand it.

      This thing to me, this press conference, should have been – if not simple – straightforward. It was an important event and I just don’t understand why we let these things go this way.

      • Don T.

        I get why you were critical. I think one point we can agree on…Wayne LaPierre is not Mr. Charisma. He was ponderous and he had all the sublty of a meat cleaver. I was sure hoping that Asa Hutchinson was going to get much more press conference time. I think your points about having good spokesmen and a much more finely tuned message are good critiques of the NRA.

    • bantamwait

      Yeah, what was that, calling for billions more in federal spending? And this comes from a guy who’s on Grover Norquist’s board!

      • Dave_A

        The NRA is a gun-rights .org, not a conservative or tax-reduction .org.

        Their priority is preventing new gun control legislation, not anything to do with the budget…

  • joshinca

    I though LaPierre did fine. Somber is the right tone in the aftermath of the massacre.

    I was glad to see someone, anyone, prominently defending the right to self defense publicly and calling out the lies and propaganda coming from the media. I wasn’t crazy about some of the other points he hit including blaming video games but saw that a distraction to derail the anti gun hysteria that’s running rampant in the media now.

  • Dave_A

    Blaming the video game industry is as stupid a cop-out as blaming the gun industry, anyway…

    Besides, the video-game industry has created more new NRA members than any other in recent time…

    The problem, is that the group that is really to blame is wearing a ‘Victim Shield’ right now, because members of said group (the education & child-studies establishment) died at Sandyhook…

    The actual problem, is a cultural one created by ‘Attachment Parenting’ & self-esteem focused education – a problem that takes drastic measures NORMALLY only taken in support of a fanatical political or religious cause (Suicide terrorism) and makes such acceptable as a response to ‘hurt feelings’ and ‘depression’.