The Indecent President


A decent man would have declined Notre Dame's invitation.

President Barack Obama made the commencement address today at the University of Norte Dame.  The university’s invitation, and the president’s appearance, have been the subject of much controversy both inside the Church and in the pro-life community.  President Obama, in four short months, has established himself as the most radically pro-abortion president in U.S. history, and many in the Catholic Church - including a large contingent of bishops - have been critical of Notre Dame for giving the president a platform and bestowing upon him an honorary law degree.

But President Obama’s decision to accept the invitation, and to keep it in the face of the growing controversy, is worthy of examination as well. President Obama may not have thought that his acceptance of the invitation to speak at Notre Dame would be controversial when he confirmed it.  However, as the controversy surrounding the speech grew from an online petition drive to angry comments from the Vatican, President Obama should have realized that his presence at the school on graduation day had become a distraction for the graduates and their families, and placed his host in an awkward situation.  As a guest has an obligation to avoid placing his host in embarrassing circumstances, President Obama should have found a way to gracefully extricate himself from the speech.  That he did not is evidence of a fundamental lack of decency in the President of the United States.

A decent man is aware of the impact of his statements and beliefs on others. President Obama certainly knows that his beliefs on abortion run counter to the teachings of the Catholic Church.  He knows, too, that Notre Dame is taking pointed criticism over his appearance.  If the president harbored any respect for Notre Dame, the Church, or the beliefs of pro-life alumni and friends of the university who have been so agitated over the school’s actions, he would not have appeared today.

And it is not the first time the president has shown a marked disrespect for a Catholic institution.  Last month, the White House requested that Georgetown University cover Christian symbols so they would not appear as a backdrop to Obama for a planned speech there.  Georgetown, sadly, complied.  The request, however, was insulting, and could have only come from an Administration hostile to religious tradition and values.

But this president is a man possessed of a deep and abiding respect for himself before all others.  This is evident in his speeches and actions.  Obama famously claimed that his nomination as the Democratic Party’s candidate for president would be looked back upon as the moment when the seas stopped rising due to global warming.  That is no ordinary conceit.  It is the conceit of a man who believes entirely in the rightness of his positions, and by implication the wrongness of his opponents’.  He is also said to believe strongly in his ability to convince others of the merits of his position.  Doubtless these qualities played a role in President Obama’s stubborn insistence on speaking at Notre Dame today, and bringing a raft of protests, media, and condemnation with him.

In the end, the ultimate fault lies with the university for turning its back on its Catholic heritage and inviting the foremost advocate for the continued killing of the unborn within its walls.  But President Obama should not be excused for trampling on that tradition.  There are lines that, yes even a president, should not cross.  And there is a basic decency that even presidents must display.  Barack Obama clearly believes that the high office he temporarily occupies relieves him of the need to follow basic tenents of decency.  That is as big a shame as the university’s refusal to live up to its heritage.

Category: , , , , , , ,

RSS feed | Trackback URI

32 Comments Leave a comment

An intelligent university would never have invited Obama

izoneguy Sunday, May 17th at 3:33PM EDT (link)

n/t

“When the government fears the people, there is liberty. When the people fear the government, there is tyranny.”
Thomas Jefferson

and the question of decency was settled when he opposed the BAIPA - LINK

Mike gamecock DeVine Sunday, May 17th at 4:19PM EDT (link)

http://www.redstate.com/gamecock/2009/05/17/notre-dame-deserves/

Mike DeVine’s Examiner.com, Charlotte Observer and The Minority Report columns
“One man with courage makes a majority.” - Andrew Jackson

Right gamecock, but it goes even further. I would say the question

mbecker908 Sunday, May 17th at 9:43PM EDT (link)

of his humanity was settled at that point as well.

CongressCritter™: Never have so few felt like they were owed so much by so many for so little.

do creatures from Kenyan lagoons get birth certificates?

Mike gamecock DeVine Monday, May 18th at 11:34AM EDT (link)

this is a joke re humanity everyone…

Mike DeVine’s Examiner.com, Charlotte Observer and The Minority Report columns
“One man with courage makes a majority.” - Andrew Jackson

 
 
 
 

His arrogance puts him above all.

penguin2 Sunday, May 17th at 3:53PM EDT (link)

Another word that goes with decency is class. You essentially are talking about manners Mark, and there is a definite lack of them from the Obama administration. Diplomacy is a critical requirement for heads of state, even presidents. Someday, this deficit on the Obama administrations part, will come back to haunt them. For now, he can demonstrate with impunity, an “in your face” arrogance.

The tragedy of today for us, is his ability to be a hypocrite and succeed in fooling at least half of the country. A man who has no value for the beginning of life, will have no value for human failings and short comings on the continuum of life. People will see this in the coming years, when health care is rationed-the elderly and infirm will be first affected by this, after that, who knows? Ironically, abortions will not be on the rationing list.

Resistance to tyrants is obedience to God.
Benjamin Franklin

 

A decent man doesn't promote abortion around the world

avgamerican Sunday, May 17th at 5:36PM EDT (link)

with U.S. tax dollars. And decent presidents don’t as a matter of priority sign an executive order in the first three days of office to expand abortion. Barack Obama doesn’t really believe in reducing abortions like he told those Notre Dame students today. He believes in expanding abortions as a matter of priority. See that is the negative difference with this president. He is allowed to say one thing while obviously doing the other and people clap and stand to their feet saying hooorah while the president of Notre Dame hands him an honorary degree. See that is what is called moral relativism. It’s rampant in our culture.

NOTRE DAME ALUMNI CONFIRM $13.9 MILLION

izoneguy Sunday, May 17th at 6:14PM EDT (link)

http://www.replacejenkins.com/references.html

Financial Penalty of Obama Invite Continues to Mount
DEARBORN, MI - (May 13, 2009) – Organizers of ReplaceJenkins.com, the online effort that asks alumni and donors to the University of Notre Dame to withhold donations, announced Wednesday that they have tallied nearly $14 million in withheld donations from alumni and donors who feel disenfranchised by the trend of Notre Dame’s leadership to abandon its Catholic identity.
The website ReplaceJenkins.com has received over 1,400 pledges from alumni and donors promising to withhold future donations. After more than three weeks since the website was launched, the addition of new alumni and donors on the site continues daily.
ReplaceJenkins.com spokesperson David DiFranco (Class of ‘95) commented: “Most of the donors were at least loosely aware of the University’s trend away from its Catholic identity. But the invitation of President Obama to speak and to receive an honorary degree, combined with the weak responses presented by Father Jenkins as a defense to those who have criticized the decision, is what drives most alumni to our site.”
“Unwittingly, Father Jenkins has brought national attention to a problem that is decades in the making,” DiFranco explained. “A shrinking percentage of Catholic faculty and the efforts of secular-minded board members has long been eroding the Catholic heritage and foundation that makes Notre Dame great. President Obama’s invitation represents the culminating scandal in this trend.”
Alumni and financial supporters of the University of Notre Dame launched the online effort in an effort to withhold donations from Notre Dame, until Rev. John Jenkins, CSC is replaced. The coalition website – http://www.replacejenkins.com - urges supporters to withhold all contributions to the Notre Dame General Fund until President Jenkins is replaced with someone who is committed to the authentic identity of Notre Dame, grounded in the teachings of the Catholic Church.
“We have discovered, in no uncertain terms, that alumni did not need our suggestion to withhold contributions. In nearly all cases, those who have contacted us had already decided to cease donating. Our website merely tallies the sum of their collective decision” said DiFranco.

“When the government fears the people, there is liberty. When the people fear the government, there is tyranny.”
Thomas Jefferson

Notre Dame will be begging for a bailout by years end then (nt)

Karina Sunday, May 17th at 6:32PM EDT (link)

Stop confusing me with the facts, I’m making up my own imagination. ~My grandmother who voted for Obama

 
 

It made me sick

Cris2365 Monday, May 18th at 12:45AM EDT (link)

It made me sick to watch that Pompous ass talk at Notre Dame . Nothing is beyond his Narcissistic mental disorder. You want to read a really good story on Obama? Go here and check this out.
http://theblacksphere.blogspot.com/2009/05/notre-dang-angels-and-demons.html

Cris

 
 

Put up or shut up

Kyle-MI Sunday, May 17th at 9:24PM EDT (link)

Once again a leftist president brings up the old canard about making abortion, “safe, legal, and rare”. What a load of garbage. When has he voted for any piece of legislation that would do this? Where in any of his current plans is he proposing to do this? It is all just nice sounding words meaning nothing.

I disagree - it's not nice sounding words meaning nothing

bk Sunday, May 17th at 9:50PM EDT (link)

When a leftie says it, it’s nice-sounding words meaning unlimited abortion on demand at any time at taxpayer expense.

 
 

As an ND alum,

paint_it_red Sunday, May 17th at 9:25PM EDT (link)

I am disappointed Obama was invited to Notre Dame. But, at the same time, Notre Dame has hosted as a graduation speaker Presidents George W. Bush, Bill Clinton, George Bush Sr., and Ronald Reagan. Inviting people of high office to speak at the University is not the chief problem. The invitation itself is made out of the tradition of inviting the President, and confers no particular endorsement of Obama’s positions. I think the vast majority of those who were in favor of welcoming the POTUS took this viewpoint.

The chief problem was the fact they conferred an honorary degree on him. While the right thing to do would have been to not invite him as a keynote speaker, (I believe politicians by and large at grad events always piss off half the population, so its not a good choice), there was certainly no obligation to give him an honorary degree. That was atrocious. I myself have a ND Law degree, for which I worked hard, and now they throw one at someone whose values are antithetical to what the University stands for.

Most disappointing though were the actions of the Notre Dame Security Police which arrested peaceful protestors for trespassing and some for resisting arrest. The Gestappo like bandits who have made themselves a laughingstock in the past by arresting a 38 year old man for underage drinking at a tailgate party and other inappropriate acts, arrested people praying the rosary, a priest, and Norma McCorvey.

“It is not good to cultivate a respect so much for the law as for the right. The only obligation which I have a right to assume is to do at any time what I think is right.” Henry David Thoreau

“The means we use must be as pure as the ends we seek.” Martin Luther King Jr.

“If you want peace, work for Justice.” Pope John Paul II

Degree? Heh.

mbecker908 Sunday, May 17th at 9:50PM EDT (link)

No, that is not a problem at all. It’s a meaningless piece of paper, just ask the faculty committee at ASU who refused him a degree because of his singular lack of accomplishment.

The problem is that they allowed [a variety of phrases that will get my account disabled] the BoyPresident™, an avowed supporter of abortion at any time during the pregnancy and with absolutely no restrictions as well as infanticide, to even set foot on the campus.

I keep hearing about how “graduation is supposed to be about the graduates”. If that’s the case they should never let a god damned politician set foot on the podium. And those words were chosen for TBP.

CongressCritter™: Never have so few felt like they were owed so much by so many for so little.

Funny thing about ASU Becker...

Aaron Gardner Monday, May 18th at 10:11AM EDT (link)

SNL took a bunch of shots at them for not giving Obama an honorary degree….and their reasoning why he deserved one was simply that Obama is the first Black President.

I assume that if the election had been different and ASU had VP Palin as a speaker and gave her an honorary degree that SNL would have still been derisive of ASU for giving her one.

Hypocritical tools

Aaron’s Archive

conform and celebrate diversity….or else!!!

 

Agree mostly

paint_it_red Wednesday, May 20th at 8:47PM EDT (link)

Graduation is supposed to be about the grads and anytime politicians come on campus, they are making it about themselves. But I have no problem with someone of contrary views coming on campus. If you believe in something, you’ve gotta be willing to dialogue with those who disagree with you. Problem is though that a graduation speech is not a dialogue, its a monologue. They just gave him a podium and microphone and an honorary degree.

Disagree that a degree is just a piece of paper. Its the reward for students of years of hard work, and, in the case of honorary degrees, a signification of admiration and acceptance into one’s community. Maybe not the biggest thing in the world, but very meaningful to many, especially at graduation.

“It is not good to cultivate a respect so much for the law as for the right. The only obligation which I have a right to assume is to do at any time what I think is right.” Henry David Thoreau

“The means we use must be as pure as the ends we seek.” Martin Luther King Jr.

“If you want peace, work for Justice.” Pope John Paul II

 
 

I usually support the police, but

WarEagle01 Sunday, May 17th at 10:04PM EDT (link)

Why in the world would the administration, Jenkins included, allow them to arrest those protesters, especially since it looked like they were just holding signs and saying the rosary? Since it is a big-name university I would imagine there is some kind of protest or gathering on campus involving non-students all the time. So does campus security really arrest everyone who comes on campus without an ND ID card? I doubt it. I guess that since it is a private school they can get away with calling it trespassing, but I think the NDPD way overreacted with the arrests.

“A wise, doughy leg with rich tingly experiences will always reach better conclusions than will a more tanned, muscular leg that hasn’t felt those thrills.” –Chris Matthews’ Leg

 

The AP story I read ...

skorrent1 Monday, May 18th at 10:17AM EDT (link)

Listed 5 previous presidents as commencement speakers: Ike, Carter, Reagan and the Bushs. Three others, unnamed, received honorary degrees. Conspicuously absent from the speakers list were JFK, the first Catholic president, Nixon, Ford and Clinton. Notre Dame was not impelled by precedent to offer the honor to a new president. The administration must have had another reason for the invitation.

 
 

Was his decency ever the question?

JustLeaveMeAlone Sunday, May 17th at 9:53PM EDT (link)

Obama supports, nay, promotes abortion. And infanticide. Any claim of “decency” seems moot in the face of those positions.

I am not a Catholic. But I have to ask, simply on a logical basis, why the Church permitted this.

I’m serious. Either Church doctrine is true and supported by the institution that believes in it, or it isn’t.

For the Church to NOT condemn those who thumb their noses at so basic a tenet as the sanctity of life seems completely illogical to me. And for the Church, in the person of a Catholic university, to honor such a man with a degree seems to defy all reason and logic

But then, I cannot understand why the Pope allows a Catholic such as Nancy Pelosi, whom he has met with, to continue to receive sacraments when she is defying Church doctrine on this subject.

“To compel a man to subsidize with his taxes the propagation of ideas which he disbelieves and abhors is sinful and tyrannical.” Thomas Jefferson

reply to "JustLeaveMeAlone"

rfpzzzzz Sunday, May 17th at 10:21PM EDT (link)

I used to know all this stuff but as I remember it , history gives a certain autonomy to each bishop ( a bishop traces his origin back to a specific apostle, for example the pope is the bishop of Rome, the seat of Peter). That is why there is still a certain respect/legitimacy for the eastern orthodox church that split off in about 1000AD. The specific bishop where Notre Dame resides is essentially the controlling authority. 2000 years of history leads to all sorts of strange rules as our much shorter US government history shows. This is only my vague recollection of Catholic authority.

 
 

C'mon Mark - it's not about Notre Dame

Jack_Savage Sunday, May 17th at 10:06PM EDT (link)

And it sure isn’t about the students. It’s all about Obama. Always has been, always will be, and this is another in a series of prime examples.

Maybe the Catholic Church is trying to appeal to “moderates”. Looks like it’s going pretty well. I am sure their pews will be overflowing since Notre Dame reached across the aisle with their bireligionship.

Right. This guy is seriously in love with himself.

bs Sunday, May 17th at 11:16PM EDT (link)

And he’s on a perpetual re-election campaign. The old addage is something like “all publicity is good publicity”, or similar. He doesn’t care about the impact on Notre Dame. He’s just concerned about Barry…whatever benefits himself the most, that’s what he does.

Decorum is fo’ suckas

 
 

The arrogance of this man is sickening.

ceciliatrent Sunday, May 17th at 10:13PM EDT (link)

It is a sad day in our Nation when the powers that be at Notre Dame would turn a blind eye to the fact that the man that they chose to give an honorary degree to is the most pro abortion President in history. He spoke of reaching a “common ground” on this issue. Disgusting! There is no common ground when it comes to the slaughter of innocent babies. Shame on you Obama. God help you!

 

Any time I heard an enemy used the word Fair,

bobojake Sunday, May 17th at 10:35PM EDT (link)

I knew I had to keep my back side covered because some thug was coming out in the dark with dirty fighting. The only FAIR way to deal with obama is the same way obama has dealt with the United States taxpayers. obama -ACORN scummmer, kerry, kennedy, dodd, frank, dodd has raped the taxpayers and that was not FAIR. Abortion-squeezing the life out of a newborn isTORTURE.
Waterborading terrorists and non-uniformed thugs is NOT TORTUE.

 

ND's Father Jenkins: Useful idiot

Uma Richie Sunday, May 17th at 10:54PM EDT (link)

Obama, in his address, mentioned those opposed to stem-cell research, but blatantly omitted the word “embryonic.”

ND’s president defended this whole commencement fiasco on the grounds of opening a dialogue with a president who holds an opposing viewpoint to Catholic teaching.

Father Jenkins, please tell me how you can have a reasoned debate with someone who isn’t honest in defining the points of disagreement from the start?

Source:
http://president.nd.edu/events-and-communications/communications/fr-jenkins-statement-on-2009-commencement-speaker

……………………………………………………………………………..
“We hold our heads high, despite the price we have paid, because freedom is priceless.” -Lech Walesa

 

Father Jenkins should be made an

Tbone Sunday, May 17th at 11:18PM EDT (link)

Episcopalian.

Envisioning when all that is Left is the Right.

 

What ND Faculty should have taken into consideration

avgamerican Sunday, May 17th at 11:53PM EDT (link)

is that Obama can’t claim to stand for reducing abortions. He expanded it internationally with US tax dollars. That makes no sense in of itself. But it also reveals that Obama believes in it aggressively. The man even voted against a bill that in rare instances when an infant survived the ,doctors would be obligated to save it. This reveals a darkness we have never witnessed in our presidency before.

 

Arrogant, arrogant, arrogant!

azaeroprof Monday, May 18th at 5:06AM EDT (link)

You’re absolutely right that Obama’s arrogant narcissism fueled his desire to appear at ND despite the costs to the university.

The left continues to beat us by redefining and twisting language to push and sell their ideas. For 8 years, you couldn’t hear GWB’s name without the word “idiot” getting snuck in there somewhere by some lefty. That became part of the general understanding of GWB.

I advocate for all of us on the right, that EVERY TIME you discuss The One, you include the word ARROGANT in there somewhere. That needs to become the major meme on Obama. We don’t have the MSM to help push this, but we do have one major advantage to pushing the Obama/arrogant theme over the Bush/idiot one: IT’S ACTUALLY TRUE!

 

Perhaps

Joe_Cor Monday, May 18th at 8:43AM EDT (link)

Catholic Neuman associations across American should not take this lying down. Football is a high profile activity, and ND is still the “face” of college football for many Americans. So how about every Neuman associations at rival schools demonstrating before ND away games? Draw attention to the fact that ND does not represent Church doctrine faithfully, and how shamefully it misrepresented it on 5/18/09. Say the Rosary and hold signs outside the stadium. Hand out literature documenting how ND does not support the sanctity of human life. Give the school some negative publicity it so richly deserves.

– Of course, many Neuman associations probably have Fr. Jenkins types for pastors.

 

The first mistake would possessing a belief that Notre Dame somehow represents Catholic doctrine

Marcus_Traianus Monday, May 18th at 12:44PM EDT (link)

That is pure fallacy and ND is not alone since other similar colleges are moving away (or at least distancing themselves) from church teachings. In fact, many colleges starting as Catholic or Christian learning institutions have viewed that identity as an albatross and barrier to attracting more “diverse” students. I was frankly shocked at the lengths to which this point was scripted on some recent visits. The pillars of doctrine are seen as an accoutrement or sideline- there if that sort of thing interests you.

The grand movement is towards a slow disassociation from their heritage. This is of course driven by a numbers and demographic game- premise being that broader appeal somehow translates into attracting better, more diverse students.

The weakness of their approach is that folks such as myself are amazed at such counter intellectual behavior- what do they believe made those into such prestigious institutions and bastions of collegial excellence? Do colleges realize they are trading one group of students for another- making them less diverse? What distinction does that school ultimately possess amongst the other “prestigious” institutions? Or do such colleges just anticipate their “brand” and established history will cause students to toss principal and beliefs to the wind? Sure. That is perhaps a good first lesson in propaganda or liberal inculcation, but not one for independent and well reasoned thinking.

As an issue and in church teaching, abortion is very black and white. Either one supports the killing of fetuses or one does not. Mr. Obama does, and has gone to great lengths in order to establish the process globally, including previous support of what can only be termed infanticide. Abortion was one of his first priorities and missed in the 100 day accolades. In sum, this is not meeting “halfway”, it is “get on board the train is about to leave”. Sorry, I won’t be buying the ticket.

Nonetheless, this is not really the debate or discussion we should be having and once again Mr. Obama, either purposefully or misguidedly, misses the point. You don’t “meet halfway” on abortion. An abortion detractor establishes first they are against the practice, fights against proliferation, federalization and any other means of making this an acceptable practice. But that posture can not be separated from what ultimately drives that individual. It is love, compassion and understanding for our fellow man, including those who are considering or had an abortion. It is NOT a posture or policy of vehement exclusion, isolation or stigma as many abortion advocates like to characterize those against this practice. People having or believing in abortion are not the enemy or excluded from our party, in fact they are already welcomed. They are potentially the misled, uninformed, confused, conflicted or pained who need compassion and understanding. And in the end, if we agree to disagree on the issue and leave it between them and God, which is where the final resolution rests- so be it. They are still welcome in my house.

As an aside, we used to call priests who act contrary to church teaching heretics. I guess that has gone out of vogue with Catholic Church leadership.

“Both of our political parties, at least the honest portion of them, agree conscientiously in the same object—the public good; but they differ essentially in what they deem the means of promoting that good. One side believes it best done by one composition of the governing powers; the other, by a different one. One fears most the ignorance of the people; the other, the selfishness of rulers independent of them. Which is right, time and experience will prove.”.Thomas Jefferson

Contributor to The Minority Report

 

Well, there are growing number of blogs for "Sarah for President" for 2012.

Rod_Patrick Monday, May 18th at 1:03PM EDT (link)

Anti-Palin Rs/Cs should do something about it if they want their Candidates to stand a chance by 2012.

Heh!

Rod_Patrick Monday, May 18th at 1:04PM EDT (link)

This is supposed to be a comment on the Josh Painter’s diary.

Sorry.

 
 

Thanks Mark

66lotuscortina Monday, May 18th at 11:00PM EDT (link)

You have put into words what I have been rumaging over for some time. I don’t read all the replys so please don’t accuse me of being Mareen Dowd-esq, but the epitome of irony is that a beauty contestsant can stand up for her confictions but a major Catholic university can’t.

 

Leave a Comment

 

Be respectful, or be banned. No Profanity.