MSNBC’s First Read reported last night that the Obama Administration is now saying that illegal immigrants will be specifically prevented from obtaining coverage under the president’s health care proposal. The chage comes on the heels of Rep. Joe Wilson’s (R-SC) “You lie!” outburst during Obama’s health care address to a joint session of Congress on Wednesday. Although the president denied from the rostrum of the House chamber that illegals would be covered by the plan, the Administration thought it necessary to make changes to the existing proposal in order to clarify the issue.
But the bigger story the MSNBC missed with its focus on the Wilson flap is found in the second bullet point sent out by the White House last night. The Obama Administration inadvertently confirmed that the president’s plan will begin a slow take over of the health care system by the federal government. How else could this be interpreted?
“Undocumented immigrants would be able to buy insurance in the non-exchange private market, just as they do today. That market will shrink as the exchange takes hold, but it will still exist and will be subject to reforms such as the bans on pre-existing conditions and caps.”
In other words, as the federal exchange takes hold, plans not complying with the federal government’s standards will start to disappear. Eventually, it won’t make any sense for any company to offer health insurance as the federal requirements will make the business of providing health insurance far too expensive, and the premiums far too expensive for the insured.
The result will be that everyone will wind up with no other “choice” than the so-called public option, just as the Administration has planned all along. It took Wilson “calling out” the president’s “misinformation” and “lies” to finally get the Administration to admit it.

This is the unfortunate circumstance...
Fred Maidment Saturday, September 12th at 12:41PM EDT (link)…of any government program that “competes” with private business.
The government gets to set the rules, change it as it sees fit, and never has to score points (make money) to win the game.
The result? All the other players take their ball and go home (or rather, leave the marketplace).
How to Start a Business - Fred’s News
Follow Me on Twitter
“I would rather be exposed to the inconveniences attending too much liberty than to those attending too small a degree of it.”
- - Thomas Jefferson, to Archibald Stuart, 1791
How does any initiative that shrinks the market
Vegas_Rick Saturday, September 12th at 12:56PM EDT (link)encourage competition? They really MUST think we are all stupid. There’s simply no other explaination for their approach to the facts.
“Nothing in this world can take the place of persistence. Talent will not; nothing is more common than unsuccessful people with talent. Genius will not; unrewarded genius is almost a proverb. Education will not; the world is full of educated derelicts. Persistence and determination alone are omnipotent. The slogan ‘press on’ has solved and always will solve the problems of the human race.” Calvin Coolidge.
That, or they honestly believe it
Fred Maidment Saturday, September 12th at 1:08PM EDT (link)…which of course, would mean they are too stupid to govern.
How to Start a Business - Fred’s News
Follow Me on Twitter
“I would rather be exposed to the inconveniences attending too much liberty than to those attending too small a degree of it.”
- - Thomas Jefferson, to Archibald Stuart, 1791
Why is anyone
kowalski Saturday, September 12th at 1:41PM EDT (link)Why is anyone lamenting the fact that Joe Wilson stood up during the address the other night and called the President out?
You know, for a long time I was notorious on this blog and elsewhere (Caleb Howe knows) for being a miniature version of John McCain every time there was a bit of news about Republicans that could be spun negatively by the people in the press and by the Democrats themselves. I was a hand-wringer for Republican decorum who lamented Terri Schiavo, Dick Cheney and his shooting accident, and a lot of other things small and large.
Each time some event happened that I worried about liberals using against us, I sat here and whined and cried about it, and more than anything else criticized our side.
Those days are over. These are not ordinary times and we have no ordinary team of prevaricators in the Executive Branch. Joe Wilson spoke for millions of people when he stood up and said what he said, all thoughts of decorum aside. The President and his lapdogs in Congress and the press really need to understand that we’re going to continue to object to the policies of the Obama Administration vocally, on line, and with our dollars and our votes. Otherwise the Ratchet Mechanism™ that Bob Hahn so precisently wrote about on this blog is going to continue clicking left irreversably.
I find it more than ironic that Vladimir Putin himself talked about the mistakes of State control while he was in Davos. Here’s Mad Vlad Putin as free market Capitalist:
And yet that is precisely what the Obama Administration is trying to do.
One of our State Reps. standing up during Obama’s Biggest Snowjob and calling it out as such should be something this blog is standing up and cheering. There should be more of it, not less. The people in Congress who stand up to this President should be rewarded generously, not rebuked or chastised.
Defend Liberty — Join the NRA | Live in Massachusetts? Join GOAL.
The Ratchet Mechanism
kowalski Saturday, September 12th at 1:52PM EDT (link)Just as an aside:
I hope the Editors will look back through the archives and dig out Robert A. Hahn’s post about the Ratchet Mechanism from several years back and I hope he’ll reprise it himself in one of his classic front page tour de force posts, because it needs to be said again.
The big picture of what is going on with this healthcare bill is a vast expansion of the authority of the federal government that will be irreversible once it occurs, for reasons political, psychological and demographic. The people who want to Rahm it through know that very well.
I hope Mr. Hahn will reprise that post again here, it was one of the best things that was ever written at this weblog, and it applies more than ever before at this particular moment.
Defend Liberty — Join the NRA | Live in Massachusetts? Join GOAL.
And as an aside aside...
kowalski Saturday, September 12th at 1:54PM EDT (link)Someone please close my italics tag. Boy, the more things change…
Defend Liberty — Join the NRA | Live in Massachusetts? Join GOAL.
Nothing wrong with worry, unless it paralyzes you.
archer52 Saturday, September 12th at 2:21PM EDT (link)To Kowalski:
Eisenhour worried every second of every day in the war. He just didn’t let the worry paralyze him. Glad to have you on board the “Screw ‘em” train. Political correctness is a cancer living within the culture of this nation. And a good deal of our decline can be directly connected to it.
Sometimes a man just has to stand up and say what he thinks and tell people what the facts are, regardless if it “offends” some else.
The bad mouthing arrogant politicians of today are lucky they don’t live in my grandfather’s time. They would have suffered bloody noses at the least if they tried to push their loudmouth agendas on men like him.
The good news is that PC may be reaching its limit. People will tolerate a lot in the name of diversity, but not go broke, watch their kids suffer, or loose their nation.
Oh, they’ll try to push universal healthcare as a right, or the right thing to do, but it has not traction. That leaves simply forcing it on us. If in 2010 the system is still in place, we’ll have the chance to vote them out.
If not, well, there is always my grandad’s solution. You’d be surprised how effective it is.
Hear, hear, archer52!
rmekrnl Monday, September 14th at 10:42AM EDT (link)I’m a crusty, old, retired Army colonel, plus I’m from the South where what the DC pols politely call being “disingenuous,” we call just plain “lyin’, so I’m already not that PC anyway, either by training or by nature.
And I’m a multiple gun owner and still a better than just fair to middlin’ shot, too, so I’m ready for your grandad’s solution if need be.
Rmekrnl, I'm right there with you.
towerclimber Monday, September 14th at 3:47PM EDT (link)I am a crusty old Ex-Army NCO and I agree with you.
Folks, many political elites scoff at Americans who were buying firearms at the beginning of Obama’s election.
that’s because they’re too stupid to see danger looming in front of them.
HR3200 is simply one of the last straws.
if you notice, HR3200 gives the IRS the ability to LEVY FINES against citizens if they don’t have “adequate” health care coverage.
wtf?? I will openly defy the government…ANY government to levy fines against me for the state of my health care coverage.
they can lie and hem and haw all they like..but the minute they attempt something that is such a blatant act of tyranny, I will advocate for armed insurrection.
I’m tired of being pushed around and by God, I’m not going to take it anymore.
“The ultimate result of shielding man from the effects of his folly is to fill the world with fools.”
Herbert Spencer
"Non-exchange market"
nsander1 Saturday, September 12th at 3:09PM EDT (link)Doesn’t HR 3200 specifically forbid a non-exchange market for individual coverage? If it’s not individual, how would people be able to “choose” their coverage anyway, through their oh-so-responsive corporate HR departments?
its here now
mrbill Saturday, September 12th at 5:08PM EDT (link)There has always been an item on this in the bill. A section says that after 5 years all insurance programs will be evaluated. If the Gov. doesnt like it then it will be rolled into the Gov plan.
This is just a shill for Single payer and always has been.
No plan will ever meet their wants and all will be rolled up into one large cluster*uck.
Oh boy "Fannie Med"... can't wait to see how that will turn out.
Old_Crow Saturday, September 12th at 5:25PM EDT (link)“Enlightened statesmen will not always be at the helm.” — James Madison
“So this is how liberty dies.. with thunderous applause” — Star Wars III
HR3200 will drive up costs (so any Public Option Trigger compromise - is Russian Roulette with a fully loaded gun)...
JLenardDetroit Saturday, September 12th at 10:40PM EDT (link)It is just dumb for anyone to entertain any thought that LIBERALS in Govt. will ever allow Costs (and Budgets) to ever go down!!!
(RS:Help) (JLD) (Hollyweird) (Brain-deads) (SPIN-cycle) (Obamaocare) (Party of kNOw) (Conservatism) (TEApeats) (respectful) (Reco) (Quotes) (removeRINOs.com) (RSmas)
+ 0bama Lies & your Bank acct will Die! (4/15 Truthers)
+ Heil “O” Hell No Obamao is NOT MY PRESIDENT! “No U won’t”
+ I want “O” to FAIL (here, here, & whole Diary (Ofail) here, is why)
“The first Liberal was Satan” - a Rush caller (other Quotes)
But isn't that good if it drives up costs?
bk Monday, September 14th at 5:37AM EDT (link)Pelosi said last week that the only way to reduce the deficit is to add a trillion of health care spending to it. The more you spend, the more you save!
Sounds like Pete Stark's logic. nt
Xasteius Monday, September 14th at 11:05AM EDT (link)Don’t leave the party, hijack it back!
Eternal vigilance is the price of freedom.
When I grow up, I don’t want to be Reagan. I want to be Art Chance.
~Aaron Gardner
ILLEGAL ALIENS
beanerecmo Sunday, September 13th at 2:14PM EDT (link)are to be prohibited from receiving healthcare without paying for because BHO intends to make all current illegals aliens residents of the US through an amnesty program that will be supported by McCain and other liberals (there are no moderates; there are liberals or conservatives); consequently, those 12 million will be eligible for medical care through the government (you and me) paying for it. Besides, unless the bill specifically says it supersedes EMTALA; illegal aliens will still receive medical care in ERs. EMTALA: The Emergency Medical Treatment and Active Labor Act (42 U.S.C. § 1395dd) is a United States Act of Congress passed in 1986 as part of the Consolidated Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act. It requires hospitals and ambulance services to provide care to anyone needing emergency treatment regardless of citizenship, legal status or ability to pay. There are no reimbursement provisions. As a result of the act, patients needing emergency treatment can be discharged only under their own informed consent or when their condition requires transfer to a hospital better equipped to administer the treatment.
I was a liberal until I learned to read, got a job and was mugged by weak-willed tax and spend politicians and their naive acolytes.
In reference to your 'there are no moderates, there are only liberals and conservatives"
avgamerican Sunday, September 13th at 4:01PM EDT (link)I second that. Moderates turn out to be liberals or conservatives who haven’t figured out yet what they really believe.
no responsibility, no moderates
moebadderman Monday, September 14th at 2:23AM EDT (link)Beanerecmo wrote:
“there are no moderates”
You’re right, the principle of moderation went out the window along with what Vladimir Putin called “the principle of personal responsibility” — see Kowalski’s post above. When people feel no personal responsibility for what they say and do, and have no other principles to constrain them (honour, discipline, dignity, etcetera) then they feel free to be extreme as they please.
Wait, the author of this article...
rmekrnl Monday, September 14th at 10:23AM EDT (link)…actually seems somewhat surprised that MSNBC missed the main point of this whole incident. Isn’t that what MSNBC normally does, either because they’re Obama apologists and propagandists or because they can’t get outside of their own liberal lame-brained bubble enough to know what’s really going on?
SLOWLY I TURN, STEP-BY-STEP, INCH-BY-INCH
robertbelvedere Sunday, September 20th at 6:27PM EDT (link)Linked to at:
CLEANING OUT THE CACHE