« BACK  |  PRINT

RS

MEMBER DIARY

50-50 Senate balance on Nov. 3 could make for interesting party switch pitches

Three weeks out as I write this, The Real Clear Politics “Senate No Toss Ups” map shows a 50-50 Senate after the votes are counted next month. It suggests the potential for intrigue and high jinks even after the polls close (not including the danger our nation faces until January 3, 2011 from the Obama Democrats’ lame duck session).

A 50-50 Senate recalls the 2001 Senate power-sharing that held until Jim Jeffords switched parties and handed the Senate to the Democrats. (Interestingly, neither of the architects of that short-lived sharing are still Senators…recall the names Daschle and Lott?)

With a socialist Democrat in the White House and a conservative GOP likely in the House of Representatives, control of the Senate would appear to be less important this time around. Most Senate legislation also requires 60 votes to move, anyway. Don’t believe it.

As we have recently seen, a lot of bad things can get through the Senate with 51 votes, and on judicial nominees alone, great and lasting damage can be done to our country through the confirmation of judges and Justices with life tenure.

In addition, incredibly important, yet tricky communications and tactical issues await the Congress as conservatives attempt to effectively repeal ObamaCare through defunding it, among other legislative efforts to block the budget-busting government takeover of our health care.

So control of the Senate will matter, in the words of a great American former Senate tie-breaker, “big time.”

So what would happen? A look at the list of 2012 Senate races gives us an idea. (As an aside, this list also shows the Democrats face trouble in 2012 just from the mix of incumbents they must defend and the lack of tough seats for the GOP to defend, but that is a topic for another day.)

The GOP has some potential targets to secure their 51st vote. Obviously, Ben Nelson of Nebraska, he of the Cornhusker Kickback, will face an onslaught of attention as a possible party switcher. But in light of Sen. Arlen Specter’s demise after switching parties, he may decide he has a better chance in November 2012 than in a GOP primary.

Independent Sen. Joe Lieberman of Connecticut would be the other focus of much attention, but he has one of the trickiest situations in terms of his survival in 2012. His best bet for re-election might be to continue to caucus with the Democrats, vote sometimes with the GOP, and get to November 2012 as an independent and triangulate again. But with a revitalized Connecticut GOP after this cycle, he may pull fewer GOP votes in two years. (He could lose and still end up as, perhaps, Secretary of State in a GOP Administration.)

The other Democrat Senators in trouble in 2012 have no clear route to enter the GOP anyway. Jim Webb will be in a world of hurt in 2012 unless the mood shifts in Virginia over the next two years, but he could not become a Republican. There are a few others…does Democrat Sen. Jon Tester really have Montana locked up? But the power of the Tea Parties and the greatly decreased ability of “party leaders” to clear the field for a chosen nominee make it less likely that party switching will make sense for Democrat Senators in the near future.

Of course, the Democrats will also be looking for a GOP switch to secure the 51st vote. They, too, have a few options. Olympia Snowe of Maine is perhaps most likely of anyone in either party to switch. But if she feels Obama is truly doomed in 2012, why cast your lot with a rapidly-shrinking party? The GOP is no longer dead in the northeast anyway (the GOP candidate, Paul LePage, is currently leading, though narrowly, a three-way race in Snowe’s Maine, for example).

Scott Brown? Kills his entire reform identity. And the Obama Democrats are far too left for him. Not gonna happen.

That leaves just one more (and no, stop with your Sen. Dick Lugar jokes). If a hellish miracle occurs and Sen. Lisa Murkowski of Alaska were to win her write-in campaign, she would be wooed heavily by the Democrats to join them officially. (The only other plausible name would be Maine’s Sen. Susan Collins, up in 2014, on a theory that you actually have a better chance of surviving a primary in your new party if you have more time to reinvent yourself. But I don’t see her joining a party in decline. Besides, if you can survive 2008 as a Republican, you can survive anything. Plus, like Justice Anthony Kennedy, I think she has learned there are joys in being a swing vote.)

The bottom line is a Jeffords-like party switch is less likely now, thanks in part to Sen. Specter’s failure (and Gov. Charlie Crist’s coming failure in Florida), which failures reflect the continued decline of party bosses and the rise of insurgent candidates closer to the people.

But that also means that 50 GOP Senators is not good enough this year. Yet another reminder in these closing days to stop eating out, in fact to eliminate all discretionary spending, and to send money to as many candidates and independent expenditure organizations as you can. The House and Senate are both poised to flip to the GOP. Your money sacrificed now can secure the Congress and increase the numbers of new conservatives in Washington next year, to block ObamaCare, left-wing judges, bailouts, Cap and Tax and amnesty, and to reduce spending and get our economy moving again. And yes, to get those subpoenas over to the White House.

Get Alerts

COMMENTS

  • AKSteveB

    Joe Miller’s campaign is starting to derail. The Alaska Dispatch (a local blog) has sued to get access to his his personnel records from FNSB (Fairbanks North Star Borough), and there is some noise that he used borough time/equipment in his campaign to dump Randy Ruedrich. He had scheduled a news conference to answer questions about it, then canceled. Later in the day, after a candidate forum at the Anchorage COC, he stated that he would no longer answer any personal questions before the election. This seemed to catch his campaign by surprise.

    This is going to give the local media 3 weeks to throw everything including the kitchen sink at him. As you can guess, they are already giving him the full Bork treatment.

    http://www.adn.com/2010/10/11/1496632/miller-vows-silence-about-personal.html

    There is a link to his announcement on there.

    (ADN is a McClatchy rag, so take it in context)

    Apparently Tea Party Express has decided to hold their ads until later in the campaign.

    The nightmare scenario I’m concerned about, is, if there is a 50-50 split or even close, Lisa probably ends up staying in the Republican caucus (and at the end of the day they won’t kick her out), and ends up joining the Maine Twins as the power brokers in the Senate. I supported her, and still don’t think her past record is that bad, but given the bad blood now, that seems like a strong possibility.

    • fbks

      The FNSB records were an issue before the primary; it cooled off for awhile and now is the eye of the storm. It appears the Borough was granting a preferential tax treatment for an outside development company and Miller opposed it.
      Of course Miller being involved in attempting to dump Ruedrich, he might have used Borough computer, if so, how serious is that?
      There is the “eligible for re hire” issue. I am not sure why he is fighting this, but resisting is killing him by a thousand cuts. I can say I will not ever vote for Lisa again, and there are a considerable number of people feel the same way. I am also done with contributions to the Alaska Republicans; I do give considerable time and donations and get people out to vote to individual Republicans. I am not even sure I can bring myself to vote for Don Young this time around. I do not trust or like the leadership.
      If Miller goes down I don’t think Murkowski will make it either. McAdams appears to be consolidating Dem support, and Lisa is showing herself to have no character. Miller brought out the homeschoolers, right to lifers, en masse, proposition #2 was a good primary draw.

      • AKSteveB

        He has lost discipline and that is doubleplusungood this close to the election. You have the right metaphor, it is death by a thousand cuts. The using the borough computer thing matters only because that is the same thing they got Ruedrich for.

        I’ve got mixed feelings on it overall. On the National level, Miller losing would be a disaster because of the scenario I mentioned, plus the media lynching makes it even less likely, that anyone other than lifetime politicos ever run. On the State level, I continue to believe that the Republican Party is better off neutering the Palinistas, and this would probably do it.

        • IJB

          Frankly, I think that’s nuts – get rid of the old boys first, *then* you can worry about neutering the Palinistas…

          • AKSteveB

            Part of the main reason with my disgust over the whole Palin thing at the state level is that her and her followers are no more (or less) ethical than the Old Guard but sold themselves as pure. The advantage of the Old Guard is that they had at least some governmental success.

        • http://www.gmsplace.com/ civil_truth

          Or am I another lower-48er clueless about AK politics? I could use a reality check.

          http://www.redstate.com/erick/2010/10/12/on-the-battle-between-midgets-vs-tigers/#comment-86160

          If McAdams does win the Senate, the AK-GOP will remind me of that alleged quote by some unnamed Soviet official expressing a willingness to start a nuclear war.

          Q: But if the U.S. and the USSR engage in an total nuclear won’t, won’t that utterly destroy both countries?

          A: Yes, but we will control the rubble.

          And I suspect I know who’s who.

          • AKSteveB

            I’m not inside enough to know exactly what happened, but my guess is that sometime between Lisa conceding and deciding to run as a write in, someone in FNSB leaked Miller’s file to one of her people. Something along those lines had to happen, because initial polling told her she didn’t have a chance. It was also well known that Miller is a privacy freak, and that banging against that would be the way to get him to lose control.

            I doubt the Dems as a party have much to do with this. McAdams has barely been there, and I haven’t seen an establishment Dem here do anything for him. A couple of the bloggers and radio lefties have been going through the motions for him, but even they just sound pro forma. My guess (and remember that is all it is) is that this is almost strictly driven by Lisa’s campaign and media hatred of social conservatives. In a lot of ways, this is also a proxy fight over abortion, and though this state is pro life ..it is just barely so.

            As for the AK-GOP, it’s probably a wash. McAdams won’t win. If Murkowski wins, I imagine the establishment guys will try to purge the Palinistas, and if Miller wins, I’d expect another shot at taking Ruedrich out.

        • congressworksforus

          He’s been solidly in lock-step against the Dems the past few months, and is obviously seeing Blanche Lincoln getting creamed for having a ‘D’ after her name.

          I’d rate him a more likely switch than Nelson, because Ben has no know he’s done regardless of what he does.

          The most likely scenario is that someone becomes an Independent and caucuses with the other side to retain a committee appointment rather than a full party switch.

          Well, I say most likely; I still think we’ll take the Senate anyway. No way we pick up as many House seats as we’re going to without picking up at least one or two surprises in the Senate.

          • http://www.toughloveforamerica.com mikeparanzino

            You are right, given Lincoln’s impending drubbing, I should have mentioned Pryor. But I had figured 4 years is a couple of lifetimes in politics nowadays, and given his long Dem pedigree, and his not drawing any GOP opponent in 08, I thought/think he’ll sit tight and assume things even out over the next 4 years.

            I also believe, as you do, we will take the Senate as well as House….but I keep sending (small) donations to more and more candidates to try to help my prediction prove correct!

            Thanks to all for their comments.

  • mikerazar

    I’m a card carrying Palinista. Guess what? I don’t give a hoot what she did as governor. I don’t care about the petty squabbles in the AK GOP. All politicians are corrupt. Period. So who will support the principles I believe in? Who will keep us safe? Who is more likely to look uot for my grandchildren?
    Sarah, Sarah, Sarah.

    Unless she is an ax murderer, don’t bore me with what she did to the corrupt (redundan)t Republican Party of Alaska.

    As for Joe Miller, he would instantly be one of the bestSenators in the last 220 years. So tell his detractors to shut up stop pretending to be conservatives.

  • Oz

    Snowe, Collins, and Murkowski would be the most likely to switch over.

    Hopefully, they won’t but who knows.

  • acat

    And Murkowski is already done.

    I can see her being vindictive .. but she’d be smarter to gracefully accept defeat, and seek the nom to replace the Dem senator in the 2012 election…. (IIRC) Run on an “Experience matters” (with enough visible crow on the platter) and she could well win.

    I just don’t see either of the Maine Twins acting up in this environment – not when one has already started planning the re-election and the other ought to …

    Mew

  • http://impudent.edublogs.org/ kyle8

    As we have seen before, there is no gain to the nation whatsoever by having out right liberals wearing the Republican mantle. What happens is that they continually sell their vote and forced unwanted compromises with the Democrats.

    Better to continue as a strong, and unified minority than to have the majority but end up pushing out disgusting big government legislation with an R by it’s name.

  • earlgrey

    DeMint is asking for an emergency moneybomb of $100,000 to support Joe Miller.

    I am trying to find a way to contribute, but I told myself I was done contributing $400 ago. In the end I’ll get something to them.

  • AKSteveB

    at the earliest. I wouldn’t believe any polls I see. Even Dittman who is usually pretty reliable has been way wrong this year. The only thing I’d bet on is; if it is close, the legal gymnastics are gonna be interesting.

  • AKSteveB

    is that the FNSB put Miller on unpaid leave for the Ruedrich stuff. They’ve acknowledged that they did an investigation, but haven’t released the results.

    However, that of course is not the real tragedy today. The real one is that John McCain has cancelled an appearance with him!!!! How will he EVER recover from that?

    Wherever Art is these days, he really must be having fun.

  • fbks

    what is the time frame for them to be released? I am not sure if Miller is running the clock out, or if the record is clean and would discredit the media badly.
    Miller’s strategy is questionable, because as far as the media is concerned he is hiding something and a hypocrite and this perception is the whole election, not issues.
    The liberals/Dems seem fairly split, to go in for McAdams or go for Lisa. For me, the fact that Lisa has so much union/liberal/radical environmentalist support makes her worse than an “open” Democrat.

  • AKSteveB

    I voted for Lisa in the primary, but I can’t have any respect for the way she has handled things since. Miller is a pretty strange guy, no doubt about it. I actually think he has a great resume/background but like a lot of us, doesn’t play well with others. Pretty typical “Alaska Dude” even if he is originally from Outside (as am I). I do think it is beyond funny that the Palinistas ended up doing everything they accused the Old Guard of..

    I can’t imagine Mc? winning, but I’m pretty much batting .000 on my predictions this year. If he does, we’ll have the honor of having the two most unqualified Lefties in the Senate, representing a deeply red state. Lisa winning is bad news as well at this point. In the candidates forum in Anchorage, when asked who her favorite Senators were, she named 2 Dems. I don’t think she’d caucus with them, but as I said .I’ve been wrong on pretty much everything relating to her. I think she ends up joining with the Maine Sisters to play footsie with Obama.

  • pilgrim

    Joe Miller does have an impressive resume in his leadership in combat during the first Gulf War and the discipline to graduate with honors from West Point. The attempts by the Murkowski campaign to paint him as a Palinista are going to fail.

  • AKSteveB

    Apparently he had a fight with Todd, and Conservatives 4 Palin have dropped all mention of him. It is a combination of no oppo research being done on him until he beat Murkowski and his campaign handling a media lynching very poorly.