He thinks that this is a smart ad:
…because it doesn’t mention Governor Sarah Palin by name. I think that it doesn’t mention Governor Palin by name because the Obama campaign didn’t have the slightest idea that she was in the running, let alone that she was getting the nod. If you think that’s unlikely, let me remind you that the DNC didn’t even think that she was important enough to profile as “the next Cheney.” Heck, they still haven’t updated that site, the lazy so-and-sos. Which leads me to wonder just how much work’s been actually done by these people in preparing for the general election. Hopefully, it’ll be much of the same.
Moe Lane
PS: You know, for a campaign that trumpets “change” so much, Obama’s seems curiously inept at actually handling unexpected ones.

I don't think they know what to make of her.
QueenOfCups Saturday, August 30th at 1:19PM EDT (link)Mostly because their moral compass is pointing to a leader who is mostly illusion.
It's only a smart ad
RJD Saturday, August 30th at 1:19PM EDT (link)if your a Liberal and Lefty. It has no substance and really isn’t great in style, either. It says nothing. It attacks McCain, but doesn’t promote Obama. It attacks Bush, but doesn’t do anything to define what Obama would do differently.
In my opinion, Obama’s Camp needs to keep it up. He’s preaching to his base here. I think most of America is going to want a little bit more substance than this ad provides.
Last redoubt
Crowe Saturday, August 30th at 1:49PM EDT (link)I think it’s a smart ad from Obama’s POV, but only because it avoids attacking Palin. I think this ad demonstrates that tying McCain to Bush really is the only thing left to Obama. They can’t attack Palin because any attacks they use can be turned back on Obama — I think they realize that.
Smart, I’ll give that.
Effective? I think it still has some shelf life, but only until more people realize/remember that McCain is not Bush, and more people re-convert to supporting the efforts in Iraq (both of which are advanced by the selection of Palin).
I think the constant negativity about the state of the union coming out of the Obama campaign will wear thin as gas prices continue to fall and Iraq success continues and the economy continues to grow faster than people are led to believe.
In short, I think Obama has reached his last redoubt — “McCain is Bush, and Bush is evil” — and even that won’t last much longer.
–
Looking forward to McCain getting 300 EC votes.
“We sleep soundly in our beds only because
rough men stand ready in the night to visit violence upon those who would do us harmDear Leader Obama gives us leave to do so.”Pathetic!
Fleischen Saturday, August 30th at 2:23PM EDT (link)They obviously had the ad with voiceover ready to go, planning to simply plug in some video of McCain’s VP choice at the last minute. As a result, it comes across as amateurish and has a low-budget, generic feel to it.
I can see Allahpundits reasoning.
phxg Saturday, August 30th at 3:11PM EDT (link)Avoid comparisons to Obama by not promoting the inexperience story.
Although I think he is wrong in that assumption as we saw with the DNC failing to consider her on the “Next Cheney” promotion.
This is simply a completed ad with missing 5 seconds of VP footage dropped in once Palin was announced. An indication, to me at least that the DNC has a playbook in place they were going to follow no matter who was selected.
I’m waiting to see if they keep on the McSame attack plan now.
It is the mark of an educated mind to be able to entertain a thought without accepting it. –Aristotle
Allahpundit is right
olderthangandalf Saturday, August 30th at 4:16PM EDT (link)from a tactical and strategic viewpoint.
Obama wants - maybe needs - to run against George W Bush. If the election is a referendum on the George W Bush years, Obama starts off in a good political spot, because by a 2-1 margin Bush is unpopular right now.
The math is not so compelling if the election is a referendum on whether Obama is qualified or right on the issues, whether McCain would make a good leader, or who has the best running mate.
Look for this to continue through November. Whatever the question, whatever the event, the Obama camp’s response will be some version of, “Do you want more George W Bush?”
This ad runs against George W Bush. It tries to tie McCain and the VP candidate to Bush. That’s his message, and it’s the right message for his side to be making given the current polling numbers. It goes to his core strategy - not being George W Bush.
McCain, of course, won’t sit still for that. He’s going to be busy saying that - while he respects George W Bush and much that he’s done - he’s not George W and will do things his own way. Choosing Palin, with no ties to the Bushes or DC, is part of that.
Watch the convention, where the Bush legacy will handled carefully, for more of that. The word cloud for McCain as he presents it will be less “Bush” and less “Republican,” and more “independent,” “maverick” and “reformer.” To help counter Obama’s Bush-Bush-Bush strategy, we will see Bush speak on Monday, and then he will disappear to Camp David for the rest of the week, making him literally a less visible target.
It’s going to be an interesting couple of months, and the Palin pick just makes it more interesting.
good analysis
kyle8 Saturday, August 30th at 4:19PM EDT (link)nt
“Nothing works like freedom, Nothing succeeds like liberty”
Kyle
As a wise man once said...
misterd Saturday, August 30th at 11:16PM EDT (link)If you don’t have a record to run on, then you paint your opponent as someone to run from.