Mickey Kaus notes this paragraph of a Politico article that probably should have raised more eyebrows:
“[CAP President John] Podesta’s and my experience was in the White House during the Clinton years, and we didn’t have a coordinated echo chamber on the outside backing us up,” she said. “There’s a real interest on the progressive side for groups to want to coordinate with each other and leverage each other’s work in a way I haven’t ever seen before.”
Bolding mine – and Mickey’s, for that matter. The article itself is dedicated to the completely unsurprising revelation that the Left side of the blogosphere coordinates its attacks on what it perceives to be enemies of the Democratic party. While this may surprise a few that weren’t paying attention, the only real newsworthy item here is that somebody’s willing to go on the record as calling it an “echo chamber.” Apparently, this is no longer an insult.
There are a couple of interesting things about this article, even if it isn’t very revelatory. The first is that it does look like individual members of the left blogosphere are finally starting to detach themselves from the unhealthy orbit of the Daily Kos. Unfortunately for them, the price for that is apparently to become official shills of the Democratic Party. If you’ll reread the article, you’ll note that nowhere does it say anything about the conference callers (who are carefully not named) being dedicated to pushing a progressive agenda; they’re there to push the parts of the progressive agenda that the Democratic Party is willing to pursue. I’ve been blogging for six, seven years by now, and based on my experience of the Other Side, I can guarantee you this: these people will never, ever coordinate on getting the Obama administration to end the war in Afghanistan. Or getting them to renounce rendition. Or ‘renegotiate’ our relationship with Israel. Or pursuing war crimes trials for Bush administration officials. Or any other cause that is nearer and dearer to progressive hearts than it would be to the Democratic Party’s. No, it’s all going to be about promoting the Party’s interests first for these people… which is probably why they aren’t naming who’s participating.
Second interesting bit: if you were ever wondering why the Left routinely accuses the Right of being in lockstep, this would be why: they assume that we do the same things that they do. I can speak with some authority that this is not the case, given that if we did I’d be one of the people on the invite list. I’d like to say that it’s because the rest of the Right agrees with me that the payoff on this doesn’t seem to be matching the effort*, but it’s probably much simpler: most of us have real jobs. 8:45 is an exceptionally inconvenient time to have a long phone call for most professions, including “stay at home father.”
Moe Lane
*It’s hard to tell, really. Of the examples in the Politico article, Betsy McCaughey seems to have shrugged the entire thing off entirely, it’s hard to tell about Rick Scott, given that I’ve never heard of him before (and probably neither have most of the people reading this), and Rush Limbaugh’s ratings have doubled since they first started going after him. In other words, these guys need a victory; one the size of making Daschle withdraw or wrecking Rather’s reputation for all time.
Crossposted to Moe Lane.
Neil Stevens
Steve Maley
If the Right is all in 'lockstep'...
ss396 Wednesday, March 11th at 9:55AM EST (link)…then why is it having leadership problems? Why can’t it coalesce into a cohesive Party?
It is always amusing how the Left gloats at the divisiveness of leadership in the Right, while accusing the Right of being a bunch of ‘dittoheads’.
It is always amusing how the Left projects its fear and paranoia onto all who are not them.
If you pay someone to sit on his butt, you can’t be surprised when he does.
If you're seeking diversity of opinion...
mallcopsaysno Wednesday, March 11th at 11:19AM EST (link)there are definitely some places online you shouldn’t bother to venture. The degree to which these separate ideologically pure entities coordinate their messages will give you some measure of their ‘echo-chamber’ effect. I know it happens on the other side, but let me give you an example from what I know: pretty much ever single Warner Todd Huston post that shows up at RedState shows up at NewsBusters as well. Maybe that’s not a true echo-chamber as it is exactly the same content, but it’s definitely the same message.
Not a criticism, just an observation.
There are outliers on both sides. Consider the Accountability Now PAC on the left and the Campaign for Liberty on the right. There are several prominent lefty bloggers promoting the former, and a lot more than a single rep from Texas promoting the latter. So far as I can tell there are no shills in that bunch, and no one is promoting party above principle. For that they both earn my respect even if I don’t agree with them on some fundamental points.
I refused to apologize for chickenhawking when told to.
Eisenhower was right.