« BACK  |  PRINT

RS

FRONT PAGE CONTRIBUTOR

Orrin Hatch came prepared for the Utah caucuses.

Let tell you a parable.

Once upon a time that has not yet happened – and will almost certainly not actually happen – there will be a certain starship, with a certain Captain… captaining it. And this starship will, as starships of that sort often do, encounter an amazingly heavy-handed metaphor in the form of two anthropomorphized black-and-white cookies determined to destroy each other.

(pause)

Hold on: this has a point, I swear.Well, our Captain is not particularly interested in this conflict, given that neither black-and-white cookie is a large-breasted female – but the two cookies are determined to drag him and his ship into their unsubtle social commentary*, so the Captain decides to blow up his own ship with a computerized self-destruct sequence, just to get the two cookies’ attention. And this works: getting the cookies’ attention, that is, not blowing up the ship. Attention is definitely gotten, and the captain gets the cookies to stand down. And then one of the cookies, being only an idiot when the script requires it, goes and burns out the portions of starship’s computers that regulate the computerized self-destruct sequence**.

Annnnnnd now you know why former Senator Bob Bennett (R, UT) got tossed out on his ear in 2010, while current Senator Orrin Hatch (R, UT) looks like he’s in a good place to survive a challenge in 2012. It’s because Hatch paid attention to what happened to Bennett, and acted accordingly. Which in this case meant organizing like crazy for the delegate selection process. And, if first accounts are accurate, it’s paid off; Hatch’s delegates largely won over those of Hatch’s primary opponents.

Moral of the story? Just because something works once doesn’t mean that it’ll work every time, unless of course you’re facing an idiot. And it would appear that Senator Hatch is not an idiot, so anybody trying to replace him in the Senate would probably be well-advised to not assume that he’s as dumb as, say, your average Democratic politician.

Or an anthropomorphized black-and-white cookie.

Moe Lane (crosspost)

*Did you know that people complained that the new Star Trek reboot just blew stuff up, and didn’t give us amazing social commentary like the Black-and-White Cookie Episode? – And, yes, the people complaining were mostly progressives. How did you know?

**From there it’s only a short trip to the cookies’ original planet, where we discover that the rest of the population has already conveniently killed each other off over a point of chromatic patterning. Unaccountably, the episode does not end with the starship Captain dropping a photon torpedo on the two black-and-white cookies now pointlessly fighting on the planet’s surface, then calling Starfleet to let them know that he’s just found a perfectly nice M-Class planet whose inconveniently belligerent and powerfully psionic population have conveniently killed each other off… and left the ruins for other species to loot.

Get Alerts

COMMENTS

  • Ned Reck

    nt

    ned

  • belcatar

    Making a connection between hypothetical anthropomorphic cookies and Senator Orrin Hatch is some kind of intellectual feat. I don’t mean that as sarcasm. I think it’s a fantastic way to explain your point. My question is, which cookie represents Senator Hatch? Is he the chocolate cookie with white chocolate and macadamias, or the regular chocolate chip cookie?

    I only lived in Utah for a short time, but it seems to me that the state is pretty much divided into conservative Republicans and Residents of Salt Lake City. (Or, Salt Lake Tribune readers and Deseret readers.)

  • acat

    and he’s entrenched.

    Replacing him will require a bit more effort… not impossible, just not as painless.

    Mew

  • Cowboy

    .

  • Viet71

    Don’t know about the average Utah voter.

  • naraht

    Salt Lake City actually hasn’t elected a Republican mayor since 1972! (Jake Garn).. And even though McCain won Utah by 29%, Obama won Salt Lake County (by about 300 votes), he also won Summit county which is sort of the upscale suburbs NE of SLC and Grand county on the Colorado border (still trying to figure that one out). Obama’s 176,000 votes he got in Salt Lake County are more than half of the votes he got statewide.

    OTOH, Utah county which includes Provo and numerous smaller counties were about 80-20 between McCain and Obama.

  • Justin Spagnolo (standardcandle)

    Orrin Hatch has spent the better part of 2 years LISTENING to T.E.A. Party activists and conservative leaders… and quite intelligently aligned himself almost exclusively to Mike Lee… and this might just have been enough for people to warm up to his “seniority and experience” argument.

    When Bennett faced challengers, he had 3 claiming TEA PARTY support in the year of TEA. Mike Lee had the added benefit of a lot of “party players” in his corner due to his time serving as general counsel for Jon Huntsman’s administration.

    Dan Liljenquist had 8 other primary challengers including Orrin Hatch to caucus against… Of the 9 Hatch and Herrod are the only ones that pose real challenge. Hatch I believe will benefit from the split “not Hatch” vote…

    Many of the regular party players showed up in droves primarily because “if it can happen to Bob Bennett it can happen to all of us…” Orrin is tremendously more popular than Bennett ever was, and in a way people view him as the face of the state in national politics.

    The complaint I heard on the ground the most from some of my “conservative” friends there regarding the “not Hatch” was Dan Liljenquist should have stayed in the state senate and done his job there, and waited for *his* time…

    Orrin Hatch is a very skilled politician, he has kowtowed to the TEA Party, and shored up his establishment support. Then he has framed this primary around the following argument between 2 cookies…

    “Is Utah a “terms limited” conservative state, or do they “like the seniority and experience in Washington” (The promise of chairing the Senate Finance Comittee)…

    Retire a Dinosaur, or Retain Seniority?

    Your cookie parable is apt, as clearly “10x’s the attendance in previous years… at each precinct”…

    The “not-Hatch” crowd needs to consolidate… and I would hope they do so around Dan Liljenquist.

  • belcatar

    I have a brother in Logan, my parents now live in Sandy (I think) and I have another couple of brothers scattered around the Salt Lake area. I spent my year in Utah living in Taylorsville. I never really felt at home there, and now I live up in rural northern Maine.